Driving adenovirus type 12-transformed BALB/c mouse cells to express high levels of class I major histocompatibility complex proteins enhances, rather than abrogates, their tumorigenicity.

The tumorigenicity of adenovirus type 12 (Ad12)-transformed cells has been attributed to the low levels of class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) protein expression by these cells. These levels of class I proteins are thought to be below the threshold critical for cytotoxic T-lymphocyte recognition, a process that may be involved in tumor cell immunosurveillance. We have used gene transfer experiments to investigate the role played by class I protein expression in the tumorigenicity of Ad12-transformed BALB/c mouse cells in naive, syngeneic adult mice. Our Ad12-transformed mouse cells were tumorigenic in adult mice and were similar to other Ad12-transformed mammalian cells in that they expressed low levels of class I MHC mRNA and cell surface proteins. Despite these low levels of expression, the cells were highly immunogenic in syngeneic mice and were rejected as allografts by allogeneic mice. Transfection of genomic H-2Dd or H-2Ld fragments into these cells produced a variety of cell clones that expressed increased levels of cell surface class I proteins. These cells expressing high levels of class I protein were up to 16-fold more tumorigenic than the parental cells in syngeneic adult mice. Thus, by quantitative assays, the tumorigenicity of Ad12-transformed BALB/c mouse cells is not functionally related to the low levels of class I MHC proteins they express. The increased tumorigenicity expressed by H-2Dd- and H-2Ld-transfected cells was not detected in BALB/c nu/nu mice, suggesting that a thymus-dependent mechanism that is not mediated by evasion of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte recognition could contribute to the difference in tumorigenicity of Ad12-transformed BALB/c mouse cells that express low and high levels of class I MHC proteins.     

Changes in NF-kappa B and ISGF3 DNA binding activities are responsible for differences in MHC and beta-IFN gene expression in Ad5- versus Ad12-transformed cells.

Changes in MHC class I expression are frequently observed in tumors, which represents at least one mechanism by which tumor cells escape immune surveillance. MHC class I expression is often suppressed in type 12 adenovirus (Ad12)-transformed rodent cells, but is highly induced in Ad5-transformed cells. This difference helps to explain why Ad12 but not Ad5 can induce tumors in immunocompetent syngeneic rats. In this report we demonstrate that only Ad5- but not Ad12-transformed rodent fibroblasts constitutively express beta-IFN which results in ISGF3 factor induction, and stimulation of MHC class I expression. Furthermore, we demonstrate that in contrast to Ad12-transformed cells, Ad5-transformed cells show constitutive levels of nuclear NF-kappa B-like DNA binding activity. This is of particular interest since both the beta-IFN and the MHC class I promoters contain an NF-kappa B DNA binding site. Thus, high levels of MHC class I expression in Ad5-transformed cells are due to a combinatorial stimulation of two cis-regulatory sequences of the MHC class I promoter: the NF-kappa B binding site and the interferon stimulated response element (ISRE), which binds the ISGF3 factor complex. The failure of Ad12-transformed cells to activate this pathway explains their low levels of MHC class I expression and their greater oncogenicity.     

Modulation of the tumorigenicity of human adenovirus-12-transformed cells by interferon

Human adenovirus-12-transformed cells express greatly reduced levels of the major histocompatibility complex class I antigens and are highly tumorigenic in syngeneic hosts. The finding that expression of a transfected class I gene is sufficient to abrogate their tumorigenicity underscores the importance of defining the conditions that will lead to derepression of endogenous class I genes in these cells. Brief treatment of Ad12-transformed cells with interferon results in the rapid but transient expression of class I antigens, and these interferon-treated cells have significantly reduced tumorigenicity in immunocompetent hosts. We have further demonstrated that subcutaneous administration of interferon, subsequent to the introduction of a tumorigenic dose of Ad12-transformed cells, results in complete protection against this tumor. The ability of interferon to "induce" class I gene expression may be an important modality in the treatment of a variety of spontaneous tumors that exhibit greatly reduced levels of class I antigens on their cell surface.     

Tumor formation by SV40-transformed human cells in nude mice: the role of SV40 T antigens

Human cells transformed in vitro by SV40 rarely form tumors in nude mice. We examined whether these cells as a group are inherently nontumorigenic or whether they are potentially tumorigenic but rejected by the athymic host, possibly by nonspecific immune mechanisms. SV80 and NG8 are SV40-transformed human cell lines that express all of the transformed properties, including anchorage-independent growth, but do not form tumors in adult nude mice after injection of as many as 10(8) cells. Both the SV80 and NG8 cell lines have SV40-specific transplantation antigens which crossreact with those present on SV40-transformed (but tumorigenic) rodent cells. We found that SV80 cells, though not NG8 cells, induced progressively growing lethal tumors if the cells are injected repeatedly into neonatal nude mice. Somatic cell hybrids between SV80 or NG8 cells and a highly tumorigenic cell line derived from a human tumor continue to express the virus-induced antigens and fail to form tumors in adult nude mice. These results strongly suggest that at least for some SV40-transformed human cells, the failure to form tumors in nude mice may be due to their expression of virus-induced transplantation antigens rather than the absence of tumorigenic potential.     

The level of expression of adenovirus type 2 transforming genes governs sensitivity to nonspecific immune cytolysis and other phenotypic properties of adenovirus 2-simian virus 40-transformed cell hybrids.

Syrian hamster embryo cells transformed by adenovirus type 2 (Ad2) or simian virus 40 (SV40) differ markedly in morphology, tumorigenicity, and susceptibility to in vitro lysis by nonspecific cytotoxic cells. Hybrid cells formed by fusing Ad2- and SV40-transformed Syrian hamster embryo cells may express only SV40 T antigens or both SV40 and Ad2 T antigens. Hybrids that express only SV40 T antigens are indistinguishable from the nonhybrid SV40-transformed phenotype, whereas hybrid cells that express T antigens from both viruses closely resemble the nonhybrid parental Ad2-transformed phenotype. Because these hybrid cells have been useful in the study of neoplastic transformation, we determined the amount of viral antigens that they accumulate in an attempt to correlate the level of expression of the transforming viral genes with some of their phenotypic properties. Hybrid cells that expressed proteins from both viruses showed reduced levels of SV40 T antigens compared with those of hybrid cells that did not express Ad2 T antigens. We also found that the production of several cellular proteins that influence cytomorphology was inhibited in hybrid and nonhybrid cells that expressed Ad2 T antigens, and the repression of these cellular proteins correlated with a change in cytomorphology from fibroblastic to spherical. Finally, we showed that the susceptibility of our hybrid cells to in vitro lysis by natural killer cells and activated macrophages, two putative host-effector cells involved in defense against neoplasia, correlated closely with the level of expression of a 58,000-dalton Ad2 protein. The results reported here, together with the results of previous studies, indicate that the oncogenic potential of hybrid cells that express both Ad2 and SV40 antigens is extremely sensitive to Ad2 expression, whereas other phenotypic properties depend on Ad2 expression in a dose-dependent manner.     

Immunological surveillance against DNA-virus-transformed cells: correlations between natural killer cell cytolytic competence and tumor susceptibility of athymic rodents.

Adenovirus type 2 (Ad2)-transformed hamster and rat cells are susceptible to lysis by natural killer (NK) cells from the host of origin and are nontumorigenic in immunocompetent hamsters and rats, respectively. These NK-cell-susceptible, virus-transformed cells are, however, highly tumorigenic in athymic (nude) mice--animals with intact NK-cell responses. In vitro lysis of these xenogeneic, Ad2-transformed cells by nude-mouse NK cells was found to be defective. In contrast, Ad2-transformed hamster and rat cells were highly susceptible to lysis by nude-rat NK cells. Furthermore, xenogeneic, Ad2-transformed hamster cells were nontumorigenic in nude rats unless the NK-cell responses of the challenged animals were compromised. The results of the nude-rat studies show that thymus-dependent, cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-mediated, host cellular immune responses are not essential for rejection of xenogeneic cells transformed by nononcogenic Ad2. The data suggest instead that immunologically nonspecific host cellular immune responses, such as those mediated by NK cells, are sufficient for rejection of Ad2-transformed cells. These results indicate that biologically important differences exist in the NK-cell-mediated defenses mounted by nude mice and nude rats against transformed cells that may account for the different patterns of tumor induction by various neoplastic cell types in these athymic animals.     

Characterization of a 54K dalton cellular SV40 tumor antigen present in SV40-transformed cells and uninfected embryonal carcinoma cells.

SV40 infection or transformation of murine cells stimulated the production of a 54K dalton protein that was specifically immunoprecipitated, along with SV40 large T and small t antigens, with sera from mice or hamsters bearing SV40-induced tumors. The same SV40 anti-T sera immunoprecipitated a 54K dalton protein from two different, uninfected murine embryonal carcinoma cell lines. These 54K proteins from SV40-transformed mouse cells and the uninfected embryonal carcinomas cells had identical partial peptide maps which were completely different from the partial peptide map of SV40 large T antigen. An Ad2+ND4-transformed hamster cell line also expressed a 54K protein that was specifically immunoprecipitated by SV40 T sera. The partial peptide maps of the mouse and hamster 54K protein were different, showing the host cell species specificity of these proteins. The 54K hamster protein was also unrelated to the Ad2+ND4 SV40 T antigen. Analogous proteins immunoprecipitated by SV40 T sera, ranging in molecular weight from 44K to 60K, were detected in human and monkey SV40-infected or -transformed cells. A wide variety of sera from hamsters and mice bearing SV40-induced tumors immunoprecipitated the 54K protein of SV40-transformed cells and murine embryonal carcinoma cells. Antibody produced by somatic cell hybrids between a B cell and a myeloma cell (hybridoma) against SV40 large T antigen also immunoprecipitated the 54K protein in virus-infected and -transformed cells, but did not do so in the embryonal carcinoma cell lines. We conclude that SV40 infection or transformation of mouse cells stimulates the synthesis or enhances the stability of a 54K protein. This protein appears to be associated with SV40 T antigen in SV40-infected and -transformed cells, and is co-immunoprecipitated by hybridomas sera to SV40 large T antigen. The 54K protein either shares antigenic determinants with SV40 T antigen or is itself immunogenic when in association with SV40 large T antigen. The protein varies with host cell species, and analogous proteins were observed in hamster, monkey and human cells. The role of this protein in transformation is unclear at present.     

Studies on Nondefective Adenovirus-Simian Virus 40 Hybrid Viruses I. A Newly Characterized Simian Virus 40 Antigen Induced by the Ad2+ND1 Virus

The nondefective adenovirus 2 (Ad2)-simian virus 40 (SV40) hybrid virus, Ad2(+)ND(1), does not induce heat-labile SV40 T antigen but does induce a previously uncharacterized heat-stable SV40 antigen-the SV40 "U" antigen. This antigen is detectable by both immunofluorescence and complement fixation by using sera from hamsters with SV40 tumors. Sera from hamsters bearing SV40 tumors can be divided into two groups, those that react with both SV40 T and U antigens (T(+)U(+) sera) and those that react with SV40 T antigen only (T(+)U(-) sera). SV40 U-specific sera from monkeys immunized with Ad2(+)ND(1)-infected cells do not react with SV40 T antigen by immunofluorescence but do react with an antigen in the nucleus of SV40-transformed cells and with an early, cytosine arabinoside-resistant antigen present in the nucleus of SV40-infected cells. A heat-stable SV40 antigen detectable by complement fixation with T(+)U(+) hamster sera is present in extracts of SV40-induced hamster tumors and in cell packs of SV40-infected or -transformed cells. SV40 U-antigen synthesis by Ad2(+)ND(1) virus is partially sensitive to inhibitors of deoxyribonucleic acid synthesis, whereas U-antigen synthesis by SV40 virus is an early cytosine arabinoside-resistant event. As an early SV40 antigen differing from SV40 T antigen, U antigen may play a role in malignant transformation mediated by SV40.     

Levels of bovine papillomavirus RNA and protein expression correlate with variations in the tumorigenic phenotype of hamster cells.

Three independent cell lines were established from primary cultures of LSH hamster embryo cells infected with bovine papillomavirus type 1 (BPV-1). Although these cell lines differed in their in vitro saturation densities, none was capable of colony formation in soft agar. Interestingly, two cell lines (BPV-HE1 and BPV-HE3) were tumorigenic in nude mice, syngeneic hamsters, and allogeneic hamsters, whereas BPV-HE2 was not. All three cell lines contained similar numbers of the BPV-1 genome (approximately 50 to 200 copies per cell). However, the nontumorigenic BPV-HE2 cell line contained very low levels of BPV-specific RNA and only small amounts of the BPV-1 E5 transforming protein. The efficiency and rate of tumor formation by BPV-HE1 and BPV-HE3 correlated directly with the apparent amount of viral E5 protein. This analysis suggests that there is a threshold level of BPV protein synthesis required for tumorigenicity, there is a continuum of tumorigenic phenotypes which may depend upon the level of BPV protein expression, and BPV-transformed hamster cells can withstand allogeneic transplantation.     

Suppression of hamster lymphocyte reactivity to simian virus 40 tumor surface antigens by spleen cells from pregnant hamsters

SV40-transformed tumor cells in hamsters have been found to have cell surface antigens cross-reactive with antigens temporally expressed on fetal tissues. Adoptive transfer assays performed in this laboratory have shown that peritoneal exudate cells from 10-day primiparous hamsters are cytotoxic to SV40-transformed sarcoma cells (WF5-1) carrying fetal antigen, whereas peritoneal exudate cells from multiparous hamsters are less cytotoxic. This suggests a suppressor activity might be present during subsequent pregnancies that reduces the responsiveness of lymphocytes from pregnant hamsters to stimulation by fetal antigens on tumor cells. Using a lymphocyte transformation assay, spleen cells from pregnant hamsters were found to be incapable of responding to preparations of either hamster fetal tissue or SV40-transformed cells. However, a suppressor component can be demonstrated in spleen cell populations of both primi- and multiparous hamsters during pregnancy that is capable of reducing the response of lymphocytes sensitized against SV40 tumor-associated antigens. The degree of suppression is proportional to the ratio of responder cells to spleen cells from pregnant animals. These results suggest there is a subpopulation of spleen cells involved in immunoregulation during pregnancy that has the ability to suppress the reactivity of lymphocytes sensitized against SV40-associated oncofetal antigens.     

Thymus-derived lymphocyte-dependent rejection of syngeneic papovavirus (SV40) and methylcholanthrene tumors in inbred hamsters.

Treatment of specifically sensitized MHA hamster lymphoid cells with rabbit antisera specific for hamster thymus-derived lymphocytes, in the presence of C, eliminated those cells capable of inhibiting the growth of syngeneic SV40 and methylcholanthrene tumors in vivo. Thymectomized, lethally-irradiated, bone marrow-reconstituted hamsters, shown to be devoid to T cell function, were, after attempted specific sensitization to the two syngeneic tumor cell lines, unable to reject either tumor by direct challenge in vivo. In addition, lymphocytes from such animals were incapable of inhibiting the growth of either tumor cell line in normal syngeneic recepients in the tumor cell neutralization assay. These data strongly support the conclusion that specifically sensitized thymus-derived lymphocytes are required for the rejection of syngeneic SV40 and methylcholanthrene tumors in inbred hamsters.     

Rejection of B16 melanoma induced by expression of a transfected major histocompatibility complex class I gene.

Transfection of a functional major histocompatibility complex class I gene into certain tumor cells, induced by oncogenic viruses or chemical carcinogens, can effectively abrogate their tumorigenic activity. Since experimentally induced tumors possess strong tumor-specific transplantation antigens, expression of cell surface class I antigens may present the tumor cells to appropriate immune effector cells. Most spontaneously arising tumors do not possess tumor-specific transplantation antigens, and their tumorigenicity may not be affected by the expression of a transfected class I gene. We demonstrate that the poorly immunogenic B16-BL6 melanoma can be rendered nontumorigenic in syngeneic mice by the expression of the class I H-2K antigen but not the class II I-A antigen. Furthermore, the poorly tumorigenic, class I-expressing B16-BL6-transfected cells can effectively immunize syngeneic C57BL/6 mice against the highly tumorigenic, class I-deficient B16-BL6 parental cells. Our success in experimentally manipulating the tumorigenicity of a spontaneously derived neoplasm offers hope for a potential modality for the effective treatment of human cancer.