Basis for changes in DNA recognition by the EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 type I DNA restriction and modification enzymes

EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 are type I DNA restriction and modification systems. The EcoR124/3 system arose from the EcoR124 system some 15 years ago and at the electron microscopic DNA heteroduplex level the genes for both systems are still apparently identical. We have shown that the DNA sequences recognized by the two systems are GAA(N6)RTCG for EcoR124 and GAA(N7)RTCG for EcoR124/3. The sequences thus differ only in the length of the non-specific spacer. This difference nevertheless places the two specific domains of the EcoR124/3 recognition sequence 0.34 nm further apart and rotates them 36 degrees with respect to those of EcoR124, which implies major structural differences in the proteins recognizing these sequences. We have now determined the nucleotide sequences of the hsdS and hsdM genes of both systems and of the hsdR gene of EcoR124/3. The hsdS gene products provide DNA sequence specificity in both restriction and modification, the hsdM gene products are necessary for modification and all three hsd gene products are required for restriction. The only difference that we have detected between the two systems is that a 12 base-pair sequence towards the middle of the hsdS gene is repeated twice in the EcoR124 gene and three times in the EcoR124/3 gene. We have deleted one of the repeats in the EcoR124/3 gene and shown that this changes the specificity to that of EcoR124. Thus, the extra four amino acids in the middle of the EcoR124/3 hsdS gene product, which in an alpha-helical configuration would extend 0.6 nm, are sufficient to explain the differences in sequence recognition. We suggest that the EcoR124/3 system was generated by an unequal crossing over and argue that this kind of specificity change should not be rare in Nature.     

Analysis of type I restriction modification systems in the Neisseriaceae: genetic organization and properties of the gene products

The hsd locus (host specificity of DNA) was identified in the Neisseria gonorrhoeae genome. The DNA fragment encoding this locus produced an active restriction and modification (R/M) system when cloned into Escherichia coli. This R/M system was designated NgoAV. The cloned genomic fragment (7800 bp) has the potential to encode seven open reading frames (ORFs). Several of these ORFs had significant homology with other proteins found in the databases: ORF1, the hsdM, a methylase subunit (HsdM); ORF2, a homologue of dinD; ORF3, a homologue of hsdS; ORF4, a homologue of hsdS; and ORF5, an endonuclease subunit hsdR. The endonuclease and methylase subunits possessed strongest protein sequence homology to the EcoR124II R/M system, indicating that NgoAV belongs to the type IC R/M family. Deletion analysis showed that only ORF3 imparted the sequence specificity of the RM.NgoAV system, which recognizes an interrupted palindrome sequence (GCAN(8-)TGC). The genetic structure of ORF3 (208 amino acids) is almost identical to the structure of the 5' truncated hsdS genes of EcoDXXI or EcoR124II R/M systems obtained by in vitro manipulation. Genomic sequence analysis allowed us to identify hsd loci with a very high homology to RM.NgoAV in two strains of Neisseria meningitidis. However, significant differences in the organization and structure of the hsdS genes in both these systems suggests that, if functional, they would possess recognition sites that differ from the gonococcus and from themselves.     

A third family of allelic hsd genes in Salmonella enterica: sequence comparisons with related proteins identify conserved regions implicated in restriction of DNA

Salmonella enterica serovar blegdam has a restriction and modification system encoded by genes linked to serB . We have cloned these genes, putative alleles of the hsd locus of Escherichia coli  K-12, and confirmed by the sequence similarities of flanking DNA that the hsd genes of S. enterica serovar blegdam have the same chromosomal location as those of E. coli K-12 and Salmonella enterica serovar typhimurium LT2. There is, however, no obvious similarity in their nucleotide sequences, and while the gene order in S. enterica serovar blegdam is serB hsdM , S and R , that in E. coli K-12 and S. enterica serovar typhimurium LT2 is serB hsdR , M and S . The hsd genes of S. enterica serovar blegdam identify a third family of serB -linked hsd genes (type ID). The polypeptide sequence predicted from the three hsd genes show some similarities (18–50% identity) with the polypeptides of known and putative type I restriction and modification systems; the highest levels of identity are with sequences of Haemophilus influenzae Rd. The HsdM polypeptide has the motifs characteristic of adenine methyltransferases. Comparisons of the HsdR sequence with those for three other families of type I systems and three putative HsdR polypeptides identify two highly conserved regions in addition to the seven proposed DEAD-box motifs.     

The EcoDXX1 restriction and modification system: cloning the genes and homology to type I restriction and modification systems

The Escherichia coli plasmid pDXX1 codes for a type I restriction and modification system, EcoDXX1. A 15.5-kb BamHI fragment from pDXX1 has been cloned and contains the hsdR, hsdM, and hsdS genes that encode the EcoDXX1 system. The EcoDXX1 hsd genes can complement the gene products of the EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 hsd systems, but not those of EcoK and EcoB. Hybridization experiments using EcoDXX1 hsd genes as a probe demonstrate homology between EcoDXX1 and EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 restriction-modification systems, but weak or no homology between EcoDXX1 and EcoK or EcoB systems.     

Distribution and diversity of hsd genes in Escherichia coli and other enteric bacteria.

We screened Salmonella typhimurium, Citrobacter freundii, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Shigella boydii, and many isolates of Escherichia coli for DNA sequences homologous to those encoding each of two unrelated type I restriction and modification systems (EcoK and EcoA). Both K- and A-related hsd genes were identified, but never both in the same strain. S. typhimurium encodes three restriction and modification systems, but its DNA hybridized only to the K-specific probe which we know to identify the StySB system. No homology to either probe was detected in the majority of E. coli strains, but in C. freundii, we identified homology to the A-specific probe. We cloned this region of the C. freundii genome and showed that it encoded a functional, A-related restriction system whose specificity differs from those of known type I enzymes. Sequences immediately flanking the hsd K genes of E. coli K-12 and the hsd A genes of E. coli 15T- were shown to be homologous, indicating similar or even identical positions in their respective chromosomes. E. coli C has no known restriction system, and the organization of its chromosome is consistent with deletion of the three hsd genes and their neighbor, mcrB.     

Regulation of a restriction and modification system via DNA inversion in Mycoplasma pulmonis

An invertible DNA element of 6.8 kb, designated the hsd1 locus, was identified in the chromosome of Mycoplasma pulmonis. Infection of host cells with mycoplasma virus P1 revealed that the organism's restriction and modification (R-M) properties are controlled by inversion of hsd1. The nucleotide sequence of hsd1 revealed several genes, the predicted amino acids of which bear striking similarity to the subunits of the type I R-M enzymes previously found only in enteric bacteria.     

EcoA and EcoE: alternatives to the EcoK family of type I restriction and modification systems of Escherichia coli

The genes (hsd A) encoding EcoA, a restriction and modification system first identified in Escherichia coli 15T-, behave in genetic crosses as alleles of the genes (hsd K) encoding the archetypal type I restriction and modification system of E. coli K12. Nevertheless, molecular experiments have failed to detect relatedness between the A and K systems. We have cloned the hsd A genes and have identified, on the basis of DNA homology, related genes (hsd E) conferring a new specificity to a natural isolate of E. coli. We show that the overall organization of the genes encoding EcoA and EcoE closely parallels that for EcoK. Each enzyme is encoded by three genes, of which only one, hsdS, confers the specificity of DNA interaction. The three genes are in the same order as those encoding EcoK, i.e. hsdR, hsdM and hsdS and, similarly, they include a promoter between hsdR and hsdM from which the M and S genes can be transcribed. The evidence indicates that EcoA and EcoE are type I restriction and modification enzymes, but they appear to identify an alternative family to EcoK. For both families, the hsdR polypeptide is by far the largest, but the sizes of the other two polypeptides are reversed, with the smallest polypeptide of EcoK being the product of hsd S, and the smallest for the EcoA family being the product of hsdM. Physiologically, the A restriction and modification system differs from that of K and its relatives, in that A-specific methylation of unmodified DNA is particularly effective.     

The Diversity of Alleles at the Hsd Locus in Natural Populations of Escherichia Coli

In enteric bacteria three discrete families of type I restriction and modification systems (IA, IB and ID) are encoded by alleles of the serB-linked hsd locus. Probes specific for each of the three familes were used to monitor the distribution of related systems in 37 of the 72 wild-type Escherichia coli strains comprising the ECOR collection. All 25 members of group A in this collection were screened; 12 were probe-positive, nine have hsd genes in the IA family, two in the IB and one in the ID. Twelve strains, representing all groups other than A, were screened; five were probe-positive, one has hsd genes in the IA family, one in the IB and three in the ID. The type ID genes are the first representatives of this family in E. coli, the probe-negative strains could have alternative families of hsd genes. The type IA and IB systems added at least five new specificites to the five already identified in natural isolates of E. coli. The distribution of alleles is inconsistent with the dendrogram of the bacterial strains derived from other criteria. This discrepancy and the dissimilar coding sequences of allelic hsd genes both imply lateral transfer of hsd genes.     

Complementation and hybridization evidence for additional families of type I DNA restriction and modification genes in Salmonella serotypes.

Of eight Salmonella, serB-linked hsd genes for the restriction and modification of DNA transferred to Escherichia coli/Salmonella hybrids, only two--those with SM and ST (S. muenchen and S. thompson, respectively) specificities--may have weakly complemented rSB- and none complemented rK-. An A-specific DNA probe failed to hybridize to HindIII-restricted fragments of each of the hybrids, but an SB (S. typhimurium)-specific probe hybridized to DNA from the hybrid with ST specificity. These results indicate that additional families of the type I hsd genes may exist.     

A family of moderately repetitive sequences in mouse DNA.

When mouse DNA is digested to completion with restriction endonuclease Eco R1, a distinct band of 1.3 kb segments comprising about 0.5-3% of the genome is observed upon agarose gel electrophoresis. This DNA is not tandemly repeated in the genome and is not derived from mouse satellite DNA. Restriction endonuclease analysis suggested that the 1.3 kb segments are heterogeneous. Specific sequences were selected from the 1.3 kb segments and amplified by cloning in plasmid pBR322. Southern transfer experiments indicated that three separately cloned mouse DNA inserts hybridized predominantly to the Eco R1 1.3 kb band and to the conspicuous subsegments generated by secondary restriction endonuclease cleavage of the sucrose gradient purified 1.3 kb segments. Segments were also excised by Hha I (Hha I segments) from the chimeric plasmids containing mouse DNA inserts and subjected to restriction endonuclease and cross-hybridization analysis. It was found that the three Hha I segments were different, although two of them exhibited partial sequence homology. Cot analysis indicated that each of the Hha I segments are repeated about 10(4) times in the mouse genome. These findings indicate that a family of related but non-identical, moderately repetitive DNA sequences, rather than a single homogeneous repeat, is present in the 1.3 kb Eco R1 band.     

ClpX and ClpP are essential for the efficient acquisition of genes specifying type IA and IB restriction systems

Efficient acquisition of genes that encode a restriction and modification (R–M) system with specificities different from any already present in the recipient bacterium requires the sequential production of the new modification enzyme followed by the restriction activity in order that the chromosome of the recipient bacterium is protected against attack by the restriction endonuclease. We show that ClpX and ClpP, the components of ClpXP protease, are necessary for the efficient transmission of the genes encoding Eco KI and Eco AI, representatives of two families of type I R–M systems, thus implicating ClpXP in the modulation of restriction activity. Loss of ClpX imposed a bigger barrier than loss of ClpP, consistent with a dual role for ClpX, possibly as a chaperone and as a component of the ClpXP protease. Transmission of genes specifying Eco KI was more dependent on ClpX and ClpP than transmission of the genes for Eco AI. Sensitivity to absence of the protease was also influenced by the mode of gene transfer; conjugative transfer and transformation were more dependent on ClpXP than transduction. In the absence of either ClpX or ClpP transfer of the Eco KI genes by P1-mediated transduction was impaired, transfer of the Eco AI genes was not.     

New restriction enzymes discovered from Escherichia coli clinical strains using a plasmid transformation method

The presence of restriction enzymes in bacterial cells has been predicted by either classical phage restriction-modification (R-M) tests, direct in vitro enzyme assays or more recently from bacterial genome sequence analysis. We have applied phage R-M test principles to the transformation of plasmid DNA and established a plasmid R-M test. To validate this test, six plasmids that contain BamHI fragments of phage lambda DNA were constructed and transformed into Escherichia coli strains containing known R-M systems including: type I (EcoBI, EcoAI, Eco124I), type II (HindIII) and type III (EcoP1I). Plasmid DNA with a single recognition site showed a reduction of relative efficiency of transformation (EOT = 10(-1)-10(-2)). When multiple recognition sites were present, greater reductions in EOT values were observed. Once established in the cell, the plasmids were subjected to modification (EOT = 1.0). We applied this test to screen E.coli clinical strains and detected the presence of restriction enzymes in 93% (14/15) of cells. Using additional subclones and the computer program, RM Search, we identified four new restriction enzymes, Eco377I, Eco585I, Eco646I and Eco777I, along with their recognition sequences, GGA(8N)ATGC, GCC(6N)TGCG, CCA(7N)CTTC, and GGA(6N)TATC, respectively. Eco1158I, an isoschizomer of EcoBI, was also found in this study.     

The specificity of sty SKI, a type I restriction enzyme, implies a structure with rotational symmetry.

The type I restriction and modification (R-M) enzyme from Salmonella enterica serovar kaduna ( Sty SKI) recognises the DNA sequence 5'-CGAT(N)7GTTA, an unusual target for a type I R-M system in that it comprises two tetranucleotide components. The amino target recognition domain (TRD) of Sty SKI recognises 5'-CGAT and shows 36% amino acid identity with the carboxy TRD of Eco R124I which recognises the complementary, but degenerate, sequence 5'-RTCG. Current models predict that the amino and carboxy TRDs of the specificity subunit are in inverted orientations within a structure with 2-fold rotational symmetry. The complementary target sequences recognised by the amino TRD of Sty SKI and the carboxy TRD of Eco R124I are consistent with the predicted inverted positions of the TRDs. Amino TRDs of similar amino acid sequence have been shown to recognise the same nucleotide sequence. The similarity reported here, the first example of one between amino and carboxy TRDs, while consistent with a conserved mechanism of target recognition, offers additional flexibility in the evolution of sequence specificity by increasing the potential diversity of DNA targets for a given number of TRDs. Sty SKI identifies the first member of the IB family in Salmonella species.     

Location of DNA sequences complementary to small nuclear repeat RNA (fr 3-RNA) in relation to DNA sequences coding for albumin and alpha-fetoprotein in rat liver cells

Rat liver nuclei contain a 29-nucleotides-long RNA (fr 3-RNA) which is transcribed from middle repetitive DNA sequences. By Southern analysis of restriction fragments of rat albumin and alpha-fetoprotein genomic clones, DNA sequences complementary to this RNA were detected on a 4.6 kbp Eco RI fragment located 600 bp downstream from the termination exon of the albumin gene and on a 2 kbp Eco RI-HindIII fragment located 10 kbp downstream from the restriction fragment containing the alpha-fetoprotein site. No sequence complementary to this RNA was found either in the introns of exons of both genes or in the regions extending 7 kbp upstream from the first albumin exon and 10 kbp upstream of the first alpha-fetoprotein exon. We concluded that sequences complementary to fr 3-RNA are present at the 3'-end flanking regions of the rat albumin and alpha-fetoprotein gene complexes.     

On the structure and operation of type I DNA restriction enzymes.

Type I DNA restriction enzymes are large, molecular machines possessing DNA methyltransferase, ATPase, DNA translocase and endonuclease activities. The ATPase, DNA translocase and endonuclease activities are specified by the restriction (R) subunit of the enzyme. We demonstrate that the R subunit of the Eco KI type I restriction enzyme comprises several different functional domains. An N-terminal domain contains an amino acid motif identical with that forming the catalytic site in simple restriction endonucleases, and changes within this motif lead to a loss of nuclease activity and abolish the restriction reaction. The central part of the R subunit contains amino acid sequences characteristic of DNA helicases. We demonstrate, using limited proteolysis of this subunit, that the helicase motifs are contained in two domains. Secondary structure prediction of these domains suggests a structure that is the same as the catalytic domains of DNA helicases of known structure. The C-terminal region of the R subunit can be removed by elastase treatment leaving a large fragment, stable in the presence of ATP, which can no longer bind to the other subunits of Eco KI suggesting that this domain is required for protein assembly. Considering these results and previous models of the methyltransferase part of these enzymes, a structural and operational model of a type I DNA restriction enzyme is presented.     

The DNA translocation and ATPase activities of restriction-deficient mutants of Eco KI.

Eco KI, a type I restriction enzyme, specifies DNA methyltransferase, ATPase, endonuclease and DNA translocation activities. One subunit (HsdR) of the oligomeric enzyme contributes to those activities essential for restriction. These activities involve ATP-dependent DNA translocation and DNA cleavage. Mutations that change amino acids within recognisable motifs in HsdR impair restriction. We have used an in vivo assay to monitor the effect of these mutations on DNA translocation. The assay follows the Eco KI-dependent entry of phage T7 DNA from the phage particle into the host cell. Earlier experiments have shown that mutations within the seven motifs characteristic of the DEAD-box family of proteins that comprise known or putative helicases severely impair the ATPase activity of purified enzymes. We find that the mutations abolish DNA translocation in vivo. This provides evidence that these motifs are relevant to the coupling of ATP hydrolysis to DNA translocation. Mutations that identify an endonuclease motif similar to that found at the active site of type II restriction enzymes and other nucleases have been shown to abolish DNA nicking activity. When conservative changes are made at these residues, the enzymes lack nuclease activity but retain the ability to hydrolyse ATP and to translocate DNA at wild-type levels. It has been speculated that nicking may be necessary to resolve the topological problems associated with DNA translocation by type I restriction and modification systems. Our experiments show that loss of the nicking activity associated with the endonuclease motif of Eco KI has no effect on ATPase activity in vitro or DNA translocation of the T7 genome in vivo.     

The Sse9I restriction-modification system: organization of genes and comparative analysis of proteins structures

A nucleotide sequence was established for the full-length Sporosarcina species 9D operon coding for enzymes of type II restriction-modification system Sse9I. These enzymes recognize the tetranucleotide DNA sequence 5'-AATT-3'. The operon was shown to consist of three genes that are situated with the order: sse9IC-sse9IR-sse9IM and are transcribed in the same direction. These genes encode the control protein (C.Sse9I), restriction endonuclease (R.Sse9I) and DNA-methyltransferase (M.Sse9I), respectively. A specific DNA sequence (C-box) presumably recognized by C-protein was found immediately upstream of sse9IC gene. The comparative analysis of amino acid sequences of C.Sse9I and R.Sse9I with those of relative proteins has been done. It was found that R.Sse9I revealed the most homology with the segments of R.MunI (5'-CAATTG-3') and R.EcoRI (5'-GAATTC-3'), where amino acid residues, responsible for recogniton of AATT core sequence are located. The sse9IR gene was cloned into the temperature-inducible expression vector, and recombinant Sse9I restriction endonuclease preparation was isolated.     

Two types of triplicated alpha-globin loci in humans.

DNA from healthy Malaysian newborns was studied on gene maps after digestion with different restriction endonucleases. Of 65 newborns, two were found to be carriers of two different variants of triplicated alpha-globin loci. In variant no. 1, found in an Malay, the three alpha-globin genes are in an elongated DNA fragment on digestion with Eco RI and Bam HI. The third alpha-globin gene was found in a additional 3.7-kb fragment on digestion with Hpa I, Bgl II and Hind III. In variant no. 2, a new type of triplicated alpha-globin loci, found in a Chinese, the three alpha-globin genes reside in an elongated DNA fragment longer than that of variant no. 1 on digestion with Eco RI and Bam HI. The third alpha-globin gene was found in an additional 4.2-kb fragment on digestion with Hpa I and Hind III. Digestion of this variant DNA with Bg1 II produced an abnormal 16.7-kb fragment in addition to the normal 7.0-kb Bgl-II fragment. The locations of the restriction sites in the two types of triplicated alpha-globin loci are compatible with a mechanism of unequal crossing over following two different modes of misalignment.