A butenolide, isolated from smoke, can overcome the detrimental effects of extreme temperatures during tomato seed germination

The butenolide, 3-methyl-2H-furo[2, 3-c]pyran-2-one, is an highly active compound isolated from plant-derived smoke. This compound is known to stimulate seed germination in a wide range of plants akin to smoke or aqueous extracts of smoke. The present study attempted to elucidate the role of the butenolide in overcoming detrimental effects of low and high temperatures on tomato seed germination and seedling growth. The germination percentage followed a parabolic curve for temperatures ranging from 10 to 40°C, with 25°C being the optimum for all treatments. Control seeds showed radicle emergence at two extreme temperatures (10 and 40°C) and seedlings failed to develop further, even upon prolonged incubation. By comparison the butenolide-treated seeds grew into phenotypically normal seedlings at these non-optimum temperatures. The smoke–water-treated seeds had an intermediate response as only a fraction of germinated seed developed into normal seedlings. Seedling vigour indices as well as seedling weight were significantly higher (p ≤ 0.05) for butenolide-treated seeds at all temperatures. Furthermore, seedlings developed in the presence of the butenolide had about a 1:1 correspondence between root and shoot length. Butenolide-treated seeds grew better than the control seeds in the temperature shift experiments. A gradual decline in the vigour index values was recorded with an increased duration of incubation at the extreme temperatures. Results of the present study are very important from an horticultural point of view as they indicate the potential use of the butenolide compound in restoring normal seed germination and seedling establishment in tomato below and above optimum temperatures.     

A smoke-derived butenolide improves early growth of tomato seedlings

3-Methyl-2H-furo[2,3-c]pyran-2-one is an active compound isolated from plant-derived smoke water. It has a stimulatory role during seed germination similar to that of smoke or aqueous extracts of smoke. The present study was undertaken to gain insight into the physiological events involved in seed germination and seedling development and which are affected by butenolide using tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) cultivar “Heinz 1370” seeds. No stimulatory role on the seed germination of tomato was recorded following the use of the butenolide, however, post-germinative growth of tomato seedlings was significantly improved over the control (P ≤ 0.05). The emergence of the radicle and elongation of the hypocotyls and radicles were accelerated in seeds imbibed with butenolide at 10⁻⁷ M. Flow cytometry studies showed that in butenolide-treated seeds the ratio of cells with replicated DNA was increased. Seedling vigour and weight were significantly increased by the butenolide (P ≤ 0.05). An inverse correlation was observed between the weight of cotyledons and the weight of the hypocotyls and radicle during seedling development. This is an indication that the butenolide is implicated in mobilization and utilization of stored reserve materials in developing tomato seedlings.     

Transcriptome analysis of germinating maize kernels exposed to smoke-water and the active compound KAR<Subscript>1</Subscript>

Background  

Smoke released from burning vegetation functions as an important environmental signal promoting the germination of many plant species following a fire. It not only promotes the germination of species from fire-prone habitats, but several species from non-fire-prone areas also respond, including some crops. The germination stimulatory activity can largely be attributed to the presence of a highly active butenolide compound, 3-methyl-2H-furo[2,3-c]pyran-2-one (referred to as karrikin 1 or KAR₁), that has previously been isolated from plant-derived smoke. Several hypotheses have arisen regarding the molecular background of smoke and KAR₁ action.     

Seed germination of agricultural weeds is promoted by the butenolide 3-methyl-2H-furo[2,3-c]pyran-2-one under laboratory and field conditions

Here we report that a synthesised form of a naturally occurring chemical (a butenolide, 3-methyl-2H-furo[2,3-c]pyran-2-one) found in smoke can stimulate seedling emergence of the economically important weed species Avena fatua L. (Poaceae), Arctotheca calendula (L.) Levyns (Asteraceae), Brassica tournefortii Gouan (Brassicaceae), and Raphanus raphanistrum L. (Brassicaceae) under field conditions at rates equivalent to 2–20 g/ha a.i. The butenolide also stimulates germination of freshly collected seeds from wild populations of these species, as well as those of Sisymbrium orientale L. (Brassicaceae), Hordeum leporinum Link (Poaceae) and Echium plantagineum L. (Boraginaceae) under laboratory conditions, consistently greater than that of smoke water. Experiments using B. tournefortii seeds collected from several locations across Western Australia and in different growing seasons found that these factors significantly influence the butenolide response, implying a role of the maternal environment in seed germination/dormancy characteristics. This research highlights the potential of butenolide as an agent for broad acre weed control and land restoration.     

The role of after‐ripening in promoting germination of arid zone seeds: a study on six Australian species

The effects of after‐ripening (storage under warm, dry conditions) on seed germination was examined in six plant species from the arid zone of Western Australia with the aim of improving germination and germination rate for rehabilitation objectives. Study species (Acanthocarpus preissii, Anthocercis littorea, Dioscorea hastifolia, Eremophila oldfieldii, Thryptomene baeckeacea and Zygophyllum fruticulosum) were selected based on diverse plant habits, seed types and requirements for rehabilitation. After‐ripening was investigated by adjusting seed moisture content to 13 and 50 equilibrium relative humidity (eRH) at 23 °C and storing seeds at two temperatures (30 and 45 °C) from 1 to 18 months. Following storage, seeds were incubated in water, gibberellic acid (GA₃) or karrikinolide (KAR₁; the butenolide, 3‐methyl‐2H‐furo[2,3‐c]pyran‐2‐one). All after‐ripening conditions increased germination percentage and rate of A. littorea and D. hastifolia, with A. littorea only germinating when treated with GA₃ or KAR₁. The germination of Z. fruticulosum was dependent on after‐ripening temperature and seed moisture content. After‐ripening had a limited effect on the remaining three species. The restoration implications of the findings are discussed. © 2009 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2009, 161 , 411–421.     

Comparative enhancement of germination and vigor in seed and somatic embryos by the smoke chemical 3-methyl-2H-furo[2,3-C]pyran-2-one in Baloskion tetraphyllum (Restionaceae)

Summary A butenolide (3-methyl-2H-furo[2,3-c]pyran-2-one, the phyto-active compound isolated from smoke) was tested for its effect on somatic embryogenesis with an important species for commercial horticulture, Baloskion tetraphyllum. When somatic embryos of B. tetraphyllum were transferred to basal medium supplemented with butenolide, enhanced development of growth-competent somatic embryos was observed. This study demonstrates that butenolide exhibits promotive effects on both germination of seed (stimulation of zygotic embryos), and stimulation of development and maturation of somatic embryos with B. tetraphyllum, providing a potential new class of phyto-active compounds for in vitro culture.     

Plant-derived smoke: Old technology with possibilities for economic applications in agriculture and horticulture

Fire and smoke have been used in traditional agricultural systems for centuries. In recent years, biologically active compounds have been isolated from smoke with potential uses in agriculture and horticulture. This article highlights the possibilities of using smoke-water or smoke-derived butenolide (3-methyl-2H-furo[2,3-c]pyran-2-one, termed karrikinolide, KAR₁) for the cultivation of agricultural and horticultural crops. Treatments with smoke-water show promising results for improving seed germination, seedling growth and crop productivity. In certain cases, even under adverse conditions, such as low or high temperatures and low osmotic potentials, smoke-water or a KAR₁ solution can promote seed germination and seedling growth. This phenomenon is of great significance when seeds are sown under drought conditions. Smoke-technology, therefore, has potential for use in arid and semi-arid regions. Possibilities may also exist for controlling some plant diseases and managing weeds with the use of smoke or KAR₁ solutions. In addition, smoke-technology can possibly economize the use of commercial chemical fertilizers, pesticides and herbicides, making it a feasible technology for organic farming and for resource-poor farmers in developing nations. The positive role of smoke-water in flowering and fruiting of crops cannot be overlooked as the karrikins found in smoke are now recognized as potential new plant growth regulators. Very low concentrations of smoke-water or a KAR₁ solution are effective in promoting germination and post-germination growth. Thus, early harvesting and increasing the productivity of crops using smoke-technology may be possible. Here we review some of the effects of smoke and KAR₁ on various crop species and discuss the potential uses of smoke technology in agriculture and horticulture.     

燃烧植物产生烟与热的生理生态效应

燃烧植物产生的烟与热对植物的生理生态功能有重要的影响,相关研究已成为生态学研究的热点之一。植物源烟对一些植物种子的萌发和幼苗生长有促进作用,这种促进作用与GA和细胞分裂素的作用相似。在植物烟水溶液中分离得到了具有促进植物种子萌发作用的化合物丁烯羟酸内酯,该物质具有热稳定性、挥发性和有效浓度范围广等特点。丁烯羟酸内酯可以通过纤维素加热产生,因而几乎所有的植物燃烧产生的烟中都可以产生丁烯羟酸内酯。热因子对植物种子萌发有利作用表现为打破种子休眠、清除限制种子萌发的物理、化学因素和减轻种子病原体等方面。大量研究显示,不同植物对烟与热的响应机理存在显著的差异,这是植物群落过火后物种组成改变的重要原因之一。烟与热因子对植物生理生态作用的研究我国开展较少．这与我国是一个森林、草原火灾频繁的国家是不相称的,加强这方面的研究很有必要。另外,今后我国可以在烟与热因子对植物作用的机理,揭示传统用烟火处理土壤促进农林业植物生长的物理和化学本质,以及这些机理在发展有机农业中运用等方面开展深入的研究。     

GA3浸种处理对五种晚花杜鹃种子萌发的影响

晚花杜鹃(late flower Rhododendron)是一类花期较晚的杜鹃品种,具有较高的观赏价值,被广泛应用于庭院种植和园林绿化。随着旅游以及经济发展的需要,开发和利用晚花杜鹃资源显得非常迫切。自然条件下晚花杜鹃萌发率相对较低,因此为提高晚花杜鹃萌发率,探究不同浓度赤霉素(GA_3)处理对五种杜鹃种子萌发的影响,该文以五种晚花杜鹃(小白杜鹃、大白杜鹃、桃叶杜鹃、长蕊杜鹃和九龙山杜鹃)为实验材料,通过不同浓度(0、300、400、500、600、700 mg·L~(-1))的GA_3对五种晚花杜鹃种子进行24 h浸种处理,测定其发芽指数、发芽势、发芽率以及成苗率等指标,分别确定五种杜鹃种子萌发的最适GA_3浓度,并对相同处理下五种杜鹃种子的萌发率和成苗率进行比较。结果表明:(1) GA_3浸种对五种晚花杜鹃种子萌发具有促进作用,在适当GA_3浓度下五种杜鹃种子的发芽指数、发芽势和发芽率均显著高于对照组,萌发时滞、萌发高峰期和持续萌发时间均较对照组浓度相对缩短。(2)大白杜鹃、桃叶杜鹃和九龙山杜鹃种子在GA_3浓度为600 mg·L~(-1)处理时各项萌发指标相对较好;长蕊杜鹃以GA_3浓度为700 mg·L~(-1)浸种处理萌发效果相对较好;小白杜鹃以GA_3浓度为400和700 mg·L~(-1)处理最好。因此,在杜鹃的栽培中,可以采用赤霉素GA_3处理法提高种子发芽率,缩短萌发时间。     

Germination behaviour of 14 Mediterranean species in relation to fire factors: smoke and heat

Fire is an ecological factor that has been present in the ecosystems of the Mediterranean region for thousands of years. Our study was undertaken to acquire knowledge of the effect of fire on the germination of Mediterranean species. We used high temperatures (up to 60°C) and smoke to determine the effect of these factors on the germination of species from the Mediterranean region. The species selected are characteristic of the central Mediterranean basin and are representative of both woody and herbaceous species: Rhamnus alaternus L., Cistus albidus L., Cistus monspeliensis L., Fumana ericoides (Cav.) Gand., Rosmarinus officinalis L., Melica ciliata L., Avena sterilis L., Bituminaria bituminosa (L.) C.H. Stirt., Anthyllis vulneraria L., Coronilla glauca L., Argyrolobium zanonii (Turra) P.W. Balland, Emerus major Mill., Genista scorpius (L.) D.C. and Spartium junceum L. The seeds were collected in Mediterranean shrubland (8) and woodland (6) ecosystems, around Montpellier, France (24°45′N and 3°50′E). Ten treatments were tested: a control, three smoke treatments and six heat treatments. The average germination level (germination percentage) and the average T₅₀ rates (time taken to reach 50% of germination) were calculated. The smoke and heat act in a different way on each of the species. The smoke enhanced the germination of two species, whilst moderate heat increased germination in all of the species excepting R. officinalis, F. ericoides, A. sterilis, A. vulneraria, and G. scorpius. Germination was fastest in M. ciliata and S. junceum and slowest in A. sterilis, E. major and C. albidus. The cues did not significantly affect the rate of germination. Fire modified the germination response of 12 of the 14 species studied.     

Disentangling the role of heat and smoke as germination cues in Mediterranean Basin flora

Background and Aims

The role of fire as a germination cue for Mediterranean Basin (MB) plants is still unclear. The current idea is that heat stimulates germination mainly in Cistaceae and Fabaceae and that smoke has a limited role as a post-fire germination cue, in comparison with other Mediterranean-type ecosystems (MTEs), suggesting that fire-stimulated germination is less relevant in the MB than in other MTEs. However, recent studies showed that the assembly of Mediterranean plant communities is strongly driven by post-fire germination, suggesting an important role for fire as a germination cue. We hypothesize that both heat and smoke have important effects on the different post-fire recruitment processes of MB species (e.g. level and rate of germination and initial seedling growth).

Methods

To ascertain the role of heat and smoke in the post-fire germination response of MB woody plants, a germination experiment was performed with seven heat and two smoke treatments on 30 MB woody species from seven different families, including species with water-permeable seeds and species with water-impermeable seeds.

Key Results

Heat stimulated the germination (probability and rate) of 21 species and smoke in eight species, out of the 30 species studied. In addition, six species showed enhanced initial seedling growth after the smoke treatments.

Conclusions

The results suggest that both heat and smoke are important germination cues in a wide range of MB woody species and that fire-cued germination in woody plants of the MB may be as important as in other MTEs.     

Seed dispersal by the Florida box turtle (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Terrapene carolina bauri</Emphasis>) in pine rockland forests of the lower Florida Keys,United States

Seed dispersal by animals is one of the most important plant-animal mutualisms, but saurochory, the dispersal of seeds by reptiles, has received little attention. We investigated the role of the Florida box turtle (Terrapene carolina bauri) as a seed dispersal agent in pine rockland forests of the lower Florida Keys and examined the effect of turtle digestion on seed germination. We obtained seeds of 11 species with fleshy fruits and 2 species with non-fleshy fruits (a grass and legume) from the feces of 145 box turtles collected on Key Deer National Wildlife Refuge from 1999 to 2000. We planted the seeds of nine species and germination percentage (percentage of seeds that germinated during the experiment) varied from 10% to 80%. Comparative germination experiments were conducted with Thrinax morrissii, Serenoa repens, and Byrsonima lucida. We compared the germination percentage and germination rate (number of days from planting to seedling emergence) of seeds from three treatments (seeds recovered from feces, control seeds with pulp, and control seeds without pulp) and continued these experiments for up to 2 years. Passage through the box turtle digestive tract greatly enhanced the germination percentage and germination rate of S. repens, but decreased the germination percentage of B. lucida and T. morrissii, and decreased germination rate for T. morrissii. Subsequent destructive seed viability tests revealed that many ungerminated T. morrissii seeds remained viable, suggesting long-term seed dormancy may occur, even after passage through the turtle digestive system. In addition, the proportion of ungerminated seeds which remained viable was greater for seeds recovered from turtle feces than from control seeds with pulp. Furthermore, removal of fleshy pulp either manually or by the turtle digestive system may allow T. morrissii to escape insect predation.     

Stimulation of Empress Tree Seed Germination by Liquid Smoke

The germination of Empress tree (Paulownia tomentosa Steud.) seeds is phytochrome-controlled. Liquid smoke could not induce germination in darkness but red light irradiation of liquid smoke imbibed seeds induced a high percentage of germination. Maximum germination was achieved at liquid smoke concentration of 0.1% (v/v) when present during the imbibition phase or during the phase of phytochrome activity. The light requirement of these seeds could be completely substituted by exogenously applied gibberellins. In the presence of liquid smoke, optimal concentrations of GA₃, GA₄, and GA₉ necessary for inducing germination were several times lower than in the controls, while that of GA₇ was equally active when applied at a concentration one order of magnitude lower. The inhibitory effect of the applied growth retardants was strongly reduced and liquid smoke, in the presence of retardants, allowed light-induced germination, if applied simultaneously or after retardants treatment.     

Predicting the impact of increasing carbon dioxide concentration and temperature on seed germination and seedling establishment of African grasses in Brazilian Cerrado

Global climate changes and biological invasions are environmental disturbances that may interact synergistically, causing loss of biodiversity. As the early stages of development are the most sensitive and easily affected by these constraints, this study investigated the effects of increased carbon dioxide (CO₂) and temperature, as forecasted for 2100, on seed germination and early development of three species of invasive African grasses that have gradually replaced landscapes of the Brazilian Cerrado biome. It was observed that these parameters affected percentage and rate of germination in Urochloa brizantha, rate of germination and mean germination time in Urochloa decumbens and accelerated autotrophy acquisition in U. brizantha, U. decumbens and Megathyrsus maximus. Regarding root elongation, all species showed changes in total length, absolute and relative growth rate, but at different stages of development or time intervals, with increased temperature being more significant than increased CO₂, probably due to seed reserves still being the main carbon sources at this stage. Taken together, the results indicate that the effects of CO₂ and increased temperature are species specific and highlight the greatest potential of U. brizantha to germinate, and of U. decumbens for seedling establishment under these environmental changes.     

The effect of concentrated smoke products on the restoration of highly disturbed mineral sands in southeast Victoria

Summary Recent studies have recognized the potential of broad‐scale surface application of smoke compounds for enhancing germination from the soil seed‐bank in fire‐prone vegetation communities. Results suggest that smoke technology may play, in the future, a significant role in the restoration and management of areas supporting indigenous vegetation. An important step in the development of smoke‐based restoration tools is the conduct of in situ field trials in a range of geographical locations and environmental conditions. However, most of the published work on the effectiveness of smoke products in promoting seedbank germination has been conducted at sites in southwestern Australia. The present study examines the effect of commercially available smoke‐water products on the regeneration of a highly disturbed former mine‐site at the Royal Botanic Gardens Cranbourne, in southeastern Victoria. Various combinations of concentrated smoke products and topsoil harvested from a nearby heathy woodland community were applied to exposed, uniform mineral sands to test their effect on seedling density and species richness of regrowth. The trials showed that after 12 months a number of common, herbaceous species including Austrodanthonia setacea, Opercularia varia and Platysace heterophylla were recorded in significantly higher numbers in areas treated with a commercial smoke‐water. However, there was no overall improvement in the density of seedlings or the richness of species as a result of the application of the smoke products. Similarly, total seedling density and species richness were not affected by the addition of topsoil, either alone or in combination with smoke products.     

Structure–activity relationships of analogs of 3,4,5-trimethylfuran-2(5H)-one with germination inhibitory activities

Smoke-derived butenolide compounds have, in recent years, been shown to be important germination signaling molecules, which also affect seedling growth. The butenolide 3,4,5-trimethylfuran-2(5H)-one was previously isolated from plant-derived smoke and was found to significantly reduce the effect on germination by the highly active promotor karrikinolide (KAR₁, 3-methyl-2H-furo[2,3-c]pyran-2-one), another smoke-derived compound. In this study, 11 analogs of 3,4,5-trimethylfuran-2(5H)-one were synthesized and their effect on the germination of light-sensitive ‘Grand Rapids’ lettuce seeds (Lactua sativa cv. ‘Grand Rapids’) were evaluated. A concentration series (1 mM–1 μM) of the analogs were tested alone, or in combination with 0.01 μM KAR₁. Only two compounds were found to reduce the germination promotory effect of 0.01 μM KAR₁ in a similar manner as observed with 3,4,5-trimethylfuran-2(5H)-one, with activity ranging from 1 mM to 10 μM. Four compounds were found to have inhibitory activity at 1 mM and 100 μM. The retention of activity by some of the analogs may be useful for designing novel compounds with improved activity. Furthermore, understanding the structure–activity relationships of these compounds may be helpful in synthesizing molecular probes that can be used to further investigate the mechanism of action of these compounds in regulating seed germination.     

Broad‐scale patterns in smoke‐responsive germination from the south‐eastern Australian flora

Questions

Fire is a crucial component of many ecosystems. Plants whose seeds germinate in response to smoke may benefit from resource availability in the post‐fire environment. Smoke can influence germination timing and success, as well as seedling vigour, resulting in burgeoning research interest in smoke‐responsive germination. Research in this field has largely focused on four key ‘Mediterranean‐type’ fire‐prone ecosystems: the Mediterranean Basin, South African fynbos, Californian chaparral and Western Australia. There are far fewer studies from south‐eastern Australia, a fire‐prone but not “Mediterranean‐type” region. How does smoke‐responsive germination in this region vary according to ecological, phylogenetic, and methodological variables?

Location

South‐eastern Australia.

Methods

We investigated patterns of smoke‐promoted germination in south‐eastern Australian plants across habitat types, growth forms, fire response strategies, phylogeny, taxonomic levels and smoke application methods. We compiled and interrogated data comprising 303 entries on germination responses to smoke in 233 south‐eastern Australian plant species, from 33 different sources.

Results

Smoke‐responsive germination occurs at a lower rate (~41% of tested species) in south‐eastern Australian flora than it does in fynbos and Western Australian floras, and there is clear patterning within these data. Obligate‐seeding species were more likely to respond, Leguminosae and Rubiaceae were less likely to respond (although we question the generality of these results), while Poaceae were more likely to respond to smoke. Finally, studies using aerosol smoke and studies conducted in situ were most likely to find smoke‐promoted germination.

Conclusions

Obligate seeders and Poaceae may be selected for in habitats with higher fire frequencies, consistent with literature suggesting that short inter‐fire intervals favour grasslands over forests. These findings may be particular to south‐eastern Australia, or more widely applicable; more broad‐scale comparative research will reveal the answer. By synthesizing the south‐eastern Australian smoke germination literature we broaden our understanding beyond the better‐studied Mediterranean‐type floras.

     

Multigenerational inbreeding in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Succisa pratensis</Emphasis>: Effects on fitness components

We examined the effects of repeated inbreeding on fitness components of the long-lived perennial Succisa pratensis (Dipsacaceae). Plants from six populations differing in size were used to establish lines with expected inbreeding coefficients f of 0, 0.5 and 0.75. The effects of different inbreeding levels were measured for seed set, seed mass, percentage germination and seedling relative growth rate. Seed set decreased following one generation of inbreeding and seedling growth rate decreased after two generations of inbreeding. Our study indicated that the mutational load is difficult to purge and that continued inbreeding tends to affect important traits in S. pratensis. Although the partial dominance hypothesis for inbreeding depression seems to account for the results, the overdominance hypothesis cannot be ruled out completely. Overall, we conclude that the response of a long-lived plant, such as S. pratensis, to repeated inbreeding does not differ from that of other plant species with shorter life spans, surely because the mechanisms that account for inbreeding depression are universal for all plant species.     

Maternal and direct effects of elevated CO2 on seed provisioning, germination and seedling growth in Bromus erectus

Elevated CO₂ can affect plant fitness not only through its effects on seed production but also by altering the quality of seeds and therefore germination and seedling performance. We collected seeds from mother plants of Bromus erectus grown in field plots at ambient and elevated CO₂ (m-CO₂, maternal CO₂) and germinated them in the greenhouse in a reciprocal design under ambient and elevated CO₂ (o-CO₂, offspring CO₂). This design allowed us to examine both the direct effects of elevated CO₂ on germination and seedling growth and the indirect (maternal) effects via altered seed quality. Elevated m-CO₂ significantly increased seed mass and increased the C:N ratio of seeds from field-grown plants. Percentage and rate of germination were not affected by the m-CO₂ or o-CO₂ treatments. Similarly, elevated m-CO₂ had no significant effect on seedling size as estimated by the total leaf length. When differences in seed mass were adjusted by using seed mass as a covariate in ANOVA, a negative effect of m-CO₂ on seedling size appeared which increased with increasing seed mass (significant covariate×m-CO₂ interaction). This may indicate that the advantage of increased seed mass at elevated m-CO₂ was offset by the reduced concentration of nitrogen (and possibly other nutrients) in these seeds. In contrast to m-CO₂, elevated o-CO₂ greatly increased seedling size, and this stimulatory effect of elevated o-CO₂ was found to increase with increasing seed mass (significant covariate×o-CO₂ interaction). Taken together, these results suggest that in B. erectus transgenerational effects of elevated CO₂ are relatively small. However, other factors (genetic and environmental) that contribute to variation in seed provisioning can critically influence the responsiveness of seedlings to elevated CO₂. Received: 10 May 1999 / Accepted: 6 January 2000