Protein cargo delivery properties of cell-penetrating peptides. A comparative study

Application of cell-penetrating peptides for delivering various hydrophilic macromolecules with biological function into cells has gained much attention in recent years. We compared the protein transduction efficiency of four cell-penetrating peptides: penetratin, Tat peptide, transportan, and pVEC and studied the effects of various medium parameters on the uptake. Depletion of cellular energy and lowering of temperature strongly impaired the internalization of protein complexed with cell-penetrating peptides, confirming the endocytotic mechanism of peptide-mediated protein cellular transduction. Peptide-induced protein association with HeLa cells decreased 3-6-fold in energy-depleted cells. Inhibition of clathrin-dependent endocytosis by the hyperosmolar medium decreased the uptake of peptide-avidin complexes 1.5-3-fold and the removal of cholesterol from the plasma membrane 1.2-2-fold, suggesting that both clathrin-dependent and independent endocytosis were involved in peptide-induced cellular delivery of avidin. However, even under conditions of cellular energy depletion, ceasing of cellular traffic, and partial depolarization of plasma membrane, peptide-protein complexes associated with HeLa cells, as observed by FACS analysis and spectrofluorimetry. Among the studied peptides, pTat and transportan revealed higher protein transduction efficiency than penetratin or pVEC.     

Internalisation of cell-penetrating peptides into tobacco protoplasts

Cells are protected from the surrounding environment by plasma membrane which is impenetrable for most hydrophilic molecules. In the last 10 years cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) have been discovered and developed. CPPs enter mammalian cells and carry cargo molecules over the plasma membrane with a molecular weight several times their own. Known transformation methods for plant cells have relatively low efficiency and require improvement. The possibility to use CPPs as potential delivery vectors for internalisation in plant cells has been studied in the present work. We analyse and compare the uptake of the fluorescein-labeled CPPs, transportan, TP10, penetratin and pVEC in Bowes human melanoma cells and Nicotiana tabacum cultivar (cv.) SR-1 protoplasts (plant cells without cell wall). We study the internalisation efficiency of CPPs with fluorescence microscopy, spectrofluorometry and fluorescence-activated cell sorter (FACS). All methods indicate, for the first time, that these CPPs can internalise into N. tabacum cv. SR-1 protoplasts. Transportan has the highest uptake efficacy among the studied peptides, both in mammalian cells and plant protoplast. The internalisation of CPPs by plant protoplasts may open up a new effective method for transfection in plants.     

Mitochondrial targeting of farnesyl diphosphate synthase is a widespread phenomenon in eukaryotes

Cellular internalization of cell-penetrating peptide HIV-1 Tat basic domain (RKKRRQRRR) was studied in Triticale cv AC Alta mesophyll protoplasts. Fluorescently labeled monomer (Tat) and dimer (Tat(2)) of Tat basic domain efficiently translocated through the plasma membrane of mesophyll protoplast and showed distinct nuclear accumulation within 10 min of incubation. Substitution of first arginine residue with alanine in Tat basic domain (M-Tat) severely reduced cellular uptake of the peptide (3.8 times less than Tat). Tat(2) showed greater cellular internalization than Tat (1.6 times higher). However, characteristics of cellular uptake remained same for Tat and Tat(2). Cellular internalization of Tat and Tat(2) was concentration dependent and non-saturable whereas no significant change in cellular uptake was observed even at higher concentrations of M-Tat. Low temperature (4 degrees C) remarkably increased cellular internalization of Tat as well as Tat(2) but M-Tat showed no enhanced uptake. Viability test showed that peptide treatment had no cytotoxic effect on protoplasts further indicating involvement of a common mechanism of peptide uptake at all the temperatures. Endocytic inhibitors nocodazole (10 muM), chloroquine (100 muM) and sodium azide (5 mM) did not show any significant inhibitory effect on cellular internalization of either Tat or Tat(2). These results along with stimulated cellular uptake at low temperature indicate that Tat peptide is internalized in the plant protoplasts in a non-endocytic and energy-independent manner. Competition experiments showed that non-labeled peptide did not inhibit or alter nuclear accumulation of fluorescent Tat or Tat(2) suggesting active transport to the nucleus was not involved. Studies in mesophyll protoplasts show that internalization pattern of Tat peptide is apparently similar to that observed in mammalian cell lines.     

Translocation and nuclear accumulation of monomer and dimer of HIV-1 Tat basic domain in triticale mesophyll protoplasts

Cellular internalization of cell-penetrating peptide HIV-1 Tat basic domain (RKKRRQRRR) was studied in Triticale cv AC Alta mesophyll protoplasts. Fluorescently labeled monomer (Tat) and dimer (Tat₂) of Tat basic domain efficiently translocated through the plasma membrane of mesophyll protoplast and showed distinct nuclear accumulation within 10 min of incubation. Substitution of first arginine residue with alanine in Tat basic domain (M-Tat) severely reduced cellular uptake of the peptide (3.8 times less than Tat). Tat₂ showed greater cellular internalization than Tat (1.6 times higher). However, characteristics of cellular uptake remained same for Tat and Tat₂. Cellular internalization of Tat and Tat₂ was concentration dependent and non-saturable whereas no significant change in cellular uptake was observed even at higher concentrations of M-Tat. Low temperature (4 °C) remarkably increased cellular internalization of Tat as well as Tat₂ but M-Tat showed no enhanced uptake. Viability test showed that peptide treatment had no cytotoxic effect on protoplasts further indicating involvement of a common mechanism of peptide uptake at all the temperatures. Endocytic inhibitors nocodazole (10 μM), chloroquine (100 μM) and sodium azide (5 mM) did not show any significant inhibitory effect on cellular internalization of either Tat or Tat₂. These results along with stimulated cellular uptake at low temperature indicate that Tat peptide is internalized in the plant protoplasts in a non-endocytic and energy-independent manner. Competition experiments showed that non-labeled peptide did not inhibit or alter nuclear accumulation of fluorescent Tat or Tat₂ suggesting active transport to the nucleus was not involved. Studies in mesophyll protoplasts show that internalization pattern of Tat peptide is apparently similar to that observed in mammalian cell lines.     

Cell-penetrating peptides: a comparative membrane toxicity study

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) constitute a new class of delivery vectors with high pharmaceutical potential. However, the abilities of these peptides to translocate through cell membranes can be accompanied by toxic effects resulting from membrane perturbation at higher peptide concentrations. Therefore, we investigated membrane toxicity of five peptides with well-documented cell-penetrating properties, pAntp(43-58), pTAT(48-60), pVEC(615-632), model amphipathic peptide (MAP), and transportan 10, on two human cancer cell lines, K562 (erythroleukemia) and MDA-MB-231 (breast cancer), as well as on immortalized aortic endothelial cells. We studied the effects of these five peptides on the leakage of lactate dehydrogenase and on the fluorescence of plasma membrane potentiometric dye bis-oxonol. In all cell lines, pAntp(43-58), pTAT(48-60), and pVEC(615-632) induced either no leakage or low leakage of lactate dehydrogenase, accompanied by modest changes in bis-oxonol fluorescence. MAP and transportan 10 caused significant leakage; in K562 and MDA-MB-231 cells, 40% of total lactate dehydrogenase leaked out during 10 min exposure to 10 microM of transportan 10 and MAP, accompanied by a significant increase in bis-oxonol fluorescence. However, none of the CPPs tested had a hemolytic effect on bovine erythrocytes comparable to mastoparan 7. The toxicity profiles presented in the current study are of importance when selecting CPPs for different applications.     

VE-cadherin-derived cell-penetrating peptide, pVEC, with carrier functions

Cell-penetrating peptides, CPPs, have been shown to translocate into living cells by a receptor-independent mechanism and to carry macromolecules over the plasma membrane. This article reports studies of the internalization of pVEC, an 18-amino acid-long peptide derived from the murine sequence of the cell adhesion molecule vascular endothelial cadherin, amino acids 615-632. Fluorophore-labeled pVEC entered four different cell lines tested: human aortic endothelial cells, brain capillary endothelial cells, Bowes melanoma cells, and murine brain endothelial cells. In order to evaluate the translocation efficiency of pVEC, we performed a side-by-side comparison with penetratin, a well-characterized CPP. The cellular uptake of pVEC was highest for murine brain endothelial cells. All cell lines tested contained equal or slightly higher concentrations of pVEC than penetratin. pVEC mainly accumulated in nuclear structures but was also found throughout the cells. Furthermore, pVEC functioned as a transporter of both a hexameric peptide nucleic acid molecule of 1.7 kDa and a 67-kDa protein, streptavidin-FITC, and cellular uptake of fluorophore-labeled pVEC took place at 4 degrees C, suggesting a nonendocytotic mechanism of translocation. In conclusion, our results indicate that pVEC is efficiently and rapidly taken up into cells and functions as a potent carrier peptide.     

Translocation properties of novel cell penetrating transportan and penetratin analogues

Novel analogues of the cell-penetrating peptides penetratin and transportan were synthesized. The distribution of the biotin-labeled peptides in Bowes melanoma cell line has been investigated by indirect fluorescence with fluorescein-streptavidin detection. The time course of uptake of (125)I-labeled transportan analogues has been characterized in the same cell line. Molecular modeling was used to analyze the penetration and the orientation of molecules in a simulated biological membrane. The results, both from molecular modeling and fluorescence studies, imply that penetratin and transportan do not enter the cells by related mechanisms and that they do not belong to the same family of translocating peptides.     

Internalisation of cell-penetrating peptides into tobacco protoplasts

Cells are protected from the surrounding environment by plasma membrane which is impenetrable for most hydrophilic molecules. In the last 10 years cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) have been discovered and developed. CPPs enter mammalian cells and carry cargo molecules over the plasma membrane with a molecular weight several times their own. Known transformation methods for plant cells have relatively low efficiency and require improvement. The possibility to use CPPs as potential delivery vectors for internalisation in plant cells has been studied in the present work. We analyse and compare the uptake of the fluorescein-labeled CPPs, transportan, TP10, penetratin and pVEC in Bowes human melanoma cells and Nicotiana tabacum cultivar (cv.) SR-1 protoplasts (plant cells without cell wall). We study the internalisation efficiency of CPPs with fluorescence microscopy, spectrofluorometry and fluorescence-activated cell sorter (FACS). All methods indicate, for the first time, that these CPPs can internalise into N. tabacum cv. SR-1 protoplasts. Transportan has the highest uptake efficacy among the studied peptides, both in mammalian cells and plant protoplast. The internalisation of CPPs by plant protoplasts may open up a new effective method for transfection in plants.     

Bilayer interaction and localization of cell penetrating peptides with model membranes: a comparative study of a human calcitonin (hCT)-derived peptide with pVEC and pAntp(43-58)

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) are able to translocate problematic therapeutic cargoes across cellular membranes. The exact mechanisms of translocation are still under investigation. However, evidence for endocytic uptake is increasing. We investigated the interactions of CPPs with phospholipid bilayers as first step of translocation. To this purpose, we employed four independent techniques, comprising (i) liposome buffer equilibrium dialysis, (ii) Trp fluorescence quenching, (iii) fluorescence polarization, and (iv) determination of zeta-potentials. Using unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) of different phospholipid composition, we compared weakly cationic human calcitonin (hCT)-derived peptides with the oligocationic CPPs pVEC and penetratin (pAntp). Apparent partition coefficients of hCT-derived peptides in neutral POPC LUVs were dependent on amino acid composition and secondary structure; partitioning in negatively charged POPC/POPG (80:20) LUVs was increased and mainly governed by electrostatic interactions. For hCT(9-32) and its derivatives, D values raised from about 100-200 in POPC to about 1000 to 1500 when negatively charged lipids were present. Localization profiles of CPPs obtained by Trp fluorescence quenching were dependent on the charge density of LUVs. In POPC/POPG, hCT-derived CPPs were located on the bilayer surface, whereas pVEC and pAntp resided deeper in the membrane. In POPG LUVs, an increase of fluorescence polarization was observed for pVEC and pAntp but not for hCT-derived peptides. Generally, we found strong peptide-phospholipid interactions, especially when negatively charged lipids were present.     

Bilayer interaction and localization of cell penetrating peptides with model membranes: A comparative study of a human calcitonin (hCT)-derived peptide with pVEC and pAntp(43-58)

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) are able to translocate problematic therapeutic cargoes across cellular membranes. The exact mechanisms of translocation are still under investigation. However, evidence for endocytic uptake is increasing. We investigated the interactions of CPPs with phospholipid bilayers as first step of translocation. To this purpose, we employed four independent techniques, comprising (i) liposome buffer equilibrium dialysis, (ii) Trp fluorescence quenching, (iii) fluorescence polarization, and (iv) determination of ζ-potentials. Using unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) of different phospholipid composition, we compared weakly cationic human calcitonin (hCT)-derived peptides with the oligocationic CPPs pVEC and penetratin (pAntp). Apparent partition coefficients of hCT-derived peptides in neutral POPC LUVs were dependent on amino acid composition and secondary structure; partitioning in negatively charged POPC/POPG (80:20) LUVs was increased and mainly governed by electrostatic interactions. For hCT(9-32) and its derivatives, D values raised from about 100-200 in POPC to about 1000 to 1500 when negatively charged lipids were present. Localization profiles of CPPs obtained by Trp fluorescence quenching were dependent on the charge density of LUVs. In POPC/POPG, hCT-derived CPPs were located on the bilayer surface, whereas pVEC and pAntp resided deeper in the membrane. In POPG LUVs, an increase of fluorescence polarization was observed for pVEC and pAntp but not for hCT-derived peptides. Generally, we found strong peptide-phospholipid interactions, especially when negatively charged lipids were present.     

Short polyhistidine peptides penetrate effectively into Nicotiana tabacum-cultured cells and Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells

The polyhistidine peptides (PHPs) have been previously reported as novel cell-penetrating peptides and are efficiently internalized into mammal cells; however, penetration of PHPs into other cell types is unknown. In this study, the cellular uptake of PHPs in plant and yeast cells was found to be dependent on the number of histidines, and short PHPs (H6–H10 peptides) showed effective internalization. The H8 peptide showed the highest cell-penetrating capacity and localized to vacuoles in plant and yeast cells. Low-temperature conditions inhibited significantly the cellular uptake of short PHPs by both cells. However, net charge neutralization of PHPs also completely inhibited cellular uptake by plant cells, but not by yeast cells. These results indicate that short PHPs penetrate effectively into plant and yeast cells by similar mechanism with the exception of net charge dependency. The findings show the short PHPs are promising candidates for new delivery tools into plant and yeast cells.     

In vitro uptake and stability study of pVEC and its all-D analog

A key step in the development of new hydrophilic pharmaceuticals is to get them through biological barriers. Cell-penetrating peptides, CPPs, have been shown previously to enter cells both in vitro and in vivo by a non-endocytotic mechanism and to be able to carry large cargo molecules with them. Recently, we showed that a small peptide, pVEC, from murine vascular endothelial cadherin, has the characteristics to be classified as a protein derived CPP. Here we have further investigated pVEC together with its all-D analog for cellular uptake, intra- and extracellular stability, and their enzymatic degradation. The two peptides, pVEC and all-D pVEC, translocate into aortic endothelial cells and murine fibroblasts by a non-endocytotic mechanism. In phosphate buffer, pVEC remains intact while the C-terminal lysine is quickly removed in human serum and serum-containing media. Both pVEC and pVEC without the C-terminal Lys were detected by mass spectrometry inside the two cell types tested. The pVEC half-life is 10.5 min in phosphate buffer containing 10 units of trypsin and 44.6 min in phosphate buffer containing 4.2 units of carboxypeptidase A and 18 units of carboxypeptidase B. In contrast topVEC, the all-D analog remains intact in serum and resists enzymatic degradation.     

Uptake of cell-penetrating peptides in yeasts

The uptake of different cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) in two yeast species, Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Candida albicans, was studied using fluorescence HPLC-analyses of cell content. Comparison of the ability of penetratin, pVEC and (KFF)(3)K to traverse the yeast cell envelope shows that the cellular uptake of the peptides varies widely. Moreover, the intracellular degradation of the CPPs studied varies from complete stability to complete degradation. We show that intracellular degradation into membrane impermeable products can significantly contribute to the fluorescence signal. pVEC displayed highest internalizing capacity, and considering its stability in both yeast species, it is an attractive candidate for further studies.     

pVEC hydrophobic N‐terminus is critical for antibacterial activity

Cell‐penetrating peptides (CPPs) are commonly defined by their shared ability to be internalized into eukaryotic cells, without inducing permanent membrane damage, and to improve cargo delivery. Many CPPs also possess antimicrobial action strong enough to selectively lyse microbes in infected mammalian cultures. pVEC, a CPP derived from cadherin, is able to translocate into mammalian cells, and it is also antimicrobial. Structure‐activity relationship and sequence alignment studies have suggested that the hydrophobic N‐terminus (LLIIL) of pVEC is essential for this peptide's uptake into eukaryotic cells. In this study, our aim was to examine the contribution of these residues to the antimicrobial action and the translocation mechanism of pVEC. We performed antimicrobial activity and microscopy experiments with pVEC and with del5 pVEC (N‐terminal truncated variant of pVEC) and showed that pVEC loses its antimicrobial effect upon deletion of the LLIIL residues, even though both peptides induce membrane permeability. We also calculated the free energy of the transport process using steered molecular dynamic simulations and replica exchange umbrella sampling simulations to compare the difference in uptake mechanism of the 2 peptides in atomistic detail. Despite the difference in experimentally observed antimicrobial activity, the simulations on the 2 peptides showed similar characteristics and the energetic cost of translocation of pVEC was higher than that of del5 pVEC, suggesting that pVEC uptake mechanism cannot be explained by simple passive transport. Our results suggest that LLIIL residues are key contributors to pVEC antibacterial activity because of irreversible membrane disruption.     

Cell-Penetrating Peptides Selectively Cross the Blood-Brain Barrier In Vivo

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) are a group of peptides, which have the ability to cross cell membrane bilayers. CPPs themselves can exert biological activity and can be formed endogenously. Fragmentary studies demonstrate their ability to enhance transport of different cargoes across the blood-brain barrier (BBB). However, comparative, quantitative data on the BBB permeability of different CPPs are currently lacking. Therefore, the in vivo BBB transport characteristics of five chemically diverse CPPs, i.e. pVEC, SynB3, Tat 47–57, transportan 10 (TP10) and TP10-2, were determined. The results of the multiple time regression (MTR) analysis revealed that CPPs show divergent BBB influx properties: Tat 47–57, SynB3, and especially pVEC showed very high unidirectional influx rates of 4.73 μl/(g × min), 5.63 μl/(g × min) and 6.02 μl/(g × min), respectively, while the transportan analogs showed a negligible to low brain influx. Using capillary depletion, it was found that 80% of the influxed peptides effectively reached the brain parenchyma. Except for pVEC, all peptides showed a significant efflux out of the brain. Co-injection of pVEC with radioiodinated bovine serum albumin (BSA) did not enhance the brain influx of radiodionated BSA, indicating that pVEC does not itself significantly alter the BBB properties. A saturable mechanism could not be demonstrated by co-injecting an excess dose of non-radiolabeled CPP. No significant regional differences in brain influx were observed, with the exception for pVEC, for which the regional variations were only marginal. The observed BBB influx transport properties cannot be correlated with their cell-penetrating ability, and therefore, good CPP properties do not imply efficient brain influx.     

Structure-activity relationship study of the cell-penetrating peptide pVEC

The peptide pVEC is a recently described cell-penetrating peptide, derived from the murine vascular endothelial-cadherin protein. In order to define which part of this 18-amino acid long peptide is important for the cellular translocation, we performed a structure-activity relationship study of pVEC. Together with the l-alanine substituted peptides, the retro-pVEC, D-pVEC and the scramble pVEC are studied for comparison. The peptide analogues are labeled with carboxyfluorescein at the N-terminus for monitoring the cellular uptake into human Bowes melanoma cells with different efficacy. We show that all the Fl-pVEC analogues internalize in live Bowes melanoma cells. l-Alanine substitution of the five respective N-terminal hydrophobic amino acids significantly decreases the translocation property, while replacing of Arg(6), Arg(8) or Ser(17) by alanine enhances the uptake. The uptake of pVEC is significantly reduced by treatment with an endocytosis inhibitor wortmannin. Treatment with heparinase III, nystatin and EIPA had no effect on the peptide uptake. The data presented here show that the N-terminal hydrophobic part of pVEC is crucial for efficient cellular translocation.     

Comparative Studies of Leaf Tissue 4: III. EFFECTS OF WALL-DEGRADING ENZYMES AND OSMOTIC STRESS

Commercially available cell wall-degrading enzymes frequentlyused for protoplast isolation inhibited CO₂ fixation and photosyntheticO₂ evolution, and stimulated dark respiration by leaf tissueand isolated mesophyll protoplasts of Nicotiana tabacum L. andAntirrhinum majus L. They also depolarized the membrane potentialof cells of leaf tissue, inhibited uptake of ⁸⁶Rb by tobaccoleaf tissue and isolated mesophyll protoplasts, and stimulated³⁶CI uptake by tobacco leaf tissue. Where studied, these effectswere found to be reversible. The depolarization effect on Antirrhinumleaf cells occurred even when the enzyme preparations had beendenatured, dialysed, or desalted, and the effect was greatestin those fractions of the enzyme preparation which showed thehighest cellulase activity. Plasmolysis of tobacco leaf tissue inhibited photosyntheticO₂ evolution, CO₂ fixation, and ⁸⁶Rb uptake to levels belowthose exhibited by isolated protoplasts in media of the samecomposition and osmolarity. The implications of these resultsfor work with leaf tissue and isolated protoplasts are discussed.     

Deletion analogues of transportan

Several shorter analogues of the cell penetrating peptide, transportan, have been synthesized in order to define the regions of the sequence, which are responsible for the membrane translocation property of the peptide. Penetration of the peptides into Bowes melanoma cells and the influence on GTPase activity in Rin m5F cellular membranes have been tested. The experimental data on cell penetration have been compared with molecular modeling of insertion of peptides into biological membranes. Omission of six amino acids from the N-terminus did not significantly impair the cell penetration of the peptide while deletions at the C-terminus or in the middle of the transportan sequence decreased or abolished the cellular uptake. Most transportan analogues exert an inhibitory effect on GTPase activity. Molecular modeling shows that insertion of the transportan analogues into the membrane differs for different peptides. Probably the length of the peptide as well as the location of aromatic and positively charged residues have major impact on the orientation of peptides in the membranes and thereby influence the cellular penetration. In summary, we have designed and characterized several novel short transportan analogues with similar cellular translocation properties to the parent peptide, but with reduced undesired cellular activity.     

A novel method for monitoring protoplast fusion

Summary Two fluorescent compounds, scopoletin and carboxyfluorescein, have been used to label both tissue culture and leaf mesophyll cells and protoplasts. The compounds localized within the vacuoles of cells in approximately 15 hours. They remained in the vacuole during cell wall digestion, and fluorescence was observable for several hours after protoplast release. A one day pulse of these fluorescent labels had no deleterious effect on the growth of cells or protoplasts. When morphologically indistinguishable protoplasts were labeled and treated with polyethylene glycol, multicolored fluorescent fusion products were observable. These fluorescent labels provide a convenient method for selection of heterokaryon fusion products of whole plant and tissue culture cell protoplasts.