Additive polymorphisms and reticulation in an ITS phylogeny of thrifts (Armeria, Plumbaginaceae)

A parsimony analysis of 133 sequences of the nuclear ribosomal DNA ITS1 + 5.8S + ITS2 region from 71 taxa in Armeria was carried out. The presence of additive polymorphic sites (APS; occurring in 14 accessions) fits the reticulate scenario proposed in previous work for explaining the ITS pattern of variation on a much smaller scale and is based mainly on the geographical structure of the data, irrespective of taxonomic boundaries. Despite the relatively low bootstrap values and large polytomies, part of which are likely due to disruptive effects of reticulation and concerted evolution in these multicopy sequences, the ITS analysis has phylogenetic and biogeographic implications. APS detected in this study are consistent with hypothesized hybridization events, although biased concerted evolution, previously documented in the genus, needs to be invoked for specific cases and may be responsible for a possible “sink” effect in terminals from a large clade. The causes for sequences of the same species appearing in different clades (here termed transclade) are discussed.     

Intragenomic variation in the ITS rDNA region obscures phylogenetic relationships and inflates estimates of operational taxonomic units in genus Laetiporus

Regions of rDNA are commonly used to infer phylogenetic relationships among fungal species and as DNA barcodes for identification. These regions occur in large tandem arrays, and concerted evolution is believed to reduce intragenomic variation among copies within these arrays, although some variation still might exist. Phylogenetic studies typically use consensus sequencing, which effectively conceals most intragenomic variation, but cloned sequences containing intragenomic variation are becoming prevalent in DNA databases. To understand effects of using cloned rDNA sequences in phylogenetic analyses we amplified and cloned the ITS region from pure cultures of six Laetiporus species and one Wolfiporia species (Basidiomycota, Polyporales). An average of 66 clones were selected randomly and sequenced from 21 cultures, producing a total of 1399 interpretable sequences. Significant variation (≥ 5% variation in sequence similarity) was observed among ITS copies within six cultures from three species clades (L. cincinnatus, L. sp. clade J, and Wolfiporia dilatohypha) and phylogenetic analyses with the cloned sequences produced different trees relative to analyses with consensus sequences. Cloned sequences from L. cincinnatus fell into more than one species clade and numerous cloned L. cincinnatus sequences fell into entirely new clades, which if analyzed on their own most likely would be recognized as "undescribed" or "novel" taxa. The use of a 95% cut off for defining operational taxonomic units (OTUs) produced seven Laetiporus OTUs with consensus ITS sequences and 20 OTUs with cloned ITS sequences. The use of cloned rDNA sequences might be problematic in fungal phylogenetic analyses, as well as in fungal bar-coding initiatives and efforts to detect fungal pathogens in environmental samples.     

Fine-scale geographical structure, intra-individual polymorphism and recombination in nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacers in Armeria (Plumbaginaceae)

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Isolation and drift are the main causes for geographic structure of molecular variation. In contrast, the one found in a previous survey in Armeria (Plumbaginaceae) for nuclear ribosomal ITS multicopy regions was species-independent and has been hypothesized to be due to extensive gene-flow and biased concerted evolution. Since this was inferred from a genus-level phylogenetic analysis, the aim of this study was to check for the occurrence of such structure and the validity of the proposed model at a local scale, in a southern Spanish massif (Sierra Nevada), as well as to examine the evolutionary implications at the organism level. METHODS: In addition to 117 sequences of direct PCR products from genomic DNA, 50 sequences of PCR products from cloned DNA were obtained to analyse cases of intragenomic polymorphisms for the ITS regions. KEY RESULTS: Sequence data confirm the occurrence of a species-independent structure at a local scale and reveal insights through the analysis of contact areas between different ITS copies (ribotypes). A comparison between cloned and direct sequences (a) confirms that, within these contact areas, ITS copies co-occur both in different individuals and within single genomes; and (b) reveals recombination between different copies. CONCLUSIONS: This study supports the utility of direct sequences for detecting intra-individual polymorphism and for partially inferring the ITS copies involved, given previous knowledge of the variability. The main evolutionary implication at the organism level is that gene-flow and concerted evolution shape the geographic structure of ITS variation.     

Can Extensive Reticulation and Concerted Evolution Result in a Cladistically Structured Molecular Data Set?

Hierarchy is the main criterion for informativeness in a data set, even if no explicit reference to evolution as a causal process is provided. Sequence data (nuclear ribosomal DNA ITS) from Armeria (Plumbaginaceae) contains a certain amount of hierarchical structure as suggested by data decisiveness and distribution of tree lengths. However, ancillary evidence suggests that extensive gene flow and biased concerted evolution in these multicopy regions have significantly shaped the ITS data set. This argument is discussed using parsimony analysis of four data sets, constructed by combining wild sequences with those from different generations of artificial hybrids (wild + F₁, F₂, and backcrosses; wild + backcrosses; wild + F₁; wild + F₂). Compared to the F₁ hybrids, F₂ show a certain degree of homogenization in polymorphic sites. This effect reduces topological disruption caused by F₁ and is considered to be illustrative of how extensive gene flow and biased concerted evolution may have modeled the wild ITS data. The possibility that hierarchy has arisen as a result of—or despite a significant contribution from—those two such potentially perturbing forces raises the question of what kind of signal are we recovering from this molecular data set.     

Evolution of Internal Transcribed Spacer Region of Nuclear Ribosomal DNA in Allopolyploids of Aegilops

Hybridization with subsequent polyploidy is a prominent process in evolution of higher plants, but few data address the evolution of homeologous sequences after polyploidy. The internal transcribed spacer (ITS) of nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA) from eleven allopolyploid species in Aegilops was investigated by PCR amplification and direct sequencing. The sequences obtained were used to study the evolution of ITS region in allopolyploid species. The length of ITS region varied from 599 to 606 bp and the number of variable sites was 93, i.e. 51 and 42 for ITS1 and ITS2 re spectively. Some polymorphic sites were observed in polyploid species, and this indicated that the ancestral sequences had not been homogenized completely by concerted evolution. Distance matrix analysis of diploid and polyploid species by neighbor-joining method, using Triticum monococcum as outgroup, resulted in well-resolved neighbor-joining tree indicating that the ITS regions of UUMM and UUSS genome ( sect. Vertebrata) were homogenizing toward those of UU ancestal genome. This result is in agreement with the results of ctyogenetics of Aegilops. On the other hand, the neighbor joining tree including the D-genome group species (sect. Cylindropyrum and sect. Polyeides ) com prised three clades (CC-DDCC, UU-DDMM-DDMMSS-DDMMUU and MM-DDMvMv), which sug gested that concerted evolution was homogenizing the ITS region of the polyploid derivatives to either of their ancestors.     

四照花亚属的nrDNA ITS致同进化不完全

四照花亚属(Cornus subg.Syncarpea)隶属于山茱萸科山茱萸属(Cornus),我国该亚属共有5种8亚种。为探讨四照花亚属nrDNA ITS序列的致同进化不完全现象及假基因产生的可能原因,分析了该亚属4种(每种1~2个居群)共21个个体的nrDNA ITS序列。结果表明,这些类群的nrDNA ITS存在多态性,通过分析这些nrDNA ITS克隆序列的G+C含量、5.8S保守基序和二级结构最小自由能,推测其可能存在假基因。系统发育研究结果显示所有nrDNA ITS序列分成5个分支,同一个体的不同拷贝被分别置于两个甚至多个分支中,且不同分支显示了不同种间关系。四照花亚属物种个体内部存在nrDNA ITS不完全致同进化,可能归咎于不完全的世系分选(incomplete lineage sorting)、种间杂交或多倍化等进化事件,从而导致基因组内nrITS区序列出现多态性,同时也导致难以通过外部形态来划分亚属内种间界限。     

The evolution pattern of rDNA ITS in Avena and phylogenetic relationship of the Avena species (Poaceae: Aveneae)

Ribosomal ITS sequences are commonly used for phylogenetic reconstruction because they are included in rDNA repeats, and these repeats often undergo rapid concerted evolution within and between arrays. Therefore, the rDNA ITS copies appear to be virtually identical and can sometimes be treated as a single gene. In this paper we examined ITS polymorphism within and among 13 diploid (A and C genomes), seven tetraploid (AB, AC and CC genomes) and four hexaploid (ACD genome) to infer the extent and direction of concerted evolution, and to reveal the phylogenetic and genome relationship among species of Avena. A total of 170 clones of the ITS1-5.8S-ITS2 fragment were sequenced to carry out haplotype and phylogenetic analysis. In addition, 111 Avena ITS sequences retrieved from GenBank were combined with 170 clones to construct a phylogeny and a network. We demonstrate the major divergence between the A and C genomes whereas the distinction among the A and B/D genomes was generally not possible. High affinity among the A(d) genome species A. damascena and the ACD genome species A. fatua was found, whereas the rest of the ACD genome hexaploids and the AACC tetraploids were highly affiliated with the A(l) genome diploid A. longiglumis. One of the AACC species A. murphyi showed the closest relationship with most of the hexaploid species. Both C(v) and C(p) genome species have been proposed as paternal donors of the C-genome carrying polyploids. Incomplete concerted evolution is responsible for the observed differences among different clones of a single Avena individual. The elimination of C-genome rRNA sequences and the resulting evolutionary inference of hexaploid species are discussed.     

苏铁nrDNA ITS区的序列多态性:不完全致同进化的证据

本研究对苏铁(Cycas revoluta) nrDNA ITS进行克隆测序, 并以cDNA ITS为参照, 比较分析获得的序列的碱基变异、GC含量、5.8S二级结构的稳定性和5.8S保守基序的有无以及系统发育关系。结果发现苏铁nrDNA ITS存在较高的基因组内多样性, 同时, 这些分化的nrDNA ITS拷贝中包含有假基因的存在, 而且假基因与功能拷贝之间已经形成了较大的遗传分化, 这暗示假基因起源有较长历史。苏铁核仁组织区不仅多达16个, 而且分布在13条染色体上, 这可能是其nrDNA ITS致同进化不完全的主要原因。     

Nuclear ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer 1 (ITS1) in Picea (Pinaceae): sequence divergence and structure

The nrDNA ITS1 of Picea is 2747-3271 bp, the longest known of all plants. We obtained 24 cloned ITS1 sequences from six individuals of Picea glehnii, Picea mariana, Picea orientalis, and Picea rubens. Mean sequence divergence within these individuals (0.018+/-0.009) is more than half that between the species (0.031+/-0.011) and may be maintained against concerted evolution by separation of Picea 18S-26S rDNA repeats on multiple chromosomes. Picea ITS1 contains three subrepeats with a motif (5'-GGCCACCCTAGTC) that is conserved across Pinaceae. Two subrepeats are tandem, remote from the third, and more closely related and significantly more similar to one another than either is to the third subrepeat. This correlation between similarity and proximity may be the result of subrepeat duplication or concerted evolution within rDNA repeats. In inferred secondary structures, subrepeats generally form long hairpins, with a portion of the Pinaceae conserved motif in the terminal loop, and tandem subrepeats pair with one another over most of their length. Coalescence of ITS1 sequences occurs in P. orientalis but not in the other species.     

Species relationships between antifungal chitinase and nuclear rDNA (internal transcribed spacer) sequences in the genus Hordeum.

The sequences of the chitinase gene (Chi-26) and the internal transcribed spacer of 18S - 5.8S - 26S rDNA (ITS1) were determined to analyze the phylogenetic relationships among species representing the four basic genomes of the genus Hordeum. Grouping analysis based on data for Chi-26 gene sequences placed Hordeum secalinum (H genome) near the Hordeum murinum complex (Xu genome), and Hordeum bulbosum distant from the other species that carried the I genome. ITS sequence data showed the expected grouping based on the genome classification of the species studied. Different sequences of ITS were detected even in the genomes of the diploid species. The results are interpreted in terms of defective or unfinished concerted evolution processes in each taxon.     

The evolution and utility of ribosomal ITS sequences in Bambusinae and related species: divergence, pseudogenes, and implications for phylogeny

Ribosomal internal transcribed spacer (ITS) sequences are commonly used for phylogenetic reconstruction because they are highly reiterated as components of rDNA repeats, and hence are often subject to rapid homogenization through concerted evolution. Concerted evolution leads to intragenomic uniformity of repeats even between loci on nonhomologous chromosomes. However, a number of studies have shown that the ITS polymorphism within individuals is quite common. The molecular systematics of Bambusinae and related species were recently assessed by different teams using independently generated ITS sequences, and the results disagreed in some remarkable features. Here we compared the ITS sequences of the members of Bambusa s. l., the genera Dendrocalamus, Dinochloa, Gigantochloa, Guadua, Melocalamus, Monocladus, Oxytenanthera, Thyrsostachys, Pleioblastus, Pseudosasa and Schizostachyum.We have reanalysed the ITS sequences used by different research teams to reveal the underlying patterns of their different results. After excluding the sequences suspected to represent paralogous loci, a phylogenetic analysis of the subtribe Bambusinae species were performed using maximum parsimony and maximum-likelihood methods. The implications of the findings are discussed. The risk of incorporating ITS paralogues in plant evolutionary studies that can distort the phylogenetic signal should caution molecular systematists.     

ITS sequence variation and concerted evolution in the natural hybrid species Malus toringoides

The internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA) is one of the most used molecular characters in plant systematics. Our previous studies based on morphological analysis and ITS sequence variation suggested that Malus toringoides (Rehd.) Hughes is derived from hybridization between M. transitoria (Batal.) Schneid. and M. kansuensis (Batal.) Schneid. To further understand the variation pattern of ITS sequences in M. toringoides, and to elucidate the evolutionary processes that affect ITS sequence variation after hybridization, we sampled 99 accessions from multiple populations of the hybrid and parental species, and then obtained totally 254 ITS sequences by cloning and sequencing. Our ITS variation data demonstrates three outcomes of ITS repeats after hybrid speciation. ～ 27–41% of M. toringoides have only M. transitoria type ITS sequence, ～ 40–70% have M. transitoria type ITS sequence plus one or two chimeric ITS sequences generated by recombination between parental ITS sequences, and six accessions retain both parental type ITS sequences. The plausible evolutionary processes that created the observed ITS variations were inferred to be the joint actions of recombination, concerted evolution, pseudogenization and backcrossing. Our study provides further understandings of the variation model of ITS repeats after hybridization as well as the evolution of M. toringoides after its hybrid speciation.     

Multiple origins and nrDNA internal transcribed spacer homeologue evolution in the Glycine tomentella (Leguminosae) allopolyploid complex

Despite the importance of polyploidy in the evolution of plants, patterns of molecular evolution and genomic interactions following polyploidy are not well understood. Nuclear ribosomal DNA is particularly complex with respect to these genomic interactions. The composition of nrDNA tandem arrays is influenced by intra- and interlocus concerted evolution and their expression is characterized by patterns such as nucleolar dominance. To understand these complex interactions it is important to study them in diverse natural polyploid systems. In this study we use direct sequencing to isolate and characterize nrDNA internal transcribed spacer (ITS) homeologues from multiple accessions of six different races in the Glycine tomentella allopolyploid complex. The results indicate that in most allopolyploid accessions both homeologous nrDNA repeats are present, but that there are significant biases in copy number toward one homeologue, possibly resulting from interlocus concerted evolution. The predominant homeologue often differs between races and between accessions within a race. A phylogenetic analysis of ITS sequences provides evidence for multiple origins in several of the polyploid races. This evidence for diverse patterns of nrDNA molecular evolution and multiple origins of polyploid races will provide a useful system for future studies of natural variation in patterns of nrDNA expression.     

Evolution of the 5.8S nrDNA gene and internal transcribed spacers in Carapichea ipecacuanha (Rubiaceae) within a phylogeographic context

Nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA) constitutes a multicopy gene family that is used widely to test evolutionary hypotheses across a broad range of organisms. It is presumed that, as a result of concerted evolution, tandem nrDNA repeats are homogeneous within species and different between species. We sampled 77 specimens of a disjunct species (Carapichea ipecacuanha) from throughout its three geographic ranges and obtained 266 nrDNA sequences, of which 26 were obtained by direct sequencing and 240 by cloning of PCR products. Complementary sequence analyses, which included analyses of secondary structure stability, the pattern of base substitutions, GC content, and the presence of conserved motifs, were used to characterize the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region (ITS1-5.8S nrDNA-ITS2). Our results showed that concerted evolution of the ITS region was incomplete in C. ipecacuanha, particularly in the Atlantic range. In the highly polymorphic populations of the Atlantic range, intraindividual variation was observed and involved 56 functional paralogs and 15 pseudogenes from two highly divergent ribogroups. The Amazonian range (with 12 functional paralogs) and the Central-American range (with five functional paralogs) were genetically depauperate and exhibited no pseudogenes. In the two latter ranges, almost complete homogenization of the ITS sequences had occurred. We argue that it is important to consider past evolutionary history when making inferences about the efficiency with which concerted evolution homogenizes tandem nrDNA repeats a single sequence.     

Nonuniform concerted evolution and chloroplast capture: heterogeneity of observed introgression patterns in three molecular data partition phylogenies of Asian Mitella (saxifragaceae)

Interspecific hybridization is one of the major factors leading to phylogenetic incongruence among loci, but the knowledge is still limited about the potential of each locus to introgress between species. By directly sequencing three DNA regions: chloroplast DNAs (matK gene and trnL-F noncoding region), the nuclear ribosomal external transcribed spacer (ETS) region, and internal transcribed spacer (ITS) regions, we construct three phylogenetic trees of Asian species of Mitella (Saxifragaceae), a genus of perennials in which natural hybrids are commonly observed. Within this genus, there is a significant topological conflict between chloroplast and nuclear phylogenies and also between the ETS and the ITS, which can be attributed to frequent hybridization within the lineage. Chloroplast DNAs show the most extensive introgression pattern, ITS regions show a moderate pattern, and the ETS region shows no evidence of introgression. Nonuniform concerted evolution best explains the difference in the introgression patterns between the ETS region and ITS regions, as the sequence heterogeneity of the ITS region within an individual genome is estimated to be twice that of an ETS in this lineage. Significant gene conversion patterns between two hybridizing taxa were observed in contiguous arrays of cloned ETS-ITS sequences, further confirming that only ITS regions have introgressed bidirectionally. The relatively slow concerted evolution in the ITS regions probably allows the coexistence of multiple alleles within a genome, whereas the strong concerted evolution in the ETS region rapidly eliminates heterogeneous alleles derived from other species, resulting in species delimitations highly concordant with those based on morphology. This finding indicates that the use of multiple molecular tools has the potential to reveal detailed organismal evolution processes involving interspecific hybridization, as an individual locus varies greatly in its potential to introgress between species.     

Nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA) concerted evolution in natural and artificial hybrids of Armeria (Plumbaginaceae)

Nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA) internal transcribed spacer (ITS) sequences from artificial hybrids and backcrosses between Armeria villosa ssp. longiaristata and A. colorata were studied to assess the possible effects of concerted evolution in natural hybrids. F1 artificial hybrids show the expected pattern of additive polymorphisms for five of the six variable sites as estimated from direct sequences. However, homogenization of polymorphism is already observed in the F2, and is biased towards A. colorata except for one site. In backcrosses, an expected tendency towards homogenization of polymorphic sites in the direction of the recurrent parent is observed for five sites, although this does not necessarily imply concerted evolution. Conversely, the sixth site appears to elude such a mechanism and thus provides additional support for the occurrence of biased concerted evolution. Our findings are relevant to interpreting phylogeographic patterns involving gene flow and are also consistent with the hypothesis of a hybrid origin of A. villosa ssp. carratracensis.     

Persistent nuclear ribosomal DNA sequence polymorphism in the Amelanchier agamic complex (Rosaceae)

Individual plants of several Amelanchier taxa contain many polymorphic nucleotide sites in the internal transcribed spacers (ITS) of nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA). This polymorphism is unusual because it is not recent in origin and thus has resisted homogenization by concerted evolution. Amelanchier ITS sequence polymorphism is hypothesized to be the result of gene flow between two major North American clades resolved by phylogenetic analysis of ITS sequences. Western North American species plus A. humilis and A. sanguinea of eastern North America form one clade (A), and the remaining eastern North American Amelanchier make up clade B. Five eastern North American taxa are polymorphic at many of the nucleotide sites where clades A and B have diverged and are thought to be of hybrid origin, with A. humilis or A. sanguinea as one parent and various members of clade B as the other parent. Morphological evidence suggests that A. humilis is one of the parents of one of the polymorphic taxa, a microspecies that we refer to informally as A. "erecta." Sequences of 21 cloned copies of the ITS1- 5.8S gene-ITS2 region from one A. "erecta" individual are identical to A. humilis sequence or to the clade B consensus sequence, or they are apparent recombinants of A. humilis and clade B ITS repeats. Amelanchier "erecta" and another polymorphic taxon are suspected to be relatively old because both grow several hundred kilometers beyond the range of one of their parents. ITS sequence polymorphisms have apparently persisted in these two taxa perhaps because of polyploidy and/or agamospermy (asexual seed production), which are prevalent in the genus.      

樟属植物ITS序列多态性分析

对樟科樟属(Cinnamomum Schaeffer) 17个代表样本的核糖体DNA内转录间隔区(nrDNA ITS)进行克隆测序。对获得的87条不同ITS序列的长度变异、GC含量、5.8S区二级结构的稳定性、遗传距离、进化模式以及系统发育关系进行了相关分析。研究结果显示, ITS序列在樟属植物内存在明显的多态性, 87条序列中的22条序列被鉴定为假基因序列, 其余65条序列为功能基因序列; 假基因序列采用中性进化模式, 变异明显大于功能序列。ITS序列在樟属植物中出现一致性进化不完全和假基因现象也可能发生在樟科其它类群中, 这可能是导致樟科植物ITS序列直接测序方式成功率低的重要原因。     

Application of ITS sequences of nuclear rDNA in phylogenetic and evolutionary studies of angiosperms

Nuclear rRNA genes (rDNA) in angiosperms are arranged in long tandem repeat ing units, much like those of other higher eukaryotes. Owing to rapid concerted evolution, the repeat units have homogenized or nearly so in most species. The internal transcribed spacer (ITS) of nuclear rDNA is composed of ITS1 and ITS2, which are seperated by 5.8S rDNA. The two spacers, ITS1 (187～298 bp) and ITS2 (187～252 bp), can be readily amplified by PCR and sequenced using universal primers. The sequences contain many vari able sites and potential informative sites among related species, and have been proven to be a useful molecular marker in phylogenetic and evolutionary studies of many angiosperm taxa. It can be used not only in classification and phylogenetic inferences at the levels of family, subfamily, tribe, genus and section, but also in reconstruction of reticulate evolution and de tection of the speciation via hybridization and polyploidization. But this region may not be useful for resolving phylogenetic relationships among families or taxa of higher hierarchy ow- ing to the rapid variation of the ITS sequences.     

ITS假基因对栎属系统学研究的影响及其对分子系统学研究的启示

核糖体rDNA ITS是被子植物系统发育研究中应用最广泛的分子标记之一。以前人们认为同一物种中的ITS序列因致同进化而使不同拷贝高度一致,在分子系统学研究中常以ITS1-5.8S-ITS2序列作为构建系统进化树的基础。近年来,在对一些被子植物的研究中发现这段序列在同一物种中具有多态性,有些拷贝中的5．8S区不具编码功能,人们把含有不具编码功能5．8S区的ITS1-5．8S-ITS2序列定义为ITS假基因序列,它对同源基因致同进化的假设形成了新的挑战。在诸多应用ITS序列重建系统进化关系的研究中,栎属系统学研究因ITS假基因的发现而倍受关注。本文以栎属为例回顾了ITS假基因的发现过程,分析了其对该属系统学研究的影响,为分子生物学在植物系统进化研究中的应用提供一些新的参考。