Finger-positional change in three zinc finger protein Sp1: influence of terminal finger in DNA recognition

The connection of functional modules is effective for the design of DNA binding molecules with the desired sequence specificity. C(2)H(2)-type zinc finger proteins have a tandemly repeated array structure consisting of independent finger modules and are expected to recognize any DNA sequences by permutation, multi-connection, and the substitution of various sets of zinc fingers. To investigate the effects of the replacement of the terminal finger on the DNA recognition by other fingers, we have constructed the three zinc finger peptides with finger substitution at the N- or C-terminus, Sp1(zf223), Sp1(zf323), and Sp1(zf321). From the results of gel mobility shift assays, each mutant peptide binds preferentially to the target sequence that is predicted if the fingers act in a modular fashion. The methylation interference analyses demonstrate that in the cases of the N-terminal finger substitution mutants, Sp1(zf223) and Sp1(zf323), the N-terminal finger recognizes bases to different extents from that of the wild-type peptide, Sp1(zf123). Of special interest is the fact that the N-terminal finger of the C-terminal finger substitution mutant, Sp1(zf321), shows a distinct base recognition from those of Sp1(zf123) and Sp1(zf323). DNase I footprinting analyses indicate that the C-terminal finger (active finger) induces a conformational change in the DNA in the region for the binding of the N-terminal finger (passive finger). The present results strongly suggest that the extent of base recognition of the N-terminal finger is dominated by the binding of the C-terminal finger. This information provides an important clue for the creation of a zinc finger peptide with the desired specificity, which is applicable to the design of novel drugs and biological tools.     

Novel zinc finger nuclease created by combining the Cys2His2- and His4-type zinc finger domains

To improve the DNA hydrolytic activity of the zinc finger nuclease, we have created a new artificial zinc finger nuclease (ZWH4) by connecting two distinct zinc finger domains possessing different types of Zn(II) binding sites (Cys₂His₂- and His₄-types). The overall fold of ZWH4 is similar to that of the wild-type Sp1 zinc finger (Sp1(zf123)) as revealed by circular dichroism spectroscopy. The gel mobility shift assay demonstrated that ZWH4 binds to the GC box DNA, although the DNA-binding affinity is lower than that of Sp1(zf123). Evidently, ZWH4 hydrolyzes the covalently closed circular plasmid DNA (form I) containing the GC box (pBSGC) to the linear duplex DNA (form III) in the presence of a higher concentration (50 times) of the protein than DNA for a 24-h reaction. Of special interest is the fact that the novel mixed zinc finger protein containing the Cys₂His₂- and His₄-type domains was first created. The present results provide the useful information for the redesign strategy of an artificial nuclease based on the zinc finger motif.     

Swapping of the beta-hairpin region between Sp1 and GLI zinc fingers: significant role of the beta-hairpin region in DNA binding properties of C2H2-type zinc finger peptides

The recent design strategy of zinc finger peptides has mainly focused on the alpha-helix region, which plays a direct role in DNA recognition. On the other hand, the study of non-DNA-contacting regions is extremely scarce. By swapping the beta-hairpin regions between the Sp1 and GLI zinc fingers, in this study, we investigated how the beta-hairpin region of the C(2)H(2)-type zinc finger peptides contributes to the DNA binding properties. Surprisingly, the Sp1 mutant with the GLI-type beta-hairpin had a higher DNA binding affinity than that of the wild-type Sp1. The result of the DNase I footprinting analyses also showed the change in the DNA binding pattern. In contrast, the GLI zinc finger completely lost DNA binding ability as a result of exchanging the beta-hairpin region. These results strongly indicate that the beta-hairpin region appears to function as a scaffold and has an important effect on the DNA binding properties of the C(2)H(2)-type zinc finger peptides.     

Exchange of histidine spacing between Sp1 and GLI zinc fingers: distinct effect of histidine spacing-linker region on DNA binding

In the DNA recognition mode of C(2)H(2)-type zinc fingers, the finger-finger connection region, consisting of the histidine spacing (HX(3-5)H) and linker, would be important for determining the orientation of the zinc finger domains. To clarify the influence of spacing between two ligand histidines in the DNA binding, we exchanged the histidine spacing between Sp1 and GLI zinc fingers, which have an HX(3)H-TGEKK linker (typical) and an HX(4)H-SNEKP linker (atypical), respectively. A significant decrease in the DNA binding affinity and specificity is found in Sp1-type peptides, whereas GLI-type peptides show a mild reduction. To evaluate the effect of the linker characteristics, we further designed Sp1-type mutants with an SNEKP linker. As a result, the significant effect of the histidine spacing in Sp1-type peptides was reduced. These results demonstrate that (1) the histidine spacing significantly affects the DNA binding of zinc finger proteins and (2) the histidine spacing and the following linker regions are one effective target for regulating the DNA recognition mode of zinc finger proteins.     

Interconversion between serine and aspartic acid in the alpha helix of the N-terminal zinc finger of Sp1: implication for general recognition code and for design of novel zinc finger peptide recognizing complementary strand

In the typical base recognition mode of the C(2)H(2)-type zinc finger, the amino acid residues at alpha-helical positions -1, 3, and 6 make a contact with the base in one strand (the primary strand), and the residue at position 2 interacts with the base in a complementary strand (the secondary strand). The N-terminal zinc finger of the three-zinc-finger domain of Sp1 has inherently a unique five-base-pair binding mode in which the guanine bases are recognized in both strands. To clarify the effect of the amino acid at position 2 on DNA binding affinity and base specificity, we have created a library of the mutants by the interconversion between serine and aspartic acid in the N-terminal zinc finger of Sp1 and recombinant variants of finger order. Gel mobility shift and methylation interference assays showed that the combination of arginine and serine at positions -1 and 2, respectively, provides a newly strong guanine contact in the secondary strand and a higher binding affinity than that of wild-type Sp1. Of special interest are the facts that the mutant with lysine and aspartic acid at positions -1 and 2 in the alpha helix predominantly recognizes the bases in the secondary strand and that its DNA binding affinity is higher than that of the wild-type. The aspartic acid or serine at position 2 independently contributes to the DNA binding affinity and base specificity. The present results provide useful information for the design of a novel zinc finger protein with priority for the bases in the secondary strand.     

Alpha-helical linker of an artificial 6-zinc finger peptide contributes to selective DNA binding to a discontinuous recognition sequence

Although many zinc finger motifs have been developed to recognize specific DNA triplets, a rational way to selectively skip a particular non-recognized gap in the DNA sequence has never been established. We have now created a 6-zinc finger peptide with an alpha-helix linker, Sp1ZF6(EAAAR)4, which selectively binds to the discontinuous recognition sites in the same phase (10 bp gap) against the opposite phase (5 bp gap) of the DNA helix. The linker peptide (EAAAR)4 forms an alpha-helix structure stabilized by salt bridges, and the helical length is estimated to be about 30 A, corresponding to that of the 10 bp DNA. The gel shift assays demonstrate that Sp1ZF6(EAAAR)4 preferably binds to the 10 bp-gapped target rather than the 5 bp-gapped target. The CD spectra show that the alpha-helical content of the (EAAAR)4 linker is higher in the complex with the 10 bp-gapped target than in the complex with the 5 bp-gapped target. The present results indicate that the alpha-helical linker is suitable for binding to the recognition sites in the same phase and that the linker induces the loss of binding affinity to the recognition sites with the opposite phase. The engineering of a helix-structured linker in the 6-zinc finger peptides should be one of the most promising approaches for selectively targeting discontinuous recognition sites depending on their phase situations.     

Arsenite interacts selectively with zinc finger proteins containing C3H1 or C4 motifs

Arsenic inhibits DNA repair and enhances the genotoxicity of DNA-damaging agents such as benzo[a]pyrene and ultraviolet radiation. Arsenic interaction with DNA repair proteins containing functional zinc finger motifs is one proposed mechanism to account for these observations. Here, we report that arsenite binds to both CCHC DNA-binding zinc fingers of the DNA repair protein PARP-1 (poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase-1). Furthermore, trivalent arsenite coordinated with all three cysteine residues as demonstrated by MS/MS. MALDI-TOF-MS analysis of peptides harboring site-directed substitutions of cysteine with histidine residues within the PARP-1 zinc finger revealed that arsenite bound to peptides containing three or four cysteine residues, but not to peptides with two cysteines, demonstrating arsenite binding selectivity. This finding was not unique to PARP-1; arsenite did not bind to a peptide representing the CCHH zinc finger of the DNA repair protein aprataxin, but did bind to an aprataxin peptide mutated to a CCHC zinc finger. To investigate the impact of arsenite on PARP-1 zinc finger function, we measured the zinc content and DNA-binding capacity of PARP-1 immunoprecipitated from arsenite-exposed cells. PARP-1 zinc content and DNA binding were decreased by 76 and 80%, respectively, compared with protein isolated from untreated cells. We observed comparable decreases in zinc content for XPA (xeroderma pigmentosum group A) protein (CCCC zinc finger), but not SP-1 (specificity protein-1) or aprataxin (CCHH zinc finger). These findings demonstrate that PARP-1 is a direct molecular target of arsenite and that arsenite interacts selectively with zinc finger motifs containing three or more cysteine residues.     

Effects of length and position of an extended linker on sequence-selective DNA recognition of zinc finger peptides

Engineered zinc finger proteins revealed that a linker sequence connecting zinc finger units has a significant effect on the DNA binding property of the protein. The recognition for a noncontiguous DNA target beyond the current recognition code of zinc finger proteins has never been determined because of the limitation of a zinc finger framework. DNA recognition of zinc finger proteins is limited only to a contiguous subset of three base pairs. We propose the recognition for a noncontiguous DNA target by inserting amino acids into the canonical linker between zinc finger units. The sequence selectivity of the new zinc finger peptides was evaluated by gel mobility shift assays. DNase I footprinting analyses clearly showed different DNA binding of various linker-extended zinc finger peptides. The application of a SPR measurement also revealed a DNA sequence selectivity of peptides. Insertion of three amino acids is enough for recognition of a noncontiguous DNA target with sequence selectivity. An extended linker will be useful for expansion of the recognition code of zinc finger proteins and for development of a new role for linker sequences in DNA binding of zinc finger proteins.     

DNA-induced alpha-helix capping in conserved linker sequences is a determinant of binding affinity in Cys(2)-His(2) zinc fingers

High-affinity, sequence-specific DNA binding by Cys(2)-His(2) zinc finger proteins is mediated by both specific protein-base interactions and non-specific contacts between charged side-chains and the phosphate backbone. In addition, in DNA complexes of multiple zinc fingers, protein-protein interactions between the finger units contribute to the binding affinity. We present NMR evidence for another contribution to high- affinity binding, a highly specific DNA-induced helix capping involving residues in the linker sequence between fingers. Capping at the C terminus of the alpha-helix in each zinc finger, incorporating a consensus TGEKP linker sequence that follows each finger, provides substantial binding energy to the DNA complexes of zinc fingers 1-3 of TFIIIA (zf1-3) and the four zinc fingers of the Wilms' tumor suppressor protein (wt1-4). The same alpha-helix C-capping motif is observed in the X-ray structures of four other protein-DNA complexes. The structures of each of the TGEKP linkers in these complexes can be superimposed on the linker sequences in the zf1-3 complex, revealing a remarkable similarity in both backbone and side-chain conformations. The canonical linker structures from the zinc-finger-DNA complexes have been compared to the NMR structure of the TGEKP linker connecting fingers 1 and 2 in zf1-3 in the absence of DNA. This comparison reveals that additional stabilization likely arises in the DNA complexes from hydrogen bonding between the backbone amide of E3 and the side-chain O(gamma) of T1 in the linker. We suggest that these DNA-induced C-capping interactions provide a means whereby the multiple-finger complex, which must necessarily be domain-flexible in the unbound state as it searches for the correct DNA sequence, can be "snap-locked" in place once the correct DNA sequence is encountered. These observations provide a rationale for the high conservation of the TGEKP linker sequences in Cys(2)-His(2) zinc finger proteins.     

Cooperative, non-specific binding of a zinc finger peptide to DNA.

The DNA binding and structural properties of Xfin-31 (Lee, M.S., Gippert, G.P., Soman, K.V., Case, D.A. and Wright, P.E., 1989, Science 245, 635-637), a twenty five amino acid zinc finger peptide, in the reduced, oxidized and zinc complex forms, as well as the fourteen residue helical segment of the zinc finger (residues 12-25) have been compared using affinity coelectrophoresis (ACE) and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. The zinc complex and oxidized peptides bind cooperatively to DNA although the cooperativity factor, omega, is more than 15-fold greater for the zinc complex. The reduced peptide in the absence of zinc and the helical segment do not bind cooperatively (omega = 1). Hence, the binding constant for singly contiguous sites (K omega) ranges over 100-fold for the various peptides even though the intrinsic binding constants (K) are similar. An increase in binding order and affinity for the other forms of Xfin-31 is correlated with an increasing similarity of the CD spectrum to that of the Xfin-31 zinc complex. The surprising DNA binding activity of the oxidized peptide may result from hydrophobic interactions between the amino-terminal loop formed by the Cys3-Cys6 disulfide bond and conserved hydrophobic residues in the carboxyl-terminal segment. Xfin-31 may be a particularly useful model for studying several poorly understood aspects of cooperative, non-specific DNA binding since it is small, has a stable, well-defined structure, and structures of zinc fingers bound to DNA have been determined.     

Prediction of DNA-binding specificity in zinc finger proteins

Zinc finger proteins interact via their individual fingers to three base pair subsites on the target DNA. The four key residue positions -1, 2, 3 and 6 on the alpha-helix of the zinc fingers have hydrogen bond interactions with the DNA. Mutating these key residues enables generation of a plethora of combinatorial possibilities that can bind to any DNA stretch of interest. Exploiting the binding specificity and affinity of the interaction between the zinc fingers and the respective DNA can help to generate engineered zinc fingers for therapeutic purposes involving genome targeting. Exploring the structure-function relationships of the existing zinc finger-DNA complexes can aid in predicting the probable zinc fingers that could bind to any target DNA. Computational tools ease the prediction of such engineered zinc fingers by effectively utilizing information from the available experimental data. A study of literature reveals many approaches for predicting DNA-binding specificity in zinc finger proteins. However, an alternative approach that looks into the physico-chemical properties of these complexes would do away with the difficulties of designing unbiased zinc fingers with the desired affinity and specificity. We present a physico-chemical approach that exploits the relative strengths of hydrogen bonding between the target DNA and all combinatorially possible zinc fingers to select the most optimum zinc finger protein candidate.     

Functional characterization of iron-substituted neural zinc finger factor 1: metal and DNA binding

Neural zinc finger factor 1 (NZF-1) is a nonclassical zinc finger protein involved in neuronal development. NZF-1 contains multiple copies of a unique CCHHC zinc-binding domain that recognize a promoter element in the β-retinoic acid receptor gene termed β-retinoic acid receptor element (β-RARE). Previous studies have established that a two-domain fragment of NZF-1 bound with zinc is sufficient for specific DNA binding. Proper functioning of the nervous system relies heavily on iron and misregulation of this highly redox active metal has serious consequences. Several classes of zinc finger proteins have been shown to bind other metal ions, including iron. To determine if ferrous iron can coordinate to the metal-binding sites of NZF-1 and assess the functional consequences of such coordination, a fragment of NZF-1 that contains two zinc-binding domains, NZF-1 double finger (NZF-1-DF), was prepared. UV–vis spectroscopy experiments demonstrated that Fe(II) is capable of binding to NZF-1-DF. Upon reconstitution with either Fe(II) or Zn(II), NZF-1-DF binds selectively and tightly (nanomolar affinity) to its target β-RARE DNA sequence, whereas apo-NZF-1-DF does not bind to DNA and instead aggregates.