Antibodies to rotavirus outer capsid glycoprotein VP7 neutralize infectivity by inhibiting virion decapsidation

The rotavirus capsid is composed of three concentric protein layers. Proteins VP4 and VP7 comprise the outer layer. VP4 forms spikes, is the viral attachment protein, and is cleaved by trypsin into VP8* and VP5*. VP7 is a glycoprotein and the major constituent of the outer protein layer. Both VP4 and VP7 induce neutralizing and protective antibodies. To gain insight into the virus neutralization mechanisms, the effects of neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) directed against VP8*, VP5*, and VP7 on the decapsidation process of purified OSU and RRV virions were studied. Changes in virion size were followed in real time by 90 degrees light scattering. The transition from triple-layered particles to double-layered particles induced by controlled low calcium concentrations was completely inhibited by anti-VP7 MAbs but not by anti-VP8* or anti-VP5* MAbs. The inhibitory effect of the MAb directed against VP7 was concentration dependent and was abolished by papain digestion of virus-bound antibody under conditions that generated Fab fragments but not under conditions that generated F(ab')(2) fragments. Electron microscopy showed that RRV virions reacted with an anti-VP7 MAb stayed as triple-layered particles in the presence of excess EDTA. Furthermore, the infectivity of rotavirus neutralized via VP8*, but not that of rotavirus neutralized via VP7, could be recovered by lipofection of neutralized particles into MA-104 cells. These data are consistent with the notion that antibodies directed at VP8* neutralize by inhibiting binding of virus to the cell. They also indicate that antibodies directed at VP7 neutralize by inhibiting virus decapsidation, in a manner that is dependent on the bivalent binding of the antibody.     

Proteolysis of Monomeric Recombinant Rotavirus VP4 Yields an Oligomeric VP5* Core

Rotavirus particles are activated for cell entry by trypsin cleavage of the outer capsid spike protein, VP4, into a hemagglutinin, VP8*, and a membrane penetration protein, VP5*. We have purified rhesus rotavirus VP4, expressed in baculovirus-infected insect cells. Purified VP4 is a soluble, elongated monomer, as determined by analytical ultracentrifugation. Trypsin cleaves purified VP4 at a number of sites that are protected on the virion and yields a heterogeneous group of protease-resistant cores of VP5*. The most abundant tryptic VP5* core is trimmed past the N terminus associated with activation for virus entry into cells. Sequential digestion of purified VP4 with chymotrypsin and trypsin generates homogeneous VP8* and VP5* cores (VP8CT and VP5CT, respectively), which have the authentic trypsin cleavages in the activation region. VP8CT is a soluble monomer composed primarily of beta-sheets. VP5CT forms sodium dodecyl sulfate-resistant dimers. These results suggest that trypsinization of rotavirus particles triggers a rearrangement in the VP5* region of VP4 to yield the dimeric spikes observed in icosahedral image reconstructions from electron cryomicroscopy of trypsinized rotavirus virions. The solubility of VP5CT and of trypsinized rotavirus particles suggests that the trypsin-triggered conformational change primes VP4 for a subsequent rearrangement that accomplishes membrane penetration. The domains of VP4 defined by protease analysis contain all mapped neutralizing epitopes, sialic acid binding residues, the heptad repeat region, and the membrane permeabilization region. This biochemical analysis of VP4 provides sequence-specific structural information that complements electron cryomicroscopy data and defines targets and strategies for atomic-resolution structural studies.     

Serum-neutralizing antibody to VP4 and VP7 proteins in infants following vaccination with WC3 bovine rotavirus.

Serum specimens from infants 2 to 12 months old vaccinated with the WC3 bovine rotavirus were analyzed to determine the relative concentrations of neutralizing antibody to the VP4 and VP7 proteins of the vaccine virus. To do this, reassortant rotaviruses that contained the WC3 genome segment for only one of these two neutralization proteins were made. The segment for the other neutralization protein in these reassortants was from heterotypic rotaviruses that were serotypically distinct from WC3. Sera were examined from 31 infants who had no evidence of a previous rotavirus infection and the highest postvaccination WC3-neutralizing antibody titers (i.e., 160 to 600) of the 103 subjects administered the vaccine. A reassortant (3/17) that contained both neutralization proteins from the heterotypic rotaviruses, i.e., EDIM (EW strain of mouse rotavirus) VP7 and rhesus rotavirus VP4, was not neutralized by these sera (geometric mean titer [GMT], less than 20). A reassortant (E19) that contained EDIM VP7 and WC3 VP4 was also very poorly neutralized by these antisera (GMT = 20). In contrast, antibody titers to a reassortant (R20) that contained WC3 VP7 and rhesus rotavirus VP4 were higher than those against WC3 (GMTs of 458 and 313, respectively). Thus, VP7 appeared to be the dominant immunogen for production of neutralizing antibody after intestinal infection of previously uninfected infants vaccinated with WC3 bovine rotavirus.     

Specificity and affinity of neuraminic acid exhibited by canine rotavirus strain K9 carbohydrate‐binding domain (VP8*)

The outer capsid spike protein VP4 of rotaviruses is a major determinant of infectivity and serotype specificity. Proteolytic cleavage of VP4 into 2 domains, VP8* and VP5*, enhances rotaviral infectivity. Interactions between the VP4 carbohydrate‐binding domain (VP8*) and cell surface glycoconjugates facilitate initial virus‐cell attachment and subsequent cell entry. Our saturation transfer difference nuclear magnetic resonance (STD NMR) and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) studies demonstrated that VP8*_64‐224 of canine rotavirus strain K9 interacts with N‐acetylneuraminic and N‐glycolylneuraminic acid derivatives, exhibiting comparable binding epitopes to VP8* from other neuraminidase‐sensitive animal rotaviruses from pigs (CRW‐8), cattle (bovine Nebraska calf diarrhoea virus, NCDV), and Rhesus monkeys (Simian rhesus rotavirus, RRV). Importantly, evidence was obtained for a preference by K9 rotavirus for the N‐glycolyl‐ over the N‐acetylneuraminic acid derivative. This indicates that a VP4 serotype 5A rotavirus (such as K9) can exhibit a neuraminic acid receptor preference that differs from that of a serotype 5B rotavirus (such as RRV) and the receptor preference of rotaviruses can vary within a particular VP4 genotype.     

Functional and topographical analyses of epitopes on the hemagglutinin (VP4) of the simian rotavirus SA11.

An immunochemical analysis of the hemagglutinin (VP4) of the simian rotavirus SA11 was performed to better understand the structure and function of this molecule. Following immunization of mice with double-shelled virus particles and VP4-enriched fractions from CsCl gradients, a battery of anti-SA11 hybridomas was generated. A total of 13 clones secreting high levels of anti-VP4 monoclonal antibody (MAb) was characterized and compared with two cross-reactive anti-VP4 MAbs generated against heterologous rhesus (RRV) and porcine (OSU) rotavirus strains. These cross-reactive MAbs effectively neutralized SA11 infectivity in vitro. The epitopes recognized by these 15 MAbs were grouped into six antigenic sites on the SA11 hemagglutinin. These sites were identified following analysis of the MAbs by using a simple competitive binding enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and biological assays. Three of the antigenic sites were involved in neutralization of virus infectivity in vitro. All the MAbs with neutralization activity and two nonneutralizing MAbs were able to inhibit viral hemagglutination of human erythrocytes. Competitive binding ELISA data showed a positive cooperative binding effect with some pairs of the anti-VP4 MAbs, apparently due to a conformational change induced by the binding of the first MAb. Some of the MAbs also bound better to trypsin-treated virus than to non-trypsin-treated virus. A topographic map for VP4 is proposed on the basis of the observed properties of each antigenic site.     

Trypsin cleavage stabilizes the rotavirus VP4 spike

Trypsin enhances rotavirus infectivity by an unknown mechanism. To examine the structural basis of trypsin-enhanced infectivity in rotaviruses, SA11 4F triple-layered particles (TLPs) grown in the absence (nontrypsinized rotavirus [NTR]) or presence (trypsinized rotavirus [TR]) of trypsin were characterized to determine the structure, the protein composition, and the infectivity of the particles before and after trypsin treatment. As expected, VP4 was not cleaved in NTR particles and was cleaved into VP5(*) and VP8(*) in TR particles. However, surprisingly, while the VP4 spikes were clearly visible and well ordered in the electron cryomicroscopy reconstructions of TR TLPs, they were totally absent in the reconstructions of NTR TLPs. Biochemical analysis with radiolabeled particles indicated that the stoichiometry of the VP4 in NTR particles was the same as that in TR particles and that the VP8(*) portion of NTR, but not TR, particles is susceptible to further proteolysis by trypsin. Taken together, these structural and biochemical data show that the VP4 spikes in the NTR TLPs are icosahedrally disordered and that they are conformationally different. Structural studies on the NTR TLPs after trypsin treatment showed that spike structure could be partially recovered. Following additional trypsin treatment, infectivity was enhanced for both NTR and TR particles, but the infectivity of NTR remained 2 logs lower than that of TR particles. Increased infectivity in these particles corresponded to additional cleavages in VP5(*), at amino acids 259, 583, and putatively 467, which are conserved in all P serotypes of human and animal group A rotaviruses and also corresponded with a structural change in VP7. These biochemical and structural results show that trypsin cleavage imparts order to VP4 spikes on de novo synthesized virus particles, and these ordered spikes make virus entry into cells more efficient.     

Localization of rotavirus VP4 neutralization epitopes involved in antibody-induced conformational changes of virus structure.

We previously characterized three neutralization-positive epitopes (NP1 [1a and 1b], NP2, and NP3) and three neutralization-negative epitopes on the simian rotavirus SA11 VP4 with 13 monoclonal antibodies (MAbs). Conformational changes occurred as a result of the binding of NP1 MAbs to the SA11 spike VP4, and enhanced binding of all neutralization-negative MAbs was observed when NP1 MAbs bound VP4 in a competitive MAb capture enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. To further understand the structure and function of VP4, we have continued studies with these MAbs. Electron microscopic and sucrose gradient analyses of SA11-MAb complexes showed that triple-layered viral particles disassembled following treatment with NP1b MAbs 10G6 and 7G6 but not following treatment with NP1a MAb 9F6, NP2 MAb 2G4, and NP3 MAb 23. Virus infectivity was reduced approximately 3 to 5 logs by the NP1b MAbs. These results suggest that NP1b MAb neutralization occurs by a novel mechanism. We selected four neutralization escape mutants of SA11 with these VP4 MAbs and characterized them by using plaque reduction neutralization assays, hemagglutination inhibition assays, and an antigen capture enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. These analyses support the previous assignment of the NP1a, NP1b, NP2, and NP3 MAbs into separate epitopes and confirmed that the viruses were truly neutralization escape mutants. Nucleotide sequence analyses found 1 amino acid (aa) substitution in VP8* of VP4 at (i) aa 136 for NP1a MAb mutant 9F6R, (ii) aa 180 and 183 for NP1b MAb mutants 7G6R and 10G6R, respectively, and (iii) aa 194 for NP3 MAb mutant 23R. The NP1b MAb mutants showed an unexpected enhanced binding with heterologous nonneutralization MAb to VP7 compared with parental SA11 and the other mutants. Taken together, these results suggest that the NP1b epitope is a critical site for VP4 and VP7 interactions and for virus stability.     

Binding to sialic acids is not an essential step for the entry of animal rotaviruses to epithelial cells in culture.

The infection of target cells by animal rotaviruses requires the presence of sialic acids on the cell surface. Treatment of the cells with neuraminidases or incubation of the viruses with some sialoglycoproteins, such as glycophorin A, greatly reduces virus binding, with the consequent reduction of viral infectivity. In this work, we report the isolation of animal rotavirus variants whose infectivity is no longer dependent on the presence of sialic acids on the cell surface. In addition, although these variants bind to glycophorin A as efficiently as the wild-type virus, this interaction no longer inhibit viral infectivity. These observations indicate that the initial interaction of the mutants with the cell occurs at a site different from the sialic acid-binding site located on VP8, the smaller trypsin cleavage product of VP4. Reassortant analysis showed that the mutant phenotype segregates with the VP4 gene. Neutralizing monoclonal antibodies directed to VP4 and VP7 were tested for their ability to neutralize the variants. Antibodies to VP7 and VP5, the larger trypsin cleavage product of VP4, neutralized the mutants as efficiently as the wild-type virus. In contrast, although antibodies to VP8 were able to bind to the mutants, they showed little or no neutralizing activity. The implications of these findings in rotavirus attachment to and penetration of epithelial cells in culture are discussed.     

Relative concentrations of serum neutralizing antibody to VP3 and VP7 proteins in adults infected with a human rotavirus.

Two outer capsid rotavirus proteins, VP3 and VP7, have been found to elicit neutralizing-antibody production, but the immunogenicity of these proteins during human rotavirus infection has not been determined. The relative amounts of serum neutralizing antibody against the VP3 and VP7 proteins of the CJN strain of human rotavirus were, therefore, determined in adult subjects before and after infection with this virus. Reassortant strains of rotavirus that contained the CJN gene segment for only one of these two neutralization proteins were isolated and used for this study. The geometric mean titer of serum neutralizing antibody to a reassortant virus (CJN-M) that contained VP7 of CJN and VP3 of another human rotavirus was 12.7 times less than that of antibody to CJN before infection and 20.3 times less after infection. This indicated that most neutralizing antibody was against the VP3 rather than the VP7 protein of CJN. This result was confirmed with other reassortants between CJN and animal rotavirus strains (EDIM and rhesus rotavirus). These findings suggest that VP3 is the primary immunogen that stimulates neutralizing antibody during at least some rotavirus infections of humans.     

Poliovirus Sabin type 1 neutralization epitopes recognized by immunoglobulin A monoclonal antibodies.

Immunity to poliomyelitis is largely dependent on humoral neutralizing antibodies, both after natural (wild virus or vaccine) infection and after inactivated poliovirus vaccine inoculation. Although the production of local secretory immunoglobulin A (IgA) antibody in the gut mucosa may play a major role in protection, most of information about the antigenic determinants involved in neutralization of polioviruses derives from studies conducted with humoral monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) generated from parenterally immunized mice. To investigate the specificity of the mucosal immune response to the virus, we have produced a library of IgA MAbs directed at Sabin type 1 poliovirus by oral immunization of mice with live virus in combination with cholera toxin. The epitopes recognized by 13 neutralizing MAbs were characterized by generating neutralization-escape virus mutants. Cross-neutralization analysis of viral mutants with MAbs allowed these epitopes to be divided into four groups of reactivity. To determine the epitope specificity of MAbs, virus variants were sequenced and the mutations responsible for resistance to the antibodies were located. Eight neutralizing MAbs were found to be directed at neutralization site N-AgIII in capsid protein VP3; four more MAbs recognized site N-AgII in VP1 or VP2. One IgA MAb selected a virus variant which presented a unique mutation at amino acid 138 in VP2, not previously described. This site appears to be partially related with site N-AgII and is located in a loop region facing the VP2 N-Ag-II loop around residue 164. Only 2 of 13 MAbs proved able to neutralize the wild-type Mahoney strain of poliovirus. The IgA antibodies studied were found to be produced in the dimeric form needed for recognition by the polyimmunoglobulin receptor mediating secretory antibody transport at the mucosal level.     

Similarity of the outer capsid protein VP4 of the Gottfried strain of porcine rotavirus to that of asymptomatic human rotavirus strains.

Genomic segment 4 of the porcine Gottfried strain (serotype 4) of porcine rotavirus, which encodes the outer capsid protein VP4, was sequences, and its deduced amino acid sequence was analyzed. Amino acid homology of the porcine rotavirus VP4 to the corresponding protein of asymptomatic or symptomatic human rotaviruses representing serotypes 1 to 4 ranged from 87.1 to 88.1% for asymptomatic strains and from 77.5 to 77.8% for symptomatic strains. Amino acid homology of the Gottfried strain to simian rhesus rotavirus, simian SA11 virus, bovine Nebraska calf diarrhea virus, and porcine OSU strains ranged from 71.5 to 74.3%. Antigenic similarities of VP4 epitopes between the Gottfried strain and human rotaviruses were detected by a plaque reduction neutralization test with hyperimmune antisera produced against the Gottfried strain or a Gottfried (10 genes) x human DS-1 rotavirus (VP7 gene) reassortant which exhibited serotype 2 neutralization specificity. In addition, a panel of six anti-VP4 monoclonal antibodies capable of neutralizing human rotaviruses belonging to serotype 1, 3, or 4 was able to neutralize the Gottfried strain. These observations suggest that the VP4 outer capsid protein of the Gottfried rotavirus is more closely related to human rotaviruses than to animal rotaviruses.     

Proteolytic enhancement of rotavirus infectivity: molecular mechanisms

The polypeptide compositions of single-shelled and double-shelled simian rotavirus particles were modified by exposure to proteolytic enzymes. Specifically, a major outer capsid polypeptide (VP3) having a molecular weight of 88,000 in double-shelled particles was cleaved by trypsin to yield two polypeptides, VP5* and VP8* (molecular weights, 60,000 and 28,000, respectively). The cleavage of VP3 by enzymes that enhanced infectivity (trypsin, elastase, and pancreatin) yielded different products compared to those detected when VP3 was cleaved by chymotrypsin, which did not enhance infectivity. The appearance of VP5* was correlated with an enhancement of infectivity. Cleavages of the major internal capsid polypeptide VP2 were also observed. The VP2 cleavage products had molecular weights similar to those of known structural and nonstructural rotavirus polypeptides. We confirmed the precursor-product relationships by comparing the peptide maps of the polypeptides generated by digestions with V-8 protease and chymotrypsin. The remaining rotavirus structural polypeptides, including the outer capsid glycoproteins (VP7 and 7a), were not altered by exposure to pancreatic enzymes. Cleavage of VP3 was not required for virus assembly, and specific cleavage of the polypeptides occurred only on assembled particles. We also discuss the role of cleavage activation in other virus-specific biological functions (e.g., hemagglutination and virulence).     

Serotypic analysis of VP3 and VP7 neutralization escape mutants of rhesus rotavirus.

Neutralization escape mutants of simian rotaviruses (rhesus rotavirus and SA11) were tested in hemagglutination inhibition and neutralization assays against hyperimmune and infection sera to determine if mutation in an immunodominant epitope could enable neutralization escape. An SA11 mutant with a new glycosylation site at amino acid 211 of VP7 was shown to escape neutralization by hyperimmune but not infection sera.     

Neutralizing monoclonal antibodies against three serotypes of porcine rotavirus.

Using three serotypes (four strains) of cultivable porcine rotavirus as immunizing antigens, 10 neutralizing monoclonal antibodies were characterized. One VP4-specific monoclonal antibody directed against porcine rotavirus BEN-144 (serotype G4) neutralized human rotavirus strain ST-3 in addition to the homologous porcine virus. All nine VP7-specific monoclonal antibodies were highly specific for viruses of the same serotype as the immunizing rotavirus strain. One exception was the VP7-specific monoclonal antibody C3/1, which neutralized both serotype G3 and G5 rotaviruses. However, this monoclonal antibody did not neutralize the porcine rotavirus AT/76, also of serotype G3, nor mutants of SA-11 virus (serotype G3) which were selected with monoclonal antibody A10/N3 and are known to have mutations affecting the C antigenic region.     

Location of intrachain disulfide bonds in the VP5* and VP8* trypsin cleavage fragments of the rhesus rotavirus spike protein VP4.

Because the rotavirus spike protein VP4 contains conserved Cys residues at positions 216, 318, 380, and 774 and, for many animal rotaviruses, also at position 203, we sought to determine whether disulfide bonds were structural elements of VP4. Electrophoretic analysis of untreated and trypsin-treated rhesus rotavirus (RRV) and simain rotavirus SA11 in the presence and absence of the reducing agent dithioerythritol revealed that VP4 and its cleavage fragments VP5* and VP8* possessed intrachain disulfide bonds. Given that the VP8* fragments of RRV and SA11 contain only two Cys residues, those at positions 203 and 216, these data indicated that these two residues were covalently linked. Electrophoretic examination of truncated species of VP4 and VP4 containing Cys-->Ser mutations synthesized in reticulocyte lysates provided additional evidence that Cys-203 and Cys-216 in VP8* of RRV were linked by a disulfide bridge. VP5* expressed in vitro was able to form a disulfide bond analogous to that in the VP5* fragment of trypsin-treated RRV. Analysis of a Cys-774-->Ser mutant of VP5* showed that, while it was able to form a disulfide bond, a Cys-318-->Ser mutant of VP5* was not. These results indicated that the VP4 component of all rotaviruses, except B223, contains a disulfide bond that links Cys-318 and Cys-380 in the VP5* region of the protein. This bond is located between the trypsin cleavage site and the putative fusion domain of VP4. Because human rotaviruses lack Cys-203 and, hence, unlike many animal rotaviruses cannot possess a disulfide bond in VP8*, it is apparent that VP4 is structurally variable in nature, with human rotaviruses generally containing one disulfide linkage and animal rotaviruses generally containing two such linkages. Considered with the results of anti-VP4 antibody mapping studies, the data suggest that the disulfide bond in VP5* exists within the 2G4 epitope and may be located at the distal end of the VP4 spike on rotavirus particles.     

Priming for rotavirus neutralizing antibodies by a VP4 protein-derived synthetic peptide.

In the rotavirus SA11 surface protein VP4, the trypsin cleavage sites associated with the enhancement of infectivity are flanked by two amino acid regions that are highly conserved among different rotaviruses. We have tested the ability of synthetic peptides that mimic these two regions to induce and prime for a rotavirus neutralizing antibody response in mice. After the peptide immunization schedule, both peptides induced peptide antibodies, but neither was able to induce virus antibodies, as measured by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay or a neutralization assay. However, when the peptide-inoculated mice were subsequently injected with intact SA11 virus, a rapid and high neutralizing antibody response was observed in mice that had previously received the peptide comprising amino acids 220 to 233 of the VP4 protein. This neutralizing activity was serotype specific; however, this peptide was also able to efficiently prime the immune system of mice for a neutralizing antibody response to the heterotypic rotavirus ST3 when the ST3 virus was used for the secondary inoculation.     

Immunodominance of the VP4 neutralization protein of rotavirus in protective natural infections of young children.

Natural infection by very similar strains of rotavirus during the 1988-1989 rotavirus season in Cincinnati, Ohio, provided complete protection of young children against subsequent rotavirus illnesses for a period of at least 2 years. Using this limited strain variability, we characterized the association between the titers of antibody to either the VP4 or the VP7 neutralization protein and protection against subsequent rotavirus disease. This was done by using reassortants that contained only one of the two rotavirus neutralization proteins of 89-12, a culture-adapted isolate representative of the protective rotavirus strains. The other neutralization protein in these reassortants was derived from a heterologous rotavirus (WC3 or EDIM) to which the infected subjects made little or no neutralizing antibody (titers, < or = 20). The geometric mean titer (GMT) of antibody to 89-12 in convalescent-phase sera from the 21 subjects analyzed was 2,323. The GMT of antibody to a reassortant (strain WC-4) that contained the VP7 protein of 89-12 and VP4 of WC3 was 387. In contrast, the GMT of antibody to a reassortant (strain EDIM-7) that contained the VP4 protein of 89-12 and the VP7 protein of EDIM was 1,078. Thus, the major neutralization response was directed against VP4 rather than VP7, a finding that has important implications for development of appropriate rotavirus vaccines.