2'-Deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinonucleosides and oligonucleotides (2'F-ANA): synthesis and physicochemical studies

Recently, hybrids of RNA and D-arabinonucleic acids (ANA) as well as the 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-D-arabinonucleic acid analog (2'F-ANA) were shown to be substrates of RNase H. This enzyme is believed to be involved in the primary mechanism by which antisense oligonucleotides cause a reduction in target RNA levels in vivo. To gain a better understanding of the properties of arabinose based oligonucleotides, we have prepared a series of 2'F-ANA sequences of homopolymeric (A and T) and mixed base composition (A, T, G and C). UV thermal melting and circular dichroic (CD) studies were used to ascertain the thermodynamic stability and helical conformation of 2'F-ANA/RNA and 2'F-ANA/DNA hybrids. It is shown that 2'F-ANA has enhanced RNA affinity relative to that of DNA and phosphorothioate DNA. The 2'-fluoroarabino modification showed favorable pairing to single-stranded DNA also. This is in sharp contrast to ANA, which forms weak ANA/DNA hybrids at best. According to the measured thermodynamic parameters for duplex formation, the increased stability of hybrids formed by 2'F-ANA (e.g., 2'F-ANA/RNA) appears to originate from conformational pre-organization of the fluorinated sugars and a favorable enthalpy of hybridization. In addition, NMR spectroscopy revealed a five-bond coupling between the 2'F and the base protons (H6/H8) of 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinonucleosides. This observation is suggestive of a through-space interaction between 2'F and H6/H8 atoms. CD experiments indicate that 2'F-ANA/RNA hybrids adopt an 'A-like' structure and show more resemblance to DNA/RNA hybrids than to the pure RNA/RNA duplex. This feature is believed to be an important factor in the mechanism that allows RNase H to discriminate between 2'F-ANA/RNA (or DNA/RNA) and RNA/RNA duplexes.     

Structural basis of cleavage by RNase H of hybrids of arabinonucleic acids and RNA

The origins of the substrate specificity of Escherichia coli RNase H1 (termed RNase H here), an enzyme that hydrolyzes the RNA strand of DNA-RNA hybrids, are not understood at present. Although the enzyme binds double-stranded RNA, no cleavage occurs with such duplexes [Lima, W. F., and Crooke, S. T. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 390]. Therefore, the hybrid substrates may not adopt a canonical A-form geometry. Furthermore, RNase H is exquisitely sensitive to chemical modification of the DNA strands in hybrid duplexes. This is particularly relevant to the RNase H-dependent pathway of antisense action. Thus, only very few of the modifications currently being evaluated as antisense therapeutics are tolerated by the enzyme, among them phosphorothioate DNA (PS-DNA). Recently, hybrids of RNA and arabinonucleic acid (ANA) as well as the 2'F-ANA analogue were shown to be substrates of RNase H [Damha, M. J., et al. (1998) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120, 12976]. Using X-ray crystallography, we demonstrate here that ANA analogues, such as 2'F-ANA [Berger, I., et al. (1998) Nucleic Acids Res. 26, 2473] and [3.3.0]bicyclo-ANA (bc-ANA), may not be able to adopt sugar puckers that are compatible with pure A- or a B-form duplex geometries, but rather prefer the intermediate O4'-endo conformation. On the basis of the observed conformations of these ANA analogues in a DNA dodecamer duplex, we have modeled a duplex of an all-C3'-endo RNA strand and an all-O4'-endo 2'F-ANA strand. This duplex exhibits a minor groove width that is intermediate between that of A-form RNA and B-form DNA, a feature that may be exploited by the enzyme in differentiating between RNA duplexes and DNA-RNA hybrids. Therefore, the combination of the established structural and functional properties of ANA analogues helps settle existing controversies concerning the discrimination of substrates by RNase H. Knowlegde of the structure of an analogue that exhibits enhanced RNA affinity while not interfering with RNase H activity may prove helpful in the design of future antisense modifications.     

Oligonucleotides comprised of alternating 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinonucleosides and D-2'-deoxyribonucleosides (2'F-ANA/DNA 'altimers') induce efficient RNA cleavage mediated by RNase H

Chimeric oligonucleotides comprised of alternating residues of 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-D-arabinonucleic acid (2'F-ANA) and DNA were synthesized and evaluated for an important antisense property-the ability to elicit ribonuclease H (RNase H) degradation of complementary RNA. Experiments used both human RNase HII and Escherichia coli RNase HI. Mixed backbone oligomers comprising alternating three-nucleotide segments of 2'F-ANA and three-nucleotide segments of DNA were the most efficient at eliciting RNase H degradation of target RNA, and were significantly better than oligonucleotides entirely composed of DNA, suggesting that these mixed backbone oligonucleotides may be potent antisense agents.     

PROPERTIES OF ARABINONUCLEIC ACIDS (ANA & 20′F-ANA): IMPLICATIONS FOR THE DESIGN OF ANTISENSE THERAPEUTICS THAT INVOKE RNASE H CLEAVAGE OF RNA

Inversion of configuration of the C2′ position of RNA leads to a very unique nucleic acid structure: arabinonucleic acid (ANA). ANA, and its 2′-fluoro derivative (2′ F-ANA) form hybrids with RNA that are capable of activating RNase H, resulting in cleavage of the RNA strand. In this paper, we review the properties of duplexes formed between ANA (or 2′F-ANA) and its RNA complement. These studies support the notion that RNase H is sensitive to the minor groove dimensions of the hybrid substrate.     

Antisense inhibition of Flk-1 by oligonucleotides composed of 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabino- and 2'-deoxy-nucleosides

The design of new antisense oligomers with improved binding affinity for targeted RNA, while still activating RNase H, is a major research area in medicinal chemistry. RNase H recognizes the RNA-DNA duplex and cleaves the complementary mRNA strand, providing the main mechanism by which antisense oligomers elicit their activities. It has been shown that configuration inversion at the C2' position of the DNA sugar moiety (arabinonucleic acid, ANA), combined with the substitution of the 2'OH group by a fluorine atom (2'F-ANA) increases the oligomer's binding affinity for targeted RNA. In the present study, we evaluated the antisense activity of mixed-backbone phosphorothioate oligomers composed of 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinose and 2'-deoxyribose sugars (S-2'F-ANA-DNA chimeras). We determined their abilities to inhibit the protein expression and phosphorylation of Flk-1, a vascular endothelial growth factor receptor (VEGF), and VEGF biological effects on endothelial cell proliferation, migration, and platelet-activating factor synthesis. Treatment of endothelial cells with chimeric oligonucleotides reduced Flk-1 protein expression and phosphorylation more efficiently than with phosphorothioate antisenses (S-DNA). Nonetheless, these two classes of antisenses inhibited VEGF activities equally. Herein, we also demonstrated the capacity of the chimeric oligomers to elicit RNase H activity and their improved binding affinity for complementary RNA as compared with S-DNA.     

2'-Fluoroarabino- and arabinonucleic acid show different conformations, resulting in deviating RNA affinities and processing of their heteroduplexes with RNA by RNase H

2'-Deoxy-2'-fluoro-arabinonucleic acid (FANA) and arabinonucleic acid (ANA) paired to RNA are substrates of RNase H. The conformation of the natural DNA/RNA hybrid substrates appears to be neither A-form nor B-form. Consistent with this, the conformations of FANA and ANA were found to be intermediate between the A- and B-forms. However, FANA opposite RNA is preferred by RNase H over ANA, and the RNA affinity of FANA considerably exceeds that of ANA. By investigating the conformational boundaries of FANA and ANA residues in crystal structures of A- and B-form DNA duplexes at atomic resolution, we demonstrate that FANA and ANA display subtle conformational differences. The structural data provide insight into the structural requirements at the catalytic site of RNase H. They also allow conclusions with regard to the relative importance of stereoelectronic effects and hydration as modulators of RNA affinity.     

Synthesis and biophysical properties of arabinonucleic acids (ANA): circular dichroic spectra, melting temperatures, and ribonuclease H susceptibility of ANA.RNA hybrid duplexes

Arabinonucleic acid (ANA), the 2'-epimer of RNA, was synthesized from arabinonucleoside building blocks by conventional solid-phase phosphoramidite synthesis. In addition, the biochemical and physicochemical properties of ANA strands of mixed base composition were evaluated for the first time. ANA exhibit certain characteristics desirable for use as antisense agents. They form duplexes with complementary RNA, direct RNase H degradation of target RNA molecules, and display resistance to 3'-exonucleases. Since RNA does not elicit RNase H activity, our findings establish that the stereochemistry at C2' (ANA versus RNA) is a key determinant in the activation of the enzyme RNase H. Inversion of stereochemistry at C2' is most likely accompanied by a conformational change in the furanose sugar pucker from C3'-endo (RNA) to C2'-endo ("DNA-like") pucker (ANA) [Noronha and Damha (1998) Nucleic Acids Res. 26, 2665-2671; Venkateswarlu and Ferguson (1999) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121, 5609-5610]. This produces ANA/RNA hybrids whose CD spectra (i.e., helical conformation) are more similar to the native DNA/RNA substrates than to those of the pure RNA/RNA duplex. These features, combined with the fact that ara-2'OH groups project into the major groove of the helix (where they should not interfere with RNase H binding), help to explain the RNase H activity of ANA/RNA hybrids.     

Synthesis and properties of oligonucleotide chimeras containing 5'-amino-2'-deoxy-2'-fluoroarabinonucleosides

Oligonucleotide analogues comprised of 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinose units joined via P3'-N5' phosphoramidate linkages (2'F-ANA(5'N)) were prepared for the first time. Among the compounds prepared were a series of 2'OMe-RNA-[GAP]-2'OMe-RNA 'chimeras', whereby the "GAP" consisted of DNA, DNA(5'N), 2'F-ANA or 2'F-ANA(5'N) segments. The chimeras with the 2'F-ANA and DNA gaps exhibited the highest affinity towards a complementary RNA target, followed by the 5'-amino derivatives, i.e., 2'F-ANA > DNA > 2'F-ANA(5'N) > DNA(5'N). Importantly, hybrids between these chimeras and target RNA were all substrates of both human RNase HII and E. coli RNase HI. In terms of efficiency of the chimera in recruiting the bacterial enzyme, the following order was observed: gap DNA > 2'F-ANA > 2'F-ANA(5'N) > DNA(5'N). The corresponding relative rates observed with the human enzyme were: gap DNA > 2'F-ANA(5'N) > 2'F-ANA > DNA(5'N).     

Solution structure of an arabinonucleic acid (ANA)/RNA duplex in a chimeric hairpin: comparison with 2′-fluoro-ANA/RNA and DNA/RNA hybrids

Hybrids of RNA and arabinonucleic acid (ANA) as well as the 2′-fluoro-ANA analog (2′F-ANA) were recently shown to be substrates of the enzyme RNase H. Although RNase H binds to double-stranded RNA, no cleavage occurs with such duplexes. Therefore, knowledge of the structure of ANA/RNA hybrids may prove helpful in the design of future antisense oligonucleotide analogs. In this study, we have determined the NMR solution structures of ANA/RNA and DNA/RNA hairpin duplexes and compared them to the recently published structure of a 2′F-ANA/RNA hairpin duplex. We demonstrate here that the sugars of RNA nucleotides of the ANA/RNA hairpin stem adopt the C3′-endo (north, A-form) conformation, whereas those of the ANA strand adopt a ‘rigid’ O4′-endo (east) sugar pucker. The DNA strand of the DNA/RNA hairpin stem is flexible, but the average DNA/RNA hairpin structural parameters are close to the ANA/RNA and 2′F-ANA/RNA hairpin parameters. The minor groove width of ANA/RNA, 2′F-ANA/RNA and DNA/RNA helices is 9.0 ± 0.5 Å, a value that is intermediate between that of A- and B-form duplexes. These results rationalize the ability of ANA/RNA and 2′F-ANA/RNA hybrids to elicit RNase H activity.     

Duplex recognition by oligonucleotides containing 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-D-arabinose and 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-D-ribose. Intermolecular 2'-OH-phosphate contacts versus sugar puckering in the stabilization of triple-helical complexes

To gain insight into the origins of the large binding affinity of RNA toward target duplexes, 2'-deoxy-2'-fluororibonucleic acid (2'F-RNA) and 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoroarabinonucleic acid (2'F-ANA) were tested for their ability to recognize duplex DNA, duplex RNA, and RNA-DNA hybrids. 2'F-RNA, 2'F-ANA, and the corresponding control single-stranded (ss) DNA strands were shown to form triple-helical complexes only with duplex DNA and hybrid DNA (Pu)-RNA (Py), but not with duplex RNA and hybrid RNA (Pu)-DNA (Py). In contrast, an RNA third strand recognized all four possible duplexes (DD, DR, RD, and RR) as previously demonstrated by Roberts and Crothers [(1992) Science 258, 1463-1466]. The 2'F-RNA (C3'-endo) strand exhibited significantly reduced affinity for duplexes compared to an unmodified RNA (C3'-endo) strand. These findings are consistent with the intermolecular 2'-OH-phosphate contact mechanism proposed by Escudé et al. [(1993) Nucleic Acids Res. 24, 5547-5553], as a ribo 2'-F atom should not interact with a negatively charged phosphate. In addition, they emphasize the role of the 2'-OH ribose as a general recognition and binding determinant of RNA. The 2'-F arabino modification (2'F-ANA, C2'-endo) led to a considerable increase in the binding affinity for duplex DNA, as compared to those of DNA and 2'F-RNA third strands. This is likely to be the result of a greater population of C2'-endo pucker of the 2'F-ANA compared to DNA. The enhancement observed for 2'F-ANA strands toward duplex DNA is comparable to that observed with 2'-OMe RNA. Since 2'F-ANA has been shown to be more resistant to nuclease degradation than DNA, these results are likely to stimulate experimental work on arabinose derivatives in laboratories concerned with targeting DNA sequences in vivo ("antigene" strategy).     

Functional analysis of the domain organization of Trypanosoma brucei RNase HI

The structure-function relationship of Trypanosoma brucei RNase HI was investigated by evaluating the abilities of truncated forms of the enzyme to convert RNase H substrate to product. Our studies identify a 42-amino-acid noncanonical RNase HI spacer domain essential for function. We also show that the enzyme's nuclear localization domain is not required for RNase H activity but functions as an RNA binding domain which modulates the enzyme's Mn(2+)-dependent activity. These findings show that the enzyme's RNA binding/nuclear targeting and RNase H activities are organized into discrete N- and C-terminal domains with boundaries established by its spacer domain. This is the first report of the unusual structure to function relationship of a protozoal RNase H. This relationship may be conserved in other eukaryotic RNases H suggesting that criteria preserving their structure and function may be important to their roles in nucleic acid metabolism.     

Crystal structures of RNase H2 in complex with nucleic acid reveal the mechanism of RNA-DNA junction recognition and cleavage

Two classes of RNase H hydrolyze RNA of RNA/DNA hybrids. In contrast to RNase H1 that requires four ribonucleotides for cleavage, RNase H2 can nick duplex DNAs containing a single ribonucleotide, suggesting different in vivo substrates. We report here the crystal structures of a type 2 RNase H in complex with substrates containing a (5')RNA-DNA(3') junction. They revealed a unique mechanism of recognition and substrate-assisted cleavage. A conserved tyrosine residue distorts the nucleic acid at the junction, allowing the substrate to function in catalysis by participating in coordination of the active site metal ion. The biochemical and structural properties of RNase H2 explain the preference of the enzyme for junction substrates and establish the structural and mechanistic differences with RNase H1. Junction recognition is important for the removal of RNA embedded in DNA and may play an important role in DNA replication and repair.     

Induction of RNase H activity by Arabinose-peptide nucleic acid chimeras

We report the syntheses of chimeras of peptide nucleic acid (PNA) with DNA and 2'-deoxy 2'-fluoroarabinonucleic acid (2'-FANA). Chimeric oligomers possessing a single central PNA insert were capable of forming hybrid duplexes with complementary RNA, although with diminished thermal stability in comparison to the unmodified oligomers. We subsequently determined the ability of the DNA and 2'-FANA oligomers of mixed-base composition to elicit human RNase H1 degradation of complementary RNA that was either unstructured or as a hairpin. In the case of the more rigid FANA strand, a PNA insert led to a higher ability of the chimera to direct the degradation of both types of RNA targets. Generally, the enhancement observed was greater for a butanediol linker than for a more rigid PNA linker. Along with previous work, these studies suggest that the general flexibility associated with an acyclic insert (e.g., butyl vs PNA)--and not necessarily the presence of local structural imperfections in the heteroduplex--is beneficial for RNase H1 activity. As well, there are implications to the charge nature of non-nucleotide inserts (neutral vs negative) and their ability to maintain RNase H activity that may serve to direct further design considerations. Together, these studies support the notion that flexibility of antisense oligonucleotide (AON)/RNA hybrids is essential for high RNase H catalysis, in which an enzyme-induced altered trajectory of the bound AON/RNA substrate could facilitate optimal interaction with the catalytic site of RNase H.     

PCNA directs type 2 RNase H activity on DNA replication and repair substrates

Ribonuclease H2 is the major nuclear enzyme degrading cellular RNA/DNA hybrids in eukaryotes and the sole nuclease known to be able to hydrolyze ribonucleotides misincorporated during genomic replication. Mutation in RNASEH2 causes Aicardi-Goutières syndrome, an auto-inflammatory disorder that may arise from nucleic acid byproducts generated during DNA replication. Here, we report the crystal structures of Archaeoglobus fulgidus RNase HII in complex with PCNA, and human PCNA bound to a C-terminal peptide of RNASEH2B. In the archaeal structure, three binding modes are observed as the enzyme rotates about a flexible hinge while anchored to PCNA by its PIP-box motif. PCNA binding promotes RNase HII activity in a hinge-dependent manner. It enhances both cleavage of ribonucleotides misincorporated in DNA duplexes, and the comprehensive hydrolysis of RNA primers formed during Okazaki fragment maturation. In addition, PCNA imposes strand specificity on enzyme function, and by localizing RNase H2 and not RNase H1 to nuclear replication foci in vivo it ensures that RNase H2 is the dominant RNase H activity during nuclear replication. Our findings provide insights into how type 2 RNase H activity is directed during genome replication and repair, and suggest a mechanism by which RNase H2 may suppress generation of immunostimulatory nucleic acids.     

Crystal structure of RNase H3–substrate complex reveals parallel evolution of RNA/DNA hybrid recognition

RNases H participate in the replication and maintenance of genomic DNA. RNase H1 cleaves the RNA strand of RNA/DNA hybrids, and RNase H2 in addition hydrolyzes the RNA residue of RNA–DNA junctions. RNase H3 is structurally closely related to RNases H2, but its biochemical properties are similar to type 1 enzymes. Its unique N-terminal substrate-binding domain (N-domain) is related to TATA-binding protein. Here, we report the first crystal structure of RNase H3 in complex with its RNA/DNA substrate. Just like RNases H1, type 3 enzyme recognizes the 2′-OH groups of the RNA strand and detects the DNA strand by binding a phosphate group and inducing B-form conformation. Moreover, the N-domain recognizes RNA and DNA in a manner that is highly similar to the hybrid-binding domain of RNases H1. Our structure demonstrates a remarkable example of parallel evolution of the elements used in the specific recognition of RNA and DNA.     

The SCO2299 gene from Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2) encodes a bifunctional enzyme consisting of an RNase H domain and an acid phosphatase domain

The SCO2299 gene from Streptomyces coelicolor encodes a single peptide consisting of 497 amino acid residues. Its N-terminal region shows high amino acid sequence similarity to RNase HI, whereas its C-terminal region bears similarity to the CobC protein, which is involved in the synthesis of cobalamin. The SCO2299 gene suppressed a temperature-sensitive growth defect of an Escherichia coli RNase H-deficient strain, and the recombinant SCO2299 protein cleaved an RNA strand of RNA.DNA hybrid in vitro. The N-terminal domain of the SCO2299 protein, when overproduced independently, exhibited RNase H activity at a similar level to the full length protein. On the other hand, the C-terminal domain showed no CobC-like activity but an acid phosphatase activity. The full length protein also exhibited acid phosphatase activity at almost the same level as the C-terminal domain alone. These results indicate that RNase H and acid phosphatase activities of the full length SCO2299 protein depend on its N-terminal and C-terminal domains, respectively. The physiological functions of the SCO2299 gene and the relation between RNase H and acid phosphatase remain to be determined. However, the bifunctional enzyme examined here is a novel style in the Type 1 RNase H family. Additionally, S. coelicolor is the first example of an organism whose genome contains three active RNase H genes.