Quantitative analysis of FRET assay in biology—new developments in protein interaction affinity and protease kinetics determinations in the SUMOylation cascade

F(o)rster resonance energy transfer (FRET) techniques have been widely used in biological studies in vitro and in vivo and are powerful tools for elucidating protein interactions in many regulatory cas...     

Systematic determinations of SUMOylation activation intermediates and dynamics by a sensitive and quantitative FRET assay

Ubiquitination and SUMOylation are multi-step cascade reactions, in which small protein modifiers are activated by E1 activating enzyme, transferred to E2 conjugating enzyme, and conjugated to substrates mediated by the E3 ligase in vivo. The structural and biochemical bases for the cascade reactions have been elucidated by several studies. However, the reaction intermediates and dynamics of these peptide modifiers among the enzymes have not been completely elucidated. Here we report detailed investigations of SUMOylation dynamics and interaction switches of SUMO1 among its ligases using FRET technology. These studies show that, while SUMO1 and the E1 subunit Aos1 or Uba2 have no intrinsic affinity for each other, the adenylation of SUMO1 carried out by Aos1 requires the presence of Uba2, and subsequently conformational changes trigger the interaction of SUMO1 and Uba2 for a thioester bond formation. The reaction intermediates among SUMO1 and its ligases are indirectly revealed by FRET signals generated by each pair. Furthermore, the transfer of SUMO1 from Uba2 to E2 enzyme, Ubc9, depends on the formation of a thioester bond between SUMO1 and Ubc9, and requires non-covalent interaction between Ubc9 and Uba2, but not between Ubc9 and SUMO1. These interaction switches provide the physical and biochemical bases for the SUMO activation and a transfer cascade required for SUMO activation.     

Quantitative Förster resonance energy transfer analysis for kinetic determinations of SUMO-specific protease

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) technology has been widely used in biological and biomedical research, and it is a very powerful tool for elucidating protein interactions in either dynamic or steady state. SUMOylation (the process of SUMO [small ubiquitin-like modifier] conjugation to substrates) is an important posttranslational protein modification with critical roles in multiple biological processes. Conjugating SUMO to substrates requires an enzymatic cascade. Sentrin/SUMO-specific proteases (SENPs) act as an endopeptidase to process the pre-SUMO or as an isopeptidase to deconjugate SUMO from its substrate. To fully understand the roles of SENPs in the SUMOylation cycle, it is critical to understand their kinetics. Here, we report a novel development of a quantitative FRET-based protease assay for SENP1 kinetic parameter determination. The assay is based on the quantitative analysis of the FRET signal from the total fluorescent signal at acceptor emission wavelength, which consists of three components: donor (CyPet–SUMO1) emission, acceptor (YPet) emission, and FRET signal during the digestion process. Subsequently, we developed novel theoretical and experimental procedures to determine the kinetic parameters, k_cat, K_M, and catalytic efficiency (k_cat/K_M) of catalytic domain SENP1 toward pre-SUMO1. Importantly, the general principles of this quantitative FRET-based protease kinetic determination can be applied to other proteases.     

A computational approach to inferring cellular protein‐binding affinities from quantitative fluorescence resonance energy transfer imaging

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy can measure the spatial distribution of protein interactions inside live cells. Such experiments give rise to complex data sets with many images of single cells, motivating data reduction and abstraction. In particular, determination of the value of the equilibrium dissociation constant (K_d) will provide a quantitative measure of protein–protein interactions, which is essential to reconstructing cellular signaling networks. Here, we investigate the feasibility of using quantitative FRET imaging of live cells to estimate the local value of K_d for two interacting labeled molecules. An algorithm is developed to infer the values of K_d using the intensity of individual voxels of 3‐D FRET microscopy images. The performance of our algorithm is investigated using synthetic test data, both in the absence and in the presence of endogenous (unlabeled) proteins. The influence of optical blurring caused by the microscope (confocal or wide field) and detection noise on the accuracy of K_d inference is studied. We show that deconvolution of images followed by analysis of intensity data at local level can improve the estimate of K_d. Finally, the performance of this algorithm using cellular data on the interaction between yellow fluorescent protein‐Rac and cyan fluorescent protein‐PBD in mammalian cells is shown.     

Activity-dependent SUMOylation of the brain-specific scaffolding protein GISP

G-protein coupled receptor interacting scaffold protein (GISP) is a multi-domain, brain-specific protein derived from the A-kinase anchoring protein (AKAP)-9 gene. Using yeast two-hybrid screens to identify GISP interacting proteins we isolated the SUMO conjugating enzyme Ubc9. GISP interacts with Ubc9 in vitro, in heterologous cells and in neurons. SUMOylation is a post-translational modification in which the small protein SUMO is covalently conjugated to target proteins, modulating their function. Consistent with its interaction with Ubc9, we show that GISP is SUMOylated by both SUMO-1 and SUMO-2 in both in vitro SUMOylation assays and in mammalian cells. Intriguingly, SUMOylation of GISP in neurons occurs in an activity-dependent manner in response to chemical LTP. These data suggest that GISP is a novel neuronal SUMO substrate whose SUMOylation status is modulated by neuronal activity.     

The Anaplasma phagocytophilum effector AmpA hijacks host cell SUMOylation

SUMOylation, the covalent attachment of a member of the small ubiquitin‐like modifier (SUMO) family of proteins to lysines in target substrates, is an essential post‐translational modification in eukaryotes. Microbial manipulation of SUMOylation recently emerged as a key virulence strategy for viruses and facultative intracellular bacteria, the latter of which have only been shown to deploy effectors that negatively regulate SUMOylation. Here, we demonstrate that the obligate intracellular bacterium, Anaplasma phagocytophilum, utilizes an effector, AmpA (A. phagocytophilum post‐translationally modified protein A) that becomes SUMOylated in host cells and this is important for the pathogen's survival. We previously discovered that AmpA (formerly APH1387) localizes to the A. phagocytophilum‐occupied vacuolar membrane (AVM). Algorithmic prediction analyses denoted AmpA as a candidate for SUMOylation. We verified this phenomenon using a SUMO affinity matrix to precipitate both native AmpA and ectopically expressed green fluorescent protein (GFP)‐tagged AmpA. SUMOylation of AmpA was lysine dependent, as SUMO affinity beads failed to precipitate a GFP‐AmpA protein when its lysine residues were substituted with arginine. Ectopically expressed and endogenous AmpA were poly‐SUMOylated, which was consistent with the observation that AmpA colocalizes with SUMO2/3 at the AVM. Only late during the infection cycle did AmpA colocalize with SUMO1, which terminally caps poly‐SUMO2/3 chains. AmpA was also detected in the cytosol of infected host cells, further supporting its secretion and likely participation in interactions that aid pathogen survival. Indeed, whereas siRNA‐mediated knockdown of Ubc9 – a necessary enzyme for SUMOylation – slightly bolstered A. phagocytophilum infection, pharmacologically inhibiting SUMOylation in infected cells significantly reduced the bacterial load. Ectopically expressed GFP‐AmpA served as a competitive agonist against native AmpA in infected cells, while lysine‐deficient GFP‐AmpA was less effective, implying that modification of AmpA lysines is important for infection. Collectively, these data show that AmpA becomes directly SUMOylated during infection, representing a novel tactic for A. phagocytophilum survival.     

RWD Domain as an E2 (Ubc9)-Interaction Module

An RWD domain is a well conserved domain found through bioinformatic analysis of the human proteome sequence; however, its function has been unknown. Ubiquitin-like modifications require the catalysis of three enzymes generally known as E1, E2, and E3. We solved the crystal structure of the E2 for the small ubiquitin-like modifiers (SUMO) in complex with an RWD domain and confirmed the structure using solution NMR analysis. The binding surface of RWD on Ubc9 is located near the N terminus of Ubc9 that is known to be involved in noncovalent binding of the proteins in the conjugation machinery, including a domain of E1, SUMO, and an E3 ligase. NMR data indicate that the RWD domain does not bind to SUMO and E1. The interaction between RWD and Ubc9 has a K_d of 32 ± 4 μm. Consistent with the structure and binding affinity and in contrast to a previous report, the RWD domain and RWDD3 have minimal effects on global SUMOylation. The structural and biochemical information presented here forms the basis for further investigation of the functions of RWD-containing proteins.     

Analysis of in vitro SUMOylation using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET)

We demonstrated in vitro small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO)-mediated modification (SUMOylation) of RanGTPase activating protein-1 (RanGAP1) by using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) for studying protein interactions. Renilla luciferase (Rluc) was fused to SUMO, and RanGAP1, the binding partner of SUMO, was fused to enhanced yellow fluorescence protein (EYFP). Upon binding of SUMO and RanGAP1, BRET was observed between EYFP (donor) and Rluc (acceptor) in the presence of E1 (Aos1/Uba2) and E2 (Ubc9) enzymes, whereas mutation (K524A) of RanGAP1 at its SUMO binding site prevented significant energy transfer. Comparing BRET and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) efficiencies using this in vitro model system, we observed that BRET efficiency was 3-fold higher than FRET efficiency, due to the lower background signal intensity of EYFP in the BRET system. Consequently, BRET system is expected to be useful for in vitro analysis of SUMOylation as well as studying other protein interactions.     

Quantifying intracellular equilibrium dissociation constants using single‐channel time‐resolved FRET

Quantification of the intracellular equilibrium dissociation constant of the interaction, K_d, is challenging due to the variability of the relative concentrations of the interacting proteins in the cell. Fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) of the donor provides an accurate measurement of the molecular fraction of donor involved in FRET, but the fraction of bound acceptor is also needed to reliably estimate K_d. We present a method that exploits the spectroscopic properties of the widely used eGFP – mCherry FRET pair to rigorously determine the intracellular K_d based on imaging the fluorescence lifetime of only the donor (single‐channel FLIM). We have assessed the effect of incomplete labelling and determined its range of application for different K_d using Monte Carlo simulations. We have demonstrated this method estimating the intracellular K_d for the homodimerisaton of the oncogenic protein 3‐phosphoinositide‐dependent kinase 1 (PDK1) in different cell lines and conditions, revealing a competitive mechanism for its regulation. The measured intracellular K_d was validated against in‐vitro data. This method provides an accurate and generic tool to quantify protein interactions in situ.

     

The Interaction Affinity between Vascular Cell Adhesion Molecule-1 (VCAM-1) and Very Late Antigen-4 (VLA-4) Analyzed by Quantitative FRET

Very late antigen-4 (VLA-4), a member of integrin superfamily, interacts with its major counter ligand vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 (VCAM-1) and plays an important role in leukocyte adhesion to vascular endothelium and immunological synapse formation. However, irregular expressions of these proteins may also lead to several autoimmune diseases and metastasis cancer. Thus, quantifying the interaction affinity of the VCAM-1/VLA-4 interaction is of fundamental importance in further understanding the nature of this interaction and drug discovery. In this study, we report an ‘in solution’ steady state organic fluorophore based quantitative fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) assay to quantify this interaction in terms of the dissociation constant (K_d). We have used, in our FRET assay, the Alexa Fluor 488-VLA-4 conjugate as the donor, and Alexa Fluor 546-VCAM-1 as the acceptor. From the FRET signal analysis, K_d of this interaction was determined to be 41.82 ± 2.36 nM. To further confirm our estimation, we have employed surface plasmon resonance (SPR) technique to obtain K_d = 39.60 ± 1.78 nM, which is in good agreement with the result obtained by FRET. This is the first reported work which applies organic fluorophore based ‘in solution’ simple quantitative FRET assay to obtain the dissociation constant of the VCAM-1/VLA-4 interaction, and is also the first quantification of this interaction. Moreover, the value of K_d can serve as an indicator of abnormal protein-protein interactions; hence, this assay can potentially be further developed into a drug screening platform of VLA-4/VCAM-1 as well as other protein-ligand interactions.     

FRET Based Quantification and Screening Technology Platform for the Interactions of Leukocyte Function-Associated Antigen-1 (LFA-1) with InterCellular Adhesion Molecule-1 (ICAM-1)

The interaction between leukocyte function-associated antigen-1(LFA-1) and intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) plays a pivotal role in cellular adhesion including the extravasation and inflammatory response of leukocytes, and also in the formation of immunological synapse. However, irregular expressions of LFA-1 or ICAM-1 or both may lead to autoimmune diseases, metastasis cancer, etc. Thus, the LFA-1/ICAM-1 interaction may serve as a potential therapeutic target for the treatment of these diseases. Here, we developed one simple ‘in solution’ steady state fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) technique to obtain the dissociation constant (K_d) of the interaction between LFA-1 and ICAM-1. Moreover, we developed the assay into a screening platform to identify peptides and small molecules that inhibit the LFA-1/ICAM-1 interaction. For the FRET pair, we used Alexa Fluor 488-LFA-1 conjugate as donor and Alexa Fluor 555-human recombinant ICAM-1 (D1-D2-Fc) as acceptor. From our quantitative FRET analysis, the K_d between LFA-1 and D1-D2-Fc was determined to be 17.93±1.34 nM. Both the K_d determination and screening assay were performed in a 96-well plate platform, providing the opportunity to develop it into a high-throughput assay. This is the first reported work which applies FRET based technique to determine K_d as well as classifying inhibitors of the LFA-1/ICAM-1 interaction.     

Biochemical characterization of the small ubiquitin-like modifiers of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Dynamic modification of target proteins by small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) is known to modulate many important cellular processes and is required for cell viability and development in all eukaryotes. However, understanding of SUMO systems in plants, especially in unicellular green algae, remains elusive. In this study, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii CrSUMO96, CrSUMO97 and CrSUMO148 were characterized. We show that the formation of polymeric CrSUMO96 and CrSUMO97 chains can be catalyzed either by the human SAE1/SAE2 and Ubc9 SUMOylation system in vitro or by an Escherichia coli chimeric SUMOylation system in vivo. An exposed C-terminal di-glycine motif of CrSUMO96 or CrSUMO97 is essential for functional SUMOylation. The human SUMO-specific protease, SENP1, demonstrates more processing activity for CrSUMO97 than for CrSUMO96. The CrSUMO148 precursor notably has four repeated di-glycine motifs at the C-terminus. This unique feature is not found in other known SUMO proteins. Interestingly, only 83-residual CrSUMO148_1–83 with the first di-glycine motif can form SAE1/SAE2–SUMO complex and further form polymeric chains with the help of Ubc9. More surprisingly, CrSUMO148 precursor is digested by SENP1, solely at the peptide bond after the first di-glycine motif although there are four theoretically identical processing sites in the primary sequence. This process directly generates 83-residual CrSUMO148_1–83 mature protein, which is exactly the form suitable for activation and conjugation. We also show that SENP1 displays similar isopeptidase activity in the deconjugation of polymeric CrSUMO96, CrSUMO97 or CrSUMO148 chains, revealing that the catalytic mechanisms of processing and deconjugation of CrSUMOs by SENP1 may differ.     

Selection of aptamers for aflatoxin M1 and their characterization

In the present work, aptamers against aflatoxin M1 and aflatoxin B1 were generated and tested for creating proof of principle of recognition of aflatoxin M1 by generated aptamers. The aptamers were selected through the process referred as systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment. A total of 41 different aptamer (36 aptamers for aflatoxin M1 and 5 for aflatoxin B1) sequences were obtained. The determination of dissociation constant (K_d) values revealed that aptamers generated against aflatoxin M1 exhibited K_d values in the range of 35–1515 nM. Selected aptamers were grouped on the basis of the presence of common motifs or G‐quadruplex. We find it interesting that one aptamer with no conserved motif or G‐quadruplex had lowest K_d value (K_d = 35 nM). This structural motif is very distinct from motifs present in other aptamers. The K_d values of selected aptamers for aflatoxin B1 were in the range of 96–221 nM. One aptamer from each group was further tested for its ability to be used in aptasensor. The aptamer recognized aflatoxin M1 as indicated by color change (red to purple or blue) of aptamer‐coated gold nanoparticles in the presence of 250–500 nM aflatoxin M1. The aptamers can be used in developing methods for detection/estimation/separation of aflatoxin or antidote for aflatoxin toxicity. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Principal component analysis of chemical shift perturbation data of a multiple‐ligand‐binding system for elucidation of respective binding mechanism

Chemical shift perturbations (CSPs) in NMR spectra provide useful information about the interaction of a protein with its ligands. However, in a multiple‐ligand‐binding system, determining quantitative parameters such as a dissociation constant (K_d) is difficult. Here, we used a method we named CS‐PCA, a principal component analysis (PCA) of chemical shift (CS) data, to analyze the interaction between bovine β‐lactoglobulin (βLG) and 1‐anilinonaphthalene‐8‐sulfonate (ANS), which is a multiple‐ligand‐binding system. The CSP on the binding of ANS involved contributions from two distinct binding sites. PCA of the titration data successfully separated the CSP pattern into contributions from each site. Docking simulations based on the separated CSP patterns provided the structures of βLG–ANS complexes for each binding site. In addition, we determined the K_d values as 3.42 × 10⁻⁴M² and 2.51 × 10⁻³M for Sites 1 and 2, respectively. In contrast, it was difficult to obtain reliable K_d values for respective sites from the isothermal titration calorimetry experiments. Two ANS molecules were found to bind at Site 1 simultaneously, suggesting that the binding occurs cooperatively with a partial unfolding of the βLG structure. On the other hand, the binding of ANS to Site 2 was a simple attachment without a significant conformational change. From the present results, CS‐PCA was confirmed to provide not only the positions and the K_d values of binding sites but also information about the binding mechanism. Thus, it is anticipated to be a general method to investigate protein–ligand interactions. Proteins 2013. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Molecular targets underlying SUMO‐mediated neuroprotection in brain ischemia

SUMOylation (small ubiquitin‐like modifier conjugation) is an important post‐translational modification which is becoming increasingly implicated in the altered protein dynamics associated with brain ischemia. The function of SUMOylation in cells undergoing ischemic stress and the identity of small ubiquitin‐like modifier (SUMO) targets remain in most cases unknown. However, the emerging consensus is that SUMOylation of certain proteins might be part of an endogenous neuroprotective response. This review brings together the current understanding of the underlying mechanisms and downstream effects of SUMOylation in brain ischemia, including processes such as autophagy, mitophagy and oxidative stress. We focus on recent advances and controversies regarding key central nervous system proteins, including those associated with the nucleus, cytoplasm and plasma membrane, such as glucose transporters (GLUT1, GLUT4), excitatory amino acid transporter 2 glutamate transporters, K⁺ channels (K2P1, K_v1.5, K_v2.1), GluK2 kainate receptors, mGluR8 glutamate receptors and CB1 cannabinoid receptors, which are reported to be SUMO‐modified. A discussion of the roles of these molecular targets for SUMOylation could play following an ischemic event, particularly with respect to their potential neuroprotective impact in brain ischemia, is proposed.