Temperature-dependent subunit exchange and chaperone-like activities of Hsp16.3, a small heat shock protein from Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Small heat shock proteins (sHsps) usually exist as oligomers that undergo dynamic oligomeric dissociation/re-association, with the dissociated oligomers as active forms to bind substrate proteins under heat shock conditions. In this study, however, we found that Hsp16.3, one sHsp from Mycobacterium tuberculosis, is able to sensitively modulate its chaperone-like activity in a range of physiological temperatures (from 25 to 37.5 degrees C) while its native oligomeric size is still maintained. Further analysis demonstrated that Hsp16.3 exposes higher hydrophobic surfaces upon temperatures increasing and that a large soluble complex between Hsp16.3 and substrate is formed only in the condition of heating temperature up to 35 and 37.5 degrees C. Structural analysis by fluorescence anisotropy showed that Hsp16.3 nonameric structure becomes more dynamic and variable at elevated temperatures. Moreover, subunit exchange between Hsp16.3 oligomers was found to occur faster upon temperatures increasing as revealed by fluorescence energy resonance transfer. These observations indicate that Hsp16.3 is able to modulate its chaperone activity by adjusting the dynamics of oligomeric dissociation/re-association process while maintaining its static oligomeric size unchangeable. A kinetic model is therefore proposed to explain the mechanism of sHsps-binding substrate proteins through oligomeric dissociation. The present study also implied that Hsp16.3 is at least capable of binding non-native proteins in vivo while expressing in the host organism that survives at 37 degrees C.     

Disulfide bonds convert small heat shock protein Hsp16.3 from a chaperone to a non-chaperone: implications for the evolution of cysteine in molecular chaperones

Molecular chaperones mainly function in assisting newly synthesized polypeptide folding and protect non-native proteins from aggregation, with known structural features such as the ability of spontaneous folding/refolding and high conformational flexibility. In this report, we verified the assumption that the lack of disulfide bonds in molecular chaperones is a prerequisite for such unique structural features. Using small heat shock protein (one sub-class of chaperones) Hsp16.3 as a model system, our results show the following: (1) Cysteine-free Hsp16.3 wild type protein can efficiently exhibit chaperone activity and spontaneously refold/reassemble with high conformational flexibility. (2) Whereas Hsp16.3 G89C mutant with inter-subunit disulfide bonds formed seems to lose the nature of chaperone proteins, i.e., under stress conditions, it neither acts as molecular chaperone nor spontaneously refolds/reassembles. Structural analysis indicated that the mutant exists as an unstable molten globule-like state, which incorrectly exposes hydrophobic surfaces and irreversibly tends to form aggregates that can be suppressed by the other molecular chaperone (alpha-crystallin). By contrast, reduction of disulfide bond in the Hsp16.3 G89C mutant can significantly recover its character as a molecular chaperone. In light of these results, we propose that disulfide bonds could severely disturb the structure/function of molecular chaperones like Hsp16.3. Our results might not only provide insights into understanding the structural basis of chaperone upon binding substrates, but also explain the observation that the occurrence of cysteine in molecular chaperones is much lower than that in other protein families, subsequently being helpful to understand the evolution of protein family.     

Inter-subunit Cross-linking Suppressed the Dynamic Oligomeric Dissociation of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Hsp16.3 and Reduced Its Chaperone Activity

Small heat shock proteins (sHsps) usually exist as dynamic oligomers and oligomeric dissociation was believed to be a prerequisite for their chaperone activities. The truth of this hypothesis was verified in our present study on Hsp16.3, one member of sHsps from Mycobacterium tuberculosis, mainly by utilizing chemical cross-linking. Analysis using size exclusion chromatography demonstrated that the heat-induced oligomeric dissociation of Hsp16.3 was severely blocked due to highly efficient inter-subunit cross-linkages generated by chemical cross-linking, as well as its chaperone activity being reduced. Further analysis by non-denaturing pore gradient polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and fluorescence spectrometry revealed that the dynamic oligomeric dissociation/reassociation process of Hsp16.3 at room temperature was suppressed by inter-subunit cross-linkages, accompanied by significantly decreased exposure of hydrophobic surfaces that are usually hidden in oligomers. These findings supported the hypothesis that substrate-binding sites of sHsps are exposed presumably by dissociation of larger oligomers into smaller active oligomers, and therefore such a dissociation process could be adjusted to modulate chaperone activities.     

Probing the roles of the only universally conserved leucine residue (Leu122) in the oligomerization and chaperone-like activity of Mycobacterium tuberculosis small heat shock protein Hsp16.3

To understand the role of the only universally conserved hydrophobic residue among all the members of the sHsp family, this extremely well conserved Leu122 residue in Hsp16.3 was replaced by valine, alanine, asparigine, or aspartate residues. Only very small amounts of the L122D and L122N mutant Hsp16.3 proteins were expressed in the transformed E. coli; however, both the L122V and L122A were readily expressed. The L122V and L122A mutant proteins had similar oligomeric structures to the wild-type protein at room temperature. Examination of the L122A mutant protein by native pore gradient PAGE and CD spectroscopy, however, revealed a smaller oligomeric size and different secondary structure at 37°C. Both L122V and L122A mutant proteins exhibited significantly lowered chaperone activities. Observations reported here suggest a very important role of this only universally conserved Leu residue in both the formation of specific oligomeric structures and the molecular chaperone activities of Hsp16.3.     

Hydrophobic dye inhibits aggregation of molten carbonic anhydrase during thermal unfolding and refolding

Association-seeking surfaces on partially structured polypeptides can participate in interactions that are either intramolecular (folding related) or intermolecular (aggregative). During heat shock, intermolecular associations leading to aggregation are prevented through the binding of such surfaces by chaperones of the Hsp20 family (with Hsp70 later effecting release and refolding). Here we report that the hydrophobic dye, 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonate (ANS), mimics the function of the chaperones in its interactions with molten carbonic anhydrase (CA). At 150-fold molar excess of dye over protein, heat-induced aggregation of CA is almost completely inhibited by binding of ANS to solvent-exposed clusters of nonpolar residues. After exposure of ANS-containing protein solutions to temperatures as high as 95 degrees C, refolded CA can be recovered through cooling and dialysis, with no accompanying aggregation. This apparent mimicking of chaperone activity by a small dye opens up new approaches to understanding and manipulating protein aggregation.     

Cover Image,Volume 88, Issue 6

Hsp16.3, a molecular chaperone, plays a vital role in the growth and survival of Mycobacterium tuberculosis inside the host. We previously reported that deletion of three amino acid residues (¹⁴²STN¹⁴⁴) from C-terminal extension (CTE) of Hsp16.3 triggers its structural perturbation and increases its chaperone activity, which reaches its apex upon the deletion of its entire CTE (¹⁴¹RSTN¹⁴⁴). Thus, we hypothesized that Arg141 (R141) and Ser142 (S142) in the CTE of Hsp16.3 possibly hold the key in maintaining its native-like structure and chaperone activity. To test this hypothesis, we generated two deletion mutants in which R141 and S142 were deleted individually (Hsp16.3ΔR141 and Hsp16.3ΔS142) and three substitution mutants in which R141 was replaced by lysine (Hsp16.3R141K), alanine (Hsp16.3R141A), and glutamic acid (Hsp16.3R141E), respectively. Hsp16.3ΔS142 or Hsp16.3R141K mutant has native-like structure and chaperone activity. Deletion of R141 from the CTE (Hsp16.3ΔR141) perturbs the secondary and tertiary structure, lowers the subunit exchange dynamics and decreases the chaperone activity of Hsp16.3. But, the substitution of R141 with alanine (Hsp16.3R141A) or glutamic acid (Hsp16.3R141E) perturbs its secondary and tertiary structure. Surprisingly, such charge tampering of R141 enhances the subunit exchange dynamics and chaperone activity of Hsp16.3. Interestingly, neither the deletion of R141/S142 nor the substitution of R141 with lysine, alanine and glutamic acid affects the oligomeric mass/size of Hsp16.3. Overall, our study suggests that R141 (especially the positive charge on R141) plays a crucial role in maintaining the native-like structure as well as in regulating subunit exchange dynamics and chaperone activity of Hsp16.3.     

Monodisperse Hsp16.3 nonamer exhibits dynamic dissociation and reassociation,with the nonamer dissociation prerequisite for chaperone-like activity

Small heat-shock proteins (sHsps) of various origins exist commonly as oligomers and exhibit chaperone-like activities in vitro. Hsp16.3, the sHsp from Mycobacterium tuberculosis, was previously shown to exist as a monodisperse nonamer in solution when analyzed by size-exclusion chromatography and electron cryomicroscropy. This study represents part of our effort to understand the chaperone mechanism of Hsp16.3, focusing on the role of the oligomeric status of the protein. Here, we present evidence to show that the Hsp16.3 nonamer dissociates at elevated temperatures, accompanied by a greatly enhanced chaperone-like activity. Moreover, the chaperone-like activity was increased dramatically when the nonameric structure of Hsp16.3 was disturbed by chemical cross-linking, which impeded the correct reassociation of Hsp16.3 nonamer. These suggest that the dissociation of the nonameric structure is a prerequisite for Hsp16.3 to bind to denaturing substrate proteins. On the other hand, our data obtained by using radiolabeled and non-radiolabeled proteins clearly demonstrated that subunit exchange occurs readily between the Hsp16.3 oligomers, even at a temperature as low as 4 degrees C. In light of all these observations, we propose that Hsp16.3, although it appears to be homogeneous when examined at room temperature, actually undertakes rapid dynamic dissociation/reassociation, with the equilibrium, and thus the chaperone-like activities, regulated mainly by the environmental temperature.     

Thermodynamic stability of the C-terminal domain of the human inducible heat shock protein 70

The stability of the substrate-binding region of human inducible Hsp70 was studied by a combination of spectroscopic and calorimetric methods. Thermal denaturation of the protein involves four accessible states: the native state, two largely populated intermediates, and the denatured state, with transition temperatures of 52.8, 56.2 and 71.2 degrees C, respectively, at pH 6.5. The intermediate spectroscopic properties resemble those of molten globules but they still retain substantial enthalpy and heat capacity of unfolding. Moreover, the similar heat capacities of the first intermediate and the native state suggests that the hydrophobic core of the intermediate would be highly native-like and that its formation would involve an increased disorder in localized portions of the structure rather than formation of a globally disordered state. The structure of the C-terminal of Hsp70 is destabilized as the pH separates from neutrality. The intermediates become populated under heat shock conditions at acidic and basic pHs. Denaturation by guanidine chloride also indicated that the protein undergoes a sequential unfolding process. The free energy change associated to the loss of secondary structure at 20 degrees C (pH 6.5) is 3.1 kcal.mol(-1) at high salt conditions. These values agree with the free energy changes estimated from differential scanning calorimetry for the transition between the second intermediate and the final denatured state.     

Rab3a controls exocytosis in cholecystokinin-secreting cells

We have studied the chaperone activity and conformation of Escherichia coli heat shock protein (Hsp)33, whose activity is known to be switched on by oxidative conditions. While oxidized Hsp33 completely prevents the heat-induced aggregation of zeta-crystallin at 42 degrees C at a ratio of 1:1 (w/w), the reduced form exhibits only a marginal effect on the aggregation. Far UV-circular dichroism (CD) spectra show that reduced Hsp33 contains a significant alpha-helical component. Oxidation results in significant changes in the far UV-CD spectrum. Near UV-CD spectra show changes in tertiary structural packing upon oxidation. Polarity-sensitive fluorescent probes report enhanced hydrophobic surfaces in the oxidized Hsp33. Our studies show that the oxidative activation of the chaperone function of Hsp33 involves observable conformational changes accompanying increased exposure of hydrophobic pockets.     

Role of a conserved aspartic acid in nucleotide binding domain 1 (NBD1) of Hsp100 chaperones in their activities

Besides its beneficial role in thermotolerance, the chaperone protein Hsp104 is involved in the inheritance of yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae prions. Guanidine hydrochloride was previously shown to interfere with Hsp104 chaperone activity in vivo, thus impairing thermotolerance and resulting in prion curing. It was also reported that guanidine inhibits Hsp104 ATPase and disaggregation activity. We show that in vitro guanidine significantly inhibits the disaggregation activity of ClpB, the bacterial orthologue of Hsp104. However, guanidine exerts opposite effects on the ATPase activities of Hsp104 and ClpB. While the ATPase activity of Hsp104 is inhibited, the analogous ClpB activity is stimulated several-fold. Mutation of the universally conserved aspartic acid residue in position 184 to serine (D184S) in HSP104 and the analogous mutation in clpB (D178S) resulted in chaperones with lower disaggregating and ATPase activities. The activities of such changed chaperones are not influenced by guanidine, which suggests the role of this residue in the interaction with guanidine.     

Structural alteration of Escherichia coli Hsp31 by thermal unfolding increases chaperone activity

Escherichia coli Hsp31, encoded by hchA, is a heat-inducible molecular chaperone. We found that Hsp31 undergoes a conformational change via temperature-induced unfolding, generating a high molecular weight (HMW) form with enhanced chaperone activity. Although it has previously been reported that some subunits of the Hsp31 crystal structure show structural heterogeneity with increased hydrophobic surfaces, Hsp31 basically forms a dimer. We found that a C-terminal deletion (CΔ19) of Hsp31 exhibited structurally and functionally similar characteristics to that of the HMW form. Both the CΔ19 and HMW forms achieved a structure with considerably more β-sheets and less α-helices than the native dimeric form, exposing a portion of its hydrophobic surfaces. The structural alterations were determined from its spectral changes in circular dichroism, intrinsic fluorescence of tryptophan residues, and fluorescence of bis-ANS binding to a hydrophobic surface. Interestingly, during thermal transition, the dimeric Hsp31 undergoes a conformational change to the HMW species via the CΔ19 structure, as monitored with near-UV CD spectrum, implying that the CΔ19 resembles an intermediate state between the dimer and the HMW form. From these results, we propose that Hsp31 transforms itself into a fully functional chaperone by altering its tertiary and quaternary structures.     

Self-association and chaperone activity of Hsp27 are thermally activated

The small heat shock protein 27 (Hsp27) is an oligomeric, molecular chaperone in vitro. This chaperone activity and other physiological roles attributed to Hsp27 have been reported to depend on the state of self-association. In the present work, we have used sedimentation velocity experiments to demonstrate that the self-association of Hsp27 is independent of pH and ionic strength but increases significantly as the temperature is increased from 10 to 40 degrees C. The largest oligomers formed at 10 degrees C are approximately 8-12 mer, whereas at 40 degrees C oligomers as large as 22-30 mer are observed. Similarly, the chaperone activity of Hsp27 as indicated by its ability to inhibit dithiothreitol-induced insulin aggregation also increases with increased temperature, with a particularly sharp increase in activity as temperature is increased from 34 to 43 degrees C. Similar studies of an Hsp27 triple variant that mimics the behavior of the phosphorylated protein establish that this protein has greatly diminished chaperone activity that responds minimally to increased temperature. We conclude that Hsp27 can exploit a large number of oligomerization states and that the range of oligomer size and the magnitude of chaperone activity increase significantly as temperature is increased over the range that is relevant to the physiological heat shock response.     

Preheat treatment for Mycobacterium tuberculosis Hsp16.3: correlation between a structural phase change at 60 degrees C and a dramatic increase in chaperone-like activity.

The in vitro chaperone-like activity of Mycobacterium tuberculosis small heat shock protein Hsp16.3 was found to be dramatically enhanced to the same extent after preheat treatment at or over 60 degrees C. Structural analysis using gel filtration, native pore-gradient PAGE, nondenaturing PAGE, and far-UV CD spectroscopy consistently revealed no significant difference between the native and the preheated Hsp16.3 proteins. However, near-UV CD spectroscopy clearly demonstrated that the tertiary structure of preheated Hsp16.3 is quite similar to its native conformation, with a minor but significant difference. Further analysis using differential scanning calorimetry indicated that Hsp16.3 exhibited a structural transition near 60 degrees C. All these results together indicate that Hsp16.3 suffers a phase change at approximately 60 degrees C, which seem to remove a structural energy barrier for the protein to refold to a conformational status with increased chaperone-like activity.     

Stepwise disassembly and apparent nonstepwise reassembly for the oligomeric RbsD protein

Many cellular proteins exist as homo-oligomers. The mechanism of the assembly process of such proteins is still poorly understood. We have previously observed that Hsp16.3, a protein exhibiting chaperone-like activity, undergoes stepwise disassembly and nonstepwise reassembly. Here, the disassembly and reassembly of a nonchaperone protein RbsD, from Escherichia coli, was studied in vitro. The protein was found to mainly exist as decamers with a small portion of apparently larger oligomeric forms, both of which are able to refold/reassemble effectively in a spontaneous way after being completely unfolded. Disassembly RbsD intermediates including pentamers, tetramers, trimers, dimers, and monomers were detected by using urea-containing pore gradient polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, while only pentamers were detected for its reassembly. The observation of stepwise disassembly and apparent nonstepwise reassembly for both a chaperone protein (Hsp16.3) and a nonchaperone protein (RbsD) strongly suggests that such a feature is most likely general for homo-oligomeric proteins.     

The Hsp60 protein of helicobacter pylori displays chaperone activity under acidic conditions

The heat shock protein, Hsp60, is one of the most abundant proteins in Helicobacter pylori. Given its sequence homology to the Escherichia coli Hsp60 or GroEL, Hsp60 from H. pylori would be expected to function as a molecular chaperone in this organism. H. pylori is an organism that grows on the gastric epithelium, where the pH can fluctuate between neutral and 4.5 and the intracellular pH can be as low as 5.0. This study was performed to test the ability of Hsp60 from H. pylori to function as a molecular chaperone under mildly acidic conditions. We report here that Hsp60 could suppress the acid-induced aggregation of alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) in the 7.0–5.0 pH range. Hsp60 was found to undergo a conformational change within this pH range. It was also found that exposure of hydrophobic surfaces of Hsp60 is significant and that their exposure is increased under acidic conditions. Although, alcohol dehydrogenase does not contain exposed hydrophobic surfaces, we found that their exposure is triggered at low pH. Our results demonstrate that Hsp60 from H. pylori can function as a molecular chaperone under acidic conditions and that the interaction between Hsp60 and other proteins may be mediated by hydrophobic interactions.     

Site-directed mutation on the only universally conserved residue Leu122 of small heat shock protein Hsp16.3.

Hsp16.3 from Mycobacterium tuberculosis belongs to the small heat shock protein family and has chaperone-like activity in vitro. The only universally conserved hydrophobic residue Leu122 was substituted by Val and Ala, respectively. The mutations on the Leu122 of Hsp16.3 have resulted in much lower structural stability in vivo and in vitro. Both mutant proteins exhibited much weaker chaperone-like activities than the Hsp16.3 WT under heat shock conditions. Taken together, the highly hydrophobic residue L122 of Hsp16.3 was suggested to play a very important role in maintaining not only the structural stability but also the chaperone-like activity.     

Cloning and characterization of a haloarchaeal heat shock protein 70 functionally expressed in Escherichia coli

The Hsp70 molecular chaperone machine is constituted by the 70-kDa heat shock protein Hsp70 (DnaK), cochaperone protein Hsp40 (DnaJ) and a nucleotide-exchange factor GrpE. Although it is one of the best-characterized molecular chaperone machines, little is known about it in archaea. A 5.2-kb region containing the hsp70 (dnaK) gene was cloned from Natrinema sp. J7 strain and sequenced. It contained the Hsp70 chaperone machine gene locus arranged unidirectionally in the order of grpE, hsp70 and hsp40 (dnaJ). The hsp70 gene from Natrinema sp. J7 was overexpressed in Escherichia coli BL21 (DE3). The recombinant Hsp70 protein was in a soluble and active form, and its ATPase activity was optimally active in 2.0 M KCl, whereas NaCl had less effect. In vivo, the haloarchaeal hsp70 gene allowed an E. coli dnak-null mutant to propagate lambda phages and grow at 42 degrees C. The results suggested that haloarchaeal Hsp70 should be beneficial for extreme halophiles survival in low-salt environments.     

Antagonists of Hsp16.3, a Low-Molecular-Weight Mycobacterial Chaperone and Virulence Factor, Derived from Phage-Displayed Peptide Libraries

The persistence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis is a major cause of concern in tuberculosis (TB) therapy. In the persistent mode the pathogen can resist drug therapy, allowing the possibility of reactivation of the disease. Several protein factors have been identified that contribute to persistence, one of them being the 16-kDa low-molecular-weight mycobacterial heat shock protein Hsp16.3, a homologue of the mammalian eye lens protein alpha-crystallin. It is believed that Hsp16.3 plays a key role in the persistence phase by protecting essential proteins from being irreversibly denatured. Because of the close association of Hsp16.3 with persistence, an attempt has been made to develop inhibitors against it. Random peptide libraries displayed on bacteriophage M13 were screened for Hsp16.3 binding. Two phage clones were identified that bind to the Hsp16.3 protein. The corresponding synthetic peptides, an 11-mer and a 16-mer, were able to bind Hsp16.3 and inhibit its chaperone activity in vitro in a dose-dependent manner. Little or no effect of these peptides was observed on alphaB-crystallin, a homologous protein that is a key component of human eye lens, indicating that there is an element of specificity in the observed inhibition. Two histidine residues appear to be common to the selected peptides. Nuclear magnetic resonance studies performed with the 11-mer peptide indicate that in this case these two histidines may be the crucial binding determinants. The peptide inhibitors of Hsp16.3 thus obtained could serve as the basis for developing potent drugs against persistent TB.     

Effect of methylglyoxal modification and phosphorylation on the chaperone and anti-apoptotic properties of heat shock protein 27

Heat shock protein 27 (Hsp27) is a stress-inducible protein in cells that functions as a molecular chaperone and also as an anti-apoptotic protein. Methylglyoxal (MGO) is a reactive dicarbonyl compound produced from cellular glycolytic intermediates that reacts non-enzymatically with proteins to form products such as argpyrimidine. We found considerable amount of Hsp27 in phosphorylated form (pHsp27) in human cataractous lenses. pHsp27 was the major argpyrimidine-modified protein in brunescent cataractous lenses. Modification by MGO enhanced the chaperone function of both pHsp27 and native Hsp27, but the effect on Hsp27 was at least three-times greater than on pHsp27. Phosphorylation of Hsp27 abolished its chaperone function. Transfer of Hsp27 using a cationic lipid inhibited staurosporine (SP)-induced apoptotic cell death by 53% in a human lens epithelial cell line (HLE B-3). MGO-modified Hsp27 had an even greater effect (62% inhibition). SP-induced reactive oxygen species in HLE-B3 cells was significantly lower in cells transferred with MGO-modified Hsp27 when compared to native Hsp27. In vitro incubation experiments showed that MGO-modified Hsp27 reduced the activity of caspase-9, and MGO-modified pHsp27 reduced activities of both caspase-9 and caspase-3. Based on these results, we propose that Hsp27 becomes a better anti-apoptotic protein after modification by MGO, which may be due to multiple mechanisms that include enhancement of chaperone function, reduction in oxidative stress, and inhibition of activity of caspases. Our results suggest that MGO modification and phosphorylation of Hsp27 may have important consequences for lens transparency and cataract development.