Spatial patterns of coexistence of competing species in patchy habitat

The single-species spatially realistic patch occupancy metapopulation model is, in this study, extended to a metacommunity of many competing species. Competition is assumed to reduce the local carrying capacity (effective patch area), which in turn increases local extinction rates and reduces colonization rates because of smaller population sizes. Each species is described by three parameters: pre-competitive abundance (equilibrium incidence of patch occupancy, which reflects the rate of colonization in relation to extinction rate), the spatial range of migration, and competitive ability. The model ignores spatio–temporal correlations caused by interspecific interactions, because in metacommunities of unequal competitors inhabiting heterogeneous landscapes, correlations in the occurrence of species are driven more by patch heterogeneity than by competition. The model allows the calculation of multispecies equilibria in patchy habitats without simulations. In general, the number of coexisting species in the metacommunity increases with decreasing strength of competition, increasing rate of colonization, and decreasing range of migration. Habitat heterogeneity in the form of spatial variation in patch areas tends to facilitate coexistence. Poor competitors may coexist with superior competitors in the patch network if the former have higher colonization rates (competition–colonization trade-off). When migration distances are short, competition leads to spatial pattern formation: Species tend to have restricted spatial distributions in the network, but contrary to intuitive expectations, often the distributions of many species are nested. Having more dispersive species enhances both local and global diversity, whereas more local migration decreases local but increases global diversity.     

The evolution of patch selection in stochastic environments

A null model for habitat patch selection in spatially heterogeneous environments is the ideal free distribution (IFD), which assumes individuals have complete knowledge about the environment and can freely disperse. Under equilibrium conditions, the IFD predicts that local population growth rates are zero in all occupied patches, sink patches are unoccupied, and the fraction of the population selecting a patch is proportional to the patch's carrying capacity. Individuals, however, often experience stochastic fluctuations in environmental conditions and cannot respond to these fluctuations instantaneously. An evolutionary stability analysis for fixed patch-selection strategies reveals that environmental uncertainty disrupts the classical IFD predictions: individuals playing the evolutionarily stable strategy may occupy sink patches, local growth rates are negative and typically unequal in all patches, and individuals prefer higher-quality patches less than predicted by their carrying capacities. Spatial correlations in environmental fluctuations can enhance or marginalize these trends. The analysis predicts that continually increasing environmental variation first selects for range expansion, then selects for persisting coupled sink populations, and ultimately leads to regional extinction. In contrast, continually increasing habitat degradation first selects for range contraction and may select for persisting coupled sink populations before regional extinction. These results highlight the combined roles of spatial and temporal heterogeneity on the evolution of habitat selection.     

Impact of spatial heterogeneity on a predator-prey system dynamics

This paper deals with the study of a predator-prey model in a patchy environment. Prey individuals moves on two patches, one is a refuge and the second one contains predator individuals. The movements are assumed to be faster than growth and predator-prey interaction processes. Each patch is assumed to be homogeneous. The spatial heterogeneity is obtained by assuming that the demographic parameters (growth rates, predation rates and mortality rates) depend on the patches. On the predation patch, we use a Lotka-Volterra model. Since the movements are faster that the other processes, we may assume that the frequency of prey and predators become constant and we would get a global predator-prey model, which is shown to be a Lotka-Volterra one. However, this simplified model at the population level does not match the dynamics obtained with the complete initial model. We explain this phenomenom and we continue the analysis in order to give a two-dimensional predator-prey model that gives the same dynamics as that provided by the complete initial one. We use this simplified model to study the impact of spatial heterogeneity and movements on the system stability. This analysis shows that there is a globally asymptotically stable equilibrium in the positive quadrant, i.e. the spatial heterogeneity stabilizes the equilibrium.     

Exploring rarity using a general model for distribution and abundance

We describe a simple model for changes in the distribution and abundance of a metapopulation and use it to explore the conditions leading to different types of rarity. The model suggests that localized populations (those with low patch occupancy but high local abundance) arise from low dispersal, low heterogeneity in extant population size, and frequent local extinctions relative to the potential for recolonization. Scarce populations (with low distribution and abundance) arise when relative local extinction rate is low to moderate and heterogeneity is high or successful dispersal is relatively low. Sparse populations (widespread, but with low local abundance) arise when relative local extinction rate is very low and either spatial heterogeneity or mortality through unsuccessful dispersal is high. In sparse or common species, there may be unstable as well as stable equilibria, implying a threshold distribution and abundance for persistence. The model supports a general correlation between distribution and abundance and suggests that persistence may be threatened by dispersal rates being either too high or too low. The model provides a new perspective on rarity and suggests a simple theoretical foundation for understanding the population-dynamic mechanisms that determine distribution and abundance.     

Homogenization techniques for population dynamics in strongly heterogeneous landscapes

An important problem in spatial ecology is to understand how population-scale patterns emerge from individual-level birth, death, and movement processes. These processes, which depend on local landscape characteristics, vary spatially and may exhibit sharp transitions through behavioural responses to habitat edges, leading to discontinuous population densities. Such systems can be modelled using reaction–diffusion equations with interface conditions that capture local behaviour at patch boundaries. In this work we develop a novel homogenization technique to approximate the large-scale dynamics of the system. We illustrate our approach, which also generalizes to multiple species, with an example of logistic growth within a periodic environment. We find that population persistence and the large-scale population carrying capacity is influenced by patch residence times that depend on patch preference, as well as movement rates in adjacent patches. The forms of the homogenized coefficients yield key theoretical insights into how large-scale dynamics arise from the small-scale features.     

Inferences about population dynamics from count data using multistate models: a comparison to capture–recapture approaches

Wildlife populations consist of individuals that contribute disproportionately to growth and viability. Understanding a population's spatial and temporal dynamics requires estimates of abundance and demographic rates that account for this heterogeneity. Estimating these quantities can be difficult, requiring years of intensive data collection. Often, this is accomplished through the capture and recapture of individual animals, which is generally only feasible at a limited number of locations. In contrast, N‐mixture models allow for the estimation of abundance, and spatial variation in abundance, from count data alone. We extend recently developed multistate, open population N‐mixture models, which can additionally estimate demographic rates based on an organism's life history characteristics. In our extension, we develop an approach to account for the case where not all individuals can be assigned to a state during sampling. Using only state‐specific count data, we show how our model can be used to estimate local population abundance, as well as density‐dependent recruitment rates and state‐specific survival. We apply our model to a population of black‐throated blue warblers (Setophaga caerulescens) that have been surveyed for 25 years on their breeding grounds at the Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest in New Hampshire, USA. The intensive data collection efforts allow us to compare our estimates to estimates derived from capture–recapture data. Our model performed well in estimating population abundance and density‐dependent rates of annual recruitment/immigration. Estimates of local carrying capacity and per capita recruitment of yearlings were consistent with those published in other studies. However, our model moderately underestimated annual survival probability of yearling and adult females and severely underestimates survival probabilities for both of these male stages. The most accurate and precise estimates will necessarily require some amount of intensive data collection efforts (such as capture–recapture). Integrated population models that combine data from both intensive and extensive sources are likely to be the most efficient approach for estimating demographic rates at large spatial and temporal scales.     

A neglected facet of island biogeography: The role of internal spatial dynamics in area effects

The classical theory of island biogeography has as its basic variable the presence or absence of species on entire islands, and as its basic processes colonization and extinction rates on entire islands as functions of island area, distance, and so forth. Yet for many organisms with limited dispersal abilities, it may be more reasonable to consider larger islands as comprised of an ensemble of local populations coupled by within-island dispersal. Conceptual arguments and a simple patch occupancy model are used to examine the potential relevance of such internal spatial dynamics in explaining area effects, expressed via the probability that a species is present per unit area as a function of total island area. The model suggests that strong area effects depend on a rather fine balance between local colonization and extinction rates. A fruitful direction of future research should be the application of patch dynamic theory to classic island biogeographic questions and systems.     

生态学中的尺度问题——尺度上推

尺度推绎是生态学理论和应用的核心。如何在一个异质景观中进行尺度推绎仍然是一个悬而未决的科学难题,是对当今生态学家在全球变化背景下研究环境问题的重大挑战。就目前的研究,一般可分为四大类尺度推绎途径:空间分析法(如分维分析法和小波分析法)、基于相似性的尺度上推方法、基于局域动态模型的尺度上推方法、随机(模型)法。基于相似性的尺度上推方法来源于生物学上的异量关联,可将其思想延伸至空间上,研究物种丰富度、自然河网、地形特征、生态学格局或过程变量和景观指数等。基于局域动态模型的尺度上推方法需要首先确定是否进行跨尺度推绎,以及是否考虑空间单元之间的水平相互作用和反馈,然后再应用具体的方法或途径,如简单聚合法、有效值外推法、直接外推法、期望值外推、显式积分法和空间相互作用模拟法等。随机(模型)法以其它尺度上推方法为基础,根据研究的是单个景观,还是多个景观,采用不同的途径。理解、定量和降低尺度推绎结果的不确定性已经变得越来越重要,但相关研究仍然极少。以上所有有关尺度推绎的方法、途径和结果分析共同构成了尺度推绎的概念框架。     

Movement behaviour determines competitive outcome and spread rates in strongly heterogeneous landscapes

Classical models for biological invasions were single-species models in homogeneous landscapes, but most invasions happen in the presence of interacting species and in heterogeneous environments. The combination of spatial variation and species interaction could alter the spreading process significantly. For example, the ‘environmental heterogeneity hypothesis of invasions’ posits that heterogeneity offers more opportunities for invaders and reduces the negative impact on native species. Environmental heterogeneity offers an obvious coexistence mechanism on the regional scale if two or more competing species have different spatial niches, i.e. if the local competitive advantage changes in space. We consider a more subtle mechanism of space use through individual movement behaviour when the local competitive advantage remains with the same species. Specifically, we model the densities of two species, diffusing and competing in an infinite landscape consisting of two types of patches. We include individual behaviour in terms of movement rate and patch preference. We consider the scenario that one of the species is the stronger local competitor in both patch types. We then uncover a number of mechanisms—based solely on movement behaviour—through which these two species can coexist regionally, how the inferior competitor can replace the superior competitor globally, or how a bistable situation can arise between the two. We calculate mutual invasion conditions as well as mutual spatial spread rates, and we show that spread rates may depend on movement parameters in unexpected ways.     

Molecular diversity after a range expansion in heterogeneous environments

Recent range expansions have probably occurred in many species, as they often happen after speciation events, after ice ages, or after the introduction of invasive species. While it has been shown that range expansions lead to patterns of molecular diversity distinct from those of a pure demographic expansion, the fact that many species do live in heterogeneous environments has not been taken into account. We develop here a model of range expansion with a spatial heterogeneity of the environment, which is modeled as a gamma distribution of the carrying capacities of the demes. By allowing temporal variation of these carrying capacities, our model becomes a new metapopulation model linking ecological parameters to molecular diversity. We show by extensive simulations that environmental heterogeneity induces a loss of genetic diversity within demes and increases the degree of population differentiation. We find that metapopulations with low average densities are much more affected by environmental heterogeneity than metapopulations with high average densities, which are relatively insensitive to spatial and temporal variations of the environment. Spatial heterogeneity is shown to have a larger impact on genetic diversity than temporal heterogeneity. Overall, temporal heterogeneity and local extinctions are not found to leave any specific signature on molecular diversity that cannot be produced by spatial heterogeneity.     

Evolutionary branching of dispersal strategies in structured metapopulations

 Dispersal polymorphism and evolutionary branching of dispersal strategies has been found in several metapopulation models. The mechanism behind those findings has been temporal variation caused by cyclic or chaotic local dynamics, or temporally and spatially varying carrying capacities. We present a new mechanism: spatial heterogeneity in the sense of different patch types with sufficient proportions, and temporal variation caused by catastrophes. The model where this occurs is a generalization of the model by Gyllenberg and Metz (2001). Their model is a size-structured metapopulation model with infinitely many identical patches. We present a generalized version of their metapopulation model allowing for different types of patches. In structured population models, defining and computing fitness in polymorphic situations is, in general, difficult. We present an efficient method, which can be applied also to other structured population or metapopulation models. Received: 6 March 2001 / Revised version: 12 February 2002 / Published online: 17 July 2002     

Dispersal-mediated coexistence of competing predators

Models of metapopulations have often ignored local community dynamics and spatial heterogeneity among patches. However, persistence of a community as a whole depends both on the local interactions and the rates of dispersal between patches. We study a mathematical model of a metacommunity with two consumers exploiting a resource in a habitat of two different patches. They are the exploitative competitors or the competing predators indirectly competing through depletion of the shared resource. We show that they can potentially coexist, even if one species is sufficiently inferior to be driven extinct in both patches in isolation, when these patches are connected through diffusive dispersal. Thus, dispersal can mediate coexistence of competitors, even if both patches are local sinks for one species because of the interactions with the other species. The spatial asynchrony and the competition-colonization trade-off are usual mechanisms to facilitate regional coexistence. However, in our case, two consumers can coexist either in synchronous oscillation between patches or in equilibrium. The higher dispersal rate of the superior prompts rather than suppresses the inferior. Since differences in the carrying capacity between two patches generate flows from the more productive patch to the less productive, loss of the superior by emigration relaxes competition in the former, and depletion of the resource by subsidized consumers decouples the local community in the latter.     

Frequency-dependent conspecific attraction to food patches

In many ecological situations, resources are difficult to find but become more apparent to nearby searchers after one of their numbers discovers and begins to exploit them. If the discoverer cannot monopolize the resources, then others may benefit from joining the discoverer and sharing their discovery. Existing theories for this type of conspecific attraction have often used very simple rules for how the decision to join a discovered resource patch should be influenced by the number of individuals already exploiting that patch. We use a mechanistic, spatially explicit model to demonstrate that individuals should not necessarily simply join patches more often as the number of individuals exploiting the patch increases, because those patches are likely to be exhausted soon or joining them will intensify future local competition. Furthermore, we show that this decision should be sensitive to the nature of the resource patches, with individuals being more responsive to discoveries in general and more tolerant of larger numbers of existing exploiters on a patch when patches are resource-rich and challenging to locate alone. As such, we argue that this greater focus on underlying joining mechanisms suggests that conspecific attraction is a more sophisticated and flexible tactic than currently appreciated.     

Information thresholds,habitat loss and population persistence in breeding birds

The combination of spatial structure and non‐linear population dynamics can promote the persistence of coupled populations, even when the average population growth rate of the patches seen in isolation would predict otherwise. This phenomenon has generally been conceptualized and investigated through the movement of individuals among patches that each holds many individuals, as in metapopulation models. However, population persistence can likewise increase as the result of individuals moving among sites (e.g. breeding territories) within in a single patch. Here I examine the latter: individuals making small‐scale informed decisions with respect to where to breed can promote population persistence in poor environments. Based on a simple algebraic model, I demonstrate information thresholds, and predict that greater information use is required for population persistence under lower spatial heterogeneity in habitat quality, all else equal. Second, I implement an individual‐based model to explore prior experience and prospecting on conspecific success within a more complex, and spatially heterogeneous environment. Uniquely, I jointly examine the effects of simulated habitat loss, spatial heterogeneity prior to habitat, and variation in information gathering on population persistence. I find that habitat loss accelerates population quasi‐extinction risk; however, information use reduces extinction probabilities in proportion to the level of information gathering. Per capita reproductive success declines with number of breeding sites, suggesting that information‐mediated Allee effects may contribute to extinction risk. In conclusion, my study suggests that populations in a changing world may be increasingly vulnerable to extinction where patch size and spatial heterogeneity constrain the effectiveness of information‐use strategies.     

Behavioral choices based on patch selection: a model using aggregation methods

The aim of this work is to study the influence of patch selection on the dynamics of a system describing the interactions between two populations, generically called 'population N' and 'population P'. Our model may be applied to prey-predator systems as well as to certain host-parasite or parasitoid systems. A situation in which population P affects the spatial distribution of population N is considered. We deal with a heterogeneous environment composed of two spatial patches: population P lives only in patch 1, while individuals belonging to population N migrate between patch 1 and patch 2, which may be a refuge. Therefore they are divided into two patch sub-populations and can migrate according to different migration laws. We make the assumption that the patch change is fast, whereas the growth and interaction processes are slower. We take advantage of the two time scales to perform aggregation methods in order to obtain a global model describing the time evolution of the total populations, at a slow time scale. At first, a migration law which is independent on population P density is considered. In this case the global model is equivalent to the local one, and under certain conditions, population P always gets extinct. Then, the same model, but in which individuals belonging to population N leave patch 1 proportionally to population P density, is studied. This particular behavioral choice leads to a dynamically richer global system, which favors stability and population coexistence. Finally, we study a third example corresponding to the addition of an aggregative behavior of population N on patch 1. This leads to a more complicated situation in which, according to initial conditions, the global system is described by two different aggregated models. Under certain conditions on parameters a stable limit cycle occurs, leading to periodic variations of the total population densities, as well as of the local densities on the spatial patches.     

The role of habitat quality in fragmented landscapes: a conceptual overview and prospectus for future research

There is increasing empirical evidence that the quality of habitat patches (determined by either habitat degradation or natural heterogeneity in the quality of habitat) plays an important role in determining species distribution patterns and in regulating spatial dynamics in fragmented landscapes. However, to date, most of the debate has focused on whether or not to include habitat variables in fragmentation studies, and we still lack general conclusions as well as standard and robust research approaches. In this paper we show how a weak conceptualization of “patch quality” and the inappropriate choice of target surrogate variables (e.g., density is often used as an indicator of patch quality) have mainly produced case-specific results, rather than general conclusions. We then identify weaknesses in the inclusion of habitat quality measurements within fragmentation studies. In particular, we focus on: (1) the lack of appropriate experimental design, outlining how few studies have actually included a gradient of habitat quality in their sample; (2) the lack of fundamental information provided (e.g., lack of standard outputs), which in turn hampers the possibility of carrying out meta-analyses. We finally synthesize available knowledge from empirical studies and highlight the different conceptual frameworks needed for patch occupancy versus patch use studies.     

Effects of demographic parameters on metapopulation size and persistence: an analytical stochastic model

An analytical stochastic metapopulation model is developed. It describes how individuals will be distributed among patches as a function of density-dependent birth, death and emigration rates, and the probability of successful dispersal. The model includes demographic stochasticity, but not catastrophes, environmental stochasticity or variation in patch size and suitability. All patches are equally likely to be colonized by migrants. The model predicts: (a) mean and variance of the number of individuals per patch; (b) probability distribution of individuals per patch; (c) mean number of individuals in transit; and (d) turn-over rate and expected persistence time of a single patch. The model shows that (a) dispersal rates must be intermediate in order to ensure metapopulation persistence; (b) the mean number of individuals per patch is often well below the carrying capacity; (c) long transit times and/or high mortality during dispersal reduce the mean number of individuals per patch; (d) density-dependent emigration responses will usually increase metapopulation size and persistence compared with density-independent dispersal; (e) an increase in the per capita net growth rate can both increase and decrease metapopulation size and persistence depending on whether dispersal rates are high or low; (f) density-independent birth, death, and emigration rates lead to a spatial pattern described by the negative binomial distribution.     

A field experiment on the influence of load transportation and patch distance on the locomotion velocity of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Dorymyrmex goetschi</Emphasis> (Hymenoptera,Formicidae)

Summary Locomotion velocity during foraging activities is determined by factors such as travel distance, habitat structure and load mass among others. However, few studies on foraging behavior have analyzed the influence of spatial heterogeneity and food transportation on the locomotion velocity of ants under natural conditions. In order to study the mentioned factors, we selected 20 nests of the ant Dorymyrmex goetschi (subfamily Dolichoderinae), in a lower Andes locality of central Chile. Half of the nests were offered a food patch located at 10 cm from the nest entrance, and at 20 cm for the other half. We measured the duration of trips between nest and food patch and vice versa, and the distances traveled. We also recorded spatial heterogeneity of the substratum and soil temperature. Temperature was used as a covariate in the statistical analysis. Travel speed was significantly slower when worker ants returned to the nest with a food load, compared to the velocity of foragers without load that traveled from the nest to the patch. When the food patch was located at greater distance, locomotion velocity was significantly faster. Spatial heterogeneity did not affect movement speed. The reduction in locomotion velocity in ants carrying a load of 5.6 mg represents an energetic cost of transportation equivalent to 79% of the costs involved in moving a body mass of 1.6 mg. Faster velocities at larger patch distances can be interpreted as a strategy to maintain an efficient resource exploitation, by way of decreasing the time exposed to higher predation risk.Received 28 April 2003; revised 11 November 2003; accepted 22 January 2004.     

Spontaneous Patchiness in a Host-Parasitoid Integrodifference Model

Observations of a host-parasitoid interaction in which victims are significantly less motile than their exploiters suggest the possibility of stable spatial pattern in a fairly homogeneous environment. Findings of pattern formation in continuous-time models are not fully able to account for this behavior. Those findings often rely on questionable biological conditions, and more fundamentally, the continuous nature of time in such models does not reflect the reality of the observed interaction. In this paper, we introduce a discrete-time spatial model of the interaction. The final state of our model is often a striking spatial pattern, similar to those observed. We analyze the model, describe its transient behavior, and find the conditions under which these spatial patterns occur, as well as an estimate of maximum possible patch size under those conditions. We also discuss the existence of such conditions in the natural system.     

Metapopulation dynamics for spatially extended predator–prey interactions

Traditional metapopulation theory classifies a metapopulation as a spatially homogeneous population that persists on neighboring habitat patches. The fate of each population on a habitat patch is a function of a balance between births and deaths via establishment of new populations through migration to neighboring patches. In this study, we expand upon traditional metapopulation models by incorporating spatial heterogeneity into a previously studied two-patch nonlinear ordinary differential equation metapopulation model, in which the growth of a general prey species is logistic and growth of a general predator species displays a Holling type II functional response. The model described in this work assumes that migration by generalist predator and prey populations between habitat patches occurs via a migratory corridor. Thus, persistence of species is a function of local population dynamics and migration between spatially heterogeneous habitat patches. Numerical results generated by our model demonstrate that population densities exhibit periodic plane-wave phenomena, which appear to be functions of differences in migration rates between generalist predator and prey populations. We compare results generated from our model to results generated by similar, but less ecologically realistic work, and to observed population dynamics in natural metapopulations.