Discrepancies between flow cytometric and cytogenetic studies in the detection of aneuploidy in human solid tumors

Parallel flow cytometric (FCM) cell DNA studies and cytogenetic studies were performed on clinical samples from twenty human solid tumors of various types and on cell lines established in tissue culture from three of these tumors. Six of twenty clinical samples (30%) showed concordance between flow cytometry and cytogenetics with respect to the presence or absence of aneuploidy. Among the fourteen cases with discrepancies between the two methods, 8 (40% of all cases) showed hypodiploidy by cytogenetics and had diploid DNA histograms. Three cases (15%) had prominent discrete peaks in the triploid to tetraploid region by cytogenetics but had only barely discernible corresponding peaks in the DNA histogram. In two cases (10%) cytogenetic studies revealed diffuse aneuploidy. Cytogenetic studies demonstrated near-tetraploidy in three samples, but only one of these was detected by FCM; all three cases exhibited other numerical chromosomal abnormalities. In one case aneuploidy was demonstrated by FCM and not by cytogenetics. Among the tumor cell lines established in culture, the DNA Index was often higher than the cytogenetic index. Overall, 13/20 or 65% of patients with solid tumors in this study had numerical chromosomal abnormalities that were not detected by flow cytometry. Eleven of these patients had distant metastases at the time of tumor sampling, and nine of these died of their disease within 1-11 months of the time of study.     

Genetics of early miscarriage

A miscarriage is the most frequent complication of a pregnancy. Poor chromosome preparations, culture failure, or maternal cell contamination may hamper conventional karyotyping. Techniques such as chromosomal comparative genomic hybridization (chromosomal‐CGH), array-comparative genomic hybridization (array-CGH), fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA) and quantitative fluorescent polymerase chain reaction (QF-PCR) enable us to trace submicroscopic abnormalities. We found the prevalence of chromosome abnormalities in women facing a single sporadic miscarriage to be 45% (95% CI: 38–52; 13 studies, 7012 samples). The prevalence of chromosome abnormalities in women experiencing a subsequent miscarriage after preceding recurrent miscarriage proved to be comparable: 39% (95% CI: 29–50; 6 studies 1359 samples). More chromosome abnormalities are detected by conventional karyotyping compared to FISH or MLPA only (chromosome region specific techniques), and the same amount of abnormalities compared to QF-PCR (chromosome region specific techniques) and chromosomal‐CGH and array-CGH (whole genome techniques) only. Molecular techniques could play a role as an additional technique when culture failure or maternal contamination occurs: recent studies show that by using array-CGH, an additional 5% of submicroscopic chromosome variants can be detected. Because of the small sample size as well as the unknown clinical relevance of these molecular aberrations, more and larger studies should be performed of submicroscopic chromosome abnormalities among sporadic miscarriage samples. For recurrent miscarriage samples molecular technique studies are relatively new. It has often been suggested that miscarriages are due to chromosomal abnormalities in more than 50%, but the present review has determined that chromosomal and submicroscopic genetic abnormalities on average are prevalent in maximally half of the miscarriage samples. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Molecular Genetics of Human Reproductive Failure.     

The Origin of Abnormalities in Recurrent Aneuploidy/Polyploidy

Recurrent miscarriage due to sporadic chromosomal abnormalities may simply be a consequence of the dramatic increase of trisomic conceptions with increased maternal age. However, it is also possible that some couples are at increased risk of abnormalities as a result of gonadal mosaicism, factors affecting chromosome structure and segregation, increased sperm aneuploidy in the male partner, or accelerated "aging" of the ovaries. We report cytogenetic and molecular findings from 122 spontaneous abortions (SAs) from 54 couples who were ascertained as having two or more documented aneuploid or polyploid SAs. The distribution of abnormalities in this group was similar to those from 307 SAs that involved chromosome abnormalities and were diagnosed at the same center but did not involve documented recurrent aneuploidy/polyploidy. Although recurrence of the same abnormality was observed in eight families, this number was equal to that expected by chance, indicating that gonadal mosaicism is rarely the explanation for recurrence. The origin of the abnormality was determined in 37 SAs from 23 of the couples in the study. A maternal meiotic origin was involved in 30 trisomies and in 1 triploid SA; 3 additional maternal trisomies were of possible somatic origin. A paternal origin was found in the remaining two trisomies and in one triploid SA. In addition, one double trisomy was the consequence of both a maternal and a paternal meiotic error. These results confirm that the etiology of trisomy is predominantly a result of meiotic errors related to increased maternal age, regardless of whether the couple has experienced one or multiple aneuploid SAs. Furthermore, this is true even when a second SA involves the same abnormality. Nonetheless, these data do not exclude some population variability in risk for aneuploidy.     

Comparative genomic hybridization in clinical cytogenetics.

We report the results of applying comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) in a cytogenetic service laboratory for (1) determination of the origin of extra and missing chromosomal material in intricate cases of unbalanced aberrations and (2) detection of common prenatal numerical chromosome aberrations. A total of 11 fetal samples were analyzed. Seven cases of complex unbalanced aberrations that could not be identified reliably by conventional cytogenetics were successfully resolved by CGH analysis. CGH results were validated by using FISH with chromosome-specific probes. Four cases representing common prenatal numerical aberrations (trisomy 21, 18, and 13 and monosomy X) were also successfully diagnosed by CGH. We conclude that CGH is a powerful adjunct to traditional cytogenetic techniques that makes it possible to solve clinical cases of intricate unbalanced aberrations in a single hybridization. CGH may also be a useful adjunct to screen for euchromatic involvement in marker chromosomes. Further technical development may render CGH applicable for routine aberration screening.     

Detection of aneuploidy in spontaneous abortions using the comparative hybridization method

Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) technique was used to examine a set of ten spontaneous abortions whose cell cultures were characterized by the lack of proliferation in vitro, and thereby, were not available for the analysis by means of routine cytogenetic methods. Five abortions (50%) had aneuploidy of autosomes, including trisomy 10, 14, 18, and 21, and monosomy 22. The latter variant of unbalanced chromosomal abnormalities is rarely detected in spontaneous abortions by use of conventional cytogenetic methods. The results were validated by using fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis with centromere-specific DNA probes. Embryos with trisomy 10 and monosomy 22 displayed mosaicism with the frequencies of abnormal cell clones constituting 68 and 33% respectively. The advantages and limitations of the applying of CGH technique for detection of genomic abnormalities in both nonmosaic and mosaic forms are discussed.     

Detection of Aneuploidy in Spontaneous Abortions Using Comparative Genomic Hybridization

Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) technique was used to examine a set of ten spontaneous abortions whose cell cultures were characterized by the lack of proliferation in vitro, and thereby, were not available for the analysis by means of routine cytogenetic methods. Five abortions (50%) had aneuploidy of autosomes, including trisomy 10, 14, 18, and 21, and monosomy 22. The latter variant of unbalanced chromosomal abnormalities is rarely detected in spontaneous abortions by use of conventional cytogenetic methods. The results were validated by using fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis with centromere-specific DNA probes. Embryos with trisomy 10 and monosomy 22 displayed mosaicism with the frequencies of abnormal cell clones constituting 68 and 33% respectively. The advantages and limitations of the applying of CGH technique for detection of genomic abnormalities in both nonmosaic and mosaic forms are discussed.     

Structural unbalanced chromosome rearrangements resolved by comparative genomic hybridization.

The identification of unbalanced structural chromosome rearrangements using conventional cytogenetic techniques depends on recognition of the unknown material from its banding pattern. Even with optimally banded chromosomes, when large chromosome segments are involved, cytogeneticists may not always be able to determine the origin of extrachromosomal material and supernumerary chromosomes. We report here on the application of comparative genomic hybridization (CGH), a new molecular-cytogenetic assay capable of detecting chromosomal gains and losses, to six clinical samples suspected of harboring unbalanced structural chromosome abnormalities. CGH provided essential information on the nature of the unbalanced aberration investigated in five of the six samples. This approach has proved its ability to resolve complex karyotypes and to provide information when metaphase chromosomes are not available. In cases where metaphase chromosome spreads were available, confirmation of CGH results was easily obtained by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) using specific probes. Thus the combined use of CGH and FISH provided an efficient method for resolving the origin of aberrant chromosomal material unidentified by conventional cytogenetic analysis.     

Medical applications of array CGH and the transformation of clinical cytogenetics

Microarray-based comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH) merges molecular diagnostics with traditional chromosome analysis and is transforming the field of cytogenetics. Prospective studies of individuals with developmental delay and dysmorphic features have demonstrated that array CGH has the ability to detect any genomic imbalance including deletions, duplications, aneuploidies and amplifications. Detection rates for chromosome abnormalities with array CGH range from 5-17% in individuals with normal results from prior routine cytogenetic testing. In addition, copy number variants (CNVs) were identified in all studies. These CNVs may include large-scale variation and can confound the diagnostic interpretations. Although cytogeneticists will require additional training and laboratories must become appropriately equipped, array CGH holds the promise of being the initial diagnostic tool in the identification of visible and submicroscopic chromosome abnormalities in mental retardation and other developmental disabilities.     

Risk of Chromosomal Abnormalities in Early Spontaneous Abortion after Assisted Reproductive Technology: A Meta-Analysis

Background

Studies on the risk of chromosomal abnormalities in early spontaneous abortion after assisted reproductive technology (ART) are relatively controversial and insufficient. Thus, to obtain a more precise evaluation of the risk of embryonic chromosomal abnormalities in first-trimester miscarriage after ART, we performed a meta-analysis of all available case–control studies relating to the cytogenetic analysis of chromosomal abnormalities in first-trimester miscarriage after ART.

Methods

Literature search in the electronic databases MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) based on the established strategy. Meta-regression, subgroup analysis, and Galbraith plots were conducted to explore the sources of heterogeneity.

Results

A total of 15 studies with 1,896 cases and 1,186 controls relevant to the risk of chromosomal abnormalities in first- trimester miscarriage after ART, and 8 studies with 601 cases and 602 controls evaluating frequency of chromosome anomaly for maternal age≥35 versus <35 were eligible for the meta-analysis. No statistical difference was found in risk of chromosomally abnormal miscarriage compared to natural conception and the different types of ART utilized, whereas the risk of fetal aneuploidy significantly increased with maternal age≥35 (OR 2.88, 95% CI: 1.74–4.77).

Conclusions

ART treatment does not present an increased risk for chromosomal abnormalities occurring in a first trimester miscarriage, but incidence of fetal aneuploidy could increase significantly with advancing maternal age.     

Maternal cell contamination of cultures of spontaneous abortion fibroblasts: importance for cytogenetic analysis of embryonic lethality

The results of standard cytogenetic analysis of the long-term cultures of embryonic fibroblasts of 478 first-trimester spontaneous abortions were retrospectively reviewed. In 16% of embryos with cytogenetically confirmed karyotype 46,XX, the Y chromosome was found by molecular genetic methods. Prior to obtaining the chromosome preparations, the cell cultures of Y chromosome-carrying embryos were maintained for a longer period than the cultures of embryos without the Y chromosome. Thus, a late entry of a culture into the logarithmic growth phase serves as marker of maternal cell contamination. We developed a mathematic model for assessment of karyotype incidence and the "sex ratio" of spontaneous abortions, taking into account risk of maternal cell contamination in extraembryonic tissue cultures. Thus estimated, the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities in the studied sample increased from 54.6 to 60.3% and the expected sex ratio increased from 0.66 to 1.02 in abortions with normal karyotype. Using molecular analysis of inheritance of polymorphic DNA markers of six autosomes (2, 11, 16, 19, 20, and 21), the proposed model was tested on 60 embryos with karyotype 46,XX and their parents. Numerical chromosome abnormalities were revealed in uncultured tissues of seven abortions (11.7%), including four without the Y chromosome, which is in a good agreement with the expected incidence of karyotype abnormalities (8.3%) predicted by our model. In view of this, estimating risk of maternal cell contamination in embryonic cell cultures seems necessary for correctly assessing the effect of natural selection in humans, for understanding the mechanisms that determine the sex ratio, and for evaluating the precision of prenatal cytogenetic diagnosis of chromosomal abnormalities.     

Rapid-prenatal diagnosis through fluorescence in situ hybridization for preventing aneuploidy related birth defects

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE:

Women with high-risk pregnancies are offered prenatal diagnosis through amniocentesis for cytogenetic analysis of fetal cells. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the rapid fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) technique for detecting numerical aberrations of chromosomes 13, 21, 18, X and Y in high-risk pregnancies in an Indian scenario.

MATERIALS AND METHODS:

A total of 163 samples were received for a FISH and/or a full karyotype for prenatal diagnosis from high-risk pregnancies. In 116 samples both conventional culture techniques for getting karyotype through G-banding techniques were applied in conjunction to FISH test using the AneuVysion kit (Abbott Molecular, Inc.), following standard recommended protocol to compare the both the techniques in our setup.

RESULTS:

Out of 116 patients, we got 96 normal for the five major chromosome abnormality and seven patients were found to be abnormal (04 trisomy 21, 02 monosomy X, and 01 trisomy 13) and all the FISH results correlated with conventional cytogenetics. To summarize the results of total 163 patients for the major chromosomal abnormalities analyzed by both/or cytogenetics and FISH there were 140 (86%) normal, 9 (6%) cases were abnormal and another 4 (2.5%) cases were suspicious mosaic and 10 (6%) cases of culture failure. The diagnostic detection rate with FISH in 116 patients was 97.5%. There were no false-positive and false-negative autosomal or sex chromosomal results, within our established criteria for reporting FISH signals.

CONCLUSION:

Rapid FISH is a reliable and prompt method for detecting numerical chromosomal aberrations and has now been implemented as a routine diagnostic procedure for detection of fetal aneuploidy in India.     

Cytogenetic analysis of human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells passaged in vitro

This study concerns the cytogenetic stability of in vitro human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) in primary culture and after passaging. Bone marrow samples were collected from seven brain malfunction patients involved in autologous MSC transplantation trials. Chromosome preparations from primary MSC cultures and after 3 passages were analyzed by conventional staining and G-banding techniques. All MSCs showed normal diploid karyotypes, 46 XY or 46 XX, without aneuploidy or polyploidy; chromosome structural abnormalities were not detected. The results indicate that the in vitro cultured MSCs retained normal cytogenetics before being transplanted back into the patients.     

Cytogenetic abnormalities in Tunisian women with premature ovarian failure

To identify the distribution of chromosome abnormalities among Tunisian women with premature ovarian failure (POF) referred to the department of Cytogenetic at the Pasteur Institute of Tunis (Tunisia), standard cytogenetic analysis was carried out in a total of 100 women younger than 40 affected with premature ovarian failure. We identified 18 chromosomal abnormalities, including seven X-numerical anomalies in mosaic and non-mosaic state (45,X; 47,XXX), four sex reversal, three X-structural abnormalities (terminal deletion and isochromosomes), one autosomal translocation and one supernumerary marker. The overall prevalence of chromosomal abnormalities was 18% in our cohort. X chromosome aneuploidy was the most frequent aberration. This finding confirms the essential role of X chromosome in ovarian function and underlies the importance of cytogenetic investigations in the routine management of POF.     

Identification of de novo chromosomal markers and derivatives by spectral karyotyping

Despite major advances in molecular cytogenetics during the past decade and the important diagnostic role that fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) plays in the characterization of chromosomal abnormalities, the usefulness of this technique remains limited by the number of spectrally distinguishable fluorochromes or fluorochrome combinations. Overcoming this major limitation would allow one to use FISH to screen the whole human genome for chromosomal aberrations which, until recently, was possible only through conventional karyotyping. A recently described molecular cytogenetics technology, 24-color FISH using spectral karyotyping (SKY), permits the simultaneous visualization of all human chromosomes in 24 different colors. Most chromosomal aberrations detected during cytogenetic evaluation can be resolved using routine cytogenetic techniques alone or in combination with single- or dual-color FISH. However, some cases remain unresolved, in particular de novo supernumerary marker chromosomes and de novo unbalanced structural rearrangements. These findings cause particular diagnostic and counseling concerns when detected during prenatal diagnosis. The purpose of this report is to demonstrate the application of SKY in the characterization of these de novo structural chromosomal abnormalities. Eight cases are described in this report. SKY has considerable diagnostic applications in prenatal diagnosis because of its reliability and speed. The identification of the chromosomal origin of markers and unbalanced translocations provides the patient, physician, and genetic counselor with better predictive information on the phenotype of the carrier. Received: 2 June 1998 / Accepted: 16 June 1998     

Molekularzytogenetische Methoden und Array-Diagnostik in der Pr?natalmedizin

In addition to the widely used cytogenetic standard approaches, molecular methods are being increasingly used in prenatal diagnostics. While molecular cytogenetics, e.g., fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), has been used for many years in invasive prenatal diagnostics, array-based diagnostics are only now being implemented in this field. FISH is prenatally applied for determination of size of a mosaic cell clone, for exclusion of a microdeletion, or for further clarification of structural chromosomal aberrations. Array CGH (comparative genomic hybridization) is used more conservatively in prenatal diagnostics, mostly for further clarification in sonographically abnormal fetuses and to diagnose breakpoints in cases with proven chromosomal changes. In the future, array CGH will gain further importance, but already provides a valuable supplement to the diagnostic approaches of the cytogenetic and the molecular-based methods.     

Comparative genomic hybridization-array analysis enhances the detection of aneuploidies and submicroscopic imbalances in spontaneous miscarriages

Miscarriage is a condition that affects 10%-15% of all clinically recognized pregnancies, most of which occur in the first trimester. Approximately 50% of first-trimester miscarriages result from fetal chromosome abnormalities. Currently, G-banded chromosome analysis is used to determine if large-scale genetic imbalances are the cause of these pregnancy losses. This technique relies on the culture of cells derived from the fetus, a technique that has many limitations, including a high rate of culture failure, maternal overgrowth of fetal cells, and poor chromosome morphology. Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH)-array analysis is a powerful new molecular cytogenetic technique that allows genomewide analysis of DNA copy number. By hybridizing patient DNA and normal reference DNA to arrays of genomic clones, unbalanced gains or losses of genetic material across the genome can be detected. In this study, 41 product-of-conception (POC) samples, which were previously analyzed by G-banding, were tested using CGH arrays to determine not only if the array could identify all reported abnormalities, but also whether any previously undetected genomic imbalances would be discovered. The array methodology detected all abnormalities as reported by G-banding analysis and revealed new abnormalities in 4/41 (9.8%) cases. Of those, one trisomy 21 POC was also mosaic for trisomy 20, one had a duplication of the 10q telomere region, one had an interstitial deletion of chromosome 9p, and the fourth had an interstitial duplication of the Prader-Willi/Angelman syndrome region on chromosome 15q, which, if maternally inherited, has been implicated in autism. This retrospective study demonstrates that the DNA-based CGH-array technology overcomes many of the limitations of routine cytogenetic analysis of POC samples while enhancing the detection of fetal chromosome aberrations.     

Cytogenetic analysis from DNA by comparative genomic hybridization

Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) is a modified in situ hybridization technique which allows detection and mapping of DNA sequence copy differences between two genomes in a single experiment. In CGH analysis, two differentially labelled genomic DNA (study and reference) are co-hybridized to normal metaphase spreads. Chromosomal locations of copy number changes in the DNA segments of the study genome are revealed by a variable fluorescence intensity ratio along each target chromosome. Since its development, CGH has been applied mostly as a research tool in the field of cancer cytogenetics to identify genetic changes in many previously unknown regions. CGH may also have a role in clinical cytogenetics for detection and identification of unbalanced chromosomal abnormalities.     

Rearrangements of chromosome 18 illustrate the utility of array-based comparative genomic hybridization

Comprehensive and reliable testing is an important component of counseling and management in clinical genetics. Identification of imbalances of chromosomal segments has uncovered new genes and has established phenotype/genotype correlations for many syndromes with previously unidentified causes. Conventional cytogenetics has proven to be useful for the detection of large aberrations, but its resolution limits the identification of submicroscopic alterations. Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) on a microarray-based platform has the potential to detect and characterize both microscopic and submicroscopic chromosomal abnormalities. Nine cases of aberrations involving chromosome 18 are used to illustrate the use and clinical potential of array CGH.     

Molecular cytogenetic analysis consistently identifies translocations involving chromosomes 1, 2 and 15 in five embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma cell lines and a PAX-FOXO1A fusion gene negative alveolar rhabdomyosarcoma cell line

Rhabdomyosarcoma in children is a "small round blue cell tumour" that displays skeletal muscle differentiation. Two main histological variants are recognised, alveolar (ARMS) and embryonal (ERMS) rhabdomyosarcoma. Whereas consistent chromosome translocations characteristic of ARMS have been reported, no such cytogenetic abnormality has yet been described in ERMS. We have used multiple colour chromosome painting to obtain composite karyotypes for five ERMS cell lines and one PAX-FOXO1A fusion gene negative ARMS. The cell lines were assessed by spectral karyotyping (SKY), tailored multi-fluorophore fluorescence in situ hybridisation (M-FISH) using series of seven colour paint sets generated to examine specific abnormalities, and comparative genomic hybridisation (CGH). This approach enabled us to obtain karyotypes of the cell lines in greater detail than previously possible. Several recurring cytogenetic abnormalities were demonstrated, including translocations involving chromosomes 1 and 15 and chromosomes 2 and 15, in 4/6 and 2/6 cell lines respectively. All six cell lines demonstrated abnormalities of chromosome 15. Translocations between chromosomes 1 and 15 have previously been recorded in two primary cases of ERMS by conventional cytogenetics. Analysis of the translocation breakpoints may suggest mechanisms of ERMS tumourigenesis and may enable the development of novel approaches to the clinical management of this tumour.