Recruitment of novel calcium-binding proteins for root nodule symbiosis in Medicago truncatula

Legume rhizobia symbiotic nitrogen (N2) fixation plays a critical role in sustainable nitrogen management in agriculture and in the Earth's nitrogen cycle. Signaling between rhizobia and legumes initiates development of a unique plant organ, the root nodule, where bacteria undergo endocytosis and become surrounded by a plant membrane to form a symbiosome. Between this membrane and the encased bacteria exists a matrix-filled space (the symbiosome space) that is thought to contain a mixture of plant- and bacteria-derived proteins. Maintenance of the symbiosis state requires continuous communication between the plant and bacterial partners. Here, we show in the model legume Medicago truncatula that a novel family of six calmodulin-like proteins (CaMLs), expressed specifically in root nodules, are localized within the symbiosome space. All six nodule-specific CaML genes are clustered in the M. truncatula genome, along with two other nodule-specific genes, nodulin-22 and nodulin-25. Sequence comparisons and phylogenetic analysis suggest that an unequal recombination event occurred between nodulin-25 and a nearby calmodulin, which gave rise to the first CaML, and the gene family evolved by tandem duplication and divergence. The data provide striking evidence for the recruitment of a ubiquitous Ca(2+)-binding gene for symbiotic purposes.     

The sulfate transporter SST1 is crucial for symbiotic nitrogen fixation in Lotus japonicus root nodules

Symbiotic nitrogen fixation (SNF) by intracellular rhizobia within legume root nodules requires the exchange of nutrients between host plant cells and their resident bacteria. Little is known at the molecular level about plant transporters that mediate such exchanges. Several mutants of the model legume Lotus japonicus have been identified that develop nodules with metabolic defects that cannot fix nitrogen efficiently and exhibit retarded growth under symbiotic conditions. Map-based cloning of defective genes in two such mutants, sst1-1 and sst1-2 (for symbiotic sulfate transporter), revealed two alleles of the same gene. The gene is expressed in a nodule-specific manner and encodes a protein homologous with eukaryotic sulfate transporters. Full-length cDNA of the gene complemented a yeast mutant defective in sulfate transport. Hence, the gene was named Sst1. The sst1-1 and sst1-2 mutants exhibited normal growth and development under nonsymbiotic growth conditions, a result consistent with the nodule-specific expression of Sst1. Data from a previous proteomic study indicate that SST1 is located on the symbiosome membrane in Lotus nodules. Together, these results suggest that SST1 transports sulfate from the plant cell cytoplasm to the intracellular rhizobia, where the nutrient is essential for protein and cofactor synthesis, including nitrogenase biosynthesis. This work shows the importance of plant sulfate transport in SNF and the specialization of a eukaryotic transporter gene for this purpose.     

Nitrogen transfer in the interface between the symbionts in pea root nodules

Transport mechanisms for transfer of nitrogen from the bacteroid side across the symbiosome membrane of pea (Pisum sativum L.) root nodules were identified by the use of energised bacteroid side-out symbiosome membrane vesicles. Such membrane vesicles were used to study a mechanism with high capacity for transport of ammonium and another mechanism capable of transporting aspartate. Both transport mechanisms are voltage driven and the rate of transport relates positively to the magnitude of the imposed membrane potentials. Competition for transport between ammonium and aspartate was not observed. The ammonium transporter has been identified as a voltage-driven channel whereas the symbiosome membrane aspartate transporter appears to be a H⁺/aspartate symport. The results suggest that nitrogen transfer between the symbionts in pea root nodules involves transfer of amino acids as well as ammonium. In the symbiosome subfraction, which represents the interface between the symbionts, specific aspartate aminotransferase activity was more than four times as high as in the bacteroid cytosol. This finding supports a hypothesis that transamination cycles operating between the symbionts may constitute a component of the transfer of nitrogen between the symbionts.     

Down-regulation of SymRK correlates with a deficiency in vascular bundle development in Phaseolus vulgaris nodules

The symbiotic interaction of legumes and rhizobia results in the formation of nitrogen-fixing nodules. Nodulation depends on the finely coordinated expression of a battery of genes involved in the infection and the organogenesis processes. After Nod factor perception, symbiosis receptor kinase (SymRK) receptor triggers a signal transduction cascade essential for nodulation leading to cortical cell divisions, infection thread (IT) formation and final release of rhizobia to the intracellular space, forming the symbiosome. Herein, the participation of SymRK receptor during the nodule organogenesis in Phaseolus vulgaris is addressed. Our findings indicate that besides its expression in the nodule epidermis, in IT, and in uninfected cells of the infection zone, PvSymRK immunolocalizes in the root and nodule vascular system. On the other hand, knockdown expression of PvSymRK led to the formation of scarce and defective nodules, which presented alterations in both IT/symbiosome formation and vascular system.     

Transcription of ENOD8 in Medicago truncatula nodules directs ENOD8 esterase to developing and mature symbiosomes

In Medicago truncatula nodules, the soil bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti reduces atmospheric dinitrogen into nitrogenous compounds that the legume uses for its own growth. In nitrogen-fixing nodules, each infected cell contains symbiosomes, which include the rhizobial cell, the symbiosome membrane surrounding it, and the matrix between the bacterium and the symbiosome membrane, termed the symbiosome space. Here, we describe the localization of ENOD8, a nodule-specific esterase. The onset of ENOD8 expression occurs at 4 to 5 days postinoculation, before the genes that support the nitrogen fixation capabilities of the nodule. Expression of an ENOD8 promoter-gusA fusion in nodulated hairy roots of composite transformed M. truncatula plants indicated that ENOD8 is expressed from the proximal end of interzone II to III to the proximal end of the nodules. Confocal immunomicroscopy using an ENOD8-specific antibody showed that the ENOD8 protein was detected in the same zones. ENOD8 protein was localized in the symbiosome membrane or symbiosome space around the bacteroids in the infected nodule cells. Immunoblot analysis of fractionated symbiosomes strongly suggested that ENOD8 protein was found in the symbiosome membrane and symbiosome space, but not in the bacteroid. Determining the localization of ENOD8 protein in the symbiosome is a first step in understanding its role in symbiosome membrane and space during nodule formation and function.     

Ferritins and nodulation in Lupinus luteus: iron management in indeterminate type nodules

An ability to form symbiotic associations with rhizobia and to utilize atmospheric nitrogen makes legumes ecologically successful. High iron content in legume grains, partially relocated from root nodules, is another-nutritional-advantage of this group of plants. The ferritin complex is the major cell iron storage and detoxification unit and has been recognized as a marker of many stress-induced responses. The possible participation of ferritin in nodule formation and functioning was investigated here. Correlation of increased accumulation of both ferritin polypeptide and mRNA with actual in situ localization of ferritin allowed ferritin synthesis in the developing, indeterminate-type root nodules to be related to differentiating bacteroid tissue. This kind of tissue, in contrast to the determinate-type nodules, is present in lupin nodules at almost all stages of their development. Interestingly, it was found that, in this type of nodule, senescence starting in the decaying zones induces ferritin accumulation in younger, still active, tissues. Based on the presented data, and in correlation with previous results, some aspects of the regulation of expression of lupin ferritin genes are also discussed.     

Proteome analysis of differentially displayed proteins as a tool for the investigation of symbiosis

Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was used to identify differentially displayed proteins expressed during the symbiotic interaction between the bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti strain 1021 and the legume Melilotus alba (white sweetclover). Our aim was to characterize novel symbiosis proteins and to determine how the two symbiotic partners alter their respective metabolisms as part of the interaction, by identifying gene products that are differentially present between the symbiotic and non-symbiotic states. Proteome maps from control M. alba roots, wild-type nodules, cultured S. meliloti, and S. meliloti bacteroids were generated and compared. Over 250 proteins were induced or up-regulated in the nodule, compared with the root, and over 350 proteins were down-regulated in the bacteroid form of the rhizobia, compared with cultured cells. N-terminal amino acid sequencing and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry peptide mass fingerprint analysis, in conjunction with data base searching, were used to assign putative identity to nearly 100 nodule, bacterial, and bacteroid proteins. These included the previously identified nodule proteins leghemoglobin and NifH as well as proteins involved in carbon and nitrogen metabolism in S. meliloti. Bacteroid cells showed down-regulation of several proteins involved in nitrogen acquisition, including glutamine synthetase, urease, a urea-amide binding protein, and a PII isoform, indicating that the bacteroids were nitrogen proficient. The down-regulation of several enzymes involved in polyhydroxybutyrate synthesis and a cell division protein was also observed. This work shows that proteome analysis will be a useful strategy to link sequence information and functional genomics.     

Inadequate iron supply and high bicarbonate impair the symbiosis of peanuts (Arachis hypogaea L.) with different Bradyrhizobium strains

In the present study, we examined the effects of iron deficiency in an acid solution and in an alkaline solution containing bicarbonate on the growth and nodulation of peanuts inoculated with different bradyrhizobial strains or supplied with fertilizer nitrogen.Inadequate iron supply in acid solution decreased the number of nodule initials, nodule number and nodule mass. Alleviating the iron deficiency increased acetylene reduction but not bacteroid numbers in nodules. Nitrogen concentrations in shoots of inoculated plants increased as iron concentrations in solution increased when determined at day 30 but not at day 50. Higher iron concentrations in solution were required for maximum growth of plants reliant on symbiotic nitrogen fixation than for those receiving fertilizer nitrogen.Adding bicarbonate to the solution with 7.5 M Fe markedly depressed nodule formation. This effect was much more severe than that of inadequate iron supply alone. Bicarbonate also decreased nitrogenase activity but did not decrease bacteroid concentrations in nodules.Both NC92 and TAL1000 nodulated peanuts poorly when bicarbonate was present. However, an interaction between iron concentrations in acid solutions and Bradyrhizobium strains on nodulation of peanuts was observed. Alleviating iron deficiency increased the number of nodule initials and nodules to a much greater extent for plants inoculated with TAL1000 than for plants inoculated with NC92.     

Regulatory Patterns of a Large Family of Defensin-Like Genes Expressed in Nodules of Medicago truncatula

Root nodules are the symbiotic organ of legumes that house nitrogen-fixing bacteria. Many genes are specifically induced in nodules during the interactions between the host plant and symbiotic rhizobia. Information regarding the regulation of expression for most of these genes is lacking. One of the largest gene families expressed in the nodules of the model legume Medicago truncatula is the nodule cysteine-rich (NCR) group of defensin-like (DEFL) genes. We used a custom Affymetrix microarray to catalog the expression changes of 566 NCRs at different stages of nodule development. Additionally, bacterial mutants were used to understand the importance of the rhizobial partners in induction of NCRs. Expression of early NCRs was detected during the initial infection of rhizobia in nodules and expression continued as nodules became mature. Late NCRs were induced concomitantly with bacteroid development in the nodules. The induction of early and late NCRs was correlated with the number and morphology of rhizobia in the nodule. Conserved 41 to 50 bp motifs identified in the upstream 1,000 bp promoter regions of NCRs were required for promoter activity. These cis-element motifs were found to be unique to the NCR family among all annotated genes in the M. truncatula genome, although they contain sub-regions with clear similarity to known regulatory motifs involved in nodule-specific expression and temporal gene regulation.     

LjABCB1, an ATP-binding cassette protein specifically induced in uninfected cells of Lotus japonicus nodules

Legume plants develop root nodules through symbiosis with rhizobia, and fix atmospheric nitrogen in this symbiotic organ. Development of root nodules is regulated by many metabolites including phytohormones. Previously, we reported that auxin is strongly involved in the development of the nodule vascular bundle and lenticel formation on the nodules of Lotus japonicus. Here we show that an ATP-binding cassette (ABC) protein, LjABCB1, which is a homologue of Arabidopsis auxin transporter AtABCB4, is specifically expressed during nodulation of L. japonicus. A reporter gene analysis indicated that the expression of LjABCB1 was restricted to uninfected cells adjacent to infected cells in the nodule, while no expression was observed in shoot apical meristems or root tips, in which most auxin transporter genes are expressed. The auxin transport activity of LjABCB1 was confirmed using a heterologous expression system.     

A novel ankyrin-repeat membrane protein, IGN1, is required for persistence of nitrogen-fixing symbiosis in root nodules of Lotus japonicus

Nitrogen-fixing symbiosis of legume plants with Rhizobium bacteria is established through complex interactions between two symbiotic partners. Similar to the mutual recognition and interactions at the initial stages of symbiosis, nitrogen fixation activity of rhizobia inside root nodules of the host legume is also controlled by specific interactions during later stages of nodule development. We isolated a novel Fix(-) mutant, ineffective greenish nodules 1 (ign1), of Lotus japonicus, which forms apparently normal nodules containing endosymbiotic bacteria, but does not develop nitrogen fixation activity. Map-based cloning of the mutated gene allowed us to identify the IGN1 gene, which encodes a novel ankyrin-repeat protein with transmembrane regions. IGN1 expression was detected in all organs of L. japonicus and not enhanced in the nodulation process. Immunoanalysis, together with expression analysis of a green fluorescent protein-IGN1 fusion construct, demonstrated localization of the IGN1 protein in the plasma membrane. The ign1 nodules showed extremely rapid premature senescence. Irregularly enlarged symbiosomes with multiple bacteroids were observed at early stages (8-9 d post inoculation) of nodule formation, followed by disruption of the symbiosomes and disintegration of nodule infected cell cytoplasm with aggregation of the bacteroids. Although the exact biochemical functions of the IGN1 gene are still to be elucidated, these results indicate that IGN1 is required for differentiation and/or persistence of bacteroids and symbiosomes, thus being essential for functional symbiosis.     

Sulfate is transported at significant rates through the symbiosome membrane and is crucial for nitrogenase biosynthesis

Legume–rhizobia symbioses play a major role in food production for an ever growing human population. In this symbiosis, dinitrogen is reduced (“fixed”) to ammonia by the rhizobial nitrogenase enzyme complex and is secreted to the plant host cells, whereas dicarboxylic acids derived from photosynthetically produced sucrose are transported into the symbiosomes and serve as respiratory substrates for the bacteroids. The symbiosome membrane contains high levels of SST1 protein, a sulfate transporter. Sulfate is an essential nutrient for all living organisms, but its importance for symbiotic nitrogen fixation and nodule metabolism has long been underestimated. Using chemical imaging, we demonstrate that the bacteroids take up 20‐fold more sulfate than the nodule host cells. Furthermore, we show that nitrogenase biosynthesis relies on high levels of imported sulfate, making sulfur as essential as carbon for the regulation and functioning of symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Our findings thus establish the importance of sulfate and its active transport for the plant–microbe interaction that is most relevant for agriculture and soil fertility.     

The soybean NRAMP homologue,GmDMT1, is a symbiotic divalent metal transporter capable of ferrous iron transport

Iron is an important nutrient in N2-fixing legume root nodules. Iron supplied to the nodule is used by the plant for the synthesis of leghemoglobin, while in the bacteroid fraction, it is used as an essential cofactor for the bacterial N2-fixing enzyme, nitrogenase, and iron-containing proteins of the electron transport chain. The supply of iron to the bacteroids requires initial transport across the plant-derived peribacteroid membrane, which physically separates bacteroids from the infected plant cell cytosol. In this study, we have identified Glycine max divalent metal transporter 1 (GmDmt1), a soybean homologue of the NRAMP/Dmt1 family of divalent metal ion transporters. GmDmt1 shows enhanced expression in soybean root nodules and is most highly expressed at the onset of nitrogen fixation in developing nodules. Antibodies raised against a partial fragment of GmDmt1 confirmed its presence on the peribacteroid membrane (PBM) of soybean root nodules. GmDmt1 was able to both rescue growth and enhance 55Fe(II) uptake in the ferrous iron transport deficient yeast strain (fet3fet4). The results indicate that GmDmt1 is a nodule-enhanced transporter capable of ferrous iron transport across the PBM of soybean root nodules. Its role in nodule iron homeostasis to support bacterial nitrogen fixation is discussed.     

Comparing Symbiotic Efficiency between Swollen versus Nonswollen Rhizobial Bacteroids

Symbiotic rhizobia differentiate physiologically and morphologically into nitrogen-fixing bacteroids inside legume host nodules. The differentiation is apparently terminal in some legume species, such as peas (Pisum sativum) and peanuts (Arachis hypogaea), likely due to extreme cell swelling induced by the host. In other legume species, such as beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) and cowpeas (Vigna unguiculata), differentiation into bacteroids, which are similar in size and shape to free-living rhizobia, is reversible. Bacteroid modification by plants may affect the effectiveness of the symbiosis. Here, we compare symbiotic efficiency of rhizobia in two different hosts where the rhizobia differentiate into swollen nonreproductive bacteroids in one host and remain nonswollen and reproductive in the other. Two such dual-host strains were tested: Rhizobium leguminosarum A34 in peas and beans and Bradyrhizobium sp. 32H1 in peanuts and cowpeas. In both comparisons, swollen bacteroids conferred more net host benefit by two measures: return on nodule construction cost (plant growth per gram nodule growth) and nitrogen fixation efficiency (H₂ production by nitrogenase per CO₂ respired). Terminal bacteroid differentiation among legume species has evolved independently multiple times, perhaps due to the increased host fitness benefits observed in this study.Legume-rhizobia interactions vary widely across a diverse paraphyletic group of soil bacteria known for symbiotic nitrogen fixation inside root nodules of over 18,000 species of legumes throughout the world (Lewis et al., 2005). In several legume species, rhizobial cells are induced to swell during their differentiation into nitrogen-fixing bacteroids (Oono et al., 2010). These legume species belong to five different major papilionoid clades (inverted repeat-lacking clade, genistoids, dalbergioids, mirbelioids, and millettioids), a pattern suggestive of convergent evolution. Swelling apparently leads to terminal differentiation; swollen bacteroids no longer divide normally (Zhou et al., 1985). In other legume host species, bacteroid differentiation is less extreme, leading to nonswollen bacteroids. Nonswollen bacteroids are similar in shape and size to free-living rhizobia and divide normally once outside of their nodules. The proximate mechanisms for host-imposed bacteroid swelling have been investigated (Van de Velde et al., 2010), but what drove the repeated evolution of this trait? The multiple independent origins of host traits causing bacteroids to swell suggest that swollen bacteroids may provide more net benefit to legumes. Could the swelling of bacteroids improve nitrogen fixation efficiency (e.g. nitrogen fixed relative to carbon cost)? In this study, we compare symbiotic efficiencies of rhizobia in legume hosts that are evolutionarily diverged but share a common effective rhizobial strain, whose bacteroids are swollen in one host and nonswollen in the other.Variations among host species in benefits and costs of symbiosis with rhizobia are not commonly explored (Thrall et al., 2000) because legume species typically nodulate with only one group of rhizobia (e.g. Sinorhizobium sp. in Medicago), although some legumes and some rhizobia are more promiscuous. Rhizobium sp. NGR234 has the largest known host range but does not fix nitrogen effectively with any legume species currently recognized to induce swelling of rhizobial bacteroids (Pueppke and Broughton, 1999). Some Sinorhizobium fredii strains apparently fix nitrogen in certain cultivars of soybean (Glycine max; hosting nonswollen bacteroids) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa; hosting swollen bacteroids; Hashem et al., 1997), but our efforts to replicate these results did not lead to successful nodulation. Therefore, we studied two strains, a transgenic strain that nodulates beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) and peas (Pisum sativum) and a second wild strain harvested from cowpeas (Vigna unguiculata) that also nodulates peanuts (Arachis hypogaea). Beans and cowpeas are both within the Phaseolid group and do not induce terminal differentiation of rhizobial bacteroids. Peas and peanuts both host terminally differentiated bacteroids but are in distant clades and likely have different genetic origins for traits that induce terminal differentiation (Oono et al., 2010). Also, the swollen bacteroids in peas are branched while those in peanuts are spherical.Differences in symbiotic qualities between swollen and nonswollen bacteroids have been previously explored in peanuts and cowpeas by Sen and Weaver (1980, 1981, 1984), who also hypothesized that swollen bacteroids are more beneficial to the host plant than nonswollen ones. They found 1.5 to 3 times greater acetylene reduction by nitrogenase (as well as plant nitrogen) per nodule mass in peanuts than in cowpeas at multiple nodule ages (Sen and Weaver, 1980). Acetylene reduction per bacteroid was also greater in peanuts than in cowpeas when measuring whole nodules, but this difference disappeared when isolated bacteroids were assayed (Sen and Weaver, 1984). They concluded that swelling of peanut bacteroids per se was not responsible for the higher rate of nitrogen fixation per bacteroid. They suggested that in cowpea nodules, with greater numbers of smaller bacteroids per nodule volume, availability of oxygen to each bacteroid might be restricted such that the rate of oxidative phosphorylation, necessary for nitrogen fixation, is reduced. Fixation rates per bacteroid may be different between hosts due to nodule gas permeability or bacteroid crowding within nodules. However, fixation efficiency (nitrogen fixed per carbon respired) would not necessarily be affected by these and may be more important for the host than the rate of fixation.Rhizobial performances are often compared by measuring the symbiotic benefits, e.g. rates of acetylene reduction or plant growth (Sen and Weaver, 1984; Hashem et al., 1997; Lodwig et al., 2005), but rarely by measuring the symbiotic costs, e.g. carbon consumed or respired. Up to 25% of a legume’s net photosynthate may be required for nitrogen fixation by rhizobia (Minchin et al., 1981). Faster fixation rates (mol nitrogen per s) can be beneficial for hosts, but carbon costs can also be important. Rhizobia that fix more nitrogen per carbon respired could free more carbon for other functions, including the option of supporting more nodules with the same amount of photosynthate. If legumes are sometimes carbon limited, then improved carbon-use efficiency could enhance plant fitness. Measuring both benefits and costs is therefore key to an accurate understanding of the symbiotic performance of a rhizobial strain.While we recognize the many physiological differences between peas and beans or peanuts and cowpeas, the fact that terminal differentiation induced by host legumes evolved multiple times independently (Oono et al., 2010) suggests there may be some consistent host symbiotic benefit, such as improved fixation efficiency. Here, we measured the efficiency of each of two strains as swollen bacteroids in one host and nonswollen bacteroids in another. We measured nitrogenase activity as hydrogen (H₂) production in an N₂-free atmosphere (Layzell et al., 1984; Witty and Minchin, 1998), and compared it to carbon dioxide (CO₂) respiration to estimate return on nodule operation cost. We also compared host biomass growth per total nodule mass growth to estimate return on nodule construction cost. To further assess carbon allocation to the different types of bacteroids, we also measured the average amounts per bacteroid of polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB), an energy storage compound that can comprise up to 50% of bacteroid dry weight (Trainer and Charles, 2006). A greater PHB accumulation per bacteroid may require a decreased allocation of carbon for nitrogenase activity within the bacteroids, and hence, less plant growth per carbon invested in bacteroids. We demonstrate that peas and peanuts that host swollen bacteroids have higher fixation efficiency as well as greater plant return on nodule construction than beans and cowpeas, respectively, nodulated with the same rhizobial strains. PHB was not consistently correlated with plant:nodule growth efficiency with the tested strains. These findings show that swollen bacteroids can indeed provide greater benefits to their legume hosts.     

Symbiotic root nodule bacteria isolated from yam bean (Pachyrhizus erosus)

A total of 25 isolates from root nodules of yam bean (Pachyrhizus erosus L. Urban), a tuber-producing leguminous plant, were characterized. All isolates formed effective nodules mainly on lateral roots while edible tubers were developed on the taproot. The root nodules formed were identified as the typical determinate type. By an analysis of the partial sequences of the 16S rRNA gene (approximately 300 bp) of 10 strains which were selected randomly, the isolated root nodule bacteria of yam bean were classified into two different genera, Rhizobium and Bradyrhizobium. Two strains, YB2 (Bradyrhizobium group) and YB4 (Rhizobium group) were selected and used for further analyses. The generation time of each strain was shown to be 22.5 h for strain YB2 and 0.8 h for strain YB4, respectively. Differences between strains YB2 and YB4 were also reflected in the bacteroid state in the symbiosome. Symbiosome in nodule cells for the strain YB4 contained one bacteroid cell in a peribacteroid membrane, whereas a symbiosome for strain YB2 contained several bacteroid cells.