Red foliage color reliably indicates low host quality and increased metabolic load for development of an herbivorous insect

Plant chemical defense and coevolved detoxification mechanisms in specialized herbivorous insects are fundamental in determining many insect–plant interactions. For example, Brassicale plants protect themselves from herbivory by producing glucosinolates, but these secondary metabolites are effectively detoxified by larvae of Pierid butterflies. Nevertheless, not all Brassicales are equally preferred by these specialist herbivores. Female Pieris butterflies avoid laying eggs on anthocyanin-rich red foliage, suggesting red color is a visual cue affecting oviposition behavior. In this study, we reared P. brassicae larvae on green and red cabbage leaves, to determine whether foliage color reliably indicates host plant quality. We did not find a difference in survival rates or maximal larval body mass in the two food treatments. However, larvae feeding on red cabbage leaves exhibited significantly lower growth rates and longer durations of larval development. Interestingly, this longer development was coupled with a higher consumption rate of dry food matter. The lower ratio of body mass gain to food consumption in larvae feeding on red cabbage leaves was coupled with significantly higher (ca. 10 %) larval metabolic rates. This suggests that development on red foliage may incur an increased metabolic load associated with detoxification of secondary plant metabolites. Energy and oxygen allocation to detoxification could come at the expense of growth and thus compromise larval fitness as a result of extended development. From an evolutionary perspective, red foliage color may serve as an honest defensive cue, as it reliably indicates the plant’s low quality as a substrate for larval development.     

How discriminating are cabbage butterflies?

The egg-laying responses of cabbage butterflies Pieris rapae L. to differences in the size, quality and spatial distribution of available oviposition sites, were studied in the laboratory (Australia) and the field (Australia and Canada). Differences on three scales were investigated: between leaves within the same plant, between plants within a patch, and between patches of plants. The butterflies lay most eggs on the larger, older leaves of plants, though the oldest are sometimes avoided. Larger plants also receive more eggs than smaller ones of the same cultivar, but cultivar preferences may override the response to size. The butterflies do not discriminate against plants already bearing eggs or larvae, unless larval feeding damage to the plant is severe. They lay more eggs on young plants than old ones of the same size; plants grown in the lower of two light intensities also received more eggs. Australian butterflies discriminate not only between different species of crucifers, but also between varieties of the same species. This discrimination against less acceptable varieties is just as strong when plants of preferred varieties are not present, as when both varieties occur in the same patch. The observed responses are discussed in relation to the butterflies’ host-finding behaviour and the adaptive significance of the lack of a response to eggs and larvae is considered.     

The adaptiveness of searching and host selection behaviour in Pieris rapae (L.)

This study evaluates the adaptive significance of host preferences and searching behaviour in Vancouver and Canberra populations of the cabbage butterfly Pieris rapae (L.). As a result of a complex of responses to plant age, the butterflies concentrate their eggs on middle-aged plants. Young larvae develop faster and survive better on young plants than old ones, but larvae on smaller plants are more susceptible to crowding effects. Thus a preference for plants which are well-grown but not too old is selectively advantageous. By contrast, the butterflies’ host species preferences appear non-adaptive, and are unrelated to the quality of the host as larval food. Vancouver butterflies change their flight direction often and are very responsive to hosts, thereby generating a very aggregated distribution at a low cost in flight time. Canberra butterflies tend to fly in straight lines and are less responsive to hosts; their egg distribution is consequently more nearly random, but they fly further for each egg they lay. The relative costs of aggregation and increased flight time differ between the populations in a manner consistent with the observed behavioural differences.     

Cyanide detoxification in an insect herbivore: Molecular identification of β-cyanoalanine synthases from Pieris rapae

Cyanogenic compounds occur widely in the plant kingdom. Therefore, many herbivores are adapted to the presence of these compounds in their diet by either avoiding cyanide release or by efficient cyanide detoxification mechanisms. The mechanisms of adaptation are not fully understood. Larvae of Pieris rapae (Lepidoptera: Pieridae) are specialist herbivores on glucosinolate-containing plants. They are exposed to cyanide during metabolism of phenylacetonitrile, a product of benzylglucosinolate breakdown catalyzed by plant myrosinases and larval nitrile-specifier protein (NSP) in the gut. Cyanide is metabolized to β-cyanoalanine and thiocyanate in the larvae. Here, we demonstrate that larvae of P. rapae possess β-cyanoalanine activity in their gut. We have identified three gut-expressed cDNAs designated PrBSAS1-PrBSAS3 which encode proteins with similarity to β-substituted alanine synthases (BSAS). Characterization of recombinant PrBSAS1-PrBSAS3 shows that they possess β-cyanoalanine activity. In phylogenetic trees, PrBSAS1-PrBSAS3, the first characterized insect BSAS, group together with a characterized mite β-cyanoalanine synthase and bacterial enzymes indicating a similar evolutionary history.     

Avoidance mechanisms of three Pieris butterfly species against the parasitoid wasp Apanteles glomerulus

Abstract. 1. Experimental studies have shown that larvae of three Pieris butterflies, P.rapae L., P.melete Mènètriés and P.napi L., are attacked by a parasitoid wasp, Apanteles glomeratus L. Although P.rapae larvae are parasitized heavily in the field, P.melete and P.napi are infrequently parasitized successfully because they possess mechanisms for encapsulating parasitoid larvae and for avoiding parasitism.
2. This study examines spatial and temporal variation in rates of parasitism of the three Pieris species by A.glomeratus in the field. We attempted to determine whether P.rapae possesses any means of avoiding parasitism by this wasp, and then to deduce why both P.melete and P.napi have more distinctive avoidance mechanisms than P.rapae.
3. Our results indicate that in temporary habitats, which are the main habitats of P.rapae, P.rapae is able to escape A.glomeratus in time and space by colonizing new habitats before the parasitoid arrives. In permanent habitats, however, such escape is not possible. P.rapae larvae lack physiological or behavioural avoidance mechanisms of reducing parasitism rates in permanent habitats. P.melete and P.napi , in contrast, live only in permanent habitats, where the parasitic pressure is potentially high, and have evolved active avoidance mechanisms.     

Bird predation as a selective pressure on the immature stages of the cabbage butterflies, Pieris rapae and P. brassicae

The importance of bird predation as a selective pressure on the eggs, larvae and pupae of the cabbage butterflies, Pieris rapae L. and P. brassicae L. has been investigated in a rural garden and an allotment. Birds are the main predators of all stages in a well-tended garden whereas in a field the eggs and young larvae are mainly preyed upon by arthropods. The species of avian predators vary according to the stage of development and species of prey. Consequently the relative survival rate of P. rupae and P. brussicue varies with stage of development. This changing pattern of survival has in turn acted as a selective pressure on their two main braconid parasites. Many aspects of the size, shape, colour and behaviour of the larvae and pupae of both species of Pieris appear to be adaptations to the selective pressures exerted by bird predation.     

Influence of climate on butterfly community and population dynamics in Western Ohio

Climate influences butterflies both directly and through impacts on their food plants and habitat. We look at the relationship between climate and butterflies in the Aullwood Audubon Center, west central Ohio, using the weekly Long-Term Butterfly Monitoring (LTBM) surveys (April through October 2000-2006) and the annual fourth of July counts (1989-2006). The 18 annual Fourth of July surveys yielded 20,709 butterflies and 59 species. The number of individuals though not species decreased over time. Most but not all of that decrease was from a large drop in Pieris rapae L. (Pieridae). The number of individuals was greatest when the previous and current growing seasons were cool and winter precipitation high. Individual species varied in their response to climate. Recent years have been warmer (all seasons) and have had drier winters than earlier years. The 7 yr of weekly LTBM surveys recorded 5,784 butterflies and 58 species. The total number of individuals has not changed significantly over time. The weather of the day of sampling had some effect: the total number of species was highest on clear days with some wind. The results over the 18 yr are compatible with the hypothesis that global warming has led to a decrease in the number of butterflies. Habitat changes cannot be excluded as an alternate hypothesis, but these effects seem minor. The value of a large, environmentally heterogeneous natural area like Aullwood is that it buffers short-term climatic and weather conditions to provide long-term stability for a diverse butterfly community.     

Oviposition preferences of herbivores are affected by tritrophic interaction webs

Two tritrophic systems were experimentally coupled in the present study. One system consisted of a cabbage plant ( Brassica oleracea ), diamondback moth larvae ( Plutella xylostella ) and their parasitic wasp ( Cotesia plutellae ). The other system consisted of a cabbage plant, cabbage butterfly ( Pieris rapae ) larvae and their parasitic wasp ( Cotesia glomerata ). First, we demonstrated that parasitism by C. glomerata and C. plutellae increased and decreased, respectively, on plants infested by both herbivore species than on plants infested by their host larvae alone. We then demonstrated that adult Pl. xylostella oviposited preferentially on plants infested with Pi. rapae , whereas adult Pi. rapae revealed no significant preferences between uninfested plants or plants infested with Pl. xylostella . Based on the present results and those of our previous study, we discuss the oviposition preferences of herbivores in tritrophic contexts.     

Insect herbivore counteradaptations to the plant glucosinolate-myrosinase system

The glucosinolate-myrosinase system found in plants of the Brassicales order is one of the best studied plant chemical defenses. Glucosinolates and their hydrolytic enzymes, myrosinases, are stored in separate compartments in the intact plant tissue. Upon tissue disruption, bioactivation of glucosinolates is initiated, i.e. myrosinases get access to their glucosinolate substrates, and glucosinolate hydrolysis results in the formation of toxic isothiocyanates and other biologically active products. The defensive function of the glucosinolate-myrosinase system has been demonstrated in a variety of studies with different insect herbivores. However, a number of generalist as well as specialist herbivores uses glucosinolate-containing plants as hosts causing large agronomical losses in oil seed rape and other crops of the Brassicaceae. While our knowledge of counteradaptations in generalist insect herbivores is still very limited, considerable progress has been made in understanding how specialist insect herbivores overcome the glucosinolate-myrosinase system and even exploit it for their own defense. All mechanisms of counteradaptation identified to date in insect herbivores specialized on glucosinolate-containing plants ensure that glucosinolate breakdown to toxic isothiocyanates is avoided. This is accomplished in many different ways including avoidance of cell disruption, rapid absorption of intact glucosinolates, rapid metabolic conversion of glucosinolates to harmless compounds that are not substrates for myrosinases, and diversion of plant myrosinase-catalyzed glucosinolate hydrolysis. One of these counteradaptations, the nitrile-specifier protein identified in Pierid species, has been used to demonstrate mechanisms of coevolution of plants and their insect herbivores.     

Do asynchronies in extinction debt affect the structure of trophic networks? A case study of antagonistic butterfly larvae–plant networks

Habitat loss and fragmentation affect species richness in fragmented habitats and can lead to immediate or time‐delayed species extinctions. Asynchronies in extinction and extinction debt between interacting species may have severe effects on ecological networks. However, these effects remain largely unknown. We evaluated the effects of habitat patch and landscape changes on antagonistic butterfly larvae–plant trophic networks in Mediterranean grasslands in which previous studies had shown the existence of extinction debt in plants but not in butterflies. We sampled current species richness of habitat‐specialist and generalist butterflies and vascular plants in 26 grasslands. We assessed the direct effects of historical and current patch and landscape characteristics on species richness and on butterfly larvae–plant trophic network metrics and robustness. Although positive species‐ and interactions–area relationships were found in all networks, structure and robustness was only affected by patch and landscape changes in networks involving the subset of butterfly specialists. Larger patches had more species (butterflies and host plants) and interactions but also more compartments, which decreased network connectance but increased network stability. Moreover, most likely due to the rescue effect, patch connectivity increased host‐plant species (but not butterfly) richness and total links, and network robustness in specialist networks. On the other hand, patch area loss decreased robustness in specialist butterfly larvae–plant networks and made them more prone to collapse against host plant extinctions. Finally, in all butterfly larvae–plant networks we also detected a past patch and landscape effect on network asymmetry, which indicates that there were different extinction rates and extinction debts for butterflies and host plants. We conclude that asynchronies in extinction and extinction debt in butterfly–plant networks provoked by patch and landscape changes caused changes in species richness and network links in all networks, as well as changes in network structure and robustness in specialist networks.     

A novel trade-off of insect diapause affecting a sequestered chemical defense

Diapause allows insects to temporally avoid conditions that are unfavorable for development and reproduction. However, diapause may incur a cost in the form of reduced metabolic energy reserves, reduced potential fecundity, and missed reproductive opportunities. This study investigated a hitherto ignored consequence of diapause: trade-offs involving sequestered chemical defense. We examined the aristolochic acid defenses of diapausing and non-diapausing pipevine swallowtail butterflies, Battus philenor. Pipevine swallowtail larvae acquire these chemical defenses from their host plants. Butterflies that emerge following pupal diapause have significantly less fat, a female fitness correlate, compared to those that do not diapause. However, butterflies emerging from diapaused pupae are more chemically defended compared to those that have not undergone diapause. Furthermore, non-diapausing butterflies are confronted with older, lower quality host plants on which to oviposit. Thus, a trade-off exists where butterflies may have greater energy reserves at the cost of less chemical defense and sub-optimal food resources for their larvae, or have substantially less energetic reserves with the benefit of greater chemical defense and plentiful larval food resources.     

Laboratory studies on the effects of pollen from Bt-maize on larvae of some butterfly species

Abstract:   Three lepidopteran species were tested to determine their susceptibility against the ingestion of pollen from genetically modified maize plants. To prove the existence of dose–response relations between the applied amount of pollen (Bt-maize) and the damages on the tested larvae, a method was developed which makes it possible to feed caterpillars with defined amounts of pollen. If their food plants were contaminated with pollen of a cultivar of the Bt-176 maize-line Pieris brassicae , Pieris rapae and Plutella xylostella -larvae fed less, grew more slowly and showed a higher mortality than caterpillars of an untreated control group. The 50% lethality (LD₅₀)-values were calculated for P.xylostella (L₄) with 19.2, for P. rapae (L₂) with 39.0 and also for P. brassicae (L₂) with 139.2 pollen of the transgenic maize Pactol CB. Studies with P. brassicae -caterpillars of different larval stages indicated, that older individuals showed a higher tolerance against pollen from Bt-maize than younger ones. It must be stated on the basis of the present studies, that ingestion of non-transgenic maize pollen has neither a positive nor a negative effect on caterpillars. It becomes clear from the information presented here that it is still difficult to make general statements about the endangering of butterflies, arising from cultivation of genetically modified maize lines. Further investigations on this issue are needed. Initially, the LD₅₀-values concerning the larvae of certain butterfly species have to be determined to anticipate the risks, and in addition the distances between habitats with caterpillar host plants and maize fields, and the abundance of these plants have to be considered.     

Indole-3-acetonitrile production from indole glucosinolates deters oviposition by Pieris rapae

Like many crucifer-specialist herbivores, Pieris rapae uses the presence of glucosinolates as a signal for oviposition and larval feeding. Arabidopsis thaliana glucosinolate-related mutants provide a unique resource for studying the in vivo role of these compounds in affecting P. rapae oviposition. Low indole glucosinolate cyp79B2 cyp79B3 mutants received fewer eggs than wild type, confirming prior research showing that indole glucosinolates are an important oviposition cue. Transgenic plants overexpressing epithiospecifier protein, which shifts glucosinolate breakdown toward nitrile formation, are less attractive to ovipositing P. rapae females. Exogenous application of indol-3-ylmethylglucosinolate breakdown products to cyp79B2 cyp79B3 mutants showed that oviposition was increased by indole-3-carbinol and decreased by indole-3-acetonitrile (IAN). P. rapae larvae tolerate a cruciferous diet by using a gut enzyme to redirect glucosinolate breakdown toward less toxic nitriles, including IAN, rather than isothiocyanates. The presence of IAN in larval regurgitant contributes to reduced oviposition by adult females on larvae-infested plants. Therefore, production of nitriles via epithiospecifier protein in cruciferous plants, which makes the plants more sensitive to generalist herbivores, may be a counter-adaptive mechanism for reducing oviposition by P. rapae and perhaps other crucifer-specialist insects.     

Seasonal fluctuations in butterflies and nectar resources in a semi-natural grassland near Mt. Fuji, central Japan

We investigated seasonal fluctuation patterns in species and individuals of adult butterflies and flowering plants providing nectar in a semi-natural grassland in central Japan. We considered their interrelationships and implications for conservation. The semi-natural grassland included different vegetation structures and management regimes, including: (1) firebreaks where the grass was mowed and removed, (2) plantation areas that were mowed, (3) unpaved roads with mowed banks, (4) abandoned grassland, (5) scattered scrub forest, and (6) the surrounding forest. The sites with management (e.g., firebreaks), plantations and banks of the unpaved road sustained a larger number of butterflies and flowers than sites without management, such as the abandoned grassland, scrub forest and surrounding forest. The number of butterflies increased in the firebreak in June and at all sites in August and September. The firebreak sustained flowers in the spring, and the plantation area and banks of the unpaved road sustained flowers primarily in August and September, which was correlated with the distribution of butterflies. The different treatments such as mowing or mowing with removal of grass induced different numbers of flowers of each species affecting the habitat of adult butterflies through a season. On the other hand, the shrub tree species composing the scrub forest were host plants for the larvae of certain butterfly species. Our results suggest that heterogeneous environments with different human management or different vegetation structure or both could support habitat for various butterfly species, depending on the season and the seral stage.     

Thermal ecology of Pieris butterflies (Lepidoptera: Pieridae): a new mechanism of behavioral thermoregulation

Summary I document a new mechanism for behavioral thermoregulation, not previously described in animals, called reflectance basking. This behavior, described here for Pieris butterflies, involves the use of the wings as solar reflectors that reflect solar radiation onto the body to increase body temperature. Results show that Pieris require thoracic (body) temperature. between 29° and 40° C in order to take off and fly, and achieve these elevated temperatures by basking. Diurnal patterns of population flight activity are closely correlated with patterns of body temperature during basking. Behavioral studies indicate that 1) Pieris orient to solar radiation, 2) they use thermoregulatory postures consistent with reflectance basking, and 3) they do not use the basking postures found in other Pierid butterflies (i.e., the Coliadinae). There are consistent differences in wing angles used in reflectance basking between Pieris in different subgenera. Results are discussed with respect to thermoregulation and wing color in other Pierid butterflies, and suggest that a re-evaluation of the functional significance of melanization in Pieris is needed.     

Microevolutionary dynamics of a macroevolutionary key innovation in a Lepidopteran herbivore

Background  

A molecular population genetics understanding is central to the study of ecological and evolutionary functional genomics. Population genetics identifies genetic variation and its distribution within and among populations, it reveals the demographic history of the populations studied, and can provide indirect insights into historical selection dynamics. Here we use this approach to examine the demographic and selective dynamics acting of a candidate gene involved in plant-insect interactions. Previous work documents the macroevolutionary and historical ecological importance of the nitrile-specifier protein (Nsp), which facilitated the host shift of Pieridae butterflies onto Brassicales host plants ~80 Myr ago.     

Impact of single-gene and dual-gene Bt broccoli on the herbivore <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pieris rapae</Emphasis> (Lepidoptera: Pieridae) and its pupal endoparasitoid <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pteromalus puparum</Emphasis> (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae)

Transgenic brassica crops producing insecticidal proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) are being investigated as candidates for field release to control lepidopteran pests. Information on the potential impact of Bt brassica crops on pests and non-target natural enemies is needed as part of an environmental risk assessment prior to the commercial release. This first tier study provides insight into the tritrophic interactions among Bt broccoli plants, the herbivore Pieris rapae and its parasitoid Pteromalus puparum. We first evaluated the efficacy of three types of Bt broccoli plants, cry1Ac, cry1C and cry1Ac + cry1C, on different instars of P. rapae. Bt broccoli effectively controlled P. rapae larvae, although later instars were more tolerant. The efficacy of different Bt broccoli plants on P. rapae larvae was consistently cry1Ac > cry1Ac + cry1C > cry1C. When the parasitoid P. puparum developed in a P. rapae pupa (host) that had developed from Bt plant-fed older larvae, developmental time, total number and longevity of the P. puparum generated from the Bt plant-fed host were significantly affected compared with those generated from the non-Bt control plant-fed host. Simultaneously, negative effects on P. rapae pupae were found, i.e. pupal length, width and weight were significantly reduced after older P. rapae larvae fed on different Bt plants for 1 or 2 days. Cry1C toxin was detected using ELISA in P. rapae pupae after older larvae fed on cry1C broccoli. However, no Cry1C toxin was detected in newly emerged P. puparum adults developing in Bt-fed hosts. Only a trace amount of toxin was detected from entire P. puparum pupae dissected from the Bt plant-fed host. Moreover, no negative effect was found on the progeny of P. puparum developing from the Bt plant-fed host when subsequently supplied with a healthy host, P. rapae pupae. The reduced quality of the host appears to be the only reason for the observed deleterious effects on P. puparum. Our data suggest that the effects on P. puparum developing in Bt plant-fed P. rapae are mediated by host quality rather than by direct toxicity.     

Choice and No-Choice Assays for Testing the Resistance of A. thaliana to Chewing Insects

Larvae of the small white cabbage butterfly are a pest in agricultural settings. This caterpillar species feeds from plants in the cabbage family, which include many crops such as cabbage, broccoli, Brussel sprouts etc. Rearing of the insects takes place on cabbage plants in the greenhouse. At least two cages are needed for the rearing of Pieris rapae. One for the larvae and the other to contain the adults, the butterflies. In order to investigate the role of plant hormones and toxic plant chemicals in resistance to this insect pest, we demonstrate two experiments. First, determination of the role of jasmonic acid (JA - a plant hormone often indicated in resistance to insects) in resistance to the chewing insect Pieris rapae. Caterpillar growth can be compared on wild-type and mutant plants impaired in production of JA. This experiment is considered "No Choice", because larvae are forced to subsist on a single plant which synthesizes or is deficient in JA. Second, we demonstrate an experiment that investigates the role of glucosinolates, which are used as oviposition (egg-laying) signals. Here, we use WT and mutant Arabidopsis impaired in glucosinolate production in a "Choice" experiment in which female butterflies are allowed to choose to lay their eggs on plants of either genotype. This video demonstrates the experimental setup for both assays as well as representative results.Download video file.^{(215M, mov)}     

Behavioural resistance against a protozoan parasite in the monarch butterfly

1. As parasites can dramatically reduce the fitness of their hosts, there should be strong selection for hosts to evolve and maintain defence mechanisms against their parasites. One way in which hosts may protect themselves against parasitism is through altered behaviours, but such defences have been much less studied than other forms of parasite resistance. 2. We studied whether monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus L.) use altered behaviours to protect themselves and their offspring against the protozoan parasite Ophryocystis elektroscirrha (McLaughlin & Myers (1970), Journal of Protozoology, 17, p. 300). In particular, we studied whether (i) monarch larvae can avoid contact with infectious parasite spores; (ii) infected larvae preferentially consume therapeutic food plants when given a choice or increase the intake of such plants in the absence of choice; and (iii) infected female butterflies preferentially lay their eggs on medicinal plants that make their offspring less sick. 3. We found that monarch larvae were unable to avoid infectious parasite spores. Larvae were also not able to preferentially feed on therapeutic food plants or increase the ingestion of such plants. However, infected female butterflies preferentially laid their eggs on food plants that reduce parasite growth in their offspring. 4. Our results suggest that animals may use altered behaviours as a protection against parasites and that such behaviours may be limited to a single stage in the host-parasite life cycle. Our results also suggest that animals may use altered behaviours to protect their offspring instead of themselves. Thus, our study indicates that an inclusive fitness approach should be adopted to study behavioural defences against parasites.