Post-zygotic Point Mutations Are an Underrecognized Source of De Novo Genomic Variation

De novo mutations are recognized both as an important source of genetic variation and as a prominent cause of sporadic disease in humans. Mutations identified as de novo are generally assumed to have occurred during gametogenesis and, consequently, to be present as germline events in an individual. Because Sanger sequencing does not provide the sensitivity to reliably distinguish somatic from germline mutations, the proportion of de novo mutations that occur somatically rather than in the germline remains largely unknown. To determine the contribution of post-zygotic events to de novo mutations, we analyzed a set of 107 de novo mutations in 50 parent-offspring trios. Using four different sequencing techniques, we found that 7 (6.5%) of these presumed germline de novo mutations were in fact present as mosaic mutations in the blood of the offspring and were therefore likely to have occurred post-zygotically. Furthermore, genome-wide analysis of “de novo” variants in the proband led to the identification of 4/4,081 variants that were also detectable in the blood of one of the parents, implying parental mosaicism as the origin of these variants. Thus, our results show that an important fraction of de novo mutations presumed to be germline in fact occurred either post-zygotically in the offspring or were inherited as a consequence of low-level mosaicism in one of the parents.     

Parent of Origin,Mosaicism, and Recurrence Risk: Probabilistic Modeling Explains the Broken Symmetry of Transmission Genetics

Most new mutations are observed to arise in fathers, and increasing paternal age positively correlates with the risk of new variants. Interestingly, new mutations in X-linked recessive disease show elevated familial recurrence rates. In male offspring, these mutations must be inherited from mothers. We previously developed a simulation model to consider parental mosaicism as a source of transmitted mutations. In this paper, we extend and formalize the model to provide analytical results and flexible formulas. The results implicate parent of origin and parental mosaicism as central variables in recurrence risk. Consistent with empirical data, our model predicts that more transmitted mutations arise in fathers and that this tendency increases as fathers age. Notably, the lack of expansion later in the male germline determines relatively lower variance in the proportion of mutants, which decreases with paternal age. Subsequently, observation of a transmitted mutation has less impact on the expected risk for future offspring. Conversely, for the female germline, which arrests after clonal expansion in early development, variance in the mutant proportion is higher, and observation of a transmitted mutation dramatically increases the expected risk of recurrence in another pregnancy. Parental somatic mosaicism considerably elevates risk for both parents. These findings have important implications for genetic counseling and for understanding patterns of recurrence in transmission genetics. We provide a convenient online tool and source code implementing our analytical results. These tools permit varying the underlying parameters that influence recurrence risk and could be useful for analyzing risk in diverse family structures.     

Somatic and germline mosaic mutations in the doublecortin gene are associated with variable phenotypes

Mutations in the X-linked gene doublecortin lead to "double cortex" syndrome (DC) in females and to X-linked lissencephaly (XLIS) in males. Because most patients with DC and XLIS are sporadic, representing de novo doublecortin mutations, we considered that some of these patients could be somatic or germline mosaics. Among a population of 20 patients and their families, we found evidence for mosaic doublecortin mutations in 6 individuals. Germline mosaicism was identified in two unaffected women, each with two affected children. Additionally, one affected male with DC was found to be a somatic mosaic, which presumably spared him from the more severe phenotype of lissencephaly. The high rate of mosaicism indicates that there may be a significant recurrence risk for DC/XLIS in families at risk, even when the mother is unaffected.     

Parental origin and germline mosaicism of deletions and duplications of the dystrophin gene: a European study

Summary Knowledge about the parental origin of new mutations and the occurrence of germline mosaicism is important for estimating recurrence risks in Duchenne (DMD) and Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD). However, there are problems in resolving these issues partly because not all mutations can as yet be directly detected, and additionally because genetic ratios are very sensitive to ascertainment bias. In the present study, therefore, analysis was restricted to currently detectable mutations (deletions and duplications) in particular types of families which tend to be rare. In order to obtain sufficient data we pooled results from 25 European centers. In mothers of affected patients who were the first in their family with a dystrophin gene deletion or duplication, the ratio between the paternal and the maternal origin of this new mutation was 32:49 (binomial test P = 0.075) for DMD. In five BMD families the ratio between paternal and maternal origin of new mutations was 32. Recurrence risk because of maternal germline mosaicism was studied in sisters or subsequent sibs of isolated cases with an apparently new detectable mutation. In 12 out of 59 (0.20; 95% CI 0.10–0.31) transmissions of the risk haplotype the DMD mutation was transmitted as well. No recurrences were found in nine BMD families.     

Mosaike bei monogenen Erkrankungen

Mosaicism is defined as the simultaneous presence of cells with different genotypes that originate from a common zygote. Mutations can either be present in germline or somatic cells. Monogenic disorders apparently caused by a de novo mutation may show a recurrence risk due to germline mosaicism in a parent. Duchenne muscular dystrophy is a well investigated example with a high frequency of germline mosaicism and the estimation for the risk of recurrence is based on theoretical models and empirical data. Recently, somatic mutations have been uncovered in various syndromic disorders, such as Proteus syndrome or hemimegalencephaly and respective mutations often show gain-of-function properties. Genetic testing is mainly based on next generation sequencing technologies but still remains challenging; however, detection of somatic mosaicism is expected to be of increasing relevance in the diagnosis of monogenic disorders. Somatic mosaicism may also play a hitherto underestimated role in common disorders.     

Germ line mosaicism

Mosaicism in germ cells has been recognized, over the past few years, as an important and relatively frequent mechanism at the origin of genetic disorders. There are two possibilities for the existence of such a mosaicism: one is that the mutation occurs in a germ cell that continues to divide. The other possibility is that the mutation occurs very early in a somatic cell before the separation to germinal cells and is therefore present both in somatic and germinal cells. Depending on various factors, such as the gene involved and/or the degree of mosaicism, the carrier of a somatic and germline mosaicism may be asymptomatic or may present with various symptoms of the disease. There are still relatively few reports in the literature in which the origin of germ-line mosaicism has been analyzed; nevertheless, they allow for a better insight into the mechanisms involved. In some diseases, such as osteogenesis imperfecta, new mutations are often present as asymptomatic somatic and germline mosaicism in one of the parents of the propositus. In other disorders, such as neurofibromatosis, somatic mosaicism is very rare in the parents of the propositus, perhaps since such mosaicism causes clinical symptoms. These differences are particularly important for genetic counseling in order to evaluate the risk for another affected child after the birth of the propositus. Received: 15 September 1997 / Accepted: 12 January 1998     

High rate of mosaicism in tuberous sclerosis complex.

Six families with mosaicism are identified in a series of 62 unrelated families with a mutation in one of the two tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) genes, TSC1 or TSC2. In five families, somatic mosaicism was present in a mildly affected parent of an index patient. In one family with clinically unaffected parents, gonadal mosaicism was detected after TSC was found in three children. The detection of mosaicism has consequences for genetic counseling of the families involved, as changed risks apply to individuals with mosaicism, both siblings and parents. Clinical investigation of parents of patients with seemingly sporadic mutations is essential to determine their residual chance of gonadal and/or somatic mosaicism, unless a mosaic pattern is detected in the index patient, proving a de novo event. In our data set, the exclusion of signs of TSC in the parents of a patient with TSC reduced the chance of one of the parents to be a (mosaic) mutation carrier from 10% to 2%. In the five families with somatic mosaicism, the parent was given the diagnosis after the diagnosis was made in the child.     

Germline mosaicism in 4q35 facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD1A) occurring predominantly in oogenesis

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is an autosomal dominantly inherited neuromuscular disorder affecting facial and shoulder girdle muscles with subsequent progression to the pelvic girdle and lower extremities. The major gene involved has been localized to chromosome 4q35 (FSHD1A). The 4q35 DNA marker p13E-11 (D4F104S1) detects a de novo EcoRI DNA rearrangement of < 30 kb in isolated and familial cases. The intrafamilial size of the fragment is constant, inversely correlated with the severity, and directly correlated with the age of onset of the condition. There has been evidence of parental mosaicism in FSHD1A for the D4F104S1 locus. Four female and three male clinically unaffected parents have been described to be carriers of EcoRI fragments of the same size as their affected offspring, but with a markedly less intensive hybridization signal (semi-quantitative evidence). In our total sample of 42 FSHD1A families, we found semi-quantitative evidence of parental D4F104S1 mosaicism in 11 families (EcoRI fragment size range: 12–27 kb). On analysis with adjacent 4q35 probes (D4S163, D4S139), additional qualitative evidence of germline mosaicism could be obtained in two families. In our mosaic families and in the families reported in the literature, a female predominance of mosaicism carriers (13 females versus 5 males) could be noted. In our sample, mosaicism was observed in multigeneration families, in families with isolated cases, and in families with two and three affected children from seemingly unaffected parents. A short EcoRI fragment once having emerged in a mosaicism carrier was found to be transmitted autosomal dominantly to subsequent generations. Of all reported sporadic patients, 19% have a mosaic parent. Finding evidence of parental mosaicism in all our families with more than one affected child of seemingly unaffected parents suggests that there is no autosomal recessively inherited form of FSHD1A. Received: 5 March 1996 / Revised: 14 May 1996     

Detection of somatic and germline mosaicism for the LAMP2 gene mutation c.808dupG in a Chinese family with Danon disease

Danon disease is a rare X-linked lysosomal storage disease characterized by hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, myopathy and mental retardation, and is due to a primary defect in lysosome-associated membrane protein-2 (LAMP 2). More than 26 mutations in the LAMP2 gene have been described, including a small number of de novo mutations, some of which are suspected to be caused by germline mosaicism. Here, we describe the first molecularly documented evidence of somatic mosaicism for a LAMP2 mutation, identified in the asymptomatic mother of a boy with Danon disease caused by the frameshift mutation c.808dupG (p.A270Gfx3) within exon 6. In addition, in order to gain insight into the possible explanation for the mother's lack of phenotype, the level of somatic mosaicism and the X-chromosome inactivation pattern were investigated. This study provides new insight into the causes of phenotypic variability in female mutation-carriers and underlines the importance of parental molecular testing for accurate genetic counseling for Danon disease.     

Mosaicism in von Hippel-Lindau disease: an event important to recognize

von Hippel-Lindau disease (VHL) is an autosomal dominant, familial neoplastic disorder with variable interfamilial and intrafamilial expression. VHL is characterized by pre-disposition to development of a combination of benign and malignant tumours affecting multiple organs. We provide molecular evidence of somatic mosaicism in nearly asymptomatic man whose daughter had VHL. The mosaic subject was found to have a cyst of the kidney and an angioma of the glans penis and had had surgery for a mandibular cyst and epididymal cystadenomas. Mosaicism could provide a genetic explanation for the clinical heterogeneity and variable severity of VHL. The real incidence of mosaicism is still unclear and the identification of mosaicism has important consequences in genetic counseling of VHL patients who appear to have de novo VHL mutations and should be considered when evaluating patients with isolated VHL-related tumours. Our results strongly suggest a complete and extensive clinical examination in the parents of each patient affected by an apparently de novo VHL germline mutation.We recommend performing a mutation screening of both parents of a proband with techniques that permit detection of low percentages of mosaicism before concluding that the proband has a de novo VHL mutation.     

Mosaic SCN1A mutations in familial partial epilepsy with antecedent febrile seizures

SCN1A is the most relevant epilepsy gene. Mutations of SCN1A generate phenotypes ranging from the extremely severe form of Dravet syndrome (DS) to a mild form of generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures plus (GEFS+). Mosaic SCN1A mutations have been identified in rare familial DS. It is suspected that mosaic mutations of SCN1A may cause other types of familial epilepsies with febrile seizures (FS), which are more common clinically. Thus, we screened SCN1A mutations in 13 families with partial epilepsy with antecedent febrile seizures (PEFS+) using denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography and sequencing. The level of mosaicism was further quantified by pyrosequencing. Two missense SCN1A mutations with mosaic origin were identified in two unrelated families, accounting for 15.4% (2/13) of the PEFS+ families tested. One of the mosaic carriers with ~25.0% mutation of c.5768A>G/p.Q1923R had experienced simple FS; another with ~12.5% mutation of c.4847T>C/p.I1616T was asymptomatic. Their heterozygous children had PEFS+. Recurrent transmission occurred in both families, as noted in most of the families with germline mosaicism reported previously. The two mosaic mutations identified in this study are less destructive missense, compared with the more destructive truncating and splice-site mutations identified in the majority of previous studies. This is the first report of mosaic SCN1A mutations in families with probands that do not exhibit DS, but manifest only a milder phenotype. Therefore, such families with mild cases should be approached with caution in genetic counseling and the possibility of mosaicism origin associated with high recurrence risk should be excluded.     

Fluorescence in situ hybridisation studies provide evidence for somatic mosaicism in de novo dystrophin gene deletions

The fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) technique was tested for its ability to detect somatic mosaicism in mothers of isolated deletion cases of Duchenne/ Becker muscular dystrophy. A control female with known germline and somatic mosaicism was examined, and both the normal cell line and the carrier cell line were detected. Subsequent FISH analysis of three other mothers of boys with apparent de novo dystrophin gene deletions revealed a second patient with a high level of somatic mosaicism, suggesting that a proportion of de novo dystrophin gene deletions occur as mitotic errors early in development rather than as meiotic errors during gametogenesis.     

Perinatal lethal osteogenesis imperfecta (OI type II): a biochemically heterogeneous disorder usually due to new mutations in the genes for type I collagen.

To resolve uncertainty concerning the inheritance of the perinatal lethal form of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI type II), we collected family data and radiographs for 71 probands and analyzed the collagens synthesized by dermal fibroblastic cells cultured from 43 of the probands, 19 parental pairs, and single parents of each of four additional probands. In 65 families for which there were complete data on sibship size, there was recurrence of the OI type II phenotype in five families such that six (8.6%) of 70 sibs were affected. In two families with recurrence, the radiographic phenotype was milder than that for the remainder; and one of those families was consanguinous, suggesting autosomal recessive inheritance. In the remaining three families there was no evidence of consanguinity, but in one of them the structure was compatible with gonadal mosaicism in the mother. In studies of collagens synthesized by cells from 43 infants, we identified two probands with separate rearrangements in an allele of one of the genes of type I collagen; but in the rest there were subtle mutations that disrupted the normal triple-helix structure of type I collagen molecules. In two probands we identified de novo mutations; in 16 additional families cells from the parents made only normal collagens, compatible with new mutations in their offsprings. These findings indicate that the OI type II phenotype is biochemically heterogeneous, that the majority result from new dominant mutations in the genes encoding type I collagen, and that some recurrences can be accounted for by gonadal mosaicism in one of the parents.     

Somatic and germline mosaicisms in severe myoclonic epilepsy of infancy

Severe Myoclonic Epilepsy in Infancy (SMEI) is an intractable epileptic syndrome with onset in the first year of life and is commonly caused by de novo mutations in the SCN1A gene, encoding the α1-subunit of the neuronal voltage-gated sodium channel. We report two unrelated families in which probands were affected by SMEI and their parents showed a single febrile seizure during early childhood or no neurological symptoms. Semiquantitative analysis of SCN1A mutations allowed the detection of a somatic and germline mosaicism in one of the parents. The study provides the first example of parental mosaicisms in SMEI and opens a new insight into the phenotypic variability and complex inheritance of this condition. The identification of germline mosaicisms has important consequences in genetic counseling of SMEI when SCN1A mutations appear to occur de novo with standard screening methods.     

Extensive Hidden Genomic Mosaicism Revealed in Normal Tissue

Genomic mosaicism arising from post-zygotic mutation has recently been demonstrated to occur in normal tissue of individuals ascertained with varied phenotypes, indicating that detectable mosaicism may be less an exception than a rule in the general population. A challenge to comprehensive cataloging of mosaic mutations and their consequences is the presence of heterogeneous mixtures of cells, rendering low-frequency clones difficult to discern. Here we applied a computational method using estimated haplotypes to characterize mosaic megabase-scale structural mutations in 31,100 GWA study subjects. We provide in silico validation of 293 previously identified somatic mutations and identify an additional 794 novel mutations, most of which exist at lower aberrant cell fractions than have been demonstrated in previous surveys. These mutations occurred across the genome but in a nonrandom manner, and several chromosomes and loci showed unusual levels of mutation. Our analysis supports recent findings about the relationship between clonal mosaicism and old age. Finally, our results, in which we demonstrate a nearly 3-fold higher rate of clonal mosaicism, suggest that SNP-based population surveys of mosaic structural mutations should be conducted with haplotypes for optimal discovery.     

The origin of EFNB1 mutations in craniofrontonasal syndrome: frequent somatic mosaicism and explanation of the paucity of carrier males

Craniofrontonasal syndrome (CFNS) is an X-linked disorder that exhibits a paradoxical sex reversal in phenotypic severity: females characteristically have frontonasal dysplasia, craniosynostosis, and additional minor malformations, but males are usually mildly affected with hypertelorism only. Despite this, males appear underrepresented in CFNS pedigrees, with carrier males encountered infrequently compared with affected females. To investigate these unusual genetic features of CFNS, we exploited the recent discovery of causative mutations in the EFNB1 gene, which encodes ephrin-B1, to survey the molecular alterations in 59 families (39 newly investigated and 20 published elsewhere). We identified the first complete deletions of EFNB1, catalogued 27 novel intragenic mutations, and used Pyrosequencing and analysis of nearby polymorphic alleles to quantify mosaic cases and to determine the parental origin of verified germline mutations. Somatic mosaicism was demonstrated in 6 of 53 informative families, and, of 17 germline mutations in individuals for whom the parental origin of mutation could be demonstrated, 15 arose from the father. We conclude that the major factor accounting for the relative scarcity of carrier males is the bias toward mutations in the paternal germline (which present as affected female offspring) combined with reduced reproductive fitness in affected females. Postzygotic mutations also contribute to the female preponderance, whereas true nonpenetrance in males who are hemizygous for an EFNB1 mutation appears unusual. These results highlight the importance of considering possible origins of mutation in the counseling of families with CFNS and provide a generally applicable approach to the combined analysis of mosaic and germline mutations.     

Constitutional and somatic RB1 mutation spectrum in nonfamilial unilateral and bilateral retinoblastoma in India

An epidemiologic survey has indicated a comparatively high prevalence of retinoblastoma (Rb) in Asian countries. Recently, the development of preventive strategies in nonfamilial Rb has become a major goal. The present studies were designed for identification and characterization of constitutional and somatic RB1 gene mutations by conventional cytogenetics, fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) and polymerase chain reaction-single strand conformation polymorphism (PCR-SSCP)-DNA sequencing. Of 34 patients 32 were nonfamilial and 2 were familial Rb. Maternal inheritance of del (13q14) was common. FISH was sensitive in detecting monoallelic RB1 deletion/deletion mosaicism as a first genetic hit in 20% of cases. Somatic and germline RB1 point mutations affected exons 3, 17, 20, and 21 and these were identified as novel mutations. Involvement of exon 20 as a predisposing mutation in sporadic unilateral retinoblastoma (URB) probably suggests the susceptibility of exon 20 to unknown etiologic factors in our population. A de novo RB1 deletion along with transmitted RB1 point mutation from an asymptomatic parent was identified as a unique predisposing RB1 mutation chimerism in a URB case that later evolved to bilateral retinoblastoma (BRB). The predisposing mutations such as del (13q), RB1 mono-allelic deletion and RB1 point mutation in sporadic Rb were de novo as well as transmitted mutations from asymptomatic/symptomatic parents. The RB1 mutation incidence was comparatively higher (25%) in nonfamilial Rb with emphasis on high prevalence in sporadic URB (18% versus 0%-9% in the literature series). The present studies demonstrated the efficacy of a multitechnique approach to detect various types of constitutional RB1 mutations such as RB1 deletion, deletion mosaicism, point mutation, mutation chimerism in patients of symptomatic/asymptomatic parents.     

Frequency of somatic and germ-line mosaicism in retinoblastoma: implications for genetic counseling.

Although mosaicism can have important implications for genetic counseling of families with hereditary disorders, information regarding the incidence of mosaicism is available for only a few genetic diseases. Here we describe an evaluation of 156 families with retinoblastoma; the initial oncogenic mutation in the retinoblastoma gene had been identified in these families. In 15 ( approximately 10%) families, we were able to document mosaicism for the initial mutation in the retinoblastoma gene, either in the proband or in one of the proband's parents. The true incidence of mosaicism in this group of 156 families is probably higher than our findings indicate; in some additional families beyond the 15 we identified, mosaicism was likely but could not be proven, because somatic or germ-line DNA from key family members was unavailable. Germ-line DNA from two mosaic fathers was analyzed: in one of these, the mutation was detected in both sperm and leukocyte DNA; in the other, the mutation was detected only in sperm DNA. Our data suggest that mosaicism is more common than is generally appreciated, especially in disorders such as retinoblastoma, in which a high proportion of cases represent new mutations. The possibility of mosaicism should always be considered during the genetic counseling of newly identified families with retinoblastoma. As demonstrated here, genetic tests of germ-line DNA can provide valuable information that is not available through analysis of somatic (leukocyte) DNA.     

Recurrence risk of a new dominant mutation in children of unaffected parents.

Extensions to models originally described by Hartl for predicting the recurrence risk of new dominant mutations are developed in this paper. Additions to the models are (1) possible somatic mosaicism in a parent in some families, (2) the possibility that the parental origin of the mutation may or may not be known, and (3) mutation rates which change as a function of sex and/or time. The models indicate that recurrence risks are most critically affected by (a) the amount of somatic mosaicism which can be tolerated in the parent without manifesting disease and (b) knowledge of the parental origin of the mutation. In addition, there is a moderate effect on recurrence risks if mutation rates increase in the father as a function of time. Recurrence risks are at least as large as the risk of trisomy 21 in a child of a mother of age 35 years or older, probably much higher (5%-10%) when the mutation is known to be of maternal origin or if substantial somatic mosaicism in the parent is compatible with a normal phenotype. The recurrence risk of a new mutation is high because of a very high ascertainment bias of families with substantial germ-line mosaicism.     

Dominant mutations in familial lethal and severe osteogenesis imperfecta

Summary Four families presenting with familial osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) have been studied: 2 with the lethal type II and 2 with the severe type III form. Fibroblasts of the patients, all issue from non-consanguineous parents, produced normal and abnormal (I) chains. These heterozygous mutations differentiate the recurrent forms from homozygous mutations characteristic of autosomal recessive forms. Although the identity of the mutations could not be determined, such recurrence of autosomal dominant OI is probably the result of germinal mosaicism in one of the parents. Biochemical results were consistent with a somatic mosaicism in the father's fibroblasts in one family. Moreover, our studies show that not only OI type II but also severe OI type III can arise from gonadal mosaicism. We discuss the importance of such a phenomenon for genetic counseling.