Frustration Between Preferred States of Complementary Trinucleotide Repeat DNA Hairpins Anticorrelates with Expansion Disease Propensity

DNA trinucleotide repeat (TRs) expansion beyond a threshold often results in human neurodegenerative diseases. The mechanisms causing expansions remain unknown, although the tendency of TR ssDNA to self-associate into hairpins that slip along their length is widely presumed related. Here we apply single molecule FRET (smFRET) experiments and molecular dynamics simulations to determine conformational stabilities and slipping dynamics for CAG, CTG, GAC and GTC hairpins. Tetraloops are favored in CAG (89%), CTG (89%) and GTC (69%) while GAC favors triloops. We also determined that TTG interrupts near the loop in the CTG hairpin stabilize the hairpin against slipping. The different loop stabilities have implications for intermediate structures that may form when TR-containing duplex DNA opens. Opposing hairpins in the (CAG) ∙ (CTG) duplex would have matched stability whereas opposing hairpins in a (GAC) ∙ (GTC) duplex would have unmatched stability, introducing frustration in the (GAC) ∙ (GTC) opposing hairpins that could encourage their resolution to duplex DNA more rapidly than in (CAG) ∙ (CTG) structures. Given that the CAG and CTG TR can undergo large, disease-related expansion whereas the GAC and GTC sequences do not, these stability differences can inform and constrain models of expansion mechanisms of TR regions.     

NMR studies on DNA hairpin structures with a five nucleotide loop

One- and two-dimensional NMR experiments have been undertaken to investigate the structure of DNA hairpins with a five nucleotide loop. Analysis of proton NMR spectra suggests that the four hairpin structures examined have some common structural features; B-type conformation in the stem region and the same stacking pattern, 5' (XXX-turn-XX) 3', in the loop region. The phosphorus NMR spectra suggest that the conformational changes in the loop region affect the backbone conformation of the stem duplex.     

Double threading through DNA: NMR structural study of a bis-naphthalene macrocycle bound to a thymine-thymine mismatch

The macrocyclic bis-naphthalene macrocycle (2,7-BisNP), belonging to the cyclobisintercalator family of DNA ligands, recognizes T-T mismatch sites in duplex DNA with high affinity and selectivity, as evidenced by thermal denaturation experiments and NMR titrations. The binding of this macrocycle to an 11-mer DNA oligonucleotide containing a T-T mismatch was studied using NMR spectroscopy and NMR-restrained molecular modeling. The ligand forms a single type of complex with the DNA, in which one of the naphthalene rings of the ligand occupies the place of one of the mismatched thymines, which is flipped out of the duplex. The second naphthalene unit of the ligand intercalates at the A-T base pair flanking the mismatch site, leading to encapsulation of its thymine residue via double stacking. The polyammonium linking chains of the macrocycle are located in the minor and the major grooves of the oligonucleotide and participate in the stabilization of the complex by formation of hydrogen bonds with the encapsulated thymine base and the mismatched thymine remaining inside the helix. The study highlights the uniqueness of this cyclobisintercalation binding mode and its importance for recognition of DNA lesion sites by small molecules.     

Structure of even/odd trinucleotide repeat sequences modulates persistence of non-B conformations and conversion to duplex

Expansion of trinucleotide repeats (TNR) has been implicated in the emergence of neurodegenerative diseases. Formation of non-B conformations such as hairpins by these repeat sequences during DNA replication and/or repair has been proposed as a contributing factor to expansion. In this work we employed a combination of fluorescence, chemical probing, optical melting, and gel shift assays to characterize the structure of a series of (CTG)(n) sequences and the kinetic parameters describing their interaction with a complementary sequence. Our structure-based experiments using chemical probing reveal that sequences containing an even or odd number of CTG repeats adopt stem-loop hairpins that differ from one another by the absence or presence of a stem overhang. Furthermore, we find that this structural difference dictates the rate at which the TNR hairpins convert to duplex with a complementary CAG sequence. Indeed, the rate constant describing conversion to (CAG)(10)/(CTG)(n) duplex is slower for sequences containing an even number of CTG repeats than for sequences containing an odd number of repeats. Thus, when both the CAG and CTG hairpins have an even number of the repeats, they display a longer lifetime relative to when the CTG hairpin has an odd number of repeats. The difference in lifetimes observed for these TNR hairpins has implications toward their persistence during DNA replication or repair events and could influence their predisposition toward expansion. Taken together, these results contribute to our understanding of trinucleotide repeats and the factors that regulate persistence of hairpins in these repetitive sequences and conversion to canonical duplex.     

Structural polymorphism exhibited by a quasipalindrome present in the locus control region (LCR) of the human beta-globin gene cluster

Structural polymorphism of DNA is a widely accepted property. A simple addition to this perception has been our recent finding, where a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) site present in a quasipalindromic sequence of β-globin LCR exhibited a hairpin-duplex equilibrium. Our current studies explore that secondary structures adopted by individual complementary strands compete with formation of a perfect duplex. Using gel-electrophoresis, ultraviolet (UV)-thermal denaturation, circular dichroism (CD) techniques, we have demonstrated the structural transitions within a perfect duplex containing 11 bp quasipalindromic stretch (TGGGG(G/C)CCCCA), to hairpins and bulge duplex forms. The extended version of the 11 bp duplex, flanked by 5 bp on both sides also demonstrated conformational equilibrium between duplex and hairpin species. Gel-electrophoresis confirms that the duplex coexists with hairpin and bulge duplex/cruciform species. Further, in CD spectra of duplexes, presence of two overlapping positive peaks at 265 and 285 nm suggest the features of A- as well as B-type DNA conformation and show oligomer concentration dependence, manifested in A → B transition. This indicates the possibility of an architectural switching at quasipalindromic region between linear duplex to a cruciform structure. Such DNA structural variations are likely to be found in the mechanics of molecular recognition and manipulation by proteins.     

Selective recognition of pyrimidine-pyrimidine DNA mismatches by distance-constrained macrocyclic bis-intercalators

Binding of three macrocyclic bis-intercalators, derivatives of acridine and naphthalene, and two acyclic model compounds to mismatch-containing and matched duplex oligodeoxynucleotides was analyzed by thermal denaturation experiments, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry studies (ESI-MS) and fluorescent intercalator displacement (FID) titrations. The macrocyclic bis-intercalators bind to duplexes containing mismatched thymine bases with high selectivity over the fully matched ones, whereas the acyclic model compounds are much less selective and strongly bind to the matched DNA. Moreover, the results from thermal denaturation experiments are in very good agreement with the binding affinities obtained by ESI-MS and FID measurements. The FID results also demonstrate that the macrocyclic naphthalene derivative BisNP preferentially binds to pyrimidine–pyrimidine mismatches compared to all other possible base mismatches. This ligand also efficiently competes with a DNA enzyme (M.TaqI) for binding to a duplex with a TT-mismatch, as shown by competitive fluorescence titrations. Altogether, our results demonstrate that macrocyclic distance-constrained bis-intercalators are efficient and selective mismatch-binding ligands that can interfere with mismatch-binding enzymes.     

79 Thermodynamic and kinetic studies of trinucleotide repeat (TNR) DNA

The expansion of trinucleotide repeat (TNR) DNA has been linked to several neurodegenerative diseases (McMurray, 2010). The number of repeats is usually a characteristic indication of the severity of TNR-related diseases, with longer repeats giving higher propensity to expand and earlier onset of symptoms (López, Cleary, & Pearson, 2010). It is generally accepted that formation of noncanonical secondary structures, such as stem-loop hairpins or slipouts, contributes to the expansion mechanisms during aberrant DNA replication or repair processes (Mirkin, 2007). The stability of these hairpins is considered an important factor (Paiva & Sheardy, 2005). In this work, we used differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and UV–Vis spectroscopy to study the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of a series of (CTG)_n and (CAG)_n TNR stem-loop hairpins and their corresponding (CTG)_n/(CAG)_n duplexes (n?=?6–14). We found that hairpins with n?=?even and n?=?even?+?1 (odd) repeats possess very similar thermodynamic stability. But, when converting to the canonical duplex form, odd-repeat hairpins are more stabilized compared to those of their even-repeat counterparts. Within both even- and odd-repeat series, hairpins with longer repeats are thermodynamically more stabilized compared to the shorter ones. Kinetic experiments of the stem-loop hairpin to duplex conversion revealed a longer lifetime for the even-repeat hairpins, while the odd-repeat hairpins convert to duplexes 10-fold faster. Also, hairpins with increased number of repeats are more resistant to the conversion when considered within the even- or odd-repeat series individually. Taken together, although it is thermodynamically more favored that hairpins containing longer repeats convert to canonical duplex form; On the contrary, these longer hairpins are kinetically trapped during the conversion and therefore can persist the noncanonical structures, which allows TNR expansion.     

Effects of polyamines on the thermal stability and formation kinetics of DNA duplexes with abnormal structure

The effects of ions (i.e. Na⁺, Mg²⁺ and polyamines including spermidine and spermine) on the stability of various DNA oligonucleotides in solution were studied. These synthetic DNA molecules contained sequences that mimic various cellular DNA structures, such as duplexes, bulged loops, hairpins and/or mismatched base pairs. Melting temperature curves obtained from the ultraviolet spectroscopic experiments indicated that the effectiveness of the stabilization of cations on the duplex formation follows the order of spermine > spermidine > Mg²⁺ > Na⁺ > Tris–HCl buffer alone at pH 7.3. Circular dichroism spectra showed that salts and polyamines did not change the secondary structures of those DNA molecules under study. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) observations suggested that the rates of duplex formation are independent of the kind of cations used or the structure of the duplexes. However, the rate constants of DNA duplex dissociation decrease in the same order when those cations are involved. The enhancement of the duplex stability by polyamines, especially spermine, can compensate for the instability caused by abnormal structures (e.g. bulged loops, hairpins or mismatches). The effects can be so great as to make the abnormal DNAs as stable as the perfect duplex, both kinetically and thermodynamically. Our results may suggest that the interconversion of various DNA structures can be accomplished readily in the presence of polyamine. This may be relevant in understanding the role of DNA polymorphism in cells.     

DNA hairpins destabilize duplexes primarily by promoting melting rather than by inhibiting hybridization

The effect of secondary structure on DNA duplex formation is poorly understood. Using oxDNA, a nucleotide level coarse-grained model of DNA, we study how hairpins influence the rate and reaction pathways of DNA hybridzation. We compare to experimental systems studied by Gao et al. (1) and find that 3-base pair hairpins reduce the hybridization rate by a factor of 2, and 4-base pair hairpins by a factor of 10, compared to DNA with limited secondary structure, which is in good agreement with experiments. By contrast, melting rates are accelerated by factors of ∼100 and ∼2000. This surprisingly large speed-up occurs because hairpins form during the melting process, and significantly lower the free energy barrier for dissociation. These results should assist experimentalists in designing sequences to be used in DNA nanotechnology, by putting limits on the suppression of hybridization reaction rates through the use of hairpins and offering the possibility of deliberately increasing dissociation rates by incorporating hairpins into single strands.     

The ligation and flexibility of four-arm DNA junctions

Four-arm DNA branched junctions are stable analogs of Holliday recombination intermediates, constructed from oligonucleotides. The conformational flexibility of junctions can be estimated by ligating them together and determining the set of closed macrocyclic products that are obtained among the linked units. We have performed a series of these experiments, using pairs of sticky ends that flank each of the six angles of a four-arm junction. In every case, the ligated junctions are separated by 20 nucleotide pairs, about two turns of DNA. All expected short linear products, starting with dimers, are observed for all ligations. All ligations result in a macrocyclic series that begins with trimers. Thus, over the time scale of these reactions, the arms of this junction can form angles as low as 60°. The response of this junction to torsional stress has been tested in a companion experiment. A smaller version of this same four-arm junction has been oligomerized so that successive junctions are separated by 16 nucleotide pairs, approximately 1.5 turns of DNA. If junctions were as rigid as linear duplex DNA, this system would not be expected to form macrocycles until the continuous chain approaches the Shore–Baldwin limit, ca. 160 base pairs. However, macrocyclic closure is observed in a regular ligation ladder, starting from tetramers. Model building suggests that the most likely explanation for the observed closure is that the junction adopts two different conformations, which bend the continuous strand toward opposite grooves. The junction structures formed by these ligations represent fluctuations from equilibrium structures.     

Melting studies of short DNA hairpins containing the universal base 5-nitroindole.

Effects of the universal base 5-nitroindole on the thermodynamic stability of DNA hairpins having a 6 bp stem and four base loops were investigated by optical absorbance and differential scanning calorimetry techniques. Melting studies were conducted in buffer containing 115 mM Na(+). Five different modified versions of DNA hairpins containing a 5-nitroindole base or bases substituted at different positions in the stem and loop regions were examined. Thermo-dynamic parameters of the melting transitions estimated from a two-state analysis of optical melting curves and measured directly by calorimetry revealed that the presence of 5-nitroindole bases in the duplex stem or loop regions of short DNA hairpins significantly affects both their enthalpic and entropic melting components in a compensating manner, while the transition free energy varies linearly with the transition temperature. The calorimetrically determined enthalpy and entropy values of the modified hairpins were considerably smaller (43-53%) than the two-state optical parameters, suggesting that solvent effects may be significant in the melting processes of these hairpins. Results of circular dichroism measurements also revealed slight differences between the modified hairpins and the control in both the duplex and melted states, suggesting subtle structural differences between the control and DNA hairpins containing a 5-nitroindole base or bases.     

The effect of hydrostatic pressure on the thermal stability of DNA hairpins

DNA hairpins consist of two distinct structural domains: a double stranded stem and a single-stranded loop that connect the two strands of the stem. Previous studies of short DNA hairpins have revealed that loop and stem sequences can significantly affect the thermodynamic stability of short DNA hairpins. In this work we present the effect of hydrostatic pressure on the helix-coil transition temperature (T_M) for 11 16-base, hairpin-forming DNA oligonucleotides. All of the samples form a hairpin with a 6-base pair stem and a four-base loop. In addition, the four base pairs at the end of the stem distal from the loop are the same for every molecule. We have varied loop sequence and identity of the two duplex base pairs adjacent to the loop. Using the change in UV absorption to monitor the conformational state of the oligonucleotide the hairpin-coil transition temperature of these molecules was studied as a function of sodium ion concentration and pressure. From these data we calculated the volume change accompanying the transition. Model-dependent (van't Hoff) transition parameters such as ΔH_vH and transition volume (ΔV) were estimated from the analysis of conformational transitions. Experiments revealed that the ΔV for denaturation of these molecules range from − 2.35 to + 6.74 cm³ mol⁻¹. The expansibility (ΔΔV/ΔT) and the pressure dependence of cation release are also presented. The difference in the volume change for this transition is related to the differences in the hydration of these molecules.     

X-ray crystallographic study of DNA duplex cross-linking: simultaneous binding to two d(CGTACG)2 molecules by a bis(9-aminoacridine-4-carboxamide) derivative

Acridine-4-carboxamides form a class of known DNA mono-intercalating agents that exhibit cytotoxic activity against tumour cell lines due to their ability to inhibit topoisomerases. Previous studies of bis-acridine derivatives have yielded equivocal results regarding the minimum length of linker necessary between the two acridine chromophores to allow bis-intercalation of duplex DNA. We report here the 1.7 A resolution X-ray crystal structure of a six-carbon-linked bis(acridine-4-carboxamide) ligand bound to d(CGTACG)2 molecules by non-covalent duplex cross-linking. The asymmetric unit consists of one DNA duplex containing an intercalated acridine-4-carboxamide chromophore at each of the two CG steps. The other half of each ligand is bound to another DNA molecule in a symmetry-related manner, with the alkyl linker threading through the minor grooves. The two crystallographically independent ligand molecules adopt distinct side chain interactions, forming hydrogen bonds to either O6 or N7 on the major groove face of guanine, in contrast to the semi-disordered state of mono-intercalators bound to the same DNA molecule. The complex described here provides the first structural evidence for the non-covalent cross-linking of DNA by a small molecule ligand and suggests a possible explanation for the inconsistent behaviour of six-carbon linked bis-acridines in previous assays of DNA bis-intercalation.     

Distance-dependent photoinduced electron transfer in synthetic single-strand and hairpin DNA

 The singlet state of stilbene-4,4′-dicarboxamide can serve as a fluorescent probe of both DNA conformation and electron transfer. Covalent incorporation of the stilbene-dicarboxamide into DNA structures with restricted conformational mobility results in inhibition of stilbene isomerization and an increase in its fluorescence quantum yield and lifetime. The fluorescence of stilbenedicarboxamide is selectively quenched by proximate guanine, but not by the three other DNA nucleobases. Selective quenching occurs via an electron transfer mechanism in which stilbene serves as the electron acceptor and guanine as the electron donor. Kinetic analysis of the distance dependence of electron transfer in stilbene-bridged hairpins suggests that duplex DNA is more effective than proteins as a medium for electron transfer, but that it does not function as a molecular wire. Received, accepted: 5 January 1998     

Mismatch-induced DNA unbending upon duplex opening

A DNA duplex can be torn open at a specific position by introducing a branch or bulge to create an asymmetric three-way junction (TWJ). The opened duplex manifests a bent conformation (bending angle approximately 60 degrees , relative to the unopened form), which leads to a dramatic decrease in gel electrophoretic mobility. In the presence of a basepair mismatch at the opening position, the DNA backbone becomes less bent and assumes a distorted T-shaped structure, resulting in an increase in polyacrylamide gel electrophoretic mobility. Both conformational changes are confirmed using fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments and found to be similar to the signature conformational changes of DNA duplex upon MutS protein binding. Our results imply that some structural rearrangements essential for mismatch recognition are achievable without protein interference. The gel electrophoretic mobility data for DNA TWJs with and without base mismatches correlates well with rotational diffusivity, computed by taking into account the conformational change of TWJ induced by base mismatch.     

Letter: Filamentous bacterial viruses. X. X-ray diffraction studies of the R4-protein mutant

Eukaryotic DNA fragments that are totally denatured by alkali swiftly re-form duplex regions that are several hundred up to several thousand nucleotide pairs in length. A combination of sedimentation and electron microscopic studies demonstrate that they arise by the folding-back of a single linear chain, and not from cross-linking between the two complementary chains. Thus these “hairpin”-like structures must come from inverted repetitions of the type A B C t C′B′A′ that are located at intervals along the chromatid. Electron microscopic studies, reveal no unpaired single-chain regions in the “turn-around” t. The resistance of these hairpins to single-chain specific nucleases indicates that t must only consist of a few nucleotides. Therefore we call these regions in double-chain DNA palindromes, because, given the antiparallel arrangement of the polynucleotide chains, these sequences read the same both backwards and forwards. The thermal stability profile of these hairpins is nearly identical to that of sonicated duplex fragments of comparable length. Since these hairpins have the same average base composition as bulk DNA, the palindromes are nearly perfect. By studying the fraction of DNA retained on hydroxyapatite as a function of chain length, one may determine the distribution of palindromes along the DNA. These experiments are best explained by clusters of palindromes located at intervals of 10 to 80 /gm depending on the species. The presence of such long, well-matched palindromes suggests that the linear double helix may sometimes adopt an alternative configuration, the cruciform, in which mismatches that may occur are eliminated by excision and repair.     

Rapid unwinding of triplet repeat hairpins by Srs2 helicase of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Expansions of trinucleotide repeats cause at least 15 heritable human diseases. Single-stranded triplet repeat DNA in vitro forms stable hairpins in a sequence-dependent manner that correlates with expansion risk in vivo. Hairpins are therefore considered likely intermediates during the expansion process. Unwinding of a hairpin by a DNA helicase would help protect against expansions. Yeast Srs2, but not the RecQ homolog Sgs1, blocks expansions in vivo in a manner largely dependent on its helicase function. The current study tested the idea that Srs2 would be faster at unwinding DNA substrates with an extrahelical triplet repeat hairpin embedded in a duplex context. These substrates should mimic the relevant intermediate structure thought to occur in vivo. Srs2 was faster than Sgs1 at unwinding several substrates containing triplet repeat hairpins or another structured loop. In contrast, control substrates with an unstructured loop or a Watson–Crick duplex were unwound equally well by both enzymes. Results with a fluorescently labeled, three-way junction showed that Srs2 unwinding proceeds unabated through extrahelical triplet repeats. In summary, Srs2 maintains its facile unwinding of triplet repeat hairpins embedded within duplex DNA, supporting the genetic evidence that Srs2 is a key helicase in Saccharomyces cerevisiae for preventing expansions.     

Extra stable 2',5'-linked RNA loops

We prepared hairpins that differ in the connectivity of phosphodiester linkages in the loop (RNA vs 2', 5'-RNA). We find that the stability of the extra stable RNA hairpin 5'-rGGAC(UUCG)GUCC-3' is the same as that observed for the hairpin containing a 2',5'RNA loop, i.e. 5'-rGGAC(UUCG)GUCC-3' (where UUCG = U2'p5'U2'p5' C2'p5'G2'p5'). Also significant is the finding that when the stem is duplex DNA, duplex 2',5'-RNA, or DNA:2',5'-RNA, hairpins with the UUCG loop are more stable than those with UUCG loop.     

Oligodeoxynucleotide folding in solution: loop size and stability of B-hairpins

The secondary structures of the synthetic DNA fragments d(CGCGCGTTTTTCGCGCG) (T5), d(CGCGCGAAAAACGCGCG) (A5), d(CGCGCGTACGCGCG) (TA), and d(CGCGCGATCGCGCG) (AT) were investigated in a combined electrophoretic and spectroscopic study. All the oligomers exist, at low temperature and over a wide range of ionic strength (0.5-100 mM salt) and of nucleotide concentration [0.1-2.0 mM (phosphate)], as a mixture of two slowly interconverting species, identified as the dimeric duplex and the monomeric hairpin structure. The thermodynamic parameters for hairpin denaturation of T5, A5, TA, and AT and for duplex denaturation of d(CGCGCG) show that (a) the hairpins are more stable than the reference hexamer duplex at all accessible nucleotide concentrations; (b) the loop contributes favorably to the enthalpy change of hairpin denaturation in the four DNA fragments; (c) the base composition of the loop (A vs T) and the size of the loop (A5/T5 vs TA/AT) do not appreciably influence the enthalpic contents of the hairpins; (d) hairpins TA and AT, with two AT bases intervening in the CG self-complementary part of the molecule, exhibit a markedly higher thermal stability than hairpins T5 and A5, which is entropic in origin. These findings are consistent with the presence of two-residue loops in the tetradecamers TA and AT.