The effects of presumptive morphogens on prestalk and prespore cell gene expression in monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum

Abstract. The expression of three prestalk cell-specific genes ( ecm A, ecm B and pDd26) was examined during in vitro differentiation in cell monolayers, in an attempt to explain the spatial heterogeneity of the prestalk region of migrating Dictyostelium pseudoplasmodia. Under these conditions ecm A, ecm B and pDd26 mRNAs were expressed sequentially in response to the addition of differentiation inducing factor-1 (DIF)-1, a temporal sequence similar to that observed during normal development. ecm A and ecm B mRNAs reached a maximum level 2–4 h after DIF-1 supplementation and then declined, whereas pDd26 mRNA levels increased more slowly but remained high 24 h after DIF addition. The increases in expression in response to increasing concentrations of either DIF-1 or DIF-2 were identical for the three genes, suggesting that neither alteration in DIF concentration nor species was an important determinant of spatial heterogeneity. Ammonia had the same inhibitory effect on the expression of all three prestalk cell-specific genes and stimulated the expression of the prespore cell-specific gene, D19. These results indicate that ammonia is also not responsible for the spatial heterogeneity of the prestalk cell region. In contrast, cyclic AMP had a differential effect on the expression of the prestalk cell specific genes: ecm A expression was variably stimulated, pDd26 expression was inhibited and ecm B expression was sometimes stimulated and sometimes inhibited. These results are difficult to explain in terms of a gradient of cyclic AMP in the prestalk region. We postulate that temporal responses are more important than spatial responses to cyclic AMP in regulating stalk cell differentiation.     

New prestalk and prespore inducing signals in Dictyostelium

The differentiation-inducing signals (DIFs) currently known in Dictyostelium appear unable to account for the full diversity of cell types produced in development. To search for new signals, we analyzed the differentiation in monolayers of cells expressing prestalk (ecmAO, ecmA, ecmO, ecmB and cAR2) and prespore (psA) markers. Expression of each marker drops off as the cell density is reduced, suggesting that cell interaction is required. Expression of each marker is inhibited by cerulenin, an inhibitor of polyketide synthesis, and can be restored by conditioned medium. However, the known stalk-inducing polyketide, DIF-1, could not replace conditioned medium and induce the ecmA or cAR2 prestalk markers, suggesting that they require different polyketide inducers. Polyketide production by fungi is stimulated by cadmium ions, which also dramatically stimulates differentiation in Dictyostelium cell cultures and the accumulation of medium factors. Factors produced with cadmium present were extracted from conditioned medium and fractionated by HPLC. A new factor inducing prespore cell differentiation, called PSI-2, and two inducing stalk cell differentiation (DIFs 6 and 7) were resolved. All are distinct from currently identified factors. DIF-6, but not DIF-7 or PSI-2, appears to have an essential carbonyl group. Thus Dictyostelium may use extensive polyketide signaling in its development.     

Cross-induction of cell types in Dictyostelium: evidence that DIF-1 is made by prespore cells.

To investigate how cell type proportions are regulated during Dictyostelium development, we have attempted to find out which cell type produces DIF-1, a diffusible signal molecule inducing the differentiation of prestalk-O cells. DIF-1 is a chlorinated alkyl phenone that is synthesized from a C12 polyketide precursor by chlorination and methylation, with the final step catalysed by the dmtA methyltransferase. All our evidence points to the prespore cells as the major source of DIF-1. (1) dmtA mRNA and enzyme activity are greatly enriched in prespore compared with prestalk cells. The chlorinating activity is also somewhat prespore-enriched. (2) Expression of dmtA is induced by cyclic-AMP and this induction is inhibited by DIF-1. This regulatory behaviour is characteristic of prespore products. (3) Short-term labelling experiments, using the polyketide precursor, show that purified prespore cells produce DIF-1 at more than 20 times the rate of prestalk cells. (4) Although DIF-1 has little effect on its own synthesis in short-term labelling experiments, in long-term experiments, using 36Cl(-) as label, it is strongly inhibitory (IC(50) about 5 nM), presumably because it represses expression of dmtA; this is again consistent with DIF-1 production by prespore cells. Inhibition takes about 1 hour to become effective. We propose that prespore cells cross-induce the differentiation of prestalk-O cells by making DIF-1, and that this is one of the regulatory loops that sets the proportion of prespore-to-prestalk cells in the aggregate.     

A Dictyostelium morphogen that is essential for stalk cell formation is generated by a subpopulation of prestalk cells

The stalk cell differentiation inducing factor (DIF) has the properties required of a morphogen responsible for pattern regulation during the pseudoplasmodial stage of Dictyostelium development. It induces prestalk cell formation and inhibits prespore cell formation, but there is as yet no strong evidence for a morphogenetic gradient of DIF. We have measured DIF accumulation by monolayers of isolated prestalk and prespore cells in an attempt to provide evidence for such a gradient. DIF is accumulated in the largest quantities by a subpopulation of prestalk cells that specifically express the DIF-inducible genes pDd56 and pDd26. Since it has been shown recently that cells that express pDd56 are localized in the central core of the prestalk cell region of the pseudoplasmodia, our current results suggest a morphogenetic gradient generated by this region.     

Signals controlling cell differentiation and pattern formation in Dictyostelium

The major inducers of cell differentiation in Dictyostelium appear to be cyclic AMP and DIF-1. Recently we have chemically identified DIF-1, together with the closely related DIF-2 and -3. They represent a new chemical class of potent effector molecules, based on a phenyl alkanone with chloro, hydroxy, and methoxy substitution of the benzene ring. Previous work has shown that DIF-1 can induce prestalk-specific gene expression within 15 min, whereas it suppresses prespore differentiation. Hence, DIF-1 can control the choice of pathway of cell differentiation in Dictyostelium and is therefore likely to be involved in establishing the prestalk/prespore pattern in the aggregate. In support of this, we show that DIF treatment of slugs results in an enlarged prestalk zone. Cyclic AMP seems less likely to have such a pathway-specific role, but later in development it becomes inhibitory to stalk cell differentiation. This inhibition may be important in suppressing terminal stalk cell differentiation until culmination. Spore differentiation can be induced efficiently by high levels of Br-cyclic AMP, a permeant analogue of cyclic AMP. In this, it phenocopies certain spore-maturation mutants, and we propose that during normal development spore differentiation is triggered by an elevation in intracellular cyclic AMP levels. How this elevation in cyclic AMP levels is brought about is not known. The experiments with Br-cyclic AMP also provide the first direct evidence that elevated levels of intracellular cyclic AMP induce differentiation in Dictyostelium.     

Cell-fate choice in Dictyostelium: intrinsic biases modulate sensitivity to DIF signaling

Cell fate in Dictyostelium development depends on intrinsic differences between cells, dating from their growth period, and on cell interactions occurring during development. We have sought for a mechanism linking these two influences on cell fate. First, we confirmed earlier work showing that the vegetative differences are biases, not commitments, since cells that are stalky-biased when developed with one partner are sporey with another. Then we tested the idea that these biases operate by modulating the sensitivity of cells to the signals controlling cell fate during development. Cells grown without glucose are stalky-biased when developed with cells grown with glucose. We find, using monolayer culture conditions, that they are more sensitive to each of the stalk-inducing signals, DIFs 1-3. Mixing experiments show that this bias is a cell-intrinsic property. Cells initiating development early in the cell cycle are stalky compared to those initiating development later in the cycle. Likewise, they are more sensitive to DIF-1. Assays of standard markers for prestalk and prespore cell differentiation reveal similar differences in DIF-1 sensitivity between biased cells; DIF-1 dechlorinase (an early prestalk cell marker enzyme) behaves in a consistent manner. We propose that cell-fate biases are manifest as differences in sensitivity to DIF.     

DIF-1 induces its own breakdown in Dictyostelium.

DIF-1 is a novel chlorinated alkyl phenone which induces differentiation of prestalk cells in Dictyostelium discoideum. It is broken down and inactivated by a cytoplasmic enzyme, DIF-1 3(5)-dechlorinase (hereafter referred to as DIF-1 dechlorinase), which is found only in prestalk cells. We show that DIF-1 dechlorinase levels are induced at least 50-fold when cells are treated with DIF-1. This response is rapid--enzyme activity doubles within 15 min and is fully induced within an hour--and occurs early in development, before other prestalk markers can be induced by DIF-1. Maximum inducibility is seen towards the end of aggregation, when DIF-1 dechlorinase is barely detectable in uninduced cells. The dose-dependence reveals a threshold concentration of DIF-1 (15 nM) below which almost no response is seen. Cyclic AMP, which is the chemoattractant during aggregation and plays a key role in later development, suppresses the induction of DIF-1 dechlorinase by DIF-1. We conclude that induction of DIF-1 dechlorinase is one of the first steps on the developmental pathway which leads to prestalk cell differentiation, and suggest that the resulting negative feedback on DIF-1 levels is an important part of the mechanism by which cells decide whether to become prestalk or prespore cells.     

Cell differentiation and patterning in Dictyostelium.

In Dictyostelium development, prestalk cells first differentiate at scattered positions in the aggregate and then sort out, probably by chemotaxis to cAMP. They may regulate their proportions by selective depletion of the stalk cell inducer, DIF-1. Once sorted, prestalk cells form a DIF-1 sink, which can produce gradients of DIF-1 and its metabolites in the slug. Global movements of cells in the slug may be regulated by cAMP signals, as in aggregation. Terminal differentiation of stalk and spore cells requires activation of cAMP-dependent protein kinase, possibly brought about by ammonia depletion. Finally, a technique for insertional mutagenesis promises the ready isolation of developmental genes.     

DIF signalling and cell fate

The DIFs are a family of secreted chlorinated molecules that control cell fate during development of Dictyostelium cells in culture and probably during normal development too. They induce stalk cell differentiation and suppress spore cell formation. The biosynthetic and inactivation pathways of DIF-1 (the major bioactivity) have been worked out. DIF-1 is probably synthesised in prespore cells and inactivated in prestalk cells, by dechlorination. Thus, each cell type tends to alter DIF-1 level so as to favour differentiation of the other cell type. This relationship leads to a model for cell-type proportioning during normal development.     

Cyclic AMP is an inhibitor of stalk cell differentiation in Dictyostelium discoideum

Cyclic AMP and DIF-1 (1-(3,5-dichloro-2,6-dihydroxy-4-methoxyphenyl)-1-hexanone) together induce stalk cell differentiation in vitro in Dictyostelium discoideum strain V12M2. The induction can proceed in two stages: in the first, cyclic AMP brings cells to a DIF-responsive state; in the second, DIF-1 alone can induce stalk cell formation. We report here that during the DIF-1-dependent stage, cyclic AMP is a potent inhibitor of stalk cell differentiation. Addition of cyclic AMP at this stage to V12M2 cells appreciably delays, but does not prevent, stalk cell formation. In contrast, stalk cell differentiation in the more common strain NC4 is completely suppressed by the continued presence of cyclic AMP. This fact explains earlier failures to induce stalk cells in vitro in NC4. We now consistently obtain efficient stalk cell induction in NC4 by removing cyclic AMP in the DIF-1-dependent stage. Cyclic AMP also inhibits the production of a stalk-specific protein (ST310) in both NC4 and a V12M2 derivative. Adenosine, a known antagonist of cyclic AMP action, does not relieve this inhibition by cyclic AMP and does not itself promote stalk cell formation. Finally, stalk cell differentiation of NC4 cells at low density appears to require factors in addition to cyclic AMP and DIF-1, but their nature is not yet known. The inhibition of stalk cell differentiation by cyclic AMP may be important in establishing the prestalk/prespore pattern during normal development, and in preventing the maturation of prestalk into stalk cells until culmination.     

Control of cell type proportioning in Dictyostelium discoideum by differentiation-inducing factor as determined by in situ hybridization

We have determined the proportions of the prespore and prestalk regions in Dictyostelium discoideum slugs by in situ hybridization with a large number of prespore- and prestalk-specific genes. Microarrays were used to discover genes expressed in a cell type-specific manner. Fifty-four prespore-specific genes were verified by in situ hybridization, including 18 that had been previously shown to be cell type specific. The 36 new genes more than doubles the number of available prespore markers. At the slug stage, the prespore genes hybridized to cells uniformly in the posterior 80% of wild-type slugs but hybridized to the posterior 90% of slugs lacking the secreted alkylphenone differentiation-inducing factor 1 (DIF-1). There was a compensatory twofold decrease in prestalk cells in DIF-less slugs. Removal of prespore cells resulted in cell type conversion in both wild-type and DIF-less anterior fragments. Thus, DIF-1 appears to act in concert with other processes to establish cell type proportions.     

Cellular and subcellular distribution of a cAMP-regulated prestalk protein and prespore protein in Dictyostelium discoideum: a study on the ontogeny of prestalk and prespore cells

We have analyzed a developmentally and spatially regulated prestalk-specific gene and a prespore-specific gene from Dictyostelium. The prestalk gene, pst-cathepsin, encodes a protein highly homologous to the lysosomal cysteine proteinases cathepsin H and cathepsin B. The prespore gene encodes a protein with some homology to the anti-bacterial toxin crambin and has been designated beejin. Using the lambda gtll system, we have made polyclonal antibodies directed against a portion of the protein encoded by pst-cathepsin and other antibodies directed against the beejin protein. Both antibodies stain single bands on Western blots. By immunofluorescence and Western blots, pst-cathepsin is not present in vegetative cells or developing cells during the first approximately 10 h of development. It then appears with a punctate distribution in a subset of developing cells. Beejin is detected only after approximately 15 h of development, also in a subset of cells. Pst-cathepsin is distributed in the anterior approximately 1/10 of migrating slugs and on the peripheral posterior surfaces of slugs. Beejin is distributed in the posterior region of slugs. Expression of both pst-cathepsin and beejin can be induced in subsets of isolated cultured cells by a combination of conditioned medium and extracellular cAMP in agreement with the regulation of the mRNAs encoding these proteins. We have used the antibodies as markers for cell type to examine the ontogeny and the spatial distribution of prestalk and prespore cells throughout multicellular development. Our findings suggest that prestalk cell differentiation is independent of position within the aggregate and that the spatial localization of prestalk cells within the multicellular aggregate arises from sorting of the prestalk cells after their induction. We have also found a class of cell in developing aggregates that contains neither the prestalk nor the prespore markers.     

Developmental characterization of the wheat germ agglutinin binding proteins, wst31 and wst34, enriched in prestalk and stalk cells of Dictyostelium discoideum

Abstract. The onset of prestalk differentiation of Dictyostelium discoideum has been thought to be triggered by differentiation inducing factor (DIF), which is secreted by differentiating cells. We characterized the cell-type specific proteins, wst31 (prestalk and stalk specific) and wst34 (stalk specific), using the mutant HM44 which is defective in DIF-production, and examined the effects of DIF and cAMP on the formation of the proteins. In the mutant HM44, wst34 was formed only in the presence of exogenous DIF as reported for other prestalk/stalk markers (e.g. pDd63 and acid phosphatase-2), which indicates the DIF-requirement for this protein. By contrast, the accumulation of wst31 in this mutant occurred in the presence of cAMP regardless of the presence of exogenous DIF. Thus, we propose a new and distinct state (or stage) in prestalk differentiation, where the expression of wst31 occurs but not that of pDd63 or acid phosphatase-2.     

GSK3 is a multifunctional regulator of Dictyostelium development

Glycogen synthase kinase 3 (GSK3) is a central regulator of metazoan development and the Dictyostelium GSK3 homologue, GskA, also controls cellular differentiation. The originally derived gskA-null mutant exhibits a severe pattern formation defect. It forms very large numbers of pre-basal disc cells at the expense of the prespore population. This defect arises early during multicellular development, making it impossible to examine later functions of GskA. We report the analysis of a gskA-null mutant, generated in a different parental strain, that proceeds through development to form mature fruiting bodies. In this strain, Ax2/gskA-, early development is accelerated and slug migration greatly curtailed. In a monolayer assay of stalk cell formation, the Ax2/gskA- strain is hypersensitive to the stalk cell-inducing action of DIF-1 but largely refractory to the repressive effect exerted by extracellular cAMP. During normal development, apically situated prestalk cells express the ecmB gene just as they commit themselves to stalk cell differentiation. In the Ax2/gskA- mutant, ecmB is expressed throughout the prestalk region of the slug, suggesting that GskA forms part of the repressive signalling pathway that prevents premature commitment to stalk cell differentiation. GskA may also play an inductive developmental role, because microarray analysis identifies a large gene family, the 2C family, that require gskA for optimal expression. These observations show that GskA functions throughout Dictyostelium development, to regulate several key aspects of cellular patterning.     

Cell differentiation and fine structures in the development of the cellular slime molds

Changes in fine structures during the development of the cellular slime molds D. discoideum and D. mucoroides were studied, with emphasis on the regional differentiation between the prestalk and prespore cells of the slug. Cells in the prestalk region were in closer contact than those in the prespore region. Some differences were also noticed in the structure of plasma membrane between the two types of cells. An endoplasmic reticulum, vesicle, autophagic vacuole, and cytoplasmic fibril were found more abundantly in the prestalk cell than in the prespore cell. In the prespore cells there were observed a number of prespore specific vacuoles of ca. 0.6 μ diameter which consist of membraneous and fibrous structures. The vacuole was never found in the prestalk cells, and was a sole structure that existed only in one of the two types of cells. A possible function of such a vacuole was discussed in relation to spore differentiation. No differences in structure and distribution of mitochondria and crystal bodies were noticed between the prestalk and prespore cells, although these structures underwent considerable changes during the development. The nucleolus underwent considerable structual differentiation between the prestalk and prespore cells as well as during the course of development.     

Cell-type-specific responsiveness to cAMP in cell differentiation of Dictyostelium discoideum.

In Dictyostelium discoideum, both prespore and prestalk differentiation require extracellular cAMP. We investigated the difference in inducibility of the two cell types by cAMP. Previous studies indicate that cAMP added in the early stage of development inhibits prespore differentiation, and this was confirmed using three species of prespore specific mRNAs. By contrast, early treatment with cAMP did not inhibit, but induced the expression of prestalk-specific mRNA. These results indicate that differentiation pathways of the two cell types have different processes in the early stage of development.     

The role of DIF-1 signaling in Dictyostelium development

We have constructed a mutant blocked in the biosynthesis of DIF-1, a chlorinated signal molecule proposed to induce differentiation of both major prestalk cell types formed during Dictyostelium development. Surprisingly, the mutant still forms slugs retaining one prestalk cell type, the pstA cells, and can form mature stalk cells. However, the other major prestalk cell type, the pstO cells, is missing. Normal pstO cell differentiation and their patterning in the slug are restored by development on a uniform concentration of DIF-1. We conclude that pstO and pstA cells are in fact induced by separate signals and that DIF-1 is the pstO inducer. Positional information, in the form of DIF-1 gradients, is evidently not required for pstO cell induction.     

Dictyopyrones, novel alpha-pyronoids isolated from Dictyostelium spp., promote stalk cell differentiation in Dictyostelium discoideum

Dictyopyrones A and B (DpnA and B), whose function(s) is not known, were isolated from fruiting bodies of Dictyostelium discoideum. In the present study, to assess their function(s), we examined the effects of Dpns on in vitro cell differentiation in D. discoideum monolayer cultures with cAMP. Dpns at 1-20 microM promoted stalk cell formation to some extent in the wild-type strain V12M2. Although Dpns by themselves could hardly induce stalk cell formation in a differentiation-inducing factor (DIF)-deficient strain HM44, both of them dose-dependently promoted DIF-1-dependent stalk cell formation in the strain. In the sporogenous strain HM18, Dpns at 1-20 microM suppressed spore formation and promoted stalk cell formation in a dose-dependent manner. Analogs of Dpns were less effective in affecting cell differentiation in both HM44 and HM18 cells, indicating that the activity of Dpns should be chemical structure specific. It was also shown that DpnA at 2-20 microM dose-dependently suppressed spore formation induced with 8-bromo cAMP and promoted stalk cell formation in V12M2 cells. Interestingly, it was shown by the use of RT-PCR that DpnA at 10 microM slightly promoted both prespore- and prestalk-specific gene expressions in an early phase of V12M2 and HM18 in vitro differentiation. The present results suggest that Dpns may have functions (1) to promote both prespore and prestalk cell differentiation in an early stage of development and (2) to suppress spore formation and promote stalk cell formation in a later stage of development in D. discoideum.