Cooperative signals governing ARF-mdm2 interaction and nucleolar localization of the complex

The ARF tumor suppressor protein stabilizes p53 by antagonizing its negative regulator, Mdm2 (Hdm2 in humans). Both mouse p19(ARF) and human p14(ARF) bind to the central region of Mdm2 (residues 210 to 304), a segment that does not overlap with its N-terminal p53-binding domain, nuclear import or export signals, or C-terminal RING domain required for Mdm2 E3 ubiquitin ligase activity. The N-terminal 37 amino acids of mouse p19(ARF) are necessary and sufficient for binding to Mdm2, localization of Mdm2 to nucleoli, and p53-dependent cell cycle arrest. Although a nucleolar localization signal (NrLS) maps within a different segment (residues 82 to 101) of the human p14(ARF) protein, binding to Mdm2 and nucleolar import of ARF-Mdm2 complexes are both required for cell cycle arrest induced by either the mouse or human ARF proteins. Because many codons of mouse ARF mRNA are not recognized by the most abundant bacterial tRNAs, we synthesized ARF minigenes containing preferred bacterial codons. Using bacterially produced ARF polypeptides and chemically synthesized peptides conjugated to Sepharose, residues 1 to 14 and 26 to 37 of mouse p19(ARF) were found to interact independently and cooperatively with Mdm2, while residues 15 to 25 were dispensable for binding. Paradoxically, residues 26 to 37 of mouse p19(ARF) are also essential for ARF nucleolar localization in the absence of Mdm2. However, the mobilization of the p19(ARF)-Mdm2 complex into nucleoli also requires a cryptic NrLS within the Mdm2 C-terminal RING domain. The Mdm2 NrLS is unmasked upon ARF binding, and its deletion prevents import of the ARF-Mdm2 complex into nucleoli. Collectively, the results suggest that ARF binding to Mdm2 induces a conformational change that facilitates nucleolar import of the ARF-Mdm2 complex and p53-dependent cell cycle arrest. Hence, the ARF-Mdm2 interaction can be viewed as bidirectional, with each protein being capable of regulating the subnuclear localization of the other.     

Oligomerization of the human ARF tumor suppressor and its response to oxidative stress

The tumor suppressor ARF plays an important role as an inhibitor of the Mdm2-mediated degradation of p53. Here we demonstrate that human ARF (p14ARF) can form homo-oligomers. The stability of the oligomers is favored by oxidizing agents in a reversible fashion and involves all three cysteine residues in p14ARF. Furthermore, the effect of p14ARF in clonogenic assays is moderately but reproducibly increased by the mutation of its cysteine residues. We also observed that altering the amino terminus of p14ARF resulted in the appearance of remarkably stable oligomers. This indicates that the amino terminus of p14ARF interferes with the ability of the protein to form multimeric complexes. These observations suggest that p14ARF activity may be linked to its oligomerization status and sensitive to the redox status of the cell.     

Targeting a nucleolar SUMO protease for degradation: A mechanism by which ARF induces SUMO conjugation

The p19^ARF p14^ARF in humans protein acts as a tumour suppressor through p53 dependent and independent mechanisms. A well-established role for ARF is to regulate the post-translational modification of substrate proteins with ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like molecules such as SUMO. It is now evident that induction of ARF causes a dramatic accumulation of SUMO conjugates and this has been related to the p53 independent functions of ARF. The majority of these conjugates appear to accumulate in the nucleolus where most of ARF is also found. An obvious function for ARF, which would result in increase of SUMOylation, is to act as an atypical SUMO E3-ligase. Indeed, initial studies suggested that ARF could directly interact with the SUMO E2-conjugating enzyme Ubc9 and therefore bringing the SUMO conjugation machinery in close proximity to its interacting substrates.¹ However, the highly basic charged nature of ARF makes biochemical analysis difficult and there is no clear demonstration that ARF can fulfill the criteria for an E3-ligase in vitro. Therefore, the mechanism(s) behind this phenomenon are not currently understood. As with ubiquitination, SUMO conjugation is a dynamic process controlled by E3-ligases and proteases that specifically remove SUMO from substrates. In this issue of Cell Cycle studies from the Sherr lab suggest that ARF can increase SUMO conjugation by controlling the stability of the nucleolar SUMO protease SENP3.² Recent studies have shown that SENP3 can deconjugate SUMO-2 and SUMO-3 from substrates including nucleophosmin (NPM). NPM is a nucleolar protein, which among other processes is involved in the processing of rRNA during ribosome biosynthesis. NPM interacts with ARF and this results in increased SUMOylation of NPM. SENP3 can counteract the effect of ARF by deconjugating SUMO from NPM and this appears to be critical for NPM function in rRNA processing.³ The new study now suggests that there is an opposing functional relationship between ARF and SENP3. ARF promotes phosphorylation dependent ubiquitination of SENP3, which results in SENP3 degradation and increase in NPM SUMO conjugation. In this process, NPM seems to act as a "platform" for ARF and SENP3, bringing in close proximity its two regulators. The new study suggests an interesting and complex mechanism by which ARF can control SUMOylation. It is now evident that post-translational modifications cooperate to control protein function. The new data suggest that ARF engages phosphorylation to promote ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation of a SUMO protease. This model would propose the existence of a kinase/phosphatase and an E3-ubiquitin ligase/de-ubiquitinating enzyme set which would cooperate their actions to control the stability of SENP3. Given that ARF has multiple binding partners, it would not be surprising that ARF would interact with components of the above enzymatic steps and control their activity. It would therefore be interesting to identify the role of ARF in this process. It is not clear whether degradation of SENP3 per se is sufficient to induce NPM SUMO conjugation and if this is the case which SUMO E3-ligases drive the forward reaction. Even if in this study an interaction of ARF with Ubc9 could not be demonstrated it may be the case that ARF mediates both the degradation of SENP3 and recruitment of the SUMO conjugation machinery, which will result in fast and efficient accumulation of SUMOylated NPM. Another possibility is the effect of ARF on NPM stability itself. Previous studies have shown that ARF can induce ubiquitin-mediated degradation of NPM.⁴ As NPM is important to prevent destabilisation of SENP3, ARF-mediated degradation of NPM could be part of SENP3 degradation. Another point that arises from this is the site of degradation for SENP3. Nucleoli have been suggested to be deficient for proteasomal activity, suggesting that ARF through the phosphorylation/ubiquitination events may alter the localisation/mobility of SENP3 making it susceptible to nucleoplasmic/cytoplasmic proteasomal degradation. The effect of ARF in controlling protein ubiquitination is now well established. Interaction of ARF with E3-ligases such as Mdm2 and ARF-BP1/Mule inhibits their function resulting in inhibition of p53 proteasomal degradation.^5,6 Therefore, the ability of ARF to induce ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation of SENP3 and NPM shows a complex and diverse role for ARF to control protein stability. Further experiments will show whether the ability of ARF to promote degradation of SENP3 or possibly other SUMO proteases is a general mechanism through which ARF induces SUMO conjugation of its binding partners or that the NPM/SENP3 system is a unique example.

References

1. Rizos H, Woodruff S, Kefford RF. p14ARF interacts with the SUMO-conjugating enzyme Ubc9 and promotes the sumoylation of its binding partners. Cell Cycle 2005; 4:597-603. 2. Kuo ML, den Besten W, Thomas MC, Sherr CJ. Arf-induced turnover of the nucleolar nucleophosmin-associated SUMO-2/3 protease Senp3. Cell Cycle 2008; 7:In this issue 3. Haindl M, Harasim T, Eick D, Muller S. The nucleolar SUMO-specific protease SENP3 reverses SUMO modification of nucleophosmin and is required for rRNA processing. EMBO Rep 2008; 9:273-9 4. Itahana K, Bhat KP, Jin A, Itahana Y, Hawke D, Kobayashi R, Zhang Y. Tumor suppressor ARF degrades B23, a nucleolar protein involved in ribosome biogenesis and cell proliferation. Mol Cell 2003; 12:1151-64. 5. Xirodimas D, Saville MK, Edling C, Lane DP, LaÃ?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?­n S. Different effects of p14ARF on the levels of ubiquitinated p53 and Mdm2 in vivo. Oncogene 2001; 20:4972-83. 6. Chen D, Kon N, Li M, Zhang W, Qin J, Gu W. ARF-BP1/Mule is a critical mediator of the ARF tumor suppressor. Cell 2005; 121:1071-83.     

p14ARF inhibits the growth of p53 deficient cells in a cell-specific manner

While p14(ARF) suppression of tumorigenesis in a p53-dependent manner is well studied, the mechanism by which p14(ARF) inhibits tumorigenesis independently of p53 remains elusive. A variety of factors have been reported to play a role in this latter process. We report here that p14(ARF) displays different effects on the anchorage-dependent and -independent growth of p53-null/Mdm2 wild type cells. p14(ARF) blocks both the anchorage-dependent and-independent (soft agar) proliferation of 293T and p53(-/-) HCT116, but not p53-null H1299 lung carcinoma cells. While p14(ARF) had no effect on the anchorage-dependent proliferation of p53(-/-) MEFs and Ras12V-transformed p53(-/-) MEFs, it inhibited the growth of Ras12V-transformed p53(-/-) MEFs in soft agar. Furthermore, ectopic expression of p14(ARF) did not lead to degradation of the E2F1 protein and did not result in the reduction of E2F1 activity detected by two E2F1 responsible promoters, Apaf1 and p14(ARF) promoter, in 293T, p53(-/-) HCT116, and H1299 cells. This is consistent with our observations that p14(ARF) did not result in G1 arrest, but induced apoptosis via Bax up-regulation. Taken together, our data demonstrate that the response of p53-null cells to ARF is cell type dependent and involves factors other than Mdm2 and E2F1.     

p14 Arf promotes small ubiquitin-like modifier conjugation of Werners helicase

Here we demonstrate a novel p53-independent interaction between the nucleolar tumor suppressors, p14 Arf and Werners helicase (WRN). Binding of p14 Arf to WRN is multivalent and resembles the binding of p14 Arf to Mdm2. Residues 2-14 and 82-101 of p14 Arf and residues in the central region and C terminus of WRN have particular importance for binding. p14 Arf promotes small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) modification of WRN in a synergistic manner with the SUMO-conjugating enzyme, UBCH9. p14 Arf causes redistribution of WRN within the nucleus, and this effect is reversed by expression of a SUMO-specific protease, thus implicating the SUMO conjugation pathway in WRN re-localization. We establish that the ability to promote SUMO conjugation is a general property of the p14 Arf tumor suppressor.     

Hypophosphorylation of Mdm2 augments p53 stability

The Mdm2 protein mediates ubiquitylation and degradation of p53 and is a key regulator of this tumor suppressor. More recently, it has been shown that Mdm2 is highly phosphorylated within its central acidic domain. In order to address the issue of how these modifications might regulate Mdm2 function, putative phosphorylation sites within this domain were substituted, individually or in pairs, with alanine residues. Mutants with serine-to-alanine substitutions between residues 244 and 260 abolished or at least reduced the capacity of Mdm2 to promote p53 degradation. In each case, loss of degradation function was independent of the ability to bind to p53 or p14ARF. Moreover, each of the Mdm2 mutants completely retained the capacity to act as a ubiquitin ligase in vivo. Thus, ubiquitylation and degradation can be uncoupled. Two-dimensional phosphopeptide mapping coupled with the use of phospho-specific antibodies revealed that Mdm2 is phosphorylated physiologically at several sites within this region, consistent with the idea that phosphorylation is important for Mdm2 activity. Strikingly, treatment of cells with ionizing radiation resulted in a significant decrease in the phosphorylation of residues that are important for p53 turnover. This hypophosphorylation preceded p53 accumulation. These findings indicate that Mdm2 contributes an additional function toward the degradation of p53 that is distinct from its ubiquitin ligase activity and is regulated by phosphorylation. Our model suggests that hypophosphorylation of Mdm2 in response to ionizing irradiation inactivates this novel function, thereby contributing to p53 stabilization.     

Association of p19(ARF) with Mdm2 inhibits ubiquitin ligase activity of Mdm2 for tumor suppressor p53.

We have demonstrated previously that the oncoprotein Mdm2 has a ubiquitin ligase activity for the tumor suppressor p53 protein. In the present study, we characterize this ubiquitin ligase activity of Mdm2. We first demonstrate the ubiquitination of several p53 point mutants and deletion mutants by Mdm2. The point mutants, which cannot bind to Mdm2, are not ubiquitinated by Mdm2. The ubiquitination of the C-terminal deletion mutants, which contain so-called Mdm2-binding sites, is markedly decreased, compared with that of wild-type p53. The binding of Mdm2 to p53 is essential for ubiquitination, but p53's tertiary structure and/or C-terminal region may also be important for this reaction. DNA-dependent protein kinase is known to phosphorylate p53 on Mdm2-binding sites, where DNA damage induces phosphorylation, and p53 phosphorylated by this kinase is not a good substrate for Mdm2. This suggests that DNA damage-induced phosphorylation stabilizes p53 by inhibiting its ubiquitination by Mdm2. We further investigated whether the tumor suppressor p19(ARF) affects the ubiquitin ligase activity of Mdm2 for p53. The activity of p19(ARF)-bound Mdm2 was found to be lower than that of free Mdm2, suggesting that p19(ARF) promotes the stabilization of p53 by inactivating Mdm2.     

MdmX binding to ARF affects Mdm2 protein stability and p53 transactivation

Regulation of p53 involves a complex network of protein interactions. The primary regulator of p53 protein stability is the Mdm2 protein. ARF and MdmX are two proteins that have recently been shown to inhibit Mdm2-mediated degradation of p53 via distinct associations with Mdm2. We demonstrate here that ARF is capable of interacting with MdmX and in a manner similar to its association with Mdm2, sequestering MdmX within the nucleolus. The sequestration of MdmX by ARF results in an increase in p53 transactivation. In addition, the redistribution of MdmX by ARF requires that a nucleolar localization signal be present on MdmX. Although expression of either MdmX or ARF leads to Mdm2 stabilization, coexpression of both MdmX and ARF results in a decrease in Mdm2 protein levels. Similarly, increasing ARF protein levels in the presence of constant MdmX and Mdm2 leads to a dose-dependent decrease in Mdm2 levels. Under these conditions, ARF can synergistically reverse the ability of Mdm2 and MdmX to inhibit p53-dependent transactivation. Finally, the association and redistribution of MdmX by ARF has no effect on the protein stability of either ARF or MdmX. Taken together, these results demonstrate that the interaction between MdmX and ARF represents a novel pathway for regulating Mdm2 protein levels. Additionally, both MdmX and Mdm2, either individually or together, are capable of antagonizing the effects of the ARF tumor suppressor on p53 activity.     

Nucleophosmin (B23) targets ARF to nucleoli and inhibits its function

The ARF tumor suppressor is a nucleolar protein that activates p53-dependent checkpoints by binding Mdm2, a p53 antagonist. Despite persuasive evidence that ARF can bind and inactivate Mdm2 in the nucleoplasm, the prevailing view is that ARF exerts its growth-inhibitory activities from within the nucleolus. We suggest ARF primarily functions outside the nucleolus and provide evidence that it is sequestered and held inactive in that compartment by a nucleolar phosphoprotein, nucleophosmin (NPM). Most cellular ARF is bound to NPM regardless of whether cells are proliferating or growth arrested, indicating that ARF-NPM association does not correlate with growth suppression. Notably, ARF binds NPM through the same domains that mediate nucleolar localization and Mdm2 binding, suggesting that NPM could control ARF localization and compete with Mdm2 for ARF association. Indeed, NPM knockdown markedly enhanced ARF-Mdm2 association and diminished ARF nucleolar localization. Those events correlated with greater ARF-mediated growth suppression and p53 activation. Conversely, NPM overexpression antagonized ARF function while increasing its nucleolar localization. These data suggest that NPM inhibits ARF's p53-dependent activity by targeting it to nucleoli and impairing ARF-Mdm2 association.     

Nucleotide binding by the Mdm2 RING domain facilitates Arf-independent Mdm2 nucleolar localization

The RING domain of Mdm2 contains a conserved Walker A or P loop motif that is a characteristic of nucleotide binding proteins. We found that Mdm2 binds adenine-containing nucleotides preferentially and that nucleotide binding leads to a conformational change in the Mdm2 C terminus. Although nucleotide binding is not required for Mdm2 E3 ubiquitin ligase activity, we show that nucleotide binding-defective P loop mutants are impaired in p14(ARF)-independent nucleolar localization both in vivo and in vitro. Consistent with this, ATP-bound Mdm2 is preferentially localized to the nucleolus. Indeed, we identify a unique amino acid substitution in the P loop motif (K454A) that uncouples nucleolar localization and E3 ubiquitin ligase activity of Mdm2 and leads to upregulation of the E3 activity both in human cells and in Caenorhabditis elegans. We propose that nucleotide binding-facilitated nucleolar localization of Mdm2 is an evolutionarily conserved regulator of Mdm2 activity.     

p53-independent apoptosis is induced by the p19ARF tumor suppressor

p19(ARF) is a potent tumor suppressor. By inactivating Mdm2, p19(ARF) upregulates p53 activities to induce cell cycle arrest and sensitize cells to apoptosis in the presence of collateral signals. It has also been demonstrated that cell cycle arrest is induced by overexpressed p19(ARF) in p53-deficient mouse embryonic fibroblasts, only in the absence of the Mdm2 gene. Here, we show that apoptosis can be induced without additional apoptosis signals by expression of p19(ARF) using an adenovirus-mediated expression system in p53-intact cell lines as well as p53-deficient cell lines. Also, in primary mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) lacking p53/ARF, p53-independent apoptosis is induced irrespective of Mdm2 status by expression of p19(ARF). In agreement, p19(ARF)-mediated apoptosis in U2OS cells, but not in Saos2 cells, was attenuated by coexpression of Mdm2. We thus conclude that there is a p53-independent pathway for p19(ARF)-induced apoptosis that is insensitive to inhibition by Mdm2.     

p14ARF activates a Tip60-dependent and p53-independent ATM/ATR/CHK pathway in response to genotoxic stress

p14ARF is a tumor suppressor that controls a well-described p53/Mdm2-dependent checkpoint in response to oncogenic signals. Here, new insights into the tumor-suppressive function of p14ARF are provided. We previously showed that p14ARF can induce a p53-independent G2 cell cycle arrest. In this study, we demonstrate that the activation of ATM/ATR/CHK signaling pathways contributes to this G2 checkpoint and highlight the interrelated roles of p14ARF and the Tip60 protein in the initiation of this DNA damage-signaling cascade. We show that Tip60 is a new direct p14ARF binding partner and that its expression is upregulated and required for ATM/CHK2 activation in response to p14ARF. Strikingly, both p14ARF and Tip60 products accumulate following a cell treatment with alkylating agents and are absolutely required for ATM/CHK2 activation in this setting. Moreover, and consistent with p14ARF being a determinant of CHK2 phosphorylation in lung carcinogenesis, a strong correlation between p14ARF and phospho-CHK2 (Thr68) protein expression is observed in human lung tumors (P < 0.00006). Overall, these data point to a novel regulatory pathway that mediates the p53-independent negative-cell-growth control of p14ARF. Inactivation of this pathway is likely to contribute to lung carcinogenesis.     

Multiple domains of the mouse p19ARF tumor suppressor are involved in p53-independent apoptosis

The ARF (p19ARF for the mouse ARF consisting of 169 amino acids and p14ARF for the human ARF consisting of 132 amino acids) genes upregulate p53 activities to induce cell cycle arrest and sensitize cells to apoptosis by inhibiting Mdm2 activity. p53-independent apoptosis also is induced by ectopic expression of p19ARF. We constructed various deletion mutants of p19ARF with a cre/loxP-regulated adenoviral vector to determine the regions of p19ARF which are responsible for p53-independent apoptosis. Ectopic expression of the C-terminal region (named C40) of p19ARF whose primary sequence is unique to the rodent ARF induced prominent apoptosis in p53-deficient mouse embryo fibroblasts. Relatively low-grade but significant apoptosis also was induced in p53-deficient mouse embryo fibroblasts by ectopic expression of p19ARF1-129, a p19ARF deletion mutant deficient in the C40 region. In contrast, ectopic expression of the wild-type p14ARF did not induce significant apoptosis in human cells. Taken together, we concluded that p53-independent apoptosis was mediated through multiple regions of the mouse ARF including C40, and the ability of the ARF gene to mediate p53-independent apoptosis has been not well conserved during mammalian evolution.     

Mdm2 is a RING finger-dependent ubiquitin protein ligase for itself and p53

Mdm2 has been shown to regulate p53 stability by targeting the p53 protein for proteasomal degradation. We now report that Mdm2 is a ubiquitin protein ligase (E3) for p53 and that its activity is dependent on its RING finger. Furthermore, we show that Mdm2 mediates its own ubiquitination in a RING finger-dependent manner, which requires no eukaryotic proteins other than ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1) and an ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (E2). It is apparent, therefore, that Mdm2 manifests an intrinsic capacity to mediate ubiquitination. Mutation of putative zinc coordination residues abrogated this activity, as did chelation of divalent cations. After cation chelation, the full activity could be restored by addition of zinc. We further demonstrate that the degradation of p53 and Mdm2 in cells requires additional potential zinc-coordinating residues beyond those required for the intrinsic activity of Mdm2 in vitro. Replacement of the Mdm2 RING with that of another protein (Praja1) reconstituted ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation of Mdm2. However, this RING was ineffective in ubiquitination and proteasomal targeting of p53, suggesting that there may be specificity at the level of the RING in the recognition of heterologous substrates.