Imaging protein-protein interactions using fluorescence resonance energy transfer microscopy

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) detects the proximity of fluorescently labeled molecules over distances >100 A. When performed in a fluorescence microscope, FRET can be used to map protein-protein interactions in vivo. We here describe a FRET microscopy method that can be used to determine whether proteins that are colocalized at the level of light microscopy interact with one another. This method can be implemented using digital microscopy systems such as a confocal microscope or a wide-field fluorescence microscope coupled to a charge-coupled device (CCD) camera. It is readily applied to samples prepared with standard immunofluorescence techniques using antibodies labeled with fluorescent dyes that act as a donor and acceptor pair for FRET. Energy transfer efficiencies are quantified based on the release of quenching of donor fluorescence due to FRET, measured by comparing the intensity of donor fluorescence before and after complete photobleaching of the acceptor. As described, this method uses Cy3 and Cy5 as the donor and acceptor fluorophores, but can be adapted for other FRET pairs including cyan fluorescent protein and yellow fluorescent protein.     

Enhanced fluorescence resonance energy transfer between spectral variants of green fluorescent protein through zinc-site engineering

Although spectral variants of GFP should in theory be suited for fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and therefore suited for studies of protein-protein interactions, the unfavorable location of the fluorophore 15 A deep inside the GFP molecule has especially impaired this application. Here, metal-ion site engineering around the dimerization interface known from the X-ray structure of GFP is applied to the cyan and the yellow spectral variant of GFP to stabilize the heterodimeric form of these molecules and thereby increase FRET signaling. The FRET signal, determined as the ratio between the maximal emission for the yellow variant, 530 nm, and the cyan variant, 475 nm, during excitation of the cyan variant at 433 nm was increased up to 8-10-fold in the presence of 10(-4) M ZnCl2 by engineering of two symmetric metal-ion sites being either bidentate or tridentate. A similar increase in FRET signaling was however obtained in a pair of molecules in which a single bidentate metal-ion site was generated by introducing a zinc-binding residue in each of the two spectral variants of GFP and therefore creating an obligate heterodimeric pair. It is concluded that FRET signaling between spectral variants of GFP can be increased by stabilizing dimer formation and especially by favoring heterodimer formation in this case performed by metal-ion site engineering.     

Spectral imaging and linear un-mixing enables improved FRET efficiency with a novel GFP2-YFP FRET pair

Spectral variants of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) have been extensively used as reporters to image molecular interactions in living cells by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). However, those GFP variants which are the most efficient donor acceptor pairs for FRET measurements show a high degree of spectral overlap which has hampered in the past their use in FRET applications. Here we use spectral imaging and subsequent un-mixing to quantitatively separate highly overlapping donor and acceptor emissions in FRET measurements. We demonstrate the method in fixed and living cells using a novel GFP based FRET pair (GFP2-YFP (yellow)), which has an increased FRET efficiency compared to the most commonly used FRET pair consisting of cyan fluorescent protein and YFP. Moreover, GFP2 has its excitation maximum at 396 nm at which the YFP acceptor is excited only below the detection level and thus this FRET pair is ideal for applications involving sensitized emission.     

In situ analysis of spatial relationships between proteins of the nuclear pore complex

Macromolecular transport between the nucleus and cytoplasm occurs through the nuclear pore complexes (NPCs). The NPC in the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae is a 60-MDa structure embedded in the nuclear envelope and composed of ~30 proteins, termed nucleoporins or nups. Here we present a large-scale analysis of spatial relationships between nucleoporins using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) in living yeast cells. Energy transfer was measured in a panel of strains, each of which coexpresses the enhanced cyan and yellow fluorescent proteins as fusions to distinct nucleoporins. With this approach, we have determined 13 nucleoporin pairs yielding FRET signals. Independent experiments are consistent with the FRET results: Nup120 localization is perturbed in the nic96-1 mutant, as is Nup82 localization in the nup116Delta mutant. To better understand the spatial relationship represented by an in vivo FRET signal, we have investigated the requirements of these signals. We demonstrate that in one case FRET signal is lost upon insertion of a short spacer between the nucleoporin and its enhanced yellow fluorescent protein label. We also show that the Nup120 FRET signals depend on whether the fluorescent moiety is fused to the N- or C-terminus of Nup120. Combined with existing data on NPC structure, the FRET pairs identified in this study allow us to propose a refined molecular model of the NPC. We suggest that the approach may serve as a prototype for the in situ study of other large macromolecular complexes.     

Monitoring receptor-mediated activation of heterotrimeric G-proteins by fluorescence resonance energy transfer

Green fluorescent protein (GFP)-centered fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) relies on a distance-dependent transfer of energy from a donor fluorophore to an acceptor fluorophore and can be used to examine protein interactions in living cells. Here we describe a method to monitor the association and disassociation of heterotrimeric GTP-binding (G-proteins) from one another before and after stimulation of coupled receptors in living Dictyostelium discoideum cells. The Galpha(2)and Gbetagamma proteins were tagged with cyan and yellow fluorescent proteins and used to observe the state of the G-protein heterotrimer. Data from emission spectra were used to detect the FRET fluorescence and to determine kinetics and dose-response curves of bound ligand and analogs. Extending G-protein FRET to mammalian G-proteins should enable direct in situ mechanistic studies and applications such as drug screening and identifying ligands of new G-protein-coupled receptors.     

Visualization of bHLH transcription factor interactions in living mammalian cell nuclei and developing chicken neural tube by FRET

Members of the basic helix-loop-helix （bHLH） gene family play important roles in vertebrate neurogenesis. In this study, confocal microscopy-based fluorescence resonance energy transfer （FRET） is used to monitor bHLH protein-protein interactions under various physiological conditions. Tissue-specific bHLH activators, NeuroD 1, Mash 1, Neurogenin 1 （Ngn 1）, Neurogenin2 （Ngn2）, and ubiquitous expressed E47 protein are tagged with enhanced yellow fluorescence protein （EYFP） and enhanced cyan fluorescence protein （ECFP）, respectively. The subcellular localization and mobility ofbHLH fusion proteins are examined in HEK293 cells. By transient transfection and in ovo electroporation, four pairs of tissue-specific bHLH activators and E47 protein are over-expressed in HEK293 cells and developing chick embryo neural tube. With the acceptor photobleaching method, FRET could be detected between these bHLH protein pairs in the nuclei of transfected cells and developing neural tubes. Mashl/E47 and Ngn2/E47 FRET pairs show higher FRET efficiencies in the medial and the lateral half of chick embryo neural tube, respectively. It suggests that these bHLH protein pairs formed functional DNA-protein complexes with regulatory elements of their downstream target genes in the specific regions. This work will help one understand the behaviours of bHLH factors in vivo.     

Heterooligomerization between vasotocin and corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH) receptors augments CRH-stimulated 3',5'-cyclic adenosine monophosphate production

In birds, ACTH release from the anterior pituitary gland during stress is controlled by CRH and arginine vasotocin (AVT). Using 5-wk-old male chicks, simultaneous iv injections of CRH and AVT were found to result in a greater than additive increase in plasma corticosterone levels compared with that obtained with individual administration of either peptide hormone. In order to investigate molecular mechanisms underlying this observation, the chicken CRH receptor (CRHR) and vasotocin VT2 receptor (VT2R) were fused to cyan and yellow fluorescent proteins and expressed in HeLa cells. The resulting CRHR and VT2R fusion proteins were expressed appropriately in the plasma membrane and were found to couple to downstream signal transduction pathways. Quantitative fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) analysis was used to determine whether the CRHR and VT2R formed heterodimers. In the absence of CRH and AVT, the FRET efficiency was 15-18%, and the distance between receptors was 5-6 nm. Treatment of the cells that expressed both cyan fluorescent protein-CRHR and yellow fluorescent protein-VT2R with CRH or AVT alone did not lead to a significant change in the FRET efficiency. However, simultaneous addition of these hormones increased the efficiency of the FRET signal and decreased the distance between the two receptors. In HeLa cells expressing both CRHR and VT2R, treatment with CRH and AVT resulted in a significant increase in cAMP production over that with CRH alone, indicating that heterodimer formation may enhance the ability of the CRHR to activate downstream signal transduction.     

Enhanced dynamic range in a genetically encoded Ca2+ sensor

Genetically encoded fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) indicators are powerful tools for real-time detection of second messenger molecules and activation of signal proteins. However, these fluorescent protein-based sensors typically display marginal FRET efficiency. To improve their FRET efficiency for optical imaging and screening, we developed a number of fluorescent protein mutants based on cyan fluorescent protein (CFP) and yellow fluorescent protein (YFP). To improve FRET ratios, which were initially within a narrow dynamic range, we used DNA shuffling to develop a new FRET pair called 3xCFP/Venus. The optimized 3xCFP/Venus pair exhibited higher FRET ratios than CyPet/YPet, which has one of the greatest dynamic ranges of protein-based FRET pairs. We converted this FRET pair to a Ca(2+) FRET indicators using circular permutation Venus (cpVenus) linked with 3xCFP to form 3xCFP/cpVenus, which displayed an ～11-fold change in dynamic range in response to Ca(2+) binding. The enhanced dynamic range for Ca(2+) concentration detection using 3xCFP/cpVenus was confirmed in PC12 cells using previously established indicators (TN-XXL, ECFP/cpCitrine). To our knowledge, this FRET pair displays the largest dynamic range so far among genetically-encoded sensors, and can be used for sensitive FRET detection.     

Polarized fluorescence resonance energy transfer microscopy

Current methods for fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy of living cells involve taking a series of images with alternating excitation colors in separate camera exposures. Here we present a new FRET method based on polarization that requires only one camera exposure and thereby offers the possibility for better time resolution of dynamic associations among subcellular components. Polarized FRET (p-FRET) uses a simultaneous combination of excitation wavelengths from two orthogonally polarized sources, along with an emission channel tri-image splitter outfitted with appropriate polarizers, to concurrently excite and collect fluorescence from free donors, free acceptors, and FRET pairs. Based upon the throughput in each emission channel as premeasured on pure samples of each of the three species, decoupling of an unknown sample's three polarized fluorescence images can be performed to calculate the pixel-by-pixel concentrations of donor, acceptor, and FRET pairs. The theory of this approach is presented here, and its feasibility is experimentally confirmed by measurements on mixtures of cyan fluorescent protein (CFP), citrine ((Cit) a yellow fluorescent protein variant), and linked fusion proteins (CFP-L16-Cit, CFP-L7-Cit, CFP-L54-Cit) in living cells. The effects of shot noise, acceptor polarization, and FRET efficiency on the statistical accuracy of p-FRET experimental results are investigated by a noise-simulation program.     

Enhanced dynamic range in a genetically encoded Ca sensor

Genetically encoded fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) indicators are powerful tools for real-time detection of second messenger molecules and activation of signal proteins. However, these fluorescent protein-based sensors typically display marginal FRET efficiency. To improve their FRET efficiency for optical imaging and screening, we developed a number of fluorescent protein mutants based on cyan fluorescent protein (CFP) and yellow fluorescent protein (YFP). To improve FRET ratios, which were initially within a narrow dynamic range, we used DNA shuffling to develop a new FRET pair called 3xCFP/Venus. The optimized 3xCFP/Venus pair exhibited higher FRET ratios than CyPet/YPet, which has one of the greatest dynamic ranges of protein-based FRET pairs. We converted this FRET pair to a Ca²⁺ FRET indicators using circular permutation Venus (cpVenus) linked with 3xCFP to form 3xCFP/cpVenus, which displayed an ∼11-fold change in dynamic range in response to Ca²⁺ binding. The enhanced dynamic range for Ca²⁺ concentration detection using 3xCFP/cpVenus was confirmed in PC12 cells using previously established indicators (TN-XXL, ECFP/cpCitrine). To our knowledge, this FRET pair displays the largest dynamic range so far among genetically-encoded sensors, and can be used for sensitive FRET detection.     

Imaging FRET between spectrally similar GFP molecules in single cells

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) detection in fusion constructs consisting of green fluorescent protein (GFP) variants linked by a sequence that changes conformation upon modification by enzymes or binding of ligands has enabled detection of physiological processes such as Ca(2+) ion release, and protease and kinase activity. Current FRET microscopy techniques are limited to the use of spectrally distinct GFPs such as blue or cyan donors in combination with green or yellow acceptors. The blue or cyan GFPs have the disadvantages of less brightness and of autofluorescence. Here a FRET imaging method is presented that circumvents the need for spectral separation of the GFPs by determination of the fluorescence lifetime of the combined donor/acceptor emission by fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM). This technique gives a sensitive, reproducible, and intrinsically calibrated FRET measurement that can be used with the spectrally similar and bright yellow and green fluorescent proteins (EYFP/EGFP), a pair previously unusable for FRET applications. We demonstrate the benefits of this approach in the analysis of single-cell signaling by monitoring caspase activity in individual cells during apoptosis.     

A high-throughput method for development of FRET-based indicators for proteolysis

SCAT3 is a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based indicator for activity of caspase-3, which is composed of an enhanced cyan fluorescent protein, a caspase-3-sensitive linker, and an enhanced yellow fluorescent protein with efficient maturation property (Venus). Despite its considerable promise, however, greater responsivity of fluorescence to the proteolysis has been desired for better understanding of spatio-temporal pattern of the activation of caspase-3 during apoptosis. In the present study, the length of linker regions of SCAT3 has been thoroughly optimized by use of a PCR technique. The bacterial colonies expressing the constructs were screened for high FRET efficiency using our home-made fluorescence image analyzer. The FRET signal of an improved SCAT3 changed by about tenfold during apoptotic events in mammalian cells, enabling visualization of caspase-3 activation with better spatial resolution than before. This new high-throughput method will be applicable to development and improvement of FRET-based indicators for proteolysis.     

Differential Ras activation between caveolae/raft and non-raft microdomains

Although the consequences of Ras activation have been studied extensively in the context of oncogenesis, its regulation in physiological modes of signal transduction is not well understood. A fluorescent indicator, Raichu-Ras, was fused to the C-terminal hypervariable regions of H-Ras and K-Ras to create indicators for Ras activation within caveolae/rafts (Raichu-tH) and non-raft domains (Raichu-tK) of the plasma membrane, respectively. Raichu-tH was also found abundantly in endomembranes. To monitor Ras activation with high spatial resolution, it is imperative to observe sectioned images of the signals. We have developed a wide-field fluorescence microscope equipped with a digital micromirror device (DMD) to acquire optically sectioned images using fringe projection. This system provides reliable signals from fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between cyan and yellow mutants of green fluorescent protein. We have used this system to demonstrate that, upon stimulation with growth factors, the two indicators are activated in spatially and temporally unique patterns.     

Development of dual receptor biosensors: an analysis of FRET pairs

The development of a dual receptor detection method for enhanced biosensor monitoring was investigated by analyzing potential fluorescent resonance energy transfer (FRET) pairs. The dual receptor scheme requires the integration of a chemical transducer system with two unique protein receptors that bind to a single biological agent. The two receptors are tagged with special molecular groups (donors and acceptors fluorophores) while the chemical transduction system relies on the well-known mechanisms of FRET. During the binding event, the two FRET labeled receptors dock at the binding sites on the surface of the biological agent. The resulting close proximity of the two fluorophores upon binding will initiate the energy transfer resulting in fluorescence. The paper focuses on the analysis and optimization of the chemical transduction system. A variety of FRET fluorophore pairs were tested in a spectrofluorimeter and promising FRET pairs were then tagged to the protein, avidin and its ligand, biotin. Due to their affinities, the FRET-tagged biomolecules combine in solution, resulting in a stable, fluorescent signal from the acceptor FRET dye with a simultaneous decrease in fluorescent signal from the donor FRET dye. The results indicate that the selected FRET pairs can be utilized in the development of dual receptor sensors.     

Reliable and global measurement of fluorescence resonance energy transfer using fluorescence microscopes

Green fluorescence protein (GFP)-based fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) is increasingly used in investigation of inter- and intramolecular interactions in living cells. In this report, we present a modified method for FRET quantification in cultured cells using conventional fluorescence microscopy. To reliably measure FRET, three positive control constructs in which a cyan fluorescence protein and a yellow fluorescence protein were linked by peptides of 15, 24, or 37 amino acid residues were prepared. FRET was detected using a spectrofluorometer, a laser scanning confocal microscope, and an inverted fluorescence microscope. Three calculation methods for FRET quantification using fluorescence microscopes were compared. By normalization against expression levels of GFP fusion proteins, the modified method gave consistent FRET values that could be compared among different cells with varying protein expression levels. Whole-cell global analysis using this method allowed FRET measurement with high spatial resolutions. Using such a procedure, the interaction of synaptic proteins syntaxin and the synaptosomal associated protein of 25 kDa (SNAP-25) was examined in PC12 cells, which showed strong FRET on plasma membranes. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of the modified method for FRET measurement in live cell systems.     

The Use of a Stably Expressed FRET Biosensor for Determining the Potency of Cancer Drugs

Many cancer drugs are intended to kill cancer cells by inducing apoptosis. However, the potency assays used for measuring the bioactivity of these products are generally cell viability assays which do not distinguish between cell death and growth inhibition. Here we describe a cell-based fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) biosensor designed to measure the bioactivity of apoptosis inducing cancer drugs. The biosensor contains cyan fluorescent protein (CFP) linked via caspase 3 and caspase 8 specific cleavage recognition sequences to yellow fluorescent protein (YFP). Upon caspase activation, as in the case of apoptosis induction, the linker is cleaved abolishing the cellular FRET signal. This assay closely reflects the mechanism of action of cancer drugs, in killing cancer cells and therefore can function as a potency test for different cancer drugs. We rigorously demonstrate this through characterization of a class of proteins targeting the death receptors. The one-step assay appears to be superior to other apoptosis-based assays because of its simplicity, convenience, and robustness.     

A miniaturized cell-based fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay for insulin-receptor activation

This report describes the development, optimization, and implementation of a miniaturized cell-based assay for the identification of small-molecule insulin mimetics and potentiators. Cell-based assays are attractive formats for compound screening because they present the molecular targets in their cellular environment. A fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) cell-based assay that measures the insulin-dependent colocalization of Akt2 fused with either cyan fluorescent protein or yellow fluorescent protein to the cellular membrane was developed. This ratiometric FRET assay was miniaturized into a robust, yet sensitive 3456-well nanoplate assay with Z' factors of approximately 0.6 despite a very small assay window (less than twofold full activation with insulin). The FRET assay was used for primary screening of a large compound collection for insulin-receptor agonists and potentiators. To prioritize compounds for further development, primary hits were tested in two additional assays, a biochemical time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay to measure insulin-receptor phosphorylation and a translocation-based imaging assay. Results from the three assays were combined to yield 11 compounds as potential leads for the development of insulin mimetics or potentiators.     

Constitutive interaction of the P2Y2 receptor with the hematopoietic cell-specific G protein G(alpha16) and evidence for receptor oligomers

Hematopoietic cells uniquely express G(alpha16), a G protein alpha-subunit of the G(q)-type. G(alpha16) is obligatory for P2Y2 receptor-dependent Ca2+-mobilization in human erythroleukemia cells and induces hematopoietic cell differentiation. We tested whether P2Y2 receptors physically interact with G(alpha16). Receptor and G protein were fused to cyan (CFP) and yellow (YFP) variants of the green fluorescent protein (GFP), respectively. When expressed in K562 leukemia cells, the fusion proteins were capable of triggering a Ca2+-signal upon receptor stimulation, demonstrating their functional integrity. In fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements using confocal microscopy, a strong FRET signal from the plasma membrane region of fixed, resting cells was detected when the receptor was co-expressed with the G protein as the FRET acceptor, as well as when the CFP-tagged receptor was co-expressed with receptor fused to YFP. We conclude that, under resting conditions, G(alpha16) and P2Y2 receptors form constitutive complexes, and that the P2Y2 receptor is present as an oligomer.     

Direct optical recording of intrinsic efficacy at a G protein-coupled receptor

Full and partial agonists activate receptors to varying degrees, presumably by inducing full or partial conformational changes in the receptor protein. Varying degrees of partial agonism corresponding to varying intrinsic efficacies have been demonstrated for many compounds acting at G-protein-coupled receptors, but a method to determine intrinsic efficacies directly at the receptor level has so far been lacking. Here we describe a method that allows the direct monitoring of agonist-induced conformational changes in G-protein-coupled receptors. The cyan (CFP) and yellow (YFP) variants of the green fluorescent protein were fused to the receptors. This resulted in fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between the CFP- and YFP-moieties. The extent of FRET was reduced in the presence of an agonist. The FRET signal strictly followed agonist occupancy of the receptor. Using the alpha(2)-adrenergic receptor as a model system, the full agonist noradrenaline produced a full signal, the partial agonist clonidine produced only a partial signal, and the antagonist phentolamine had no effect. Thus, optical recording of the agonist-induced conformational change in a G-protein-coupled receptor allows the direct analysis of the intrinsic efficacies of agonists.