Degradation of a peptide in pitcher fluid of the carnivorous plant Nepenthes alata Blanco

Carnivorous plants acquire substantial amounts of nitrogen from insects. The tropical carnivorous plant Nepenthes produces trapping organs called pitchers at the tips of tendrils elongated from leaf ends. Acidic fluid is secreted at the bottoms of the pitchers. The pitcher fluid includes several hydrolytic enzymes, and some, such as aspartic proteinase, are thought to be involved in nitrogen acquisition from insect proteins. To understand the nitrogen-acquisition process, it is essential to identify the protein-degradation products in the pitcher fluid. To gain insight into protein degradation in pitcher fluid, we used the oxidized B-chain of bovine insulin as a model substrate, and its degradation by the pitcher fluid of N. alata was investigated using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS). LC-MS analysis of the degradation products revealed that the oxidized B-chain of bovine insulin was initially cleaved at aromatic amino acids such as phenylalanine and tyrosine. These cleavage sites are similar to those of aspartic proteinases from other plants and animals. The presence of a series of peptide fragments as degradation products suggests that exopeptidase(s) is also present in the pitcher fluid. Amino acid analysis and peptide fragment analysis of the degradation products demonstrated that three amino acids plus small peptides were released from the oxidized B-chain of bovine insulin, suggesting that insect proteins are readily degraded to small peptides and amino acids in the pitcher fluid of N. alata.     

Wheat (Triticum aestivum) seedlings secrete proteases from the roots and, after protein addition, grow well on medium without inorganic nitrogen

This paper reports on the role of proteases secreted by roots in nitrogen capture by plants. The study was conducted on aseptically cultivated wheat seedlings (Triticum aestivum cv. Tacher) obtained from embryos isolated from grains. Seedlings were cultivated for 21 days on deionised water, Murashige Skoog medium (MS), MS without inorganic nitrogen (IN), and MS without IN, in which IN was replaced by casein (0.01%, 0.1% or 1%). Comparison of seedlings grown on these media showed that casein entirely compensated for the lack of inorganic nitrogen in the medium. Shoots and roots of seedlings cultivated on MS medium with this protein had higher fresh weight than those cultivated on MS medium without casein. The increase in fresh weight of seedlings was correlated with casein concentration and proteolytic activity in the medium. In conclusion, wheat that uses proteases secreted by the roots can directly utilise proteins in the medium as a source of nitrogen without prior digestion by microbial proteases and without protein mineralisation. These results suggest the important role of organic nitrogen fertilisers in increasing wheat yield.     

Proteins as nitrogen source for plants: A short story about exudation of proteases by plant roots

Interest in the problem of plant nitrogen nutrition is increasing. Certain plants can use not only inorganic nitrogen but also intact amino acids and short peptides. According to our studies, the roots of several agricultural and wild-living plants are able to exude proteases and use them to create a pool of accessible N. This mini-review offers an overview of the problem of protease exudation by plant roots and its potential role in plant nitrogen nutrition.Key words: amino acids, organic nitrogen, nutrient uptake, plant nitrogen nutrition, protease exudation     

The ability of plants to secrete proteases by roots.

The aim of our study was to find out if the culture medium of aseptically cultivated seedlings exhibits proteolytic activity and if this event is universal in angiospermous plants. Seedlings of 15 agricultural and wild-living plant species were cultivated for 14days without any addition of nutrients. Our studies showed that roots of higher plants could secrete proteases and that levels of proteolytic activity in the culture medium of individual species (and cultivars of the same species) could be significantly different. The differences between quantities of the secreted proteases were connected neither with the fresh weight of the growing seedlings nor with the surface of the root system. No proteins were required to induce secretion of proteases. The culture medium of a few studied species (Allium porrum, Zea mays, Helianthus annuus) showed the highest proteolytic activity at pH 7. Studies of the influence of standard protease inhibitors showed that examined proteases belong to the cysteine protease family. The results suggest that the apical parts of roots exuded proteases more intensively than mature parts. Our studies suggest that some plant species could develop a strategy to actively increase the level of free amino acids in the soil solution as a source of N. Our results may contribute to studying plant N nutrition in natural ecosystems and to increasing yield after organic fertilization of agricultural species.     

Studies on Mold Proteases

The substrate specificity of the crystalline acid protease obtained from Rhizopus chinensis was determined using B-chain of oxidized beef insulin and numerous synthetic peptides, comparing with that of several acid proteases from various sources. The peptide bonds susceptible to the action of Rhiz. acid protease were found to be mainly those involving the amino group of bulky amino acids. The enzyme split the B-chain of oxidized insulin at twelve sites of the peptide linkages and a certain similarity in the specificity was observed among the three acid proteases, Rhiz. protease, rennin and pepsin, all of which were known to show potent milk clotting activities.     

Structural modifications of oxidized insulin B-chain induced by glycerol addition

Summary ¹H-NMR studies of the bovine insulin S-sulfonated B-chain are reported in H₂O/D₂O (9/1) and in glycerol-d ₅ (5 M) using two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy. The first results show that the oxidized insulin B-chain secondary structure differs from that of native insulin by a loss of the α-helix between the two disulfide bridges and that the glycerol favours the structuring of the peptide.     

Soil acidification and adaptations of plants and microorganisms in Bornean tropical forests

In tropical forest ecosystems, a paradoxical relationship is commonly observed between massive biomass production and low soil fertility (low pH). The loss and deficiency of soil phosphorus (P) and bases generally constrain biomass production; however, high productivity on nutrient-deficient soils of Bornean tropical forests is hypothesized to be maintained by plant and microorganism adaptation to an acidic soil environment. Proton budgets in the plant–soil system indicated that plants and microorganisms promote acidification to acquire bases, even in highly acidic tropical soils. The nitric and organic acids they produce contribute to the mobilization of basic cations and their uptake by plants. In response to soil P deficiency and the recalcitrance of lignin-rich organic matter, specific trees and fungi can release organic acids and enzymes for nutrient acquisition. Organic acids exuded by roots and rhizosphere microorganisms can promote the solubilization of P bonded to aluminum and iron oxides and its uptake by plants from P-poor soils. Lignin degradation, a rate-limiting step in organic matter decomposition, is specifically enhanced in acidic organic layers by lignin peroxidase, produced by white-rot fungi, which may solubilize recalcitrant lignin and release soluble aromatic substances into the soil solution. This dissolved organic matter functions in the transport of nitrogen, P, and basic cations in acidic soils without increasing leaching loss. In Bornean tropical forests, soil acidification is promoted by plants and microorganisms as a nutrient acquisition strategy, while plant roots and fungi can develop rhizosphere and enzymatic processes that promote tolerance of low pH.     

Action and Specificity of a Streptomyces Alkalophilic Proteinase

Action of the crystalline alkalophilic proteinase of a Streptomyces sp. which was active at pH values around 13, was investigated. The enzyme attacked various keratinous proteins such as wool, hair, feather etc., dissolving them with hydrolysis degrees from 2 to 6%, and the degradation of several keratins was observed under a microscope and scanning electron-microscope. Specificity of the enzyme was also studied using oxidized insulin B-chain. The enzyme cleaved most easily the peptide linkages between -Ser · His-, -Leu · Val-, -Phe · Tyr- and -Lys · Ala-, though it split several other sites of oxidized insulin B-chain, too, indicating that the action pattern of the proteinase is distinguished from those of alkaline proteinases so far reported.     

Stress-induced changes in protease composition are determined by nitrogen supply in non-nodulating white clover

An inbreeding line of white clover has been identified which remains non-nodulated under appropriate physiological conditions and so the nitrogen concentration of the plant can be manipulated by altering the nitrate supply to the roots. Non-nodulating plants were used to test the hypothesis that acclimation to nitrogen limitation in white clover involves changes in protease activity and composition. These results indicate that acclimation to nitrogen limitation involves the realignment of constituent proteases without necessarily incurring significant changes in total protease activity. Plants grown at 2.5, 5.0, 7.5, and 10 mM nitrate showed a positive correlation between nitrate supply and foliar protein concentration. Protein profiles, revealed by Coomassie-stained SDS-PAGE, were unchanged between treatments for a given amount of protein. Serine, aspartate/metalloprotease, and two cysteine proteases were identified in the leaves. Although total protease activity per gram fresh weight was unchanged between treatments, the relative contributions of these four proteases was determined by nitrate supply. When plants were stressed further by withholding nitrate there was an increase in cysteine protease activity, but a senescence-related aspartate/metalloprotease was not visible. Hence, while protease expression in white clover leaves responded to the current and past nitrogen status of the plant, the proteases involved in remobilization during nutrient limitation were distinct from those involved during the main senescence period. It is suggested that nitrogen limitation induced an early, reversible stage of senescence in which perturbations in protease activity facilitated the degradation of non-essential proteins in order to increase the chances of plant survival or seed set.     

Effect of Pseudomonas fluorescens on the root exudates of two tomato mutants differently sensitive to Fe chlorosis

Plants with different Fe-mobilization properties are known to differ in the amount and kind of Fe-reducing and Fe-chelating compounds exuded by their roots. Although rhizosphere bacteria are known to affect the exudation of organic compounds by the plant roots, their effect on the root exudates of plants differing in Fe-mobilization properties is not known. We studied the effect of Pseudomonas fluorescens, on the exudation of sugars and organic and amino acids by roots of an iron chlorosis-resistant (T3238FER) and a chlorosis-susceptible (T3238fer) tomato mutant. Under sterile conditions two tomato mutants grew equally well and did not differ in the total amount of sugars and organic acid exuded by their roots. More amino acids, however, were exuded by the roots of T3238FER than T323fer. Mutants differed in the amount of oxalic acid and the amino acids Ala, Asp, Gaba, Gln, Gly, His, Hyl, Ile, Leu, Lys, Phe, Pro, and Val exuded by their roots into sterile rooting media. Addition of P. fluorescens to the rooting medium did not affect the growth of T3238FER but stimulated the root growth of chlorosis-susceptible T3238fer, reduced the amounts of glucose, arabinose and fructose but increased the amount of sucrose, reduced the amounts of fumaric, malic and oxalic acid but increased the amounts of citric and succinic acid in the rooting media of both mutants. P. fluorescens resulted in the following changes in the amino acids in the rooting media: reduced the amounts of Gly, Leu, and Lys in T3238FER, and of Asp, Gln, Hyp, and Ile in T3238fer, and increased the amounts of Cys, Glu, His, Hyp, Ile, Phe and Tyr in T3238FER and of Ala, Glu, His, Phe, and Ser in T323fer—in cases more than 40-fold. These differential effects of P. fluorescens in altering the pattern of organic and amino acids compounds with some Fe-chelating properties detected in the rooting medium of these two mutants may indicate that the differences in Fe-chlorosis susceptibility of these tomato mutants may be the result of, or modified by, the interactions between plant roots and rhizosphere microorganisms. We postulate that the Fe-chlorosis susceptibility in plants may be the product of the interactions between soil microorganisms and plant roots, and may not be solely related to the plant per se.     

Root proteases: reinforced links between nitrogen uptake and mobilization and drought tolerance

Integral subcellular and cellular functions ranging from gene expression, protein targeting and nutrient supply to cell differentiation and cell death require proteases. Plants have unique organelles such as chloroplasts composed of unique proteins that carry out the unique process of photosynthesis. Hence, along with proteases common across kingdoms, plants contain unique proteases. Improved knowledge on proteases can lead to a better understanding of plant development, differentiation and death. Because of their importance in multiple processes, plant proteases are actively studied. However, root proteases specifically are not as well studied. The associated rhizosphere, organic matter and/or inorganic matter make roots a difficult system. Yet recent research conclusively demonstrated the occurrence of endocytosis of proteins, peptides and even microbes by root cells, which, hitherto known for specialized pathogenesis or symbiosis, was unsuspected for nutrient uptake. These results reinforced the importance of root proteases in endocytosis or root exudate-mediated nutrient uptake. Rhizoplane, rhizosphere or in planta protease action on proteins, peptides and microbes generates sources of nitrogen, especially during abiotic stresses such as drought. This article highlights the recent research on root proteases for nitrogen uptake and the connection of the two to drought-tolerance mechanisms. Drought-induced proteases in rice roots, as known from rice expression databases, are discussed for future research on certain M50, Deg, FtsH, AMSH and deubiquitination proteases. The recent emphasis on linking drought and plant hydraulics to nutrient metabolism is illustrated and connected to the value of a systematic study of root proteases in crop improvement.     

A test of a potential short cut in the nitrogen cycle: The role of exudation of symbiotically fixed nitrogen from the roots of a N-fixing tree and the effects of increased atmospheric CO2 and temperature

N-fixing trees facilitate the growth of neighboring trees of other species. These neighboring species benefit from the simple presence of the N fixation symbiosis in their surroundings. Because of this phenomenon, it has been hypothesized that a change in atmospheric CO₂ concentration may alter the role of N-fixing trees in their environment. It is thought that the role of N-fixing trees in ecosystems of the future may be more important since they may help sustain growth increases due to increased CO₂ concentration in nitrogen limited forests. We examined: (1) whether symbiotically fixed N was exuded from roots, (2) whether a doubled atmospheric CO₂ concentration would result in increased organic N exudation from roots, and (3) whether increased temperature or N availability affected N exudation from roots. This study analyzed exudation of dissolved organic N from the roots of seedlings of the N-fixing tree Robinia pseudoacacia L. in a full factorial design with 2 CO₂ (35.0 and 70.0 Pa) × 2 temperature (26 or 30 °C during the day) × 2 N fertilizer (0 and 10.0 mM N concentration) levels. Trees with no other source of N except N fixation exuded about 1% to 2% of the fixed N through their roots as dissolved organic N. Increased atmospheric CO₂ concentrations did not, however, increase N exudation rates on a per gram belowground biomass basis. A 4 °C increase in temperature and N fertilization did, however, significantly increase N exudation rates. These results suggest that exudation of dissolved organic N from roots or nodules of N-fixing trees could be a significant, but minor, pathway of transferring N to neighboring plants in a much more rapid and direct way than cycling through death, decomposition and mineralization of plant residues. And, while exudation rates of dissolved organic N from roots were not significantly affected by atmospheric CO₂ concentration, the previously observed CO₂ fertilization effect on N-fixing trees suggests that N exudation from roots could play a significant but minor role in sustaining increases in forest growth, and thus C storage, in a CO₂ enriched atmosphere.     

Root Carbon Dioxide Fixation by Phosphorus-Deficient Lupinus albus (Contribution to Organic Acid Exudation by Proteoid Roots)

When white lupin (Lupinus albus L.) is subjected to P deficiency lateral root development is altered and densely clustered, tertiary lateral roots (proteoid roots) are initiated. These proteoid roots exude large amounts of citrate, which increases P solubilization. In the current study plants were grown with either 1 mM P (+P-treated) or without P (-P-treated). Shoots or roots of intact plants from both P treatments were labeled independently with 14CO2 to compare the relative contribution of C fixed in each with the C exuded from roots as citrate and other organic acids. About 25-fold more acid-stable 14C, primarily in citrate and malate, was recovered in exudates from the roots of -P-treated plants compared with +P-treated plants. The rate of in vivo C fixation in roots was about 4-fold higher in -P-treated plants than in +P-treated plants. Evidence from labeling intact shoots or roots indicates that synthesis of citrate exuded by -P-treated roots is directly related to nonphotosynthetic C fixation in roots. C fixed in roots of -P-treated plants contributed about 25 and 34% of the C exuded as citrate and malate, respectively. Nonphotosynthetic C fixation in white lupin roots is an integral component in the exudation of large amounts of citrate and malate, thus increasing the P available to the plant.     

植物对有机氮源的利用及其在自然生态系统中的意义

近来大量实验研究表明,许多植物能够在不经矿化的情况下直接吸收、利用环境介质中的生物有机氮,尤其氨基酸类。而且,有些植物利用氨基酸的效率可以与矿质氮源(NH4 、NO3)相当或更高。自然界植物赖以生存的土壤生境中同时存在多种有机氮和矿质氮养分,这是导致植物(至少部分植物)进化产生利用各种不同氮源能力的环境驱动力。土壤中的游离氨基酸尽管含量不高,但其周转快、通量大,理论上可远大于植物的氮需求。尽管植物在与土壤微生物的有机氮源竞争中处于根本性劣势,但土壤中氨基酸的巨大潜在通量和植物相对于微生物的生命周期仍可使植物在长期竞争中获取数量可观的氮。基于植物根对氨基酸的吸收能力、土壤中游离氨基酸库的大小和通量、植物与土壤微生物对氨基酸氮源的竞争以及有关的原位实验结果,近来许多研究者都认为植物有机氮营养在多种生态系统中是重要或潜在重要的。尤其是在一些极地、高山、亚高山、北方针叶林或泰加林生态系统中,由于低温等因素限制有机氮矿化,土壤氨基酸浓度常超过矿质氮(NH4 、NO3-)浓度,氨基酸可能代表着植物的一个主要氮源。认识到现实生态系统中植物对有机氮源利用的重要性意味着传统的矿质营养观念的更新,这将在很大程度上改变人们对某些重要生态过程的理解,并导致对若干生态学中心问题的再认识。研究以森林生态系统为例,阐述了我国开展该领域研究的科学意义和基本框架。     

A new B-chain mutant of insulin: comparison with the insulin crystal structure and role of sulfonate groups in the B-chain structure.

The solution structure of a new B-chain mutant of bovine insulin, in which the cysteines B7 and B19 are replaced by two serines, has been determined by circular dichroism, 2D-NMR and molecular modeling. This structure is compared with that of the oxidized B-chain of bovine insulin [Hawkins et al. (1995) Int. J. Peptide Protein Res.46, 424-433]. Circular dichroism spectroscopy showed in particular that a higher percentage of helical secondary structure for the B-chain mutant is estimated in trifluoroethanol solution in comparison with the oxidized B-chain. 2D-NMR experiments confirmed, among multiple conformations, that the B-chain mutant presents defined secondary structures such as a alpha-helix between residues B9 and B19, and a beta-turn between amino acids B20 and B23 in aqueous trifluoroethanol. The 3D structures, which are consistent with NMR data and were obtained using a simulated annealing protocol, showed that the tertiary structure of the B-chain mutant is better resolved and is more in agreement with the insulin crystal structure than the oxidized B-chain structure described by Hawkins et al. An explanation could be the presence of two sulfonate groups in the oxidized insulin B-chain. Either by their charges and/or their size, such chemical groups could play a destructuring effect and thus could favor peptide flexibility and conformational averaging. Thus, this study provides new insights on the folding of isolated B-chains.     

Organic nitrogen use by salal ericoid mycorrhizal fungi from northern Vancouver Island and impacts on growth in vitro of Gaultheria shallon

 Salal (Gaultheria shallon) recovers quickly from rhizomes after clear-cut timber harvesting and dominates clearcuts of Tsuga heterophylla and Thuja plicata forests. Thus it contributes to considerable problems in regeneration of these sites in coastal British Columbia, Canada. Based on what is known about other ericaceous plants, we speculated that mycorrhizal fungi of salal play a vital role in the growth and dominance of salal by providing access to organic nitrogen. In this study, the ability of four species of fungi isolated from salal to use different forms of organic nitrogen was tested in pure culture and in association with salal. The organic forms of nitrogen applied were glutamine (an amino acid), glutathione (a peptide), and bovine serum albumin (BSA, a protein). The fungi tested were Oidiodendron maius, Acremonium strictum, and two nonsporulating fungi. Inoculated plants always grew better than noninoculated plants regardless of nitrogen source. Glutamine was used as readily as ammonium nitrogen by all four fungi and the mycorrhizal plants of salal colonized by those fungi. There was considerable variation between fungus species or the plants inoculated with those fungi in using glutathione and BSA. Salal inoculated with O. maius grew better on glutathione than BSA, while A. strictum and unknown 1 produced significantly greater yields of salal on BSA. Colonization rates of salal by all four fungi was higher on glutathione or BSA than on ammonium or glutamine. Accepted: 19 June 1999     

Quantification of the Daily Cytokinin Transport from the Root to the Shoot of Urtica dioica L.*

Cytokinins are predominantly root-born phytohormones which are distributed in the shoot via the xylem stream. In the hormone message concept they are considered as root signals mediating the transport of the photosynthates to the various sinks of a plant. In this paper the cytokinin relations of Urtica dioica L., the stinging nettle, are described, based on the daily flux from the roots to the shoot. Trans-zeatin-type cytokinins predominate in the various tissues of Urtica (Wagner and Beck, 1993), and accordingly trans-zeatin riboside and trans-zeatin are the forms transported by the xylem sap. The daily time-course of cytokinin concentration in root pressure exudates and in xylem sap collected from a petiole after pressurizing the root bed showed high concentrations in the morning, followed by a substantial drop to a level of 15–30% of the initial concentration which was then maintained during the afternoon. This time-course is interpreted as resulting from continuous synthesis and exudation of cytokinins into the xylem fluid of the roots whose cytokinin concentration is then modified by the dynamics of the transpiration stream. Loading of cytokinins into the xylem sap could be enhanced several times by increasing the flux rate of the xylem stream to the maximal transpiration rate when a maximum export rate was reached. The total daily cytokinin gain by the shoot depended on the nitrogen status of the plant. Roots of Urtica plants grown on a sufficient nitrogen supply had a significantly higher cytokinin content and exuded more cytokinins into the shoot than those of plants raised under nitrogen shortage. A positive correlation was found between the steady rates of cytokinin export measured during the afternoon and the shoot to root-ratios of biomass which, in turn, corresponded to the nitrogen status of the plants.     

Regrowth dynamics of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Calamagrostis epigejos</Emphasis> after defoliation as affected by nitrogen availability

Young plants of a rhizomatous grass Calamagrostis epigejos (L.) Roth were grown from seed in nutrient solutions containing nitrogen in concentrations 0.1, 1.0, and 10 mM. After six weeks of cultivation the plants were defoliated and changes in growth parameters and in content of storage compounds were measured in the course of regrowth under highly reduced nitrogen availability. Plants grown at higher nitrogen supply before defoliation had higher amount of all types of nitrogen storage compounds (nitrates, free amino acids, soluble proteins), which was beneficial for their regrowth rate, in spite of lower content of storage saccharides. Amino acids and soluble proteins from roots and stubble bases were the most important sources of storage compounds for regrowth of the shoot. Faster growth of plants with higher N content was mediated by greater leaf area expansion and greater number of leaves. In plants with lower contents of N compounds number of green leaves decreased after defoliation significantly and senescing leaves presumably served as N source for other growing organs. Results suggest that internal N reserves can support regrowth of plants after defoliation even under fluctuating external N availability. Faster regrowth of C. epigejos with more reserves was mediated mainly by changes in plant morphogenesis.     

植物内生菌促进宿主氮吸收与代谢研究进展

内生菌与植物共生能够提高宿主的氮吸收与氮代谢水平,这可能是由于内生菌在植物体内引发的多种效应的综合结果.植物内生菌能够通过促进植物根系发育和固氮作用为宿主植物提供更多的无机氮素;能够通过分泌多种胞外酶系如漆酶、蛋白水解酶等使宿主植物更好地利用有机氮素;能够提高宿主氮代谢关键酶如硝酸还原酶(NR)、谷氨酰胺合成酶(GS)等酶的活性;能够提高宿主植物激素水平和维生素含量从而促进宿主氮代谢;能够通过影响宿主植物氮代谢促进宿主植物分蘖、提高宿主植物叶绿素含量和光合速率等等.综述了国内外关于植物内生菌促进宿主氮代谢的相关报道,归纳了植物内生菌影响宿主氮素吸收与代谢的可能机制,并展望了关于植物内生菌促进宿主氮代谢机制方面的研究方向.     

Exudation of amino acids by intact and damaged roots of wheat and peas

Summary Wheat and pea seedlings were grown aseptically in solution-culture and the total free amino nitrogen released by the roots was determined by a quantitative ninhydrin test. Amino nitrogen from wheat plants after 14 days growth was not detected by the test, indicating the release of less than 3 µg of amino nitrogen from a culture of 15 plants. Pea plants of the same age released from 2 to 7 µg per plant. Paper chromatograms of highly concentrated undisturbed solution-cultures revealed up to 13 amino compounds from wheat and 11 from pea. The pattern of amino acids in exudates was similar to that in crushed roots, except for an unidentified amino compound which was detected only in exuded material. The total amino nitrogen and relative proportions of several amino acids in the root exudates of sand-grown peas was influenced by several ratios of oxygen and carbon dioxide supplied to the root zone. Roots, experimentally damaged by swirling and rinsing in sand, released in 1 hour amino nitrogen of from 73 to 120 per cent of that released by normal exudation over a 2-week period. Our findings suggest that experimental and environmental root damage may be responsible for a large proportion of organic materials released by growing plant roots.Trade names are used in this publication to provide specific information. Their use does not constitute a guarantee of the products named and does not signify that they are approved by the U.S. Department of Agriculture to the exclusion of others of suitable composition.