SNP genotyping using alkali cleavage of RNA/DNA chimeras and MALDI time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are now widely used for many DNA analysis applications such as linkage disequilibrium mapping, pharmacogenomics and traceability. Many methods for SNP genotyping exist with diverse strategies for allele-distinction. Mass spectrometers are used most commonly in conjunction with primer extension procedures with allele-specific termination. Here we present a novel concept for allele-preparation for SNP genotyping. Primer extension is carried out with an extension primer positioned immediately upstream of the SNP that is to be genotyped, a complete set of four ribonucleotides and a ribonucleotide incorporating DNA polymerase. The allele-extension products are then treated with alkali, which results in the cleavage immediately after the first added ribonucleotide. In addition, to obtain fragments easily detectable by mass spectrometry, we have included a ribonucleotide in the primer usually at the fourth nucleotide from the 3′ terminus. The method was tested on four SNPs each with a different combination of nucleotides. The advantage over other mass spectrometry-based SNP genotyping assays is that this one only requires a PCR, a primer extension reaction with a universal extension mix and an inexpensive facile cleavage reaction, which makes it overall very cost effective and easy in handling.     

Multiplex automated primer extension analysis: simultaneous genotyping of several polymorphisms.

Accurate and fast genotyping of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) is of significant scientific importance for linkage and association studies. We report here an automated fluorescent method we call multiplex automated primer extension analysis (MAPA) that can accurately genotype multiple known SNPs simultaneously. This is achieved by substantially improving a commercially available protocol (SNaPshot). This protocol relies on the extension of a primer that ends one nucleotide 5'of a given SNP with fluorescent dideoxy-NTPs (minisequencing), followed by analysis on an ABI PRisMS 377 Semi-Automated DNA Sequencer Our modification works by multiplexing the initial reaction that produces the DNA template for primer extension and/or multiplexing several primers (corresponding to several SNPs) in the same primer extension reaction. Then, we run each multiplexed reaction on a single gel lane. We demonstrate that MAPA can be used to genotype up to four SNPs simultaneously, even in compound heterozygote samples, with complete accuracy (based on concordance with sequencing results). We also show that primer design, unlike the DNA template purification method, can significantly affect genotyping accuracy, and we suggest useful guidelines for quick optimization.     

Primer-design for multiplexed genotyping

Single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) analysis is a powerful tool for mapping and diagnosing disease-related alleles. Mutation analysis by polymerase-mediated single-base primer extension (minisequencing) can be massively parallelized using DNA microchips or flow cytometry with microspheres as solid support. By adding a unique oligonucleotide tag to the 5′ end of the minisequencing primer and attaching the complementary antitag to the array or bead surface, the assay can be ‘demultiplexed’. Such high-throughput scoring of SNPs requires a high level of primer multiplexing in order to analyze multiple loci in one assay, thus enabling inexpensive and fast polymorphism scoring. We present a computer program to automate the design process for the assay. Oligonucleotide primers for the reaction are automatically selected by the software, a unique DNA tag/antitag system is generated, and the pairing of primers and DNA tags is automatically done in a way to avoid any crossreactivity. We report results on a 45-plex genotyping assay, indicating that minisequencing can be adapted to be a powerful tool for high-throughput, massively parallel genotyping. The software is available to academic users on request.     

An in vitro screening technique for DNA polymerases that can incorporate modified nucleotides. Pseudo-thymidine as a substrate for thermostable polymerases.

DNA polymerases are desired that incorporate modified nucleotides into DNA with diminished pausing, premature termination and infidelity. Reported here is a simple in vitro assay to screen for DNA polymerases that accept modified nucleotides based on a set of primer extension reactions. In combination with the scintillation proximity assay (SPA[trade]), this allows rapid and simple screening of enzymes for their ability to elongate oligonucleotides in the presence of unnatural nucleotides. A proof of the concept is obtained using pseudo-thymidine (psiT), the C-nucleoside analog of thymidine, as the unnatural substrate. The conformational properties of psiT arising from the carbon-carbon bond between the sugar and the base make it an interesting probe for the importance of conformational restraints in the active site of polymerases during primer elongation. From a pool of commercially available thermostable polymerases, the assay identified Taq DNA polymerase as the most suitable enzyme for the PCR amplification of oligonucleotides containing psiT. Subsequent experiments analyzing PCR performance and fidelity of Taq DNA polymerase acting on psiT are presented. This is the first time that PCR has been performed with a C-nucleoside.     

Facile method for automated genotyping of single nucleotide polymorphisms by mass spectrometry

In the future, analysis of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) should become a powerful tool for many genetic applications in areas such as association studies, pharmacogenetics and traceability in the agro-alimentary sector. A number of technologies have been developed for high-throughput genotyping of SNPs. Here we present the simplified GOOD assay for SNP genotyping by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI). The simplified GOOD assay is a single-tube, purification-free, three-step procedure consisting of PCR, primer extension and phosphodiesterase II digestion followed by mass spectrometric analysis. Due to the application of charge-tag technology, no sample purification is required prior to the otherwise very impurity-sensitive MALDI analysis. The use of methylphosphonate containing primers and ddNTPs or α-S-ddNTPs together with a novel DNA polymerase derived from Thermotoga maritima for primer extension allow the fluent preparation of negatively charge-tagged, allele-specific products. A key feature of this polymerase is its preference for ddNTPs and α-S-ddNTPs over dNTPs. The simplified GOOD assay was run with automatic liquid handling at the lowest manageable volumes, automatic data acquisition and interpretation. We applied this novel procedure to genotyping SNPs of candidate genes for hypertension and cardiovascular disease.     

Mutation detection using nucleotide analogs that alter electrophoretic mobility.

A simple primer extension assay has been developed to distinguish homologous DNA segments differing by as little as a single nucleotide. DNA strands are synthesized with one of the four natural nucleotides replaced with an analog that affects electrophoretic mobility. DNAs that are the same length but differ in the number of analog molecules per strand exhibit different mobilities on a sequencing gel. In combination with the polymerase chain reaction (PCR; 1, 2), this method has been used to distinguish mutant and normal alleles of the human insulin receptor gene that differ by a single-base substitution. The method appears to be generally applicable to the detection of any nucleotide polymorphism in any segment of DNA.     

A single multiplex PCR and SNaPshot minisequencing reaction of 42 SNPs to classify admixture populations into mitochondrial DNA haplogroups

SNaPshot minisequencing reaction is in increasing use because of its fast detection of many polymorphisms in a single assay. In this work we described a highly sensitive single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) typing method with detection of 42 mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) SNPs in a single PCR and SNaPshot multiplex reaction, in order to allow haplogroup classification in Latin American admixture population. We validated the panel typing 160 Brazilian individuals. Complete SNP profiles were obtained from 10 pg of total DNA. We conclude that it is possible to build and genotype more than forty mtDNA SNPs in a single multiplex PCR and SNaPshot reaction, with sensitivity and reliability, resolving haplogroup classification in admixture populations.     

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) using ssDNA binding fluorescent dye

There is a need for simple and inexpensive methods for genotyping single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and short insertion/deletion variations (InDels). In this work, I demonstrate that a single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding dye can be used as a donor fluorophore for fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). The method presented is a homogenous assay in which detection is based on the FRET from the fluorescence of the ssDNA dye bound to the unmodified detection primer to the fluorescent nucleotide analog incorporated into this detection primer during cyclic template directed primer extension reaction. Collection of the FRET emission spectrum with a scanning fluorescence spectrophotometer allows powerful data analysis. The fluorescence emission signal is modified by the optical properties of the assay vessel. This seems to be a completely neglected parameter. By proper selection of the optical properties of the assay plate one can improve the detection of the fluorescence emission signal.     

SNP typing by apyrase-mediated allele-specific primer extension on DNA microarrays

This study reports the development of a microarray-based allele-specific extension method for typing of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). The use of allele-specific primers has been employed previously to identify single base variations but it is acknowledged that certain mismatches are not refractory to extension. Here we have overcome this limitation by introducing apyrase, a nucleotide-degrading enzyme, to the extension reaction. We have shown previously that DNA polymerases exhibit slower reaction kinetics when extending a mismatched primer compared with a matched primer. This kinetic difference is exploited in the apyrase-mediated allele-specific extension (AMASE) assay, allowing incorporation of nucleotides when the reaction kinetics are fast but degrading the nucleotides before extension when the reaction kinetics are slow. Here we show that five homozygous variants (14% of the total number of variants) that were incorrectly scored in the absence of apyrase were correctly typed when apyrase was included in the extension reaction. AMASE was performed in situ on the oligonucleotide microarrays using fluorescent nucleotides to type 10 SNPs and two indels in 17 individuals generating approximately 200 genotypes. Cluster analysis of these data shows three distinct clusters with clear-cut boundaries. We conclude that SNP typing on oligonucleotide microarrays by AMASE is an efficient, rapid and accurate technique for large-scale genotyping.     

Rapid identification of single nucleotide polymorphisms by fluorescence-based capillary electrophoresis

We describe the application of two different fluorescence-based techniques (ddNTP primer extension and single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP)) to the detection of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) by capillary electrophoresis. The ddNTP primer extension technique is based on the extension, in the presence of fluorescence-labeled dideoxy nucleotides (ddNTP, terminators), of an unlabeled oligonucleotide primer that binds to the complementary template immediately adjacent to the mutant nucleotide position. Given that there are no unlabeled dNTPs, a single ddNTP is added to its 3' end, resulting in a fluorescence-labeled primer extension product which is readily separated by capillary electrophoresis. On the other hand, the non-radioisotopic version of SSCP established in this study uses fluorescent dye to label the PCR products, which are also analyzed by capillary electrophoresis. These procedures were used to identify a well-defined SNP in exon 7 of the human p53 gene in DNA samples isolated from two human cell lines (CEM and THP-1 cells). The results revealed a heterozygous single-base transition (G to A) at nucleotide position 14071 in CEM cells, proving that both fluorescence-based ddNTP primer extension and SSCP are rapid, simple, robust, specific and with no ambiguity in interpretation for the detection of well-defined SNPs.     

Alternative dideoxy sequencing of double-stranded DNA by cyclic reactions using Taq polymerase.

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is a technique to amplify a specific DNA sequence millions of times. The thermostable enzyme Taq polymerase allows this procedure to take place under conditions of high specificity and automatization. By combining the techniques of PCR and dideoxy sequencing, it is possible to perform DNA sequencing independently of their structures. The cyclic sequencing reaction is carried out in the presence of an excess amount of sequencing primer and a radioactive nucleotide ([alpha-35S]dATP) using a DNA thermal cycler. Different reaction conditions were investigated and optimized including nucleotide ratios in each termination mix, primer/template ratios, amount of a radioactive nucleotide, and the program of the reaction. This method allows the detection of single base substitutions in heterozygous alleles, and the detection of homozygous deletions. A new RFLP of the human porphobilinogen deaminase (PBGD) gene was identified using this technique. This RFLP is created by one base difference (cytosine or adenine) that changes the restriction site for Apa LI. The alternative sequencing method described in this study is a simple and time-saving procedure that can also be used for large sequencing projects.     

Minisequencing on oligonucleotide microarrays: comparison of immobilisation chemistries

In the microarray format of the minisequencing method multiple oligonucleotide primers immobilised on a glass surface are extended with fluorescent ddNTPs using a DNA polymerase. The method is a promising tool for large-scale single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) detection. We have compared eight chemical methods for covalent immobilisation of the oligonucleotide primers on glass surfaces. We included both commercially available, activated slides and slides that were modified by ourselves. In the comparison the differently derivatised glass slides were evaluated with respect to background fluorescence, efficiency of attaching oligonucleotides and performance of the primer arrays in minisequencing reactions. We found that there are significant differences in background fluorescence levels among the different coatings, and that the attachment efficiency, which was measured indirectly using extension by terminal transferase, varied largely depending on which immobilisation strategy was used. We also found that the attachment chemistry affects the genotyping accuracy, when minisequencing on microarrays is used as the genotyping method. The best genotyping results were observed using mercaptosilane-coated slides attaching disulfide-modified oligonucleotides.     

Competitive enzymatic reaction to control allele-specific extensions

Here, we present a novel method for SNP genotyping based on protease-mediated allele-specific primer extension (PrASE), where the two allele-specific extension primers only differ in their 3′-positions. As reported previously [Ahmadian,A., Gharizadeh,B., O'Meara,D., Odeberg,J. and Lundeberg,J. (2001), Nucleic Acids Res., 29, e121], the kinetics of perfectly matched primer extension is faster than mismatched primer extension. In this study, we have utilized this difference in kinetics by adding protease, a protein-degrading enzyme, to discriminate between the extension reactions. The competition between the polymerase activity and the enzymatic degradation yields extension of the perfectly matched primer, while the slower extension of mismatched primer is eliminated. To allow multiplex and simultaneous detection of the investigated single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), each extension primer was given a unique signature tag sequence on its 5′ end, complementary to a tag on a generic array. A multiplex nested PCR with 13 SNPs was performed in a total of 36 individuals and their alleles were scored. To demonstrate the improvements in scoring SNPs by PrASE, we also genotyped the individuals without inclusion of protease in the extension. We conclude that the developed assay is highly allele-specific, with excellent multiplex SNP capabilities.     

A new approach to SNP genotyping with fluorescently labeled mononucleotides

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) is one of the most powerful and promising tools for single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping. However, the present methods using FRET require expensive reagents such as fluorescently labeled oligonucleotides. Here, we describe a novel and cost-effective method for SNP genotyping using FRET. The technique is based on allele-specific primer extension using mononucleotides labeled with a green dye and a red dye. When the target DNA contains the sequence complementary to the primer, extension of the primer incorporates the green and red dye-labeled nucleotides into the strand, and red fluorescence is emitted by FRET. In contrast, when the 3′ end nucleotide of the primer is not complementary to the target DNA, there is no extension of the primer, or FRET signal. Therefore, discrimination among genotypes is achieved by measuring the intensity of red fluorescence after the extension reaction. We have validated this method with 11 SNPs, which were successfully determined by end-point measurements of fluorescence intensity. The new strategy is simple and cost-effective, because all steps of the preparation consist of simple additions of solutions and incubation, and the dye-labeled mononucleotides are applicable to all SNP analyses. This method will be suitable for large-scale genotyping.     

A novel procedure for efficient genotyping of single nucleotide polymorphisms

Due to the surge in interest in using single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) for genotyping a facile and affordable method for this is an absolute necessity. Here we introduce a procedure that combines an easily automatable single tube sample preparation with an efficient high throughput mass spectrometric analysis technique. Known point mutations or single nucleotide polymorphisms are easily analysed by this procedure. It starts with PCR amplification of a short stretch of genomic DNA, for example an exon of a gene containing a SNP. By shrimp alkaline phosphatase digest residual dNTPs are destroyed. Allele-specific products are generated using a special primer, a conditioned set of α-S-dNTPs and α-S-ddNTPs and a fresh DNA polymerase in a primer extension reaction. Unmodified DNA is removed by 5′-phosphodiesterase digestion and the modified products are alkylated to increase the detection sensitivity in the mass spectrometric analysis. All steps of the preparation are simple additions of solutions and incubations. The procedure operates at the lowest practical sample volumes and in contrast to other genotyping protocols with mass spectrometric detection requires no purification. This reduces the cost and makes it easy to implement. Here it is demonstrated in a version using positive ion detection on described mutations in exon 17 of the amyloid precursor protein gene and in a version using negative ion detection on three SNPs of the granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor gene. Preparation and analysis of SNPs is shown separately and simultaneously, thus demonstrating the multiplexibility of this genotyping procedure. The preparation protocol for genotyping is adapted to the conditions used for the SNP discovery method by denaturing HPLC, thus demonstrating a facile link between protocols for SNP discovery and SNP genotyping. Results corresponded unanimously with the control sequencing. The procedure is useful for high throughput genotyping as it is required for gene identification and pharmacogenomics where large numbers of DNA samples have to be analysed. We have named this procedure the ‘GOOD Assay’ for SNP analysis.     

Quantitative evaluation by minisequencing and microarrays reveals accurate multiplexed SNP genotyping of whole genome amplified DNA

Whole genome amplification (WGA) procedures such as primer extension preamplification (PEP) or multiple displacement amplification (MDA) have the potential to provide an unlimited source of DNA for large-scale genetic studies. We have performed a quantitative evaluation of PEP and MDA for genotyping single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) using multiplex, four-color fluorescent minisequencing in a microarray format. Forty-five SNPs were genotyped and the WGA methods were evaluated with respect to genotyping success, signal-to-noise ratios, power of genotype discrimination, yield and imbalanced amplification of alleles in the MDA product. Both PEP and MDA products provided genotyping results with a high concordance to genomic DNA. For PEP products the power of genotype discrimination was lower than for MDA due to a 2-fold lower signal-to-noise ratio. MDA products were indistinguishable from genomic DNA in all aspects studied. To obtain faithful representation of the SNP alleles at least 0.3 ng DNA should be used per MDA reaction. We conclude that the use of WGA, and MDA in particular, is a highly promising procedure for producing DNA in sufficient amounts even for genome wide SNP mapping studies.     

Bioluminescent reporters for identification of gene allelic variants

A method for single nucleotide polymorphism identification was developed, which was based on the primer extension reaction (PEXT) followed by bioluminescent solid-phase microassay. Recombinant Ca²⁺-regulated photoprotein obelin and coelenterazine-dependent Renilla muelleri luciferase were used as reporters. The study was performed as an example of SNP genotyping of the human F5 gene encoding human Factor V Leiden polymorphism 1691 G??A (R506Q). Genomic DNA was amplified by PCR using primers flanking polymorphic site of 140 base pairs. PCR products were used as templates for two PEXT reactions using two primers containing 3??-terminal nucleotides, which were complementary to either normal or mutant alleles. If the template and allele-specific primer were completely complementary, the latter was elongated with DNA polymerase. The resulting extension product contained biotin residue due to the presence of biotinylated deoxyuridine triphosphate (B-dUTP) in the reaction mixture. The products were analyzed using obelin-streptavidin conjugates. The optimal PEXT-reaction conditions were found, which ensured a high reliability of SNP genotyping. A new approach to simultaneously revealing both alleles in one well was developed using two bioluminescent reporters. The efficiency of the proposed approach was shown in the study of clinical DNA samples.     

New separation-free assay technique for SNPs using two-photon excitation fluorometry

A new separation-free method for detection of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) is described. The method is based on the single base extension principle, fluorescently labeled dideoxy nucleotides and two-photon fluorescence excitation technology, known as ArcDia™ TPX technology. In this assay technique, template-directed single base extension is carried out for primers which have been immobilized on polymer microparticles. Depending on the sequence of the template DNA, the primers are extended either with a labeled or with a non-labeled nucleotide. The genotype of the sample is determined on the basis of two-photon excited fluorescence of individual microparticles. The effect of various assay condition parameters on the performance of the assay method is studied. The performance of the new assay method is demonstrated by genotyping the SNPs of human individuals using double-stranded PCR amplicons as samples. The results show that the new SNP assay method provides sensitivity and reliability comparable to the state-of-the-art SNaPshot™ assay method. Applicability of the new method in routine laboratory use is discussed with respect to alternative assay techniques.     

Template-directed dye-terminator incorporation (TDI) assay: a homogeneous DNA diagnostic method based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer.

A new method for DNA diagnostics based on template-directed primer extension and detection by fluorescence resonance energy transfer is described. In this method, amplified genomic DNA fragments containing polymorphic sites are incubated with a 5'-fluorescein-labeled primer (designed to hybridize to the DNA template adjacent to the polymorphic site) in the presence of allelic dye-labeled dideoxyribonucleoside triphosphates and a modified Taq DNA polymerase (Klentaq1-FY). The dye-labeled primer is extended one base by the dye-terminator specific for the allele present on the template. At the end of the genotyping reaction, the fluorescence intensities of the two dyes in the reaction mixture are analyzed directly without separation or purification. This homogeneous DNA diagnostic method, which we call the template-directed dye-terminator incorporation assay, is shown to be highly sensitive and specific and is suitable for automated genotyping of large numbers of samples.     

Direct transduction of allele-specific primer extension into electrical signal using genetic field effect transistor

We have developed a genetic field effect transistor (FET) for single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping, which is based on potentiometric detection of molecular recognition on the gate insulator. Here, we report direct transduction of allele-specific primer extension on the gate surface into electrical signal using the genetic FETs. This method is based on detection of intrinsic negative charges of polynucleotide synthesized by DNA polymerase. The charge density change at the gate surface could be monitored during primer extension reaction. Moreover, three different genotypes could be successfully distinguished without any labeling for target DNA by the use of the genetic FET in combination with allele-specific primer extension. The platform based on the genetic FETs is suitable for a simple, accurate and inexpensive system for SNP genotyping in clinical diagnostics.