Genetic approaches to molecular mechanisms of programmed cell death in Dictyostelium

Caspase-independent cell deaths have been observed in many species including the human. However, the molecular mechanisms which govern them are largely unknown. Our present work makes use of a model organism, the protist Dictyostelium discoideum, which displays a caspase-independent cell death during its development. In rich medium, Dictyostelium multiplies vegetatively as a unicellular organism, but in starvation conditions, Dictyostelium cells aggregate, differentiate and morphogenize into a multicellular structure, called sorocarp, containing a mass of spores supported by a stalk. Cells in the stalk are considered dead on the basis of non-regrowth in a rich medium and are vacuolized. This programmed cell death is therefore developmental and vacuolar, and in addition, caspase-independent since the Dictyostelium genome does not contain caspases genes. In order to study in detail this cell death without induction of development, an in vitro experimental protocol has been adopted, which enabled us to describe the cascade of morphological events during this cell death. An insertional mutagenesis approach, followed by appropriate selection or screening of mutants potentially resistant to death, attempted at establishing the cascade of molecular events leading to vacuolar death of Dictyostelium cells. A better understanding of alternative death pathways may allow to control different types of cell deaths in the cases of cancers or neurodegenerative diseases. In this short review, we will discuss briefly some generalities about the development of Dictyostelium in starvation conditions, and we will focus on the course of programmed cell death in Dictyostelium and on the genetic tools used to elucidate the corresponding molecular mechanisms.     

Correlates of developmental cell death in Dictyostelium discoideum

We have studied the correlates of cell death during stalk cell differentiation in Dictyostelium discoideum. Our main findings are four. (i) There is a gradual increase in the number of cells with exposed phosphatidyl serine residues, an indicator of membrane asymmetry loss and increased permeability. Only presumptive stalk cells show this change in membrane asymmetry. Cells also show an increase in cell membrane permeability under conditions of calcium-induced stalk cell differentiation in cell monolayers. (ii) There is a gradual fall in mitochondrial membrane potential during development, again restricted to the presumptive stalk cells. (iii) The fraction of cells showing caspase-3 activity increases as development proceeds and then declines in the terminally differentiated fruiting body. (iv) There is no internucleosomal cleavage of DNA, or DNA fragmentation, in D. discoideum nor is there any calcium- and magnesium-dependent endonucleolytic activity in nuclear extracts from various developmental stages. However, nuclear condensation and peripheralization does occur in stalk cells. Thus, cell death in D. discoideum shows some, but not all, features of apoptotic cell death as recognized in other multicellular systems. These findings argue against the emergence of a single mechanism of 'programmed cell death (PCD)' before multicellularity arose during evolution.     

The cold war of the social amoebae

When confronted with starvation, the amoebae of Dictyostelium discoideum initiate a developmental process that begins with cell aggregation and ends with a ball of spores supported on a stalk. Spores live and stalk cells die. Because the multicellular organism is produced by cell aggregation and not by growth and division of a single cell, genetically diverse amoebae may enter an aggregate and, if one lineage has a capacity to avoid the stalk cell fate, it may have a selective advantage. Such cheater mutants have been found among wild isolates and created in laboratory strains. The mutants raise a number of questions--how did such a cooperative system evolve in the face of cheating? What is the basis of self recognition? What genes are involved? How is cheating constrained? This review summarizes the results of studies on the social behavior of Dictyostelium and its relatives, including the familiar asexual developmental cycle and the lesser known, but puzzling, sexual cycle.     

The control of chemotactic cell movement during Dictyostelium morphogenesis

Differential cell movement is an important mechanism in the development and morphogenesis of many organisms. In many cases there are indications that chemotaxis is a key mechanism controlling differential cell movement. This can be particularly well studied in the starvation-induced multicellular development of the social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum. Upon starvation, up to 10(5) individual amoebae aggregate to form a fruiting body The cells aggregate by chemotaxis in response to propagating waves of cAMP, initiated by an aggregation centre. During their chemotactic aggregation the cells start to differentiate into prestalk and prespore cells, precursors to the stalk and spores that form the fruiting body. These cells enter the aggregate in a random order but then sort out to form a simple axial pattern in the slug. Our experiments strongly suggest that the multicellular aggregates (mounds) and slugs are also organized by propagating cAMP waves and, furthermore, that cell-type-specific differences in signalling and chemotaxis result in cell sorting, slug formation and movement.     

Bimodal distribution of motility and cell fate in Dictyostelium discoideum

Pre-starvation amoebae of Dictyostelium discoideum exhibit random movements. Starved cells aggregate by directed movements (chemotaxis) towards cyclic AMP and differentiate into live spores or dead stalk cells. Many differences between presumptive spore and stalk cells precede differentiation. We have examined whether cell motility-related factors are also among them. Cell speeds and localisation of motility-related signalling molecules were monitored by live cell imaging and immunostaining (a) in nutrient medium during growth, (b) immediately following transfer to starvation medium and (c) in nutrient medium that was re-introduced after a brief period of starvation. Cells moved randomly under all three conditions but mean speeds increased following transfer from nutrient medium to starvation medium; the transition occurred within 15 min. The distribution of speeds in starvation medium was bimodal: about 20% of the cells moved significantly faster than the remaining 80%. The motility-related molecules F-actin, PTEN and PI3 kinase were distributed differently in slow and fast cells. Among starved cells, the calcium content of slower cells was lower than that of the faster cells. All differences reverted within 15 min after restoration of the nutrient medium. The slow/fast distinction was missing in Polysphondylium pallidum, a cellular slime mould that lacks the presumptive stalk and spore cell classes, and in the trishanku (triA(-)) mutant of D. discoideum, in which the classes exist but are unstable. The transition from growth to starvation triggers a spontaneous and reversible switch in the distribution of D. discoideum cell speeds. Cells whose calcium content is relatively low (known to be presumptive spore cells) move slower than those whose calcium levels are higher (known to be presumptive stalk cells). Slow and fast cells show different distributions of motility-related proteins. The switch is indicative of a bistable mechanism underlying cell motility.     

Involvement of the glucose-regulated protein 94 (Dd-GRP94) in starvation response of Dictyostelium discoideum cells

Upon deprivation of nutrients, Dictyostelium discoideum Ax-2 cells arrest proliferation and initiate a metamorphosed developmental program including induction of altered gene expressions which are necessary for differentiation. In Ax-2 cells, we found out a member of Hsp90 family usually contained in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), Dd-GRP94 (Dictyostelium discoideum glucose-regulated protein 94). In general, GRP94 are induced either by glucose-depletion or by depletion of Ca(2+) in intracellular Ca(2+) stores. Unexpectedly, however, the expression of Dd-grp94 was greatly reduced within 60 min of starvation. Dd-grp94-overexpressing cells (GRP94(OE) cells) collected without forming distinct aggregation streams, and never formed normal fruiting bodies. Also, prespore differentiation as well as maturation into spores and stalk cells were particularly impaired in the GRP94(OE) cells. Thus Dd-GRP94 seems to be crucial in late differentiation as well as in starvation response.     

Re-expression of 117 antigen, a cell surface glycoprotein of aggregating cells, during terminal differentiation of Dictyostelium discoideum prespore cells

117 antigen is a glycoprotein expressed on the surface of D. discoideum cells at aggregation. It then disappears and is later re-expressed on the surface of a subpopulation of cells at culmination, the terminal differentiation stage (Sadeghi et al. 1987). A cDNA clone was used to show that the appearance of cell surface 117 antigen accurately reflects the expression of the 117 gene as measured by mRNA levels. It was also shown that during multicellular development there is a reciprocal relationship between the levels of 117 mRNA and the mRNA which codes for prespore surface glycoprotein, PsA. Dual parameter flow cytometry was used to demonstrate that the 117 antigen is found on the surface of maturing prespore cells after the PsA glycoprotein disappears, but that it is not found on mature spores. Using three monoclonal antibodies which identify respectively 117 antigen, PsA, and MUD3 antigen (a spore coat glycoprotein--probably Sp96), two new stages of final spore maturation were defined. These results indicate that there is a recapitulation of at least one aggregative cell surface glycoprotein in the prespore subpopulation of cells as they rise up the stalk during final spore development. This raises the possibility that culmination, which involves complex three dimensional morphogenetic movements not unlike those observed during animal embryogenesis, involves components of the two-dimensional pattern seen during aggregation.     

Guanylate Cyclase Activity in Dictyostelium discoideum and Its Increase during Cell Development

Following consumption of the food supply, cells of the cellular slime mould Dictyostelium discoideum aggregate and form a multicellular organism. The mechanism for cell aggregation is chemotaxis. The chemotactic signal in D. discoideum is released periodically from aggregation centers and propagated from cell to cell. cAMP mediates cell aggregation by acting as chemotactic attractant and as propagator of the signal. cAMP signals are measured by cell-surface receptors. Recent evidence indicates a role for cGMP during cAMP-mediated cell aggregation in D. discoideum .
During cell differentiation to aggregation competence, cAMP binding sites appear at the cell surface, and the activity of the enzymes adenylate cyclase and phosphodiesterase increases several-fold. In the present work we investigate the synthesis of cGMP in D. discoideum . Conditions for the assay of guanylate cyclase in cell homogenates are described. Guanylate cyclase activity was followed during cell differentiation to aggregation competence and found to increase fourfold. These results indicate that cGMP is involved in cell differentiation of D. discoideum . In contrast to adenylate cyclase, which is activated by cAMP, guanylate cyclase was under our conditions activated neither by cAMP, nor by folic acid.     

PKA在盘基网柄菌(Dictyostelium discoideum)多细胞发育中的作用

在盘基网柄菌(Dictyosteliumdiscoideum)多细胞发育中,蛋白激酶A(proteinkinaseA,PKA)发挥多重作用.细胞聚集阶段,PKA调节腺苷酰环化酶的活性,中转cAMP,诱导dut、pdi等一些发育早期的基因表达;参与启动聚集后的细胞分化和形态构成,增强GBF活性,激活前孢子细胞特有基因的表达;它还精密调控前柄细胞特有基因ecmB的表达,准确启动拔顶发育,诱导孢柄和孢子的成熟.子实体形成后,PKA又是维持孢子休眠和保证孢子有效萌发的必需因子.在PKA调控下,盘基网柄菌有条不紊地完成整个发育过程.     

Dictyostelium mucoroides cells exhibit cell cycle-dependent sorting behavior as observed in D. discoideum development

Evidence has been obtained indicating that the cell's position in the cell cycle at the onset of starvation is a naturally occurring variable closely involved in the subsequent sorting and pattern formation during the development of Dictyostelium discoideum Ax2. It is of interest to know whether a similar phenomenon is also noticed in species other than D. discoideum and also without any treatment of cells for cell synchronization. For this, the sorting behavior of D. mucoroides-7 ( Dm7 ) cells and its relation to the cell-cycle phase at the onset of starvation were analyzed, using non-synchronized Dm7 cells pulse-labeled with 5'-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BrdU). The results demonstrate that Dm7 cells starved at the early G2 phase aggregate most rapidly, but are eventually sorted out to the posterior prespore zone of migrating slugs. In contrast, cells starved at the mid late G2 phase exhibited slower aggregation, but were sorted out to the anterior zone (tip), this being basically similar to the sorting behavior of D. discoideum cells. Measurements of cell numbers and nuclearity provided evidence that approximately 80% of cells progressed their cell-cycle after the formation of multicellular structures (mounds), probably coupling with prespore differentiation as in the case of D. discoideum . Thus, cell cycle-dependent sorting during Dictyostelium development is most likely to be a common phenomenon in different species.     

盘基网柄菌细胞分化和凋亡的形态特征

本文用透射电镜和DAPI荧光染色法研究了盘基网柄菌(Dictyosteliumdiscoideum)细胞分化和柄细胞的凋亡特征,结果显示:细胞丘中绝大部分细胞的线粒体内出现一小空泡,随着发育进程,空泡逐渐增大,线粒体的嵴随之变少,直至线粒体完全空泡化,最后形成单层膜的空泡。据此我们推测前孢子细胞特有的空泡来源于线粒体,并且这种细胞器水平上的内自噬现象与前孢子细胞分化密切相关。在前柄细胞分化阶段,前柄细胞中出现数个自噬泡,最初吞噬的线粒体嵴结构完整;随着前柄细胞进一步分化,部分线粒体内出现类似于前孢子细胞中的内自噬现象,并且自噬泡只吞噬这种线粒体。在凋亡后期,细胞核内核仁消失,染色体固缩形成高电子密度斑块,自噬泡采用与细胞核膜融合的方式来完成核的清除,最后柄细胞完全空泡化且包被一层纤维素壁。作者认为前柄细胞凋亡过程实质上是一种分化过程,所以有其鲜明特点:细胞出现自噬泡,标志着凋亡开始,用自噬而不是凋亡小体来清除胞内各种细胞器,直到分化最后阶段才清除细胞核和形成纤维素壁。这些特点不仅是前柄细胞凋亡的形态学指标,也和细胞发育和分化相关。     

Diphospho-myo-inositol phosphates during the life cycle of Dictyostelium and Polysphondylium.

The intracellular amounts of diphospho-myo-inositol phosphates and InsP6 were determined in Dictyostelium discoideum AX2 throughout the life cycle, including exponential growth, starvation, differentiation, sporulation and spore germination. Similar experiments were performed with the closely related species Polysphondylium pallidum under conditions resulting in microcyst formation. A distinct accumulation of these compounds is observed during the early starvation phase of the cell population before the onset of the actual differentiation program. When exponentially growing D. discoideum cells were shifted to starvation conditions, a 25-fold accumulation of 5,6-bis-PP-InsP4 within 3 h was observed. In P. pallidum, the 5,6-bis-PP-InsP4 pool rises around 20-fold within 8 h during the formation of microcysts from vegetative cells. Finally, the diphosphoinositol phosphates are deposited in spores or microcysts and are degraded when spores or microcysts germinate at low cell density.     

Differentiation of Dictyostelium discoideum in monolayer cultures and its modification by ionic conditions

We have compared the pattern of enzyme expression in cyclic AMP-induced monolayer cultures of Dictyostelium discoideum with that found during normal development. We find that both the temporal and quantitative pattern of enzyme expression are initially similar in the two situations, although the developmental sequence is more protracted and terminal cell differentiation is delayed in the monolayer situation. We describe differentiation conditions that permit the expression of only one terminal phenotype, which may be useful for further biochemical studies. Enzyme accumulation patterns under these conditions indicate that UDP gal transferase is not required for stalk cell differentiation (i.e., it is a prespore enzyme). We have shown that, when cell monolayers are incubated with cAMP, the presence of a weak acid at low extracellular pH favors stalk-cell differentiation, while a weak base at high extracellular pH favors spore differentiation. Finally, we show that variations in the monovalent cation content of the buffer, or the addition of an ion transport inhibitor (scillaren), or an ionophore (valinomycin) all affect the ratio of stalk cells to spores. Taken together, these results suggest that intracellular H+ and/or other cations may play an important role in regulating differentiation of specific cell types in D. discoideum.     

Alternative Developmental Pathways Determined by Environmental Conditions in the Cellular Slime Mold Dictyostelium discoideum

The cellular slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum grows in the soil as a population of independent, uninucleate amoebae. Upon entrance to the stationary phase, the amoebae collect in multicellular aggregates to form organized fruiting bodies composed of spores and stalk cells. Depending upon environmental conditions, the developing aggregate either constructs the fruiting body at the site of aggregation or transforms into a structure that can migrate to a more favorable location. Environmental conditions that favor migration are (i) the accumulation of metabolite(s) produced by the aggregate and (ii) a low ionic strength in the substratum. Conditions that prevent migration or that stop a migrating slug are (i) the presence of buffer and (ii) illumination by overhead light.     

Apoptosis in a unicellular eukaryote (Trypanosoma cruzi): implications for the evolutionary origin and role of programmed cell death in the control of cell proliferation, differentiation and survival

The origin of programmed cell death (PCD) has been linked to the emergence of multicellular organisms. Trypanosoma cruzi, a member of one of the earliest diverging eukaryotes, is a protozoan unicellular parasite that undergoes three major differentiation changes and requires two different hosts. We report that the in vitro differentiation of the proliferating epimastigote stage into the G0/G1 arrested trypomastigote stage is associated with massive epimastigote death that shows the cytoplasmic and nuclear morphological features and DNA fragmentation pattern of apoptosis, the most frequent phenotype of PCD in multicellular organisms. Apoptosis could be accelerated or prevented by modifying culture conditions or cell density, indicating that extracellular signals influenced the epimastigote decision between life and death. Epimastigotes responded to complement-mediated immunological agression by undergoing apoptosis, while undergoing necrosis in response to nonphysiological saponin-mediated damage. PCD may participate into the optimal adaptation of T. cruzi to its different hosts, and the avoidance of a local competition between a G0/G1 arrested stage and its proliferating progenitor. The existence of a regulated cell death programme inducing an apoptotic phenotype in a unicellular eukaryote provides a paradigm for a widespread role for PCD in the control of cell survival, which extends beyond the evolutionary constraints that may be specific to multicellular organisms and raises the question of the origin and nature of the genes involved. Another implication is that PCD induction could represent a target for therapeutic strategies against unicellular pathogens.     

Signaling molecules involved in the transition of growth to development of Dictyostelium discoideum

The social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum, a powerful paradigm provides clear insights into the regulation of growth and development. In addition to possessing complex individual cellular functions like a unicellular eukaryote, D. discoideum cells face the challenge of multicellular development. D. discoideum undergoes a relatively simple differentiation process mainly by cAMP mediated pathway. Despite this relative simplicity, the regulatory signaling pathways are as complex as those seen in metazoan development. However, the introduction of restriction-enzyme-mediated integration (REMI) technique to produce developmental gene knockouts has provided novel insights into the discovery of signaling molecules and their role in D. discoideum development. Cell cycle phase is an important aspect for differentiation of D. discoideum, as cells must reach a specific stage to enter into developmental phase and specific cell cycle regulators are involved in arresting growth phase genes and inducing the developmental genes. In this review, we present an overview of the signaling molecules involved in the regulation of growth to differentiation transition (GDT), molecular mechanism of early developmental events leading to generation of cAMP signal and components of cAMP relay system that operate in this paradigm.     

CbfA, the C-module DNA-binding factor, plays an essential role in the initiation of Dictyostelium discoideum development

We recently isolated from Dictyostelium discoideum cells a DNA-binding protein, CbfA, that interacts in vitro with a regulatory element in retrotransposon TRE5-A. We have generated a mutant strain that expresses CbfA at <5% of the wild-type level to characterize the consequences for D. discoideum cell physiology. We found that the multicellular development program leading to fruiting body formation is highly compromised in the mutant. The cells cannot aggregate and stay as a monolayer almost indefinitely. The cells respond properly to prestarvation conditions by expressing discoidin in a cell density-dependent manner. A genomewide microarray-assisted expression analysis combined with Northern blot analyses revealed a failure of CbfA-depleted cells to induce the gene encoding aggregation-specific adenylyl cyclase ACA and other genes required for cyclic AMP (cAMP) signal relay, which is necessary for aggregation and subsequent multicellular development. However, the cbfA mutant aggregated efficiently when mixed with as few as 5% wild-type cells. Moreover, pulsing cbfA mutant cells developing in suspension with nanomolar levels of cAMP resulted in induction of acaA and other early developmental genes. Although the response was less efficient and slower than in wild-type cells, it showed that cells depleted of CbfA are able to initiate development if given exogenous cAMP signals. Ectopic expression of the gene encoding the catalytic subunit of protein kinase A restored multicellular development of the mutant. We conclude that sensing of cell density and starvation are independent of CbfA, whereas CbfA is essential for the pattern of gene expression which establishes the genetic network leading to aggregation and multicellular development of D. discoideum.     

Differentiation of Dictyostelium discoideum in monolayer cultures and its modification by ionic conditions

Abstract. We have compared the pattern of enzyme expression in cyclic AMP-induced monolayer cultures of Dictyostelium discoideum with that found during normal development. We find that both the temporal and quantitative pattern of enzyme expression are initially similar in the two situations, although the developmental sequence is more protracted and terminal cell differentiation is delayed in the monolayer situation. We describe differentiation conditions that permit the expression of only one terminal phenotype, which may be useful for further biochemical studies. Enzyme accumulation patterns under these conditions indicate that UDP gal transferase is not required for stalk cell differentiation (i.e., it is a prespore enzyme). We have shown that, when cell monolayers are incubated with CAMP, the presence of a weak acid at low extracellular pH favors stalk-cell differentiation, while a weak base at high extracellular pH favors spore differentiation. Finally, we show that variations in the monovalent cation content of the buffer, or the addition of an ion transport inhibitor (scillaren), or an ionophore (valinomycin) all affect the ratio of stalk cells to spores. Taken together, these results suggest that intracellular H⁺ and or other cations may play an important role in regulating differentiation of specific cell types in D. discoideum .