Sequence specificity of illegitimate plasmid recombination in Bacillus subtilis: possible recognition sites for DNA topoisomerase I.

Previous work in our group indicated that structural plasmid instability in Bacillus subtilis is often caused by illegitimate recombination between non-repeated sequences, characterized by a relatively high AT content. Recently we developed a positive selection vector for analysis of plasmid recombination events in B. subtilis which enables measurement of recombination frequencies without interference of selective growth differences of cells carrying wild-type or deleted plasmids. Here we have used this system to further analyse the sequence specificity of illegitimate plasmid recombination events and to assess the role of the host-encoded DNA topoisomerase I enzyme in this process. Several lines of evidence suggest that single-strand DNA nicks introduced by DNA topoisomerase I are a major source of plasmid deletions in pGP100. First, strains overproducing DNA topoisomerase I showed increased levels of plasmid deletion. Second, these deletions occurred predominantly (>90% of the recombinants) between non-repeated DNA sequences, the majority of which resemble potential DNA topoisomerase I target sites. Sequence alignment of 66 deletion end-points confirmed the previously reported high AT content and, most importantly, revealed a highly conserved C residue at position -4 relative to the site of cleavage at both deletion termini. Based on these genetic data we propose the following putative consensus cleavage site for DNA topoisomerase I of B.subtilis: 5'-A/TCATA/TTAA/TA/TA-3'.     

Topoisomerase I-mediated integration of hepadnavirus DNA in vitro.

Hepadnaviruses integrate in cellular DNA via an illegitimate recombination mechanism, and clonally propagated integrations are present in most hepatocellular carcinomas which arise in hepadnavirus carriers. Although integration is not specific for any viral or cellular sequence, highly preferred integration sites have been identified near the DR1 and DR2 sequences and in the cohesive overlap region of virion DNA. We have mapped a set of preferred topoisomerase I (Topo I) cleavage sites in the region of DR1 on plus-strand DNA and in the cohesive overlap near DR2 and have tested whether Topo I is capable of mediating illegitimate recombination of woodchuck hepatitis virus (WHV) DNA with cellular DNA by developing an in vitro assay for Topo I-mediated linking. Four in vitro-generated virus-cell hybrid molecules have been cloned, and sequence analysis demonstrated that Topo I can mediate both linkage of WHV DNA to 5'OH acceptor ends of heterologous DNA fragments and linkage of WHV DNA into internal sites of a linear double-stranded cellular DNA. The in vitro integrations occurred at preferred Topo I cleavage sites in WHV DNA adjacent to the DR1 and were nearly identical to a subset of integrations cloned from hepatocellular carcinomas. The end specificity and polarity of viral sequences in the integrations allows us to propose a prototype integration mechanism for both ends of a linearized hepadnavirus DNA molecule.     

Effect of mutations in genes affecting homologous recombination on restriction enzyme-mediated and illegitimate recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Restriction enzyme-mediated events (REM events; integration of transforming DNA catalyzed by in vivo action of a restriction enzyme) and illegitimate recombination events (IR events; integration of transforming DNA that shares no homology with the host genomic sequences) have been previously characterized in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This study determines the effect of mutations in genes that are involved in homologous recombination and/or in the repair of double-stranded DNA breaks on these recombination events. Surprisingly, REM events are completely independent of the double-strand-break repair functions encoded by the RAD51, RAD52, and RAD57 genes but require the RAD50 gene product. IR events are under different genetic control than homologous integration events. In the rad50 mutant, homologous integration occurred at wild-type frequency, whereas the frequency of IR events was 20- to 100-fold reduced. Conversely, the rad52 mutant was grossly deficient in homologous integration (at least 1,000-fold reduced) but showed only a 2- to 8-fold reduction in IR frequency.     

Common sites for recombination and cleavage mediated by bacteriophage T4 DNA topoisomerase in vitro

We have previously shown that purified T4 DNA topoisomerase promotes illegitimate recombination between two lambda DNA molecules, or between lambda and plasmid DNA in vitro (Ikeda, H. (1986) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 83, 922-926). Since the recombinant DNA contains a duplication or deletion, it is inferred that the cross-overs take place between nonhomologous sequences of lambda DNA. In this paper, we have examined the sequences of the recombination junctions produced by the recombination between two lambda DNA molecules mediated by T4 DNA topoisomerase. We have shown that there is either no homology or there are 1-5-base pair homologies between the parental DNAs in seven combinations of lambda recombination sites, indicating that homology is not essential for the recombination. Next, we have shown an association of the recombination sites with the topoisomerase cleavage sites, indicating that a capacity of the topoisomerase to make a transient double-stranded break in DNA plays a role in the illegitimate recombination. A consensus sequence for T4 topoisomerase cleavage sites, RNAY decreases NNNNRTNY, was deduced. The cleavage experiment showed that T4 topoisomerase-mediated cleavage takes place in a 4-base pair staggered fashion and produces 5'-protruding ends.     

Role of DNA ligase in the illegitimate recombination that generates lambdabio-transducing phages in Escherichia coli

We studied the role of DNA ligase in illegitimate recombination in Escherichia coli. A temperature-sensitive mutation in the lig gene reduced the frequency with which lambdabio-transducing phages were generated to 10-14% of that of wild type under UV irradiation. Reintroduction of the lig gene into this mutant restored the frequency of recombinant phage generation to that of wild type. Furthermore, overexpression of DNA ligase enhanced illegitimate recombination by 10-fold with or without UV irradiation. In addition, when DNA ligase was present in only limited amounts, UV-induced or spontaneous illegitimate recombination occurred exclusively at hotspot sites that have relatively long sequences of homology (9 or 13 bp). However, when DNA ligase was overexpressed, most of the illegitimate recombination took place at non-hotspot sites having only short sequences of homology (<4 bp). Thus, the level of ligase activity affects the frequency of illegitimate recombination, the length of sequence homology at the recombination sites, and the preference for recombination at hotspots, at least after UV irradiation. These observations support our hypothesis that the illegitimate recombination that generates lambdabio-transducing phages is mediated by the DNA break-and-join mechanism.     

Molecular characterization of transforming plasmid rearrangements in transgenic rice reveals a recombination hotspot in the CaMV 35S promoter and confirms the predominance of microhomology mediated recombination

The characterization of plasmid-genomic DNA junctions following plant transformation has established links between DNA double-strand break repair (DSBR), illegitimate recombination and plasmid DNA integration. The limited information on plasmid-plasmid junctions in plants comes from the dicot species tobacco and Arabidopsis. We analyzed 12 representative transgenic rice lines, carrying a range of transforming plasmid rearrangements, which predominantly reflected microhomology mediated illegitimate recombination involving short complementary patches at the recombining ends. Direct end-ligation, in the absence of homology between the recombining molecules, occurred only rarely. Filler DNA was found at some of the junctions. Short, purine-rich tracts were present, either at the junction site or in the immediate flanking regions. Putative DNA topoisomerase I binding sites were clustered around the junctions. Although different regions of the transforming plasmid were involved in plasmid-plasmid recombination, we showed that a 19 bp palindromic sequence, including the TATA box of the CaMV 35S promoter, acted as a recombination hotspot. The purine-rich half of the palindromic sequence was specifically involved at the recombination junctions. This recombination hotspot is located within the 'highly recombinogenic' region of the full-length CaMV RNA that has been shown to promote viral recombination in dicot plants. Clustering of plasmid recombination events in this highly recombinogenic region, even in the absence of viral enzymes and other cis-acting elements proves that the plant cellular machinery alone is sufficient to recognize and act on these viral sequences. Our data also show the similarity between mechanisms underlying junction formation in dicot and monocot plants transformed using different procedures.     

Frequency and character of alternative somatic recombination fates of paralogous genes during T-DNA integration

A synthetic RBCSB gene cluster was transformed into Arabidopsis in order to simultaneously evaluate the frequency and character of somatic illegitimate recombination, homologous recombination, and targeted gene replacement events associated with T-DNA-mediated transformation. The most frequent type of recombination event observed was illegitimate integration of the T-DNA without activation of the silent ΔRBCS1B: LUC transgene. Sixteen luc⁺ (firefly luciferase positive) T1 plants were isolated. Six of these were due to illegitimate recombination events resulting in a gene trapping effect. Nine resulted from homologous recombination between paralogous RBCSB sequences associated with T-DNA integration. The frequency of somatic homologous recombination associated with T-DNA integration was almost 200 times higher than previously reported rates of meiotic homologous recombination with the same genes. The distribution of (somatic homologous) recombination resolution sites generally fits a fractional interval length model. However, a small region adjacent to an indel showed a significant over-representation of resolution sites, suggesting that DNA mismatch recognition may also play an important role in the positioning of somatic resolution sites. The frequency of somatic resolution within exon-2 was significantly different from that previously observed during meiotic recombination. Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available for this article at     

Ionizing radiation and restriction enzymes induce microhomology-mediated illegitimate recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

DNA double-strand breaks can be repaired by illegitimate recombination without extended sequence homology. A distinct mechanism namely microhomology-mediated recombination occurs between a few basepairs of homology that is associated with deletions. Ionizing radiation and restriction enzymes have been shown to increase the frequency of nonhomologous integration in yeast. However, the mechanism of such enhanced recombination events is not known. Here, we report that both ionizing radiation and restriction enzymes increase the frequency of microhomology-mediated integration. Irradiated yeast cells displayed 77% microhomology-mediated integration, compared to 27% in unirradiated cells. Radiation-induced integration exhibited lack of deletions at genomic insertion sites, implying that such events are likely to occur at undamaged sites. Restriction enzymes also enhanced integration events at random non-restriction sites via microhomology-mediated recombination. Furthermore, generation of a site-specific I-SceI-mediated double-strand break induces microhomology-mediated integration randomly throughout the genome. Taken together, these results suggest that double-strand breaks induce a genome-wide microhomology-mediated illegitimate recombination pathway that facilitates integration probably in trans at non-targeted sites and might be involved in generation of large deletions and other genomic rearrangements.     

Illegitimate Recombination Induced by Overproduction of DnaB Helicase in Escherichia coli

Illegitimate recombination that usually takes place at a low frequency is greatly enhanced by treatment with DNA-damaging agents. It is thought that DNA double-strand breaks induced by this DNA damage are important for initiation of illegitimate recombination. Here we show that illegitimate recombination is enhanced by overexpression of the DnaB protein in Escherichia coli. The recombination enhanced by DnaB overexpression occurred between short regions of homology. We propose a model for the initiation of illegitimate recombination in which DnaB overexpression may excessively unwind DNA at replication forks and induce double-strand breaks, resulting in illegitimate recombination. The defect in RecQ has a synergistic effect on the increased illegitimate recombination in cells containing the overproduced DnaB protein, implying that DnaB works in the same pathway as RecQ does but that they work at different steps.     

Type I restriction enzyme with RecA protein promotes illegitimate recombination

Illegitimate (non-homologous) recombination requires little or no sequence homology between recombining DNAs and has been regarded as being a process distinct from homologous recombination, which requires a long stretch of homology between recombining DNAs. However, we have found a type of illegitimate recombination that requires an interaction between long homologous DNA sequences. It was detected when a plasmid that carried 2-kb-long inverted repeats was subjected to type I (EcoKI) restriction in vivo within a special mutant strain of Escherichia coli. In the present work, we analyzed genetic requirements for this type of illegitimate recombination in well-defined genetic backgrounds. Our analysis demonstrated dependence on RecA function and on the presence of two EcoKI sites on the substrate DNA. These results are in harmony with a model in which EcoKI restriction enzyme attacks an intermediate of homologous recombination to divert it to illegitimate recombination.     

Biochemistry of homologous recombination in Escherichia coli.

Homologous recombination is a fundamental biological process. Biochemical understanding of this process is most advanced for Escherichia coli. At least 25 gene products are involved in promoting genetic exchange. At present, this includes the RecA, RecBCD (exonuclease V), RecE (exonuclease VIII), RecF, RecG, RecJ, RecN, RecOR, RecQ, RecT, RuvAB, RuvC, SbcCD, and SSB proteins, as well as DNA polymerase I, DNA gyrase, DNA topoisomerase I, DNA ligase, and DNA helicases. The activities displayed by these enzymes include homologous DNA pairing and strand exchange, helicase, branch migration, Holliday junction binding and cleavage, nuclease, ATPase, topoisomerase, DNA binding, ATP binding, polymerase, and ligase, and, collectively, they define biochemical events that are essential for efficient recombination. In addition to these needed proteins, a cis-acting recombination hot spot known as Chi (chi: 5'-GCTGGTGG-3') plays a crucial regulatory function. The biochemical steps that comprise homologous recombination can be formally divided into four parts: (i) processing of DNA molecules into suitable recombination substrates, (ii) homologous pairing of the DNA partners and the exchange of DNA strands, (iii) extension of the nascent DNA heteroduplex; and (iv) resolution of the resulting crossover structure. This review focuses on the biochemical mechanisms underlying these steps, with particular emphases on the activities of the proteins involved and on the integration of these activities into likely biochemical pathways for recombination.     

Effect of the DNA topoisomerase II inhibitor VP-16 on illegitimate recombination in yeast chromosomes

Etoposide and teniposide, derivatives of podophyllotoxin, are inhibitors of DNA topoisomerase II and are potent anticancer agents. An adverse effect linked to the use of these drugs is the development of acute myeloid leukemia, a disorder usually associated with chromosomal translocation. To examine podophyllotoxin-induced DNA rearrangement, we developed an assay system to measure illegitimate recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae chromosomes. This approach uses juxtaposed CAN1-CYH2 negative selection markers that are introduced into the LEU2 locus, which is located on chromosome III, in a yeast strain carrying the mutated can1 and cyh2 genes. Upon formation of a deletion over the active CAN1-CYH2 genes, a cell becomes resistant to both canavanine and cycloheximide. To introduce drugs into the cell, we used a yeast strain carrying an ISE2 mutation, thereby making the cell drug-permeable. Here we show that treatment of cells with etoposide (VP-16) increases the rate of illegitimate recombination in yeast, indicating that VP-16 stimulates DNA topoisomerase-mediated illegitimate recombination. Structural analysis of the resulting recombinants indicate that most are formed by deletion mutations on chromosome III, which take place between short homologous regions of DNA. We propose a model for illegitimate recombination, in which VP-16 facilitates formation of a cleavable complex between DNA topoisomerase II and DNA, thus promoting DNA double-strand breakage with the resulting DNA ends joined by a non-homologous mechanism.     

The structures of integration sites in transgenic rice

Extensive genomic sequencing and sequence motif analysis have been conducted over the integration sites of two transgenic rice plants, #478 and #559, carrying the luciferase gene and/or hygromycin phosphotransferase gene. The transgenes reside in a region with inverted structure and a large duplication of rice genome over 2 kb. Integration was found at the AT-rich region and/or at the repetitive sequence region, including a SAR-like structure, retrotransposon and telomere repeats. The presence of a patch of sequence homology between plasmid and target DNA, and a small region of duplication involving the target DNA around the recombination site, implicated illegitimate recombination in the process of gene integration. Massive rearrangement of genomic DNA including deletion or translocation was also observed at the integration site and the flanking region of the transgene. The recognition sites of DNA topoisomerases I or II were observed in the rearranged sequences. Since only three junctions of transgenic rice were implicated in the illegitimate recombination and extensive rearrangement of the rice genome, rice protoplasts may be active in this process.     

Restriction enzymes increase efficiencies of illegitimate DNA integration but decrease homologous integration in mammalian cells

Mammalian cells repair DNA double-strand breaks by illegitimate end-joining or by homologous recombination. We investigated the effects of restriction enzymes on illegitimate and homologous DNA integration in mammalian cells. A plasmid containing the neo^R expression cassette, which confers G418 resistance, was used to select for illegitimate integration events in CHO wild-type and xrcc5 mutant cells. Co-transfection with the restriction enzymes BamHI, BglII, EcoRI and KpnI increased the efficiency of linearized plasmid integration up to 5-fold in CHO cells. In contrast, the restriction enzymes did not increase the integration efficiency in xrcc5 mutant cells. Effects of restriction enzymes on illegitimate and homologous integration were also studied in mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells using a plasmid containing the neo^R gene flanked by exon 3 of Hprt. The enzymes BamHI, BglII and EcoRI increased the illegitimate integration efficiency of transforming DNA several-fold, similar to the results for CHO cells. However, all three enzymes decreased the absolute frequency of homologous integration ~2-fold, and the percentage of homologous integration decreased >10-fold. This suggests that random DNA breaks attract illegitimate recombination (IR) events that compete with homology search.     

Integration of simian virus 40 into cellular DNA occurs at or near topoisomerase II cleavage hot spots induced by VM-26 (teniposide).

Inhibition of DNA topoisomerase II in simian virus 40 (SV40)-infected BSC-1 cells with a topoisomerase II poison, VM-26 (teniposide), resulted in rapid conversion of a population of the SV40 DNA into a high-molecular-weight form. Characterization of this high-molecular-weight form of SV40 DNA suggests that it is linear, double stranded, and a recombinant with SV40 DNA sequences covalently joined to cellular DNA. The majority of the integrants contain fewer than two tandem copies of SV40 DNA. Neither DNA-damaging agents, such as mitomycin and UV, nor the topoisomerase I inhibitor camptothecin induced detectable integration in this system. In addition, the recombination junctions within the SV40 portion of the integrants correlate with VM-26-induced, topoisomerase II cleavage hot spots on SV40 DNA. These results suggest a direct and specific role for topoisomerase II and possibly the enzyme-inhibitor-DNA ternary cleavable complex in integration. The propensity of poisoned topoisomerase II to induce viral integration also suggests a role for topoisomerase II in a pathway of chromosomal DNA rearrangements.     

Suppression of gamma ray-induced illegitimate recombination in Escherichia coli by the DNA-binding protein H-NS

To study the mechanism of gamma-ray-induced illegitimate recombination, we examined the formation of lambdabio transducing phage in Escherichia coli after gamma-ray irradiation. We show that gamma-ray irradiation enhances the formation of lambdabio transducing phage during prophage induction. Moreover, an hns mutation synergistically enhanced the incidence of lambda-ray-induced illegitimate recombination. Next we determined the sequences at the recombination junctions of the lambdabio transducing phages induced by gamma-ray irradiation. Most of the recombination sites coincided with known hotspots. Among them, hotspot I accounted for 67% and 77% of gamma-ray-induced lambdabio transducing phages in the wild type and the hns mutant, respectively. Therefore, the recombination sites appear to occur mostly at hotspot I or at other hotspots, but rarely at non-hotspot sites. These results suggest that types of DNA damage other than the double-strand breaks induced at random sites are mainly responsible for the introduction of the site-specific or region-specific DNA double strand breaks that lead to recombination at the hotspots. The results also showed that the recombination events took place between DNA sequences possessing short stretches of homology. H-NS protein, which binds to curved DNA, suppresses illegitimate recombination in the presence and absence of gamma-ray irradiation. Models for gamma-ray-induced illegitimate recombination are discussed.     

Integration of a vector containing a repetitive LINE-1 element in the human genome.

Mammalian cells contain numerous nonallelic repeated sequences, such as multicopy genes, gene families, and repeated elements. One common feature of nonallelic repeated sequences is that they are homeologous (not perfectly identical). Our laboratory has been studying recombination between homeologous sequences by using LINE-1 (L1) elements as substrates. We showed previously that an exogenous L1 element could readily acquire endogenous L1 sequences by nonreciprocal homologous recombination. In the study presented here, we have investigated the propensity of exogenous L1 elements to be involved in a reciprocal process, namely, crossing-overs. This would result in the integration of the exogenous L1 element into an endogenous L1 element. Of over 400 distinct integration events analyzed, only 2% involved homologous recombination between exogenous and endogenous L1 elements. These homologous recombination events were imprecise, with the integrated vector being flanked by one homologous and one illegitimate junction. This type of structure is not consistent with classical crossing-overs that would result in two homologous junctions but rather is consistent with one-sided homologous recombination followed by illegitimate integration. Contrary to what has been found for reciprocal homologous integration, the degree of homology between the exogenous and endogenous L1 elements did not seem to play an important role in the choice of recombination partners. These results suggest that although exogenous and endogenous L1 elements are capable of homologous recombination, this seldom leads to crossing-overs. This observation could have implications for the stability of mammalian genomes.     

Structural analyses of DNA fragments integrated by illegitimate recombination in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

In order to elucidate the mechanisms of illegitimate recombination in eukaryotes, we have studied the structure of DNA fragments integrated by illegitimate recombination into the genome of fission yeast. Nonhomologous recombination was rarely identified when a long region of homology with the chromosomal leu1 ⁺ gene was present in the introduced leu1::ura4 ⁺ DNA fragment; but a decrease in length of homology leads to an increase in the ratio of nonhomologous to homologous recombination events. The introduced DNA fragments were integrated into different sites in the chromosomes by nonhomologous recombination. The results suggested that there are multiple modes of integration; most events simply involve both ends of the fragments, while in other cases, fragments were integrated in a more complicated manner, probably via circularization or multimerization. To analyze the mechanism of the major type of integration, DNA fragments containing the recombination junctions of three recombinants were amplified by inverted polymerase chain reaction (IPCR) and their nucleotide sequences were determined. There was no obvious homology between introduced DNA and chromosomal DNA at these recombination sites. Furthermore it was found that each terminal region of the introduced DNA was deleted, but that there were no or very small deletions in the target sites of chromosomal DNA. Two models are proposed to explain the mechanism of nonhomologous integration.