Epigenetic Regulation of Programmed Genomic Rearrangements in Paramecium aurelia1

ABSTRACT In ciliates, development of the polyploid somatic macronucleus after sexual events involves extensive and reproducible rearrangements of the germ-line genome, including chromosome fragmentation and precise excision of numerous internal sequence elements. In Paramecium aurelia, alternative macronuclear versions of the same germ-line genome can be maternally inherited across sexual generations, showing that rearrangement patterns are not strictly determined by the germ-line sequence. Homology-dependent maternal effects can be evidenced by transformation of the vegetative macronucleus with cloned macronuclear sequences: new fragmentation patterns or internal deletions are specifically induced during differentiation of a new macronucleus, in sexual progeny of transformed clones. Furthermore, transformation of the maternal macronucleus with germ-line sequences containing internal eliminated sequences (short single-copy elements) can result in a specific inhibition of the excision of the same elements in the zygotic macronucleus. These experiments show that the processing of many germ-line sequences in the developing macronucleus is sensitive to the structure and copy number of homologous sequences in the maternal macronucleus. The generality and sequence specificity of this trans-nuclear, epigenetic regulation of rearrangements suggest that it is mediated by pairing interactions between germ-line sequences and sequences imported from the maternal macronucleus.     

RNA-mediated programming of developmental genome rearrangements in Paramecium tetraurelia

The germ line genome of ciliates is extensively rearranged during development of the somatic macronucleus. Numerous sequences are eliminated, while others are amplified to a high ploidy level. In the Paramecium aurelia group of species, transformation of the maternal macronucleus with transgenes at high copy numbers can induce the deletion of homologous genes in sexual progeny, when a new macronucleus develops from the wild-type germ line. We show that this trans-nuclear effect correlates with homology-dependent silencing of maternal genes before autogamy and with the accumulation of approximately 22- to 23-nucleotide (nt) RNA molecules. The same effects are induced by feeding cells before meiosis with bacteria containing double-stranded RNA, suggesting that small interfering RNA-like molecules can target deletions. Furthermore, experimentally induced macronuclear deletions are spontaneously reproduced in subsequent sexual generations, and reintroduction of the missing gene into the variant macronucleus restores developmental amplification in sexual progeny. We discuss the possible roles of the approximately 22- to 23-nt RNAs in the targeting of deletions and the implications for the RNA-mediated genome-scanning process that is thought to determine developmentally regulated rearrangements in ciliates.     

Developmentally regulated chromosome fragmentation linked to imprecise elimination of repeated sequences in paramecia

The chromosomes of ciliates are fragmented at reproducible sites during the development of the polyploid somatic macronucleus, but the mechanisms involved appear to be quite diverse in different species. In Paramecium aurelia, the process is imprecise and results in de novo telomere addition at locally heterogeneous positions. To search for possible determinants of chromosome fragmentation, we have studied an ~21-kb fragmentation region from the germ line genome of P. primaurelia. The mapping and sequencing of alternative macronuclear versions of the region show that two distinct multicopy elements, a minisatellite and a degenerate transposon copy, are eliminated by an imprecise mechanism leading either to chromosome fragmentation and the formation of new telomeres or to the rejoining of flanking sequences. Heterogeneous internal deletions occur between short direct repeats containing TA dinucleotides. The complex rearrangement patterns produced vary slightly among genetically identical cell lines, show non-Mendelian inheritance during sexual reproduction, and can be experimentally modified by transformation of the maternal macronucleus with homologous sequences. These results suggest that chromosome fragmentation in Paramecium is the consequence of imprecise DNA elimination events that are distinct from the precise excision of single-copy internal eliminated sequences and that target multicopy germ line sequences by homology-dependent epigenetic mechanisms.     

Homology-Dependent Maternal Inhibition of Developmental Excision of Internal Eliminated Sequences in Paramecium tetraurelia

Thousands of single-copy internal eliminated sequences (IESs) are excised from the germ line genome of ciliates during development of the polygenomic somatic macronucleus, following sexual events. Paramecium IESs are short, noncoding elements that frequently interrupt coding sequences. No absolutely conserved sequence element, other than flanking 5′-TA-3′ direct repeats, has been identified among sequenced IESs; the mechanisms of their specific recognition and precise elimination are unknown. Previous work has revealed the existence of an epigenetic control of excision. It was shown that the presence of one IES in the vegetative macronucleus results in a specific inhibition of the excision of the same element during the development of a new macronucleus, in the following sexual generation. We have assessed the generality and sequence specificity of this transnuclear maternal control by studying the effects of macronuclear transformation with 13 different IESs. We show that at least five of them can be maintained in the new macronuclear genome; sequence specificity is complete both between genes and between different IESs in the same gene. In all cases, the degree of excision inhibition correlates with the copy number of the maternal IES, but each IES shows a characteristic inhibition efficiency. Short internal IES-like segments were found to be excised from two of the IESs when excision between normal boundaries was inhibited. Available data suggest that the sequence specificity of these maternal effects is mediated by pairing interactions between homologous nucleic acids.     

Reproducible and variable genomic rearrangements occur in the developing somatic nucleus of the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila.

We analyzed the extent, reproducibility, and developmental control of genomic rearrangements in the somatic macronucleus of the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. To exclude differences caused by genetic polymorphisms, we constructed whole-genome homozygotes, and we compared the homozygous progeny derived from single macronuclear differentiation events. This strategy enabled us to identify a novel form of variable rearrangement and to confirm previous findings that rearranged sequences occur at a high frequency in the Tetrahymena genome. Rearrangements studied here were deletions of both unique and interchromosomally dispersed repetitive DNA sequences involving DNA rejoining of internal, nontelomeric regions of macronuclear DNAs. We showed that although rearrangements of some sequence classes are reproducible among independently developed macronuclei, other specific sequence classes are variably rearranged in macronuclear development. The variable somatic genomes so produced may be the source of phenotypically variant cell lines.     

A Mendelian Mutation Affecting Mating-Type Determination Also Affects Developmental Genomic Rearrangements in Paramecium Tetraurelia

In Paramecium tetraurelia, mating type is determined during the differentiation of the somatic macronucleus from a zygotic nucleus genetically competent for both types, O and E. Determination of the developing macronucleus is controlled by the parental macronucleus through an unknown mechanism resulting in the maternal inheritance of mating types. The pleiotropic mutation mtF(E) affects macronuclear differentiation. Determination for E is constitutive in mutant homozygotes; a number of unrelated mutant characters are also acquired during development. We have examined the possibility that the mutation causes a defect in the developmental rearrangements of the germ-line genome. We show that the excision of an IES (internal eliminated sequence) interrupting the coding sequence of a surface antigen gene is impaired in the mutant, resulting in an alternative macronuclear version of the gene. Once established, the excision defect is indefinitely transmitted across sexual generations in the cytoplasmic lineage, even in a wild-type genetic context. Thus, the processes of mating-type determination and excision of this IES, in addition to their common sensitivity to the mtF(E) mutation, show a similar maternal inheritance of developmental alternatives in wild-type cells, suggesting a molecular model for mating-type determination.     

Macronuclear transformation with specific DNA fragments controls the content of the new macronuclear genome in Paramecium tetraurelia.

A previously isolated mutant cell line called d48 contains a complete copy of the A surface antigen gene in the micronuclear genome, but the gene is not incorporated into the macronucleus. Previous experiments have shown that a cytoplasmic factor made in the wild-type macronucleus can rescue the mutant. Recently, S. Koizumi and S. Kobayashi (Mol. Cell. Biol. 9:4398-4401, 1989) observed that injection of a plasmid containing the A gene into the d48 macronucleus rescued the cell line after autogamy. It is shown here that an 8.8-kb EcoRI fragment containing only a portion of the A gene coding region is sufficient for the rescue of d48. The inability of other A gene fragments to rescue the mutant shows that this effect is dependent upon specific Paramecium DNA sequences. Rescue results in restoration of the wild-type DNA restriction pattern in the macronucleus. These results are consistent with a model in which the macronuclear A locus normally makes an additional gene product that is required for correct processing of the micronuclear copy of the A gene.     

Micronuclear and macronuclear forms of beta-tubulin genes in the ciliate Chilodonella uncinata reveal insights into genome processing and protein evolution

Chilodonella uncinata, like all ciliates, contains two distinct nuclei in every cell: a germline micronucleus and a somatic macronucleus. During development of the macronucleus from a zygotic nucleus, the genome is processed in several ways, including elimination of internal sequences. In this study, we analyze micronuclear and macronuclear copies of beta-tubulin in C. uncinata and find at least four divergent paralogs of beta-tubulin in the macronucleus. We characterize the micronuclear version of one paralog and compare its internally eliminated sequences (IESs) with previously described IESs in this species. These comparisons reveal the presence of a conserved sequence motif within IESs. In addition, we compare the sequences of beta-tubulin from C. uncinata with other ciliates and to other alveolates in order to test the hypothesis that the mode of molecular evolution in ciliates obscures phylogenetic signal in protein-coding genes. We find that heterogeneous rates of substitution in beta-tubulin across ciliates result in unstable genealogies that are inconsistent with phylogenies based on small subunit rDNA genes and on ultrastructure. We discuss the implications of our findings for genome processing and protein evolution in ciliates.     

The DNA of ciliated protozoa.

Ciliates contain two types of nuclei: a micronucleus and a macronucleus. The micronucleus serves as the germ line nucleus but does not express its genes. The macronucleus provides the nuclear RNA for vegetative growth. Mating cells exchange haploid micronuclei, and a new macronucleus develops from a new diploid micronucleus. The old macronucleus is destroyed. This conversion consists of amplification, elimination, fragmentation, and splicing of DNA sequences on a massive scale. Fragmentation produces subchromosomal molecules in Tetrahymena and Paramecium cells and much smaller, gene-sized molecules in hypotrichous ciliates to which telomere sequences are added. These molecules are then amplified, some to higher copy numbers than others. rDNA is differentially amplified to thousands of copies per macronucleus. Eliminated sequences include transposonlike elements and sequences called internal eliminated sequences that interrupt gene coding regions in the micronuclear genome. Some, perhaps all, of these are excised as circular molecules and destroyed. In at least some hypotrichs, segments of some micronuclear genes are scrambled in a nonfunctional order and are recorded during macronuclear development. Vegetatively growing ciliates appear to possess a mechanism for adjusting copy numbers of individual genes, which corrects gene imbalances resulting from random distribution of DNA molecules during amitosis of the macronucleus. Other distinctive features of ciliate DNA include an altered use of the conventional stop codons.     

The DNA of ciliated protozoa.

Ciliates contain two types of nuclei: a micronucleus and a macronucleus. The micronucleus serves as the germ line nucleus but does not express its genes. The macronucleus provides the nuclear RNA for vegetative growth. Mating cells exchange haploid micronuclei, and a new macronucleus develops from a new diploid micronucleus. The old macronucleus is destroyed. This conversion consists of amplification, elimination, fragmentation, and splicing of DNA sequences on a massive scale. Fragmentation produces subchromosomal molecules in Tetrahymena and Paramecium cells and much smaller, gene-sized molecules in hypotrichous ciliates to which telomere sequences are added. These molecules are then amplified, some to higher copy numbers than others. rDNA is differentially amplified to thousands of copies per macronucleus. Eliminated sequences include transposonlike elements and sequences called internal eliminated sequences that interrupt gene coding regions in the micronuclear genome. Some, perhaps all, of these are excised as circular molecules and destroyed. In at least some hypotrichs, segments of some micronuclear genes are scrambled in a nonfunctional order and are recorded during macronuclear development. Vegetatively growing ciliates appear to possess a mechanism for adjusting copy numbers of individual genes, which corrects gene imbalances resulting from random distribution of DNA molecules during amitosis of the macronucleus. Other distinctive features of ciliate DNA include an altered use of the conventional stop codons.     

The processing of macronuclear-destined DNA sequences microinjected into the macronuclear anlagen of the hypotrichous ciliate Stylonchia lemnae.

We describe the construction of a vector carrying the micronuclear versions of two macronuclear DNA molecules, one of which was modified by the insertion of a polylinker sequence. This vector was injected into the polytene chromosomes of the developing macronucleus of Stylonychia and its processing during further macronuclear development and its fate in the mature macronucleus were analyzed. In up to 30% of injected cells the modified macronuclear DNA sequence could be detected. While the internal eliminated sequences (IES) present in the macronuclear precursor DNA sequence are still retained in the mature macronucleus, the modified macronuclear DNA sequence is correctly cut out from the vector, telomeres are added de novo and it is stably retained in the macronucleus during vegetative growth of the cells. This vector system represents an experimental system that allows the identification of DNA sequences involved in the processing of macronuclear DNA sequences during macronuclear development.     

DNA elimination in Tetrahymena: a developmental process involving extensive breakage and rejoining of DNA at defined sites

Elimination of specific DNA sequences occurs during macronuclear development in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. Recombinant DNA clones containing a segment of micronuclear (germinal) DNA involved in elimination and the corresponding segment of macronuclear (somatic) DNA produced after elimination were isolated. Detailed comparisons of the cloned DNAs, as well as the genomic DNAs, by hybridization indicated that DNA elimination is accompanied by specific DNA rearrangements. In this 9.5 kb region three defined DNA segments are deleted and the remaining sequences are linked together as one contiguous piece in the macronucleus. Specific DNA rearrangement of this kind occurs widely in the genome. Analysis of 20 randomly selected DNA clones suggests that there are more than 5000 such rearrangement sites in the genome. Thus specific breakage and rejoining of DNA occurs extensively during development, and might play an essential role in nuclear differentiation.     

Analysis of the micronuclear B type surface protein gene in Paramecium tetraurelia.

The micronuclear DNA of Paramecium contains sequences that are precisely excised during the formation of the macronuclear (somatic) genome. In this paper we show that four eliminated sequences ranging in size from 28 to 416 base pairs, are present in or near the micronuclear copy of the B surface protein gene. Each excised sequence is bounded by the dinucleotide 5'-TdA-3'. Comparison of the micronuclear B gene with the previously determined micronuclear sequence of the A surface protein gene shows that although the positions of at least three of the eliminated sequences are conserved in both genes, the sequences are highly divergent. Transformation of vegetative macronuclei with fragments of the micronuclear B gene results in replication and maintenance of the DNA, but the micronuclear specific sequences are not removed. Previous studies have shown that the correct incorporation of the B gene into the new macronucleus requires copies of the macronuclear B gene in the old macronucleus. Using macronuclear transformation, we show that the micronuclear B gene can substitute for the macronuclear B gene with regard to its role in DNA processing. This suggests that the macronuclear DNA is not acting as a guide for the excision of the micronuclear specific sequences.     

Timing of developmentally programmed excision and circularization of Paramecium internal eliminated sequences

Paramecium internal eliminated sequences (IESs) are short AT-rich DNA elements that are precisely eliminated from the germ line genome during development of the somatic macronucleus. They are flanked by one 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide on each side, a single copy of which remains at the donor site after excision. The timing of their excision was examined in synchronized conjugating cells by quantitative PCR. Significant amplification of the germ line genome was observed prior to IES excision, which starts 12 to 14 h after initiation of conjugation and extends over a 2- to 4-h period. Following excision, two IESs were shown to form extrachromosomal circles that can be readily detected on Southern blots of genomic DNA from cells undergoing macronuclear development. On these circular molecules, covalently joined IES ends are separated by one copy of the flanking 5'-TA-3' repeat. The similar structures of the junctions formed on the excised and donor molecules point to a central role for this dinucleotide in IES excision.     

Characterization of a family of repetitive sequences that is eliminated late during macronuclear development of the hypotrichous ciliate Stylonychia lemnae

A repetitive element from the hypotrichous ciliate Stylonychia lemnae was characterized by restriction and hybridization analysis. This repetitive element is present in about 5,000–7,000 copies per haploid genome in the micronucleus and the macronuclear anlagen. Its DNA sequence is very conserved, but the length of the repetitive sequence blocs is variable. In some cases, it is associated with telomeric sequences and macronucleus–homologous sequences. Restriction analysis of genomic micronuclear and macronuclear anlagen DNA and in situ hybridization showed that the repetitive sequences are amplified during the formation of polytene chromosomes. They are localized in many bands of the polytene chromosomes and are eliminated during the degradation of the polytene chromosomes. Possible functions of the repetitive sequences during macronuclear differentiation are discussed. Dev. Genet. 21:201–211, 1997.© 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Internal sequences are eliminated from genes during macronuclear development in the ciliated protozoan Oxytricha nova

During the life cycle of the hypotrichous ciliate Oxytricha nova, a macronucleus containing short, gene-sized DNA molecules is produced from a copy of the chromosomal micronuclear genome. In order to characterize the process of macronuclear development, we have isolated and determined the DNA sequence of a particular macronuclear gene and its micronuclear precursor. The results of this analysis indicate that macronuclear telomeric sequences (5'C4A4(3') repeats) are not present at the ends of the gene in its micronuclear chromosomal location and must be added during development. In addition, the micronuclear copy of the gene contains three short blocks of sequence that must be removed during development, implying the involvement of a nucleic acid-splicing process in generating mature macronuclear genes.     

Evolution of Germline-Limited Sequences in Two Populations of the Ciliate Chilodonella uncinata

Ciliates are microbial eukaryotes that separate their nuclear functions into a germline micronucleus and a somatic macronucleus. During development of the macronucleus the genome undergoes a series of reorganization events that includes the precise excision of intervening DNA. Here, we determine the architecture of four loci in the micronuclear and macronuclear genomes of the ciliate Chilodonella uncinata and compare the levels of variation in micronuclear-limited sequences to macronuclear destined sequences at two of these loci. We find that within a population, germline-limited sequences are evolving at the same rate as other putatively neutral sites, but between populations germline-limited sequences are accumulating mutations at a much faster rate than other sites. We also find evidence of macronuclear recombination and incomplete elimination of intervening DNA, which result in increased diversity in the macronuclear genome. Our results support the assertion that the unusual genomic features of ciliates can result in rapid and unpredicted patterns of diversification.