Immunological hurdles in the path to gene therapy for Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), an X-linked lethal muscle-wasting disease, have abnormal expression of the protein dystrophin within their muscle fibres. In the mdx mouse model of this condition, both germline and neonatal somatic gene transfers of dystrophin cDNAs have demonstrated the potential of gene therapy in treating DMD. However, in many DMD patients, there appears to be no dystrophin expression when muscle biopsies are immunostained or western blots are performed. This raises the possibility that the expression of dystrophin following gene transfer might trigger a destructive immune response against this 'neoantigen'. Immune responses can also be generated against the gene transfer vector used to transfect the dystrophic muscle, and the combined immune response could further damage the already inflamed muscle. These problems are now beginning to be investigated in immunocompetent mdx mice. Although much work remains to be done, there are promising indications that these immune responses might not prove as much of a concern as originally envisaged.     

Birth and population prevalence of Duchenne muscular dystrophy in the Netherlands

Summary Mutations causing Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) have a short survival. Therefore, birth and population prevalence are maintained by new mutations. The present inventory was made to estimate the birth and population prevalence rates of DMD in the Netherlands. Seven methods of case identification were used. Data on 496 definite, probable or possible DMD patients born since 1961, or alive on January 1, 1983, were obtained. Several methods gave an estimated ascertainment of more than 95%. The prevalence rate at birth of DMD was estimated at 23.7×10^–5 (14215) male live births (MLB) yearly. The prevalence rate in the male population on January 1, 1983 was 5.4×10^–5 (118496). About 1% of the males in this study may have autosomal recessive Duchenne-like muscular dystrophy. Until now there has been no convincing evidence for geographic differences in DMD prevalence at birth. A list of frequency studies of Duchenne muscular dystrophy is included. The DMD mutation rate calculated by the indirect method is 7.9×10^–5 genes per generation. However, this may well be an over-estimate, as this method does not account for germline mosaicism. Using a modified sex ratio method the proportion of sporadic DMD among all cases was estimated to be 0.106 (range 0–0.332). High frequency of germline mosaicism in DMD is a likely cause for the apparent lack of sporadic cases as found in previous studies, if mutation rates in male and female gametes are equal. Therefore, methods for estimating the proportion of new mutants in DMD should take germline mosaicism into account. The modified sex ratio method allows incorporation of data on germline mosaicism if available.     

Establishment and maintenance of H19 imprinting in the germline and preimplantation embryo

The mouse H19 and Igf2 genes are oppositely imprinted and share enhancers that reside 3' to the genes. The imprinted expression of these genes is coordinated by a 2-kb regulatory element, the differentially methylated domain (DMD), positioned between the two genes. The methylation status of this region determines the ability of the insulator factor CTCF to bind to its sites in the DMD. Deletions and mutations of the DMD that affect imprinting in the soma have little effect on the methylation pattern of H19 in the germline, suggesting that additional sequences and factors contribute to the earliest stages of imprinting regulation at this locus. Less is known about these initial steps, which include the marking of the parental alleles, the onset of allele-specific expression patterns and maintenance of the imprints in the preimplantation embryo. Here, we will focus on these early steps, summarizing what is known and what questions remain to be addressed.     

Germline and somatic mosaicism in a female carrier of Duchenne muscular dystrophy

The family of a male with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) and a deletion within the dystrophin gene has been studied. Polymerase chain reaction analysis of ectopic mRNA from peripheral blood T+B lymphocytes and the use of (CA) _n repeat polymorphisms in and around the deleted region showed the proband's mother to be both a germline mosaic and a somatic mosaic for the deletion seen in her son. The mutation therefore occurred as a mitotic event early in embryogenesis.     

Mapping of four translocation breakpoints within the Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene

There are over 20 females with Duchenne or Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD or BMD) who have X-autosome translocations that break the X chromosome within band Xp21. Several of these translocations have been mapped with genomic probes to regions throughout the large (approximately 2000 kb) DMD gene. In this report, a cDNA clone from the 5' end of the gene was used to further map the breakpoints in four X-autosome translocations. A t(X;21) translocation in a patient with BMD and a t(X;1) translocation in a patient with DMD were found to break within a large 110-kb intron between exons 7 and 8. Two other DMD translocations, t(X;5) and t(X;11), were found to break between the first and the second exon of the gene within a presumably large intron (greater than 100 kb). These results demonstrate that all four translocations have disrupted the DMD gene and make it possible to clone and sequence the breakpoints. This will in turn determine whether these translocations occur by chance in these large introns or whether there are sequences that predispose to translocations.     

Mapping of 12 translocation breakpoints in the Xp21 region with respect to the locus for Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Over 20 females have been reported to carry reciprocal X; autosome translocations with breakpoints in Xp21 and to suffer from Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). We have positioned nine of these breakpoints with respect to the Duchenne gene by mapping probes from the DMD region against a panel of somatic cell hybrids, each containing one of the translocation chromosomes from a different female patient; further information has also been obtained by in situ hybridization, including the breakpoint location in a tenth DMD patient. We have also characterized two translocation breakpoints that lie in the same chromosomal region but which are not associated with the expression of DMD. All the DMD-associated translocation breakpoints examined lie at several sites within the DMD locus and between the two non-DMD breakpoints.     

Germinal mosaicism in Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Summary We have identified a Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) pedigree where the disease is associated with a molecular deletion within the DMD locus. We have examined the meiotic segregation products of the common female ancestor using marker restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) detected by probes that lie within this deletion. These studies show that this female has transmitted three distinet types of X chromosome to her offspring. This observation may be explained by postulating that the mutation arose as a postzygotic deletion within this common ancestor, who was consequently germinally mosaic.     

Hypokalemia complicating Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Although patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) have been shown to have decreased total body potassium levels, serum potassium levels have generally been though to be within normal limits. We report two siblings with DMD noted to be hypokalemic in conjunction with a respiratory illness. Hypokalemia may have exacerbated the pre-existing pulmonary insufficiency in these patients. The literature concerning hypokalemia and DMD is reviewed, and recommendations for the closer monitoring of serum potassium levels in patients with DMD are presented.     

Muskeldystrophien Duchenne und Becker

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is the most frequent muscular disorder in infancy. The inheritance is X-linked recessive with mutations in the dystrophin gene (about 65% deletions, about 7% duplications, about 26% point mutations, and about 2% unknown mutations). The genetic model is complex. The sex ratio of the mutations is unequal. Point mutations and duplications arise in spermatogenesis, whereas deletions arise in oogenesis. About 33% of all patients are new mutations; however, most new mutations are germline mosaic. Becker muscular dystrophy is allelic to DMD.     

Genotype-phenotype correlation and germline mosaicism in DMD/BMD patients with deletions of the dystrophin gene

Summary The molecular analysis of 127 DMD/BMD patients showed that 73 of them (57%) had deletions in the dystrophin gene. Two different methods were used in this study: (a) hybridization of HindIII-digested genomic DNA with nine cDNA probes corresponding to the entire 14 kb cDNA of the DMD gene; and (b) simultaneous amplification of nine exons of the DMD gene (multiplex DNA amplification) by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). When the deletion breakpoints of the intragenic deletions were analyzed with regard to their phenotypic consequences, nine patients were found to represent exceptions to the reading-frame hypothesis. Information regarding mental development was also available for 61 of the 73 deleted patients and for 34 of the 54 non-deleted ones. The proportion of mentally retarded patients was found to be similar in the two groups (deleted, 15%; non-deleted, 18%). Finally, in one family, a junction fragment present in the patient was not found in the peripheral blood DNA of the mother but was present in the sister, thus indicating germline mosaicism in the mother.     

Sex reversal due to Xp disomy by t(X;Y)(p21;q11).

A 20-month-old infant exhibiting psychomotor retardation, dysmorphisms and ambiguous external genitalia was found to have a 46-chromosome karyotype including a normal X chromosome and a marker Y with most of Yq being replaced by an extra Xp21-->pter segment. The paternal karyotype (G and C bands) was 46,XY. The marker Y composition was verified by means of FISH with a chromosome X painting, an alphoid repeat and a DMD probe. Thus, the final diagnosis was 46,X,der(Y)t(X;Y)(p21;q11)de novo.ish der(Y)(wcpX+,DYZ3+,DMD+). The patient's phenotype is consistent with the spectrum documented in 13 patients with similar Xp duplications in whom sex reversal with female or ambiguous genitalia has occurred in spite of an intact Yp or SRY gene. A review of t(X;Y) identifies five distinct exchanges described two or more times: t(X;Y)(p21;q11), t(X;Y)(p22;p11), t(X;Y)(p22;q11-12), t(X;Y) (q22;q12), and t(X;Y)(q28;q12). These translocations probably result from a recombination secondary to DNA homologies within misaligned sex chromosomes in the paternal germline with the derivatives segregating at anaphase I.     

Detection of Duchenne muscular dystrophy carriers by dosage analysis using the DMD cDNA clone 8

Deletion screening in 11 unrelated DMD patients has been performed using DMD cDNA clones 1-8. Of these 11 patients, 6 exhibit deletions of the cDNA clone 8. The carriership of 18 female relatives from these six DMD families has been investigated by dosage analysis. It is shown that dosage analysis is an available method to determine the carrier status of the female relatives of DMD patients showing a deletion within a DMD cDNA clone.     

Patterns of exon deletions in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy

Summary A panel of patients with Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD and BMD) has been screened with the cDNA probes Cf56a and Cf23a, which detect exons in the central part of the DMD gene. One or more exons were deleted in 60% of patients. The deletions were mapped and prove to be heterogeneous in size and extent, particularly in DMD. Deletions specific to DMD and to BMD are described. Half of all BMD patients have a deletion of one particular small group of exons; smaller deletions within this same group produce the more severe DMD.     

Shared role for differentially methylated domains of imprinted genes

For most imprinted genes, a difference in expression between the maternal and paternal alleles is associated with a corresponding difference in DNA methylation that is localized to a differentially methylated domain (DMD). Removal of a gene's DMD leads to a loss of imprinting. These observations suggest that DMDs have a determinative role in genomic imprinting. To examine this possibility, we introduced sequences from the DMDs of the imprinted Igf2r, H19, and Snrpn genes into a nonimprinted derivative of the normally imprinted RSVIgmyc transgene, created by excising its own DMD. Hybrid transgenes with sequences from the Igf2r DMD2 were consistently imprinted, with the maternal allele being more methylated than the paternal allele. Only the repeated sequences within DMD2 were required for imprinting these transgenes. Hybrid transgenes containing H19 and Snrpn DMD sequences and ones containing sequences from the long terminal repeat of a murine intracisternal A particle retrotransposon were not imprinted. The Igf2r hybrid transgenes are comprised entirely of mouse genomic DNA and behave as endogenous imprinted genes in inbred wild-type and mutant mouse strains. These types of hybrid transgenes can be used to elucidate the functions of DMD sequences in genomic imprinting.     

A very small frame-shifting deletion within exon 19 of the Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene

We report the molecular characterization of a Japanese Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) patient. The analysis of genomic gene by polymerase chain reaction indicates that the individuals have a limited deletion within an amplified region, which encompasses exon 19 of DMD gene. The amplified region was sequenced. Comparison of the deletion joint sequence with the normal amplified region sequence indicates that both 5' and 3' deletion end points are present within exon 19 and the deletion removes total 52 bp out of 88 bp of exon 19. Both his mother and sister are carriers of the deletion-containing allele. The mutation introduces a termination codon at residue 791 in exon 20, and is predicted to result in the production of a severely truncated protein. This sort of deletion (designated as DMD-Kobe) might be classified as a new type of DMD gene abnormality.     

A Second Family with Nonsyndromic Sensorineural Hearing Loss Linked to Xp21.2: Refinement of the DFN4 Locus within DMD

X-linked inherited hearing impairment is a group of heterogeneous disorders accounting for less than 2% of hereditary hearing loss. DFN4, a sex-linked hearing impairment associated with profound sensorineural hearing loss, has been previously mapped to Xp21.2, a region containing the DMD locus. We have identified a family from Turkey with deafness in which the disease maps to and refines the DFN4 locus. In contrast to the previous family, the crossover points are entirely within the DMD locus. Two-point lod score analysis for the markers DXS 997, DXS 1214, and DXS 1219 showed a lod score of 2.59. 5′ and 3′ crossovers were between DMD 44 and DXS 1219 and between DXS 1214 and DXS 985, respectively, suggesting that DFN4 is either an allele of DMD or a mutation in a DMD nested gene. The restriction of the DFN4 locus to DMD suggests that dystrophin may play an important role in hearing.     

Parental origin and germline mosaicism of deletions and duplications of the dystrophin gene: a European study

Summary Knowledge about the parental origin of new mutations and the occurrence of germline mosaicism is important for estimating recurrence risks in Duchenne (DMD) and Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD). However, there are problems in resolving these issues partly because not all mutations can as yet be directly detected, and additionally because genetic ratios are very sensitive to ascertainment bias. In the present study, therefore, analysis was restricted to currently detectable mutations (deletions and duplications) in particular types of families which tend to be rare. In order to obtain sufficient data we pooled results from 25 European centers. In mothers of affected patients who were the first in their family with a dystrophin gene deletion or duplication, the ratio between the paternal and the maternal origin of this new mutation was 32:49 (binomial test P = 0.075) for DMD. In five BMD families the ratio between paternal and maternal origin of new mutations was 32. Recurrence risk because of maternal germline mosaicism was studied in sisters or subsequent sibs of isolated cases with an apparently new detectable mutation. In 12 out of 59 (0.20; 95% CI 0.10–0.31) transmissions of the risk haplotype the DMD mutation was transmitted as well. No recurrences were found in nine BMD families.     

A new nonsyndromic X-linked sensorineural hearing impairment linked to Xp21.2.

X-linked deafness is a rare cause of hereditary hearing impairment. We have identified a family with X-linked dominant sensorineural hearing impairment, characterized by incomplete penetrance and variable expressivity in carrier females, that is linked to the Xp21.2, which contains the Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) locus. The auditory impairment in affected males was congenital, bilateral, profound, sensorineural, affecting all frequencies, and without evidence of radiographic abnormality of the temporal bone. Adult carrier females manifested bilateral, mild-to-moderate high-frequency sensorineural hearing impairment of delayed onset during adulthood. Eighteen commercially available, polymorphic markers from the X chromosome, generating a 10-15-cM map, were initially used for identification of a candidate region. DXS997, located within the DMD gene, generated a two-point LOD score of 2.91 at theta = 0, with every carrier mother heterozygous at this locus. Recombination events at DXS992 (located within the DMD locus, 3' to exon 50 of the dystrophin gene) and at DXS1068 (5' to the brain promoter of the dystrophin gene) were observed. No recombination events were noted with the following markers within the DMD locus: 5'DYS II, intron 44, DXS997, and intron 50. There was no clinical evidence of Duchenne or Becker muscular dystrophy in any family member. It is likely that this family represents a new locus on the X chromosome, which when mutated results in nonsyndromic sensorineural hearing loss and is distinct from the heterogeneous group of X-linked hearing losses that have been previously described.     

Long-range genomic map of the Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) gene: Isolation and use of J66 (DXS268), a distal intragenic marker

By cloning the endpoints of a DMD-associated deletion, we have "jumped" 1100 kb from pERT87-1 (DSX164) to a new locus designated J66 (DXS268), mapping distally within the Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) gene. Both J66 and JBir are mapped by field-inversion gel electrophoresis and detect abnormal SfiI fragments in DMD patients and distal DMD-associated X; autosome translocations. Our long-range map extends the physical map of the DMD gene from 800 to 2000 kb (2 Mb) and increases the mapped portion of Xp21 to approximately 8 Mb. The position of the glycerol kinase gene and the adrenal hypoplasia locus are further confined to the region between J66 and the nearest distal probe L1-4. This region spans at least 1.5 Mb. The multiallelic J66 polymorphism has immediate application in the diagnosis of DMD and generally appears to be distal to DMD mutations.