Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains I. The Staining Properties of Thionin and its Derivatives as Compared with Their Chemical Formulae

An investigation has been made of the staining properties of eight dyes of the thionin group. The dyes studied are as follows: tetra-ethyl thionin, asymmetrical di-ethyl thionin, tetra-methyl thionin (methylene blue), tri-methyl thionin (azure B), asymmetrical di-methyl thionin (azure A), symmetrical di-methyl thionin, mono-methyl thionin (azure C), and unsubstituted thionin. The staining properties were tested on sections of paraffin embedded material following five different methods of fixation. No counterstain was employed. It was shown that there was a general correlation between the extent of ethylation or methylation of the dyes and their staining properties. As one passes from tetra-ethyl thionin down the series to thionin itself, there is a progressive decrease in the amount of green showing in the preparations, and an increase in the amount of red present, also an increase in the metachromatic effects, and in the intensity of nuclear staining. There seems, also, to be a similar relation between staining qualities on the one hand and the color and solubility of the dye base on the other.     

The Oxidation Products of Methylene Blue

The mechanism of the oxidation of methylene blue varies with the conditions. The formation of trimethyl thionin (azure B) and of asymmetrical dimethyl thionolin (azure A) is followed under alkaline conditions by that of dimethyl thionin (methylene violet) and under acid conditions by that of monomethyl thionin (named by authors azure C).

Simple and practical methods are given for the preparation of azure A and azure C. The latter product, which has not been obtained from methylene blue hitherto, has valuable staining properties as a nuclear and bacterial stain in tissue and may also be employed satisfactorily as a substitute for azure A in the MacNeal tetrachrome formula as a blood stain or substitute for the Giemsa stain.

Azure B has no particular merit in staining.

Azure C proves to be a very valuable stain. A procedure is given for its use with eosin Y and orange II as counterstains, by which it is possible to demonstrate bacteria in tissue and at the same time the cytological elements of the tissue.     

The suitability of further thiazine and quinoline dyes for topo-optical reactions on the plasmalemma (author's transl)]

The present studies prove that the thiazin dyes, azure B, azure C and thionin, and the quinolin dyes pinacyanol and its hydrochloride, are suitable for topo-optical staining of the plasmalemma. On the membrane surface the orientated bound dye molecules become stabilized, and with subsequent precipitation the anisotropic effect is reinforced. On optical analysis, the thiazin dye molecules (azure B, AZURE C and Thionin) are bound radially on the membrane. The molecules of the previously studied quinolin dye, N,N'-diethylpseudoisocyanide chloride are bound parallel to the membrane, while pinacyanol and its hydrochloride, like the thiazin dyes, are bound in the radial position.     

Mechanisms of Giemsa banding

Summary We investigated the capability of individual thiazins in Giemsa mixtures (methylene blue and azures A, B, and C) and of two related dyes (toluidine blue and thionin) to produce G-banding. We further tested the effects of variations of buffer composition and concentration, dye concentration, and staining time.G-banding was produced by all of the dyes at low concentrations, although differences were noted. Overall, methylene blue and azure B produced the best banding, azures A, C, and toluidine blue produced moderately good banding, and thionin produced poor banding. This order did not appear to be altered essentially by different treatments. The optimal conditions for G-banding for all dyes and treatments included the use of (1) 0.025–0.05M phosphate buffer, (2) dye concentrations of 0.002%–0.005%, and (3) staining times of 6–15 min.     

Purification of Thionin, Azure A, Azure B and Methylene Blue

Column and paper chromatography of four thiazin dyes revealed both inorganic and organic impurities. In thionin, azure A, azure B and methylene blue, sodium and other metal cations were found as inorganic impurities. The analysis for organic impurities revealed that the dyes were mixtures; specifically each dye contained one or more of the other dyes as impurities. Inorganic impurities were detected by ashing the dyes in the presence of H₂SO₄ and chromatographing the sulfate salts on paper. They were removed by filtration through ion exchange resins. Organic impurities were detected by paper chromatography and removed by column chromatography on Woelm's neutral alumina.     

Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains II. Influence of Buffered Solutions on Staining Properties

The effect of buffer solutions of varying reaction upon staining fixed sections with thionin, azures A, B, and C, and methylene blue has been studied. The buffer solutions were employed in one of three different ways: for pre-treatment of the sections, for post-treatment, or as solvents for the dyes. Regardless of the method of employing the buffer solutions it was found that the intensity of staining increased with increasing pH-values (a fact which is generally known to be true in the case of basic dyes). It is not certain whether this effect is due to varying the H-ion concentration or to altering the salt content of the solution, or to both. It was also noticed that there was one point where the staining intensify increased most rapidly. This point was either between pH 5 and pH 6 or between pH 6 and pH 7, its position varying with the method of fixation and of applying the buffer solutions. It was further observed that between pH 5 and pH 7 there were always more pronounced metachromatic effects than with either more acid or more alkaline buffer solutions.     

Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains II. Influence of Buffered Solutions on Staining Properties

The effect of buffer solutions of varying reaction upon staining fixed sections with thionin, azures A, B, and C, and methylene blue has been studied. The buffer solutions were employed in one of three different ways: for pre-treatment of the sections, for post-treatment, or as solvents for the dyes. Regardless of the method of employing the buffer solutions it was found that the intensity of staining increased with increasing pH-values (a fact which is generally known to be true in the case of basic dyes). It is not certain whether this effect is due to varying the H-ion concentration or to altering the salt content of the solution, or to both. It was also noticed that there was one point where the staining intensify increased most rapidly. This point was either between pH 5 and pH 6 or between pH 6 and pH 7, its position varying with the method of fixation and of applying the buffer solutions. It was further observed that between pH 5 and pH 7 there were always more pronounced metachromatic effects than with either more acid or more alkaline buffer solutions.     

Methods for the Standardization of Biological Stains Part V

In this paper are given the methods for determining the suitability of certain dyes of the pyronin, thiazin, oxazin, azin and natural dye groups for certification by the Commission on Standardization of Biological Stains. These methods have been developed by the Commission in cooperation with the Color and Farm Waste Division, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils, U. S. Department of Agriculture. The dyes for which the methods are given in the present paper are: Pyronin G, pyronin B, neutral red, safranin, nigrosin water-soluble, brilliant cresyl blue, cresyl violet, Nile blue A, thionin, methylene blue, methylene azure (azure A), azure C, toluidine blue O, indigo carmin (indigotine) and carmin. For each of these dyes methods are discussed under the following headings: (1) identification or qualitative examination; (2) quantitative analysis; and (3) biological tests.     

Methods for the Standardization of Biological Stains Part V

In this paper are given the methods for determining the suitability of certain dyes of the pyronin, thiazin, oxazin, azin and natural dye groups for certification by the Commission on Standardization of Biological Stains. These methods have been developed by the Commission in cooperation with the Color and Farm Waste Division, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils, U. S. Department of Agriculture. The dyes for which the methods are given in the present paper are: Pyronin G, pyronin B, neutral red, safranin, nigrosin water-soluble, brilliant cresyl blue, cresyl violet, Nile blue A, thionin, methylene blue, methylene azure (azure A), azure C, toluidine blue O, indigo carmin (indigotine) and carmin. For each of these dyes methods are discussed under the following headings: (1) identification or qualitative examination; (2) quantitative analysis; and (3) biological tests.     

Mediation of 8-hydroxy-guanine formation in DNA by thiazin dyes plus light

We have discovered that methylene blue plus light mediates the formation of 8-OHdG in DNA. Methylene blue is one of several thiazin dyes and we report here that the other thiazin dyes tested, in combination with white light, are effective in mediating 8-OHdG formation in DNA. The effectiveness of light plus the thiazin dyes in forming 8-OHdG in DNA were as follows: methylene blue greater than azure B greater than azure A greater than toluidine blue greater than thionin. Two other compounds tested; riboflavin and fuschin acid, in combination with light, caused formation of very little, if any, 8-OHdG in DNA. Thiazin dye mediated formation of 8-OHdG in DNA was not inhibited by the spin trap alpha-phenyl-t-butyl nitrone, which supports our previous observations that oxygen free radical scavengers did not inhibit methylene blue plus light mediated 8-OHdG formation in DNA. Ascorbate addition to methylene blue plus DNA, in the absence of light, was ineffective in mediating 8-OHdG formation in DNA.     

Qualitative Analysis by Thin-Layer Chromatography of Some Common Dyes Used in Biological Staining

Thin-layer chromatography will resolve impurities in commercial dyes, and will do so much faster than paper chromatography. Solvent systems consisting of (a) n-propanol: n-butanol: NH₄OH (conc.): H₂O—4:4:1:1; (b) n-propanol: NH₄OH (conc.): H₂O—8:1:1 on silica gel G plates; and (c) n-propanol: NH₄OH (conc.): H₂O-7:2:1 on Adsorbosil plates were found to be the most effective. Dyes studied were azure A, azure B, azure C, methylene blue, toluidine blue O, thionin, pyronin B, pyronin Y, methyl green, crystal violet amido black 10B and buffalo black (NBR).     

Improved Solvents for Paper Chromatography of Thiazine Stains

Paper chromatography with new solvents applied to some commercial samples of thiazine stains, especially azures, resulted in improved resolution which gave more spots than had been obtained with previously reported solvents. To a Whatman No. 1 filter paper strip, 50 cm in length, 0.08 ml of a 0.1% solution in water was spotted 18 cm from the edge of the strip. The solvent used in most cases was a mixture of t-butylalcohol, methylcellosolve and a 1% NH₄Cl solution in distilled water (60:20:20, v/v) with the ascending technique. Several batches of thionin were found to have a high degree of purity (concerning their content of coloured components). One sample of thionin (Chroma) contained only one component (violet). The thionin-SO₂ reagent showed a chromatogram with more spots than the thionin sample from which the reagent was prepared. Qualitatively a sample of azure A appeared to have practically the same composition as a sample of azure C. At least six spots were visible in the chromatogram of these azures, which contain thionin in addition to the other components.     

The Spectrophotometric Evaluation of Mixtures of Methylene Blue and Trimethyl Thionin

Spectrophotometric analysis affords the most convenient means for determining the proportion of methylene blue and trimethyl thionin (azure B) present in a mixture of these two dyes. The method proposed depends upon the determination of an “absorption ratio.” A suitable ratio for the purpose is that of the extinction coefficient at 640 mμ to that at 670 mμ. On account of the difference in absorption maxima of the two dyes, this ratio increases as the percentage of methylene blue decreases. The ratio value for eleven different mixtures is given and a graph is plotted from this data by means of which the proportions of the two dyes present in any mixture can be calculated from the absorption ratio determined as specified.     

Zur Eignung weiterer Thiazin- bzw. Chinolinfarbstoffe für die topo-optische Reaktion am Plasmalemm

Zusammenfassung Die hier durchgeführten Untersuchungen erwiesen, daß die Thiazinfarbstoffe Azur B, Azur C und Thionin sowie der Chinolinfarbstoff Pinacyanol bzw. sein Hydrochlorid für die topooptische Reaktion am Plasmalemm geeignent sind.-Die an der Membranoberfläche orientiert gebundenen Farbstoffmoleküle werden durch eine nachträgliche Präzipitation stabilisiert und gleichzeitig wird der anisotrope Effekt verstärkt.-Die Thiazinfarbstoffmoleküle (Azur B, Azur C, Thionin) sind nach der optischen Analyse radiär zur Membran ausgerichtet.-Gegenüber dem früher untersuchten Chinolinfarbstoff N,N-Diäthylpseudoisocyaninchlorid, dessen Farbstoffmoleküle parallel zur Membran lagen, sind das Pinacyanol bzw. sein Hydrochlorid in gleicher Weise, wie die Thiazinfarbstoffe radiär zur Membran ausgerichtet.

---

The suitability of further thiazin and quinolin dyes for topo-optical reactions on the plasmalemma

Summary The present studies prove that the thiazin dyes, azure B, azure C and thionin, and the quinolin dyes pinacyanol and its hydrochloride, are suitable for topo-optical staining of the plasmalemma. On the membrane surface the orientated bound dye molecules become stabilized, and with subsequent precipitation the anisotropic effect is reinforced. On optical analysis, the thiazin dye molecules (azure B, azure C and Thionin) are bound radially on the membrane. The molecules of the previously studied quinolin dye, N,N-diethylpseudoisocyanide chloride are bound parallel to the membrane, while pinacyanol and its hydrochloride, like the thiazin dyes, are bound in the radial position.

     

The Spectrophotometric Evaluation of Mixtures of Methylene Blue and Trimethyl Thionin

Spectrophotometric analysis affords the most convenient means for determining the proportion of methylene blue and trimethyl thionin (azure B) present in a mixture of these two dyes. The method proposed depends upon the determination of an “absorption ratio.” A suitable ratio for the purpose is that of the extinction coefficient at 640 mμ to that at 670 mμ. On account of the difference in absorption maxima of the two dyes, this ratio increases as the percentage of methylene blue decreases. The ratio value for eleven different mixtures is given and a graph is plotted from this data by means of which the proportions of the two dyes present in any mixture can be calculated from the absorption ratio determined as specified.     

Additional Schiff-Type Reagents for Use in Cytochemistry

Twenty-four new Schiff-type reagents were discovered in a survey of 140 different dyes. These dyes include acid fuchsin, acridine yellow, acriflavine hydrochloride, azure C., Bismarck brown R, Bismarck brown Y, celestine blue B, chrysoidine 3R, chrysoidine Y extra, cresyl violet, crystal violet, gentian violet, methylene blue, neutral violet, phenosafranin, phosphine GN, proflavine, toluidine blue O, and toluylene blue. Positive results obtained with crystal violet and a few samples of methylene blue are considered due to impurities. Various chemical extractions, aldehyde blocking reagents, and enzymatic treatments were used to verify the aldehyde specificity of the above dye-SO₂, reagents as well as azure A, brilliant cresyl blue, neutral red, safranin O, and thionin which have been mentioned by other workers. These reagents were tested in the Feulgen reaction for DNA and the PAS reaction for polysaccharides. Absorption curves were obtained from individual nuclei stained for DNA. The absorption peaks ranged from 450 mμ, to 630 mμ. depending on the dye studied. The Feulgen reaction could be followed by the PAS reaction or vice versa in mouse intestine using reactive dyes of complementary colors. The evidence indicates that a potential Schiff-type reagent must have at least one free NH₂ group on the dye molecule.     

Can azur-B eosin replace the May-Grünwald-Giemsa stain?]

A new method is described for staining blood and bone marrow smears. It is characterized by the presence of only two dyes, purified azure B and eosin in methanol, as stock solutions. Staining results are equivalent to those obtained by using the traditional dye mixtures according to May and Grunwald, Giemsa, Leishman or Wright. Different from these azure B-eosin staining can be standardized and is easier to be handled. Correlations between the azure-B-eosin and May-Grunwald-Giemsa (MGG) staining methods are briefly discussed.     

Standardization of the Papanicolaou stain. I. A comparison of five nuclear stains.

The staining characteristics of five nuclear stains used in a Papanicolaou staining procedure were investigated. Alcohol-fixed cervical smears were stained with a modified Papanicolaou procedure using hematoxylin, alcoholic thionin bromide, alcoholic Victoria blue B, gallocyanin or the thionin Feulgen reagent (thionin-SO2) as the nuclear stain. The same anionic counterstain was used for all slides, and the optical densities of cell nuclei and cytoplasm were measured with the IBAS 2000 image analyzer. Alcoholic thionin gave the most intense nuclear stain, with a very high reproducibility of the staining pattern. Hematoxylin showed the highest coefficient of variation of the staining intensity. Both hematoxylin and gallocyanin gave some nonspecific cytoplasmic staining. Thionin-SO2 allowed a quantitative assessment of DNA, but gave a low staining intensity. Staining with the metal complex dyes interfered with subsequent staining with the pararosaniline Feulgen reagent. Alcoholic thioinin is thus recommended as a nuclear stain for cervical cytology in the Papanicolaou procedure, both for image analysis and for visual microscopy.     

Understanding Romanowsky staining. I: The Romanowsky-Giemsa effect in blood smears

Normal blood smears were stained by the standardised azure B-eosin Y Romanowsky procedure recently introduced by the ICSH, and the classical picture resulted. The effects of varying the times and temperature of staining, the composition of the solvent (buffer concentration, methanol content, & pH), the concentration of the dyes, and the mode of fixation were studied. The results are best understood in terms of the following staining mechanism. Initial colouration involves simple acid and basic dyeing. Eosin yields red erythrocytes and eosinophil granules. Azure B very rapidly gives rise to blue stained chromatin, neutrophil specific granules, platelets and ribosome-rich cytoplasms; also to violet basophil granules. Subsequently the azure B in certain structures combines with eosin to give purple azure B-eosin complexes, leaving other structures with their initial colours. The selectivity of complex formation is controlled by rate of entry of eosin into azure B stained structures. Only faster staining structures (i.e. chromatin, neutrophil specific granules, and platelets) permit formation of the purple complex in the standard method. This staining mechanism illuminates scientific problems (e.g. the nature of 'toxic' granules) and assists technical trouble-shooting (e.g. why nuclei sometimes stain blue, not purple).     

Spectrophotometric and cytochemical studies on azures A, B and C.

The cytochemical use of azures A, B and C, propared with either N HCL and potassium metabisulphite or with sodium hydrosulphite in tissue sections were investigated. Both in situ absorption curves of nuclei stained with each of these dye-SO2 reagents as well as in vitro absorption data of acqueous solutions of the dyes are also presented. It has been pointed out that the mechanism of staining with azure A-SO2 and azure C Eosinate-SO2 is the same as that of the conventional Feulgen reaction with Schiff reagent but that of staining with azure B-SO2 is by the modified Feulgen reaction because this dye does not contain any primary amino group.