Structural impact of cations on lipid bilayer models: Nanomechanical properties by AFM-force spectroscopy

Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) has become an invaluable tool for studying the micro- and nanoworlds. As a stand-alone, high-resolution imaging technique and force transducer, it defies most other surface instrumentation in ease of use, sensitivity and versatility. The main strength of AFM relies on the possibility to operate in an aqueous environment on a wide variety of biological samples, from single molecules – DNA or proteins – to macromolecular assemblies like biological membranes. Understanding the effect of mechanical stress on membranes is of primary importance in biophysics, since cells are known to perform their function under a complex combination of forces. In the later years, AFM-based Force-Spectroscopy (AFM-FS) has provided a new vista on membrane mechanics in a confined area within the nanometer realm, where most of the specific molecular interactions take place. Lipid membranes are electrostatically charged entities that physiologically coexist with electrolyte solutions. Thus, specific interactions with ions are a matter of considerable interest. The distribution of ions in the solution and their interaction with the membranes are factors that substantially modify the structure and dynamics of the cell membranes. Furthermore, signaling processes are modified by the membrane capability of retaining ions. Supported Lipid Bilayers (SLBs) are a versatile tool to investigate phospholipid membranes mimicking biological surfaces. In the present contribution, we review selected experiments on the mechanical stability of SLBs as models of lipid membranes by means of AFM-FS, with special focus on the effect of cations and ionic strength in the overall nanomechanical stability.     

Tracking Molecular Interactions in Membranes by Simultaneous ATR-FTIR-AFM

In situ atomic force microscopy (AFM) is an exceedingly powerful and useful technique for characterizing the structure and assembly of proteins in real-time, in situ, and especially at model membrane interfaces, such as supported planar lipid bilayers. There remains, however, a fundamental challenge with AFM-based imaging. Conclusions are inferred based on morphological or topographical features. It is conventionally very difficult to use AFM to confirm specific molecular conformation, especially in the case of protein-membrane interactions. In this case, a protein may undergo subtle conformational changes upon insertion in the membrane that may be critical to its function. AFM lacks the ability to directly measure such conformational changes and can, arguably, only resolve features that are topographically distinct. To address these issues, we have developed a platform that integrates in situ AFM with attenuated total reflection-Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy. This combination of tools provides a unique means of tracking, simultaneously, conformational changes, not resolvable by in situ AFM, with topographical details that are not readily identified by conventional spectroscopy. Preliminary studies of thermal transitions in supported lipid bilayers and direct evidence of lipid-induced conformational changes in adsorbed proteins illustrates the potential of this coupled in situ functional imaging strategy.     

HgCl2 disrupts the structure of the human erythrocyte membrane and model phospholipid bilayers

The structural effects of Hg(II) ions on the erythrocyte membrane were studied through the interactions of HgCl2 with human erythrocytes and their isolated resealed membranes. Studies were carried out by scanning electron microscopy and fluorescence spectroscopy, respectively. Hg(II) induced shape changes in erythrocytes, which took the form of echinocytes and stomatocytes. This finding means that Hg(II) locates in both the outer and inner monolayers of the erythrocyte membrane. Fluorescence spectroscopy results indicate strong interactions of Hg(II) ions with phospholipid amino groups, which also affected the packing of the lipid acyl chains at the deep hydrophobic core of the membrane. HgCl2 also interacted with bilayers of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine and dimyristoylphosphatidylethanolamine, representative of phospholipid classes located in the outer and inner monolayers of the erythrocyte membrane, respectively. X-ray diffraction indicated that Hg(II) ions induced molecular disorder to both phospholipid bilayers, while fluorescence spectroscopy of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine large unilamellar vesicles confirmed the interaction of Hg(II) ions with the lipid polar head groups. All these findings point to the important role of the phospholipid bilayers in the interaction of Hg(II) on cell membranes.     

Supported phospholipid/alkanethiol biomimetic membranes: insulating properties.

A novel model lipid bilayer membrane is prepared by the addition of phospholipid vesicles to alkanethiol monolayers on gold. This supported hybrid bilayer membrane is rugged, easily and reproducibly prepared in the absence of organic solvent, and is stable for very long periods of time. We have characterized the insulating characteristics of this membrane by examining the rate of electron transfer and by impedance spectroscopy. Supported hybrid bilayers formed from phospholipids and alkanethiols are pinhole-free and demonstrate measured values of conductivity and resistivity which are within an order of magnitude of that reported for black lipid membranes. Capacitance values suggest a dielectric constant of 2.7 for phospholipid membranes in the absence of organic solvent. The protein toxin, melittin, destroys the insulating capability of the phospholipid layer without significantly altering the bilayer structure. This model membrane will allow the assessment of the effect of lipid membrane perturbants on the insulating properties of natural lipid membranes.     

The Interaction of Equine Lysozyme:Oleic Acid Complexes with Lipid Membranes Suggests a Cargo Off-Loading Mechanism

The normal function of equine lysozyme (EL) is the hydrolysis of peptidoglycan residues of bacterial cell walls. EL is closely related to α-lactalbumins with respect to sequence and structure and further possesses the calcium binding site of α-lactalbumins. Recently, EL multimeric complexes with oleic acids (ELOAs) were shown to possess tinctorial and morphological properties, similar to amyloidal aggregates, and to be cytotoxic. ELOA's interactions with phospholipid membranes appear to be central to its biological action, similar to human α-lactalbumin made lethal to tumor cells. Here, we describe the interaction of ELOA with phospholipid membranes. Confocal scanning laser microscopy shows that ELOA, but not native EL, accumulates on the surface of giant unilamellar vesicles, without inducing significant membrane permeability. Quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation data indicated an essentially non-disruptive binding of ELOA to supported lipid bilayers, leading to formation of highly dissipative and “soft” lipid membrane; at higher concentrations of ELOA, the lipid membrane desorbs from the surface probably as bilayer sheets of vesicles. This membrane rearrangement occurred to a similar extent when free oleic acid (OA) was added, but not when free OA was removed from ELOA by prior incubation with bovine serum albumin, emphasizing the role of OA in this process. NMR data indicated an equilibrium between free and bound OA, which shifts towards free OA as ELOA is progressively diluted, indicating that OA is relatively loosely bound. Activity measurements together with fluorescence spectroscopy and circular dichroism suggested a conversion of ELOA towards a more native-like state on interaction with lipid membranes, although complete refolding was not observed. Altogether, these results suggest that ELOA may act as an OA carrier and facilitate OA transfer to the membrane. ELOA's properties illustrate that protein folding variants may possess specific functional properties distinct from the native protein.     

Visualization of membrane RNAs

Using fluorescence microscopy, we show that previously isolated membrane-binding RNAs coat artificial phospholipid membranes relatively uniformly, except for a frequent tendency to concentrate at bends, membrane junctions, and other unusual sites. Membrane RNAs can also be visualized as single molecules or isolated complexes by atomic force microscopy (AFM) of free RNAs on mica. Finally, RNAs can be seen within membranes by AFM of RNA-liposomes immobilized on hydrophobic mica surfaces. Monomer RNAs appear globular, as expected for small RNAs. When mixed under conditions in which RNAs bind bilayers, RNA 9 and RNA 10 combine to yield about 80% of RNAs as mainly linear oligomers of approximately 2-8 molecules. Once inserted in membranes, the RNAs oligomerize further, yielding larger, irregular ropelike structures that prefer the edges of altered lipid patches. These properties can be interpreted in terms of RNA-RNA loop interactions, and the RNA effects on membranes can be explained in terms of an RNA preference for irregular lipid conformations. The RNA-bilayer system poses new opportunities for combining the properties of membranes and RNA in contemporary cells, and also in the ribocytes of an RNA world.     

Structural and dynamic effects of oxidatively modified phospholipids in unsaturated lipid membranes.

Phospholipid hydroperoxides and phospholipid alcohols are two of the major forms of oxidatively modified phospholipids produced during oxidant stress and lipid peroxidation. The process of lipid peroxidation is known to affect the physiological function of membranes. We, therefore, investigated the effects of lipid peroxidation products on the molecular interactions in membranes. Our study was specifically focused on the effects of lipid peroxidation products on static membrane structure (molecular orientational order) and on the reorientational dynamics of the probe molecules in lipid bilayers. The study was done by performing angle-resolved fluorescence depolarization measurements (AFD) on the fluorescent probe diphenylhexatriene (DPH) and by performing angle-resolved electron spin resonance (A-ESR) measurements on cholestane (CSL) nitroxide spin probes embedded in macroscopically oriented planar bilayers consisting of 2-10% 1-palmitoyl-2-(9/13-hydroperoxylinoleoyl)phosphatidylcholine (PLPC-OOH) or 1-palmitoyl-2-(9/13-hydroxylinoleoyl)phosphatidylcholine (PLPC-OH) in 1-palmitoyl-2-linoleoylphosphatidylcholine (PLPC) or dilinoleoylphosphatidylcholine (DLPC). Both probe molecules have rigid cylindrical geometries and report on the overall molecular order and dynamics. However, being more polar, the nitroxide spin probe CSL is preferentially located near the surface of the membrane, while the less polar fluorescent probe DPH reports preferentially near the central hydrophobic region of the lipid bilayers. The results show that the presence of relatively small amounts of oxidatively modified phospholipids within the PLPC or DLPC membranes causes pronounced structural effects as the molecular orientational order of the probe molecules is strongly decreased. In contrast, the effect on membrane reorientational dynamics is minimal.     

Evolution and development of model membranes for physicochemical and functional studies of the membrane lateral heterogeneity

One of the main questions in the membrane biology is the functional roles of membrane heterogeneity and molecular localization. Although segregation and local enrichment of protein/lipid components (rafts) have been extensively studied, the presence and functions of such membrane domains still remain elusive. Along with biochemical, cell observation, and simulation studies, model membranes are emerging as an important tool for understanding the biological membrane, providing quantitative information on the physicochemical properties of membrane proteins and lipids. Segregation of fluid lipid bilayer into liquid-ordered (Lo) and liquid-disordered (Ld) phases has been studied as a simplified model of raft in model membranes, including giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs), giant plasma membrane vesicles (GPMVs), and supported lipid bilayers (SLB). Partition coefficients of membrane proteins between Lo and Ld phases were measured to gauze their affinities to lipid rafts (raftophilicity). One important development in model membrane is patterned SLB based on the microfabrication technology. Patterned Lo/Ld phases have been applied to study the partition and function of membrane-bound molecules. Quantitative information of individual molecular species attained by model membranes is critical for elucidating the molecular functions in the complex web of molecular interactions. The present review gives a short account of the model membranes developed for studying the lateral heterogeneity, especially focusing on patterned model membranes on solid substrates.     

Rotational decoupling between the hydrophilic and hydrophobic regions in lipid membranes

Cells use homeostatic mechanisms to ensure an optimal composition of distinct types of lipids in cellular membranes. The hydrophilic region of biological lipid membranes is mainly composed of several types of phospholipid headgroups that interact with incoming molecules, nanoparticles, and viruses, whereas the hydrophobic region consists of a distribution of acyl chains and sterols affecting membrane fluidity/rigidity related properties and forming an environment for membrane-bound molecules such as transmembrane proteins. A fundamental open question is to what extent the motions of these regions are coupled and, consequently, how strongly the interactions of phospholipid headgroups with other molecules depend on the properties and composition of the membrane hydrophobic core. We combine advanced solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy with high-fidelity molecular dynamics simulations to demonstrate how the rotational dynamics of choline headgroups remain nearly unchanged (slightly faster) with incorporation of cholesterol into a phospholipid membrane, contrasting the well-known extreme slowdown of the other phospholipid segments. Notably, our results suggest a new paradigm in which phospholipid dipole headgroups interact as quasi-freely rotating flexible dipoles at the interface, independent of the properties in the hydrophobic region.     

Nanoscale structural and mechanical effects of beta-amyloid (1-42) on polymer cushioned membranes: a combined study by neutron reflectometry and AFM Force Spectroscopy

The interaction of beta-amyloid peptides with lipid membranes is widely studied as trigger agents in Alzheimer's disease. Their mechanism of action at the molecular level is unknown and their interaction with the neural membrane is crucial to elucidate the onset of the disease. In this study we have investigated the interaction of water soluble forms of beta-amyloid Aβ(1-42) with lipid bilayers supported by polymer cushion. A reproducible protocol for the preparation of a supported phospholipid membrane with composition mimicking the neural membrane and in physiological condition (PBS buffer, pH=7.4) was refined by neutron reflectivity. The change in structure and local mechanical properties of the membrane in the presence of Aβ(1-42) was investigated by neutron reflectivity and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) Force Spectroscopy. Neutron reflectivity evidenced that Aβ(1-42) interacts strongly with the supported membrane, causing a change in the scattering length density profile of the lipid bilayer, and penetrates into the membrane. Concomitantly, the local mechanical properties of the bilayer are deeply modified by the interaction with the peptide as seen by AFM Force Spectroscopy. These results may be of great importance for the onset of the Alzheimer's disease, since a simultaneous change in the structural and mechanical properties of the lipid matrix could influence all membrane based signal cascades.     

Resolving the kinetics of lipid, protein and peptide diffusion in membranes

Recent developments in the understanding of molecular diffusion phenomena in membranes are reviewed. Both model bilayers and biological membranes are considered in respect of lateral diffusion, rotational diffusion and transverse diffusion (flip-flop). For model systems, particular attention is paid to recent data obtained using surface-specific techniques such as sum frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy on supported lipid bilayers, and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy on giant unilamellar vesicles, both of which have yielded new insights into the intrinsic rates of diffusion and the energetic barriers to processes such as lipid flip-flop. Advances in single-molecule and many-molecule fluorescence methodologies have enabled the observation of processes such as anomalous diffusion for some membrane species in biological membranes. These are discussed in terms of new models for the role of membrane interactions with the cytoskeleton, the effects of molecular crowding in membranes, and the formation of lipid rafts. The diffusion of peptides, proteins and lipids is considered, particularly in relation to the means by which antimicrobial peptide activity may be rationalized in terms of membrane poration and lipid flip-flop.     

Atomic force microscopy of supported lipid bilayers

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are widely used in biophysical research to investigate the properties of biological membranes and offer exciting prospects in nanobiotechnology. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) has become a well-established technique for imaging SLBs at nanometer resolution. A unique feature of AFM is its ability to monitor dynamic processes, such as the interaction of bilayers with proteins and drugs. Here, we present protocols for preparing dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC/DPPC) bilayers supported on mica using small unilamellar vesicles and for imaging their nanoscale interaction with the antibiotic azithromycin using AFM. The entire protocol can be completed in 10 h.     

Penetration of Cell Membranes and Synthetic Lipid Bilayers by Nanoprobes

Nanoscale devices have been proposed as tools for measuring and controlling intracellular activity by providing electrical and/or chemical access to the cytosol. Unfortunately, nanostructures with diameters of 50–500 nm do not readily penetrate the cell membrane, and rationally optimizing nanoprobes for cell penetration requires real-time characterization methods that are capable of following the process of membrane penetration with nanometer resolution. Although extensive work has examined the rupture of supported synthetic lipid bilayers, little is known about the applicability of these model systems to living cell membranes with complex lipid compositions, cytoskeletal attachment, and membrane proteins. Here, we describe atomic force microscopy (AFM) membrane penetration experiments in two parallel systems: live HEK293 cells and stacks of synthetic lipid bilayers. By using the same probes in both systems, we were able to clearly identify membrane penetration in synthetic bilayers and compare these events with putative membrane penetration events in cells. We examined membrane penetration forces for three tip geometries and 18 chemical modifications of the probe surface, and in all cases the median forces required to penetrate cellular and synthetic lipid bilayers with nanoprobes were greater than 1 nN. The penetration force was sensitive to the probe''s sharpness, but not its surface chemistry, and the force did not depend on cell surface or cytoskeletal properties, with cells and lipid stacks yielding similar forces. This systematic assessment of penetration under various mechanical and chemical conditions provides insights into nanoprobe-cell interactions and informs the design of future intracellular nanoprobes.     

Force spectroscopy reveals the effect of different ions in the nanomechanical behavior of phospholipid model membranes: the case of potassium cation

How do metal cations affect the stability and structure of phospholipid bilayers? What role does ion binding play in the insertion of proteins and the overall mechanical stability of biological membranes? Investigators have used different theoretical and microscopic approaches to study the mechanical properties of lipid bilayers. Although they are crucial for such studies, molecular-dynamics simulations cannot yet span the complexity of biological membranes. In addition, there are still some experimental difficulties when it comes to testing the ion binding to lipid bilayers in an accurate way. Hence, there is a need to establish a new approach from the perspective of the nanometric scale, where most of the specific molecular phenomena take place. Atomic force microscopy has become an essential tool for examining the structure and behavior of lipid bilayers. In this work, we used force spectroscopy to quantitatively characterize nanomechanical resistance as a function of the electrolyte composition by means of a reliable molecular fingerprint that reveals itself as a repetitive jump in the approaching force curve. By systematically probing a set of bilayers of different composition immersed in electrolytes composed of a variety of monovalent and divalent metal cations, we were able to obtain a wealth of information showing that each ion makes an independent and important contribution to the gross mechanical resistance and its plastic properties. This work addresses the need to assess the effects of different ions on the structure of phospholipid membranes, and opens new avenues for characterizing the (nano)mechanical stability of membranes.     

Penetration of Cell Membranes and Synthetic Lipid Bilayers by Nanoprobes

Nanoscale devices have been proposed as tools for measuring and controlling intracellular activity by providing electrical and/or chemical access to the cytosol. Unfortunately, nanostructures with diameters of 50–500 nm do not readily penetrate the cell membrane, and rationally optimizing nanoprobes for cell penetration requires real-time characterization methods that are capable of following the process of membrane penetration with nanometer resolution. Although extensive work has examined the rupture of supported synthetic lipid bilayers, little is known about the applicability of these model systems to living cell membranes with complex lipid compositions, cytoskeletal attachment, and membrane proteins. Here, we describe atomic force microscopy (AFM) membrane penetration experiments in two parallel systems: live HEK293 cells and stacks of synthetic lipid bilayers. By using the same probes in both systems, we were able to clearly identify membrane penetration in synthetic bilayers and compare these events with putative membrane penetration events in cells. We examined membrane penetration forces for three tip geometries and 18 chemical modifications of the probe surface, and in all cases the median forces required to penetrate cellular and synthetic lipid bilayers with nanoprobes were greater than 1 nN. The penetration force was sensitive to the probe's sharpness, but not its surface chemistry, and the force did not depend on cell surface or cytoskeletal properties, with cells and lipid stacks yielding similar forces. This systematic assessment of penetration under various mechanical and chemical conditions provides insights into nanoprobe-cell interactions and informs the design of future intracellular nanoprobes.     

The relationship between the antioxidant and the antibacterial properties of galloylated catechins and the structure of phospholipid model membranes

The effects of four catechins, (+)-catechin (C), (-)-epicatechin (EC), (-)-epicatechin gallate (ECG), and (-)-epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), on the physical properties of phospholipid model membranes and the correlation to their antioxidant and antibacterial capacities have been studied by using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), fluorescence spectroscopy, infrared spectroscopy (IR), AAPH-induced oxidation, and leakage experiments. DSC data revealed that galloylated catechins, especially ECG, affected the physical properties of both the phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) bilayers dramatically. Galloylated catechins showed higher phospholipid/water partition coefficients than their homologues and were immersed in the phospholipid palisade intercalating within the hydrocarbon chains, ECG being at the deepest position. In contrast, nongalloylated catechins presented a shallow location close to the phospholipid/water interface. ECG also exhibited the highest antioxidant capacity against lipid peroxidation, which correlated with its strong effect on DPH fluorescence anisotropy (as observed by the increase of the lipid order of fluid PC bilayers) and with the presence of highly cooperative transitions as seen by DSC. We propose that the high antioxidant capacity of some galloylated catechins such as ECG could be partially due to the formation of membrane structures showing resistance to detergent solubilization and in which the phospholipids have tightly packed acyl chains and highly hydrated phosphate groups. Significantly, PE was found to be essential to the promotion of carboxyfluorescein leakage from bacterial model membranes by galloylated catechins, indicating that their bactericidal activity, at least at the membrane level, could be due to the specific effect of these catechins on PE.     

Resolving the kinetics of lipid,protein and peptide diffusion in membranes

Abstract

Recent developments in the understanding of molecular diffusion phenomena in membranes are reviewed. Both model bilayers and biological membranes are considered in respect of lateral diffusion, rotational diffusion and transverse diffusion (flip-flop). For model systems, particular attention is paid to recent data obtained using surface-specific techniques such as sum frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy on supported lipid bilayers, and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy on giant unilamellar vesicles, both of which have yielded new insights into the intrinsic rates of diffusion and the energetic barriers to processes such as lipid flip-flop. Advances in single-molecule and many-molecule fluorescence methodologies have enabled the observation of processes such as anomalous diffusion for some membrane species in biological membranes. These are discussed in terms of new models for the role of membrane interactions with the cytoskeleton, the effects of molecular crowding in membranes, and the formation of lipid rafts. The diffusion of peptides, proteins and lipids is considered, particularly in relation to the means by which antimicrobial peptide activity may be rationalized in terms of membrane poration and lipid flip-flop.     

Oxidized phosphatidylcholines facilitate phospholipid flip-flop in liposomes

Lipid asymmetry is a ubiquitous property of the lipid bilayers in cellular membranes and its maintenance and loss play important roles in cell physiology, such as blood coagulation and apoptosis. The resulting exposure of phosphatidylserine on the outer surface of the plasma membrane has been suggested to be caused by a specific membrane enzyme, scramblase, which catalyzes phospholipid flip-flop. Despite extensive research the role of scramblase(s) in apoptosis has remained elusive. Here, we show that phospholipid flip-flop is efficiently enhanced in liposomes by oxidatively modified phosphatidylcholines. A combination of fluorescence spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations reveal that the mechanistic basis for this property of oxidized phosphatidylcholines is due to major changes imposed by the oxidized phospholipids on the biophysical properties of lipid bilayers, resulting in a fast cross bilayer diffusion of membrane phospholipids and loss of lipid asymmetry, requiring no scramblase protein.     

Direct visualization of saposin remodelling of lipid bilayers

Saposins A, B, C and D are soluble, non-enzymatic proteins that interact with lysosomal membranes to activate the breakdown and transfer of glycosphingolipids. The mechanisms of hydrolase activation and lipid transfer by saposins remain unknown. We have used in situ atomic force microscopy (AFM) with simultaneous confocal fluorescence microscopy to investigate the interactions of saposins with lipid membranes. AFM images of the effect of saposins A, B and C on supported lipid bilayers showed a time and concentration-dependent nucleated spread of membrane transformation. Saposin B produced deep gaps that ultimately filled with granular material, while saposins A and C lead to localized areas of membrane that were reduced in height by approximately 1.5 nm. Fluorescence-labeled saposin C co-localized with the transformed areas of the bilayer, indicating stable binding to the membrane. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer confirmed a direct interaction between saposin C and lipid. Under certain conditions of membrane lipid composition and saposin concentration, extensive bilayer lipid removal was observed. We propose a multi-step mechanism that integrates the structural features and amphipathic properties of the saposin proteins.     

The role of ion-lipid interactions and lipid packing in transient defects caused by phenolic compounds

The transient disruption of membranes for the passive permeation of ions or small molecules is a complex process relevant to understanding physiological processes and biotechnology applications. Phenolic compounds are widely studied for their antioxidant and antimicrobial properties, and some of these activities are based on the interactions of the phenolic compound with membranes. Ions are ubiquitous in cells and are known to alter the structure of phospholipid bilayers. Yet, ion-lipid interactions are usually ignored when studying the membrane-altering properties of phenolic compounds. This study aims to assess the role of Ca²⁺ ions on the membrane-disrupting activity of two phenolic acids and to highlight the role of local changes in lipid packing in forming transient defects or pores. Results from tethered bilayer lipid membrane electrical impedance spectroscopy experiments showed that Ca²⁺ significantly reduces membrane disruption by caffeic acid methyl ester and caffeic acid. As phenolic acids are known metal chelators, we used UV-vis and fluorescence spectroscopy to exclude the possibility that Ca²⁺ interferes with membrane disruption by binding to the phenolic compound and subsequently preventing membrane binding. Molecular dynamics simulations showed that Ca²⁺ but not caffeic acid methyl ester or caffeic acid increases lipid packing in POPC bilayers. The combined data confirm that Ca²⁺ reduces the membrane-disrupting activity of the phenolic compounds, and that Ca²⁺-induced changes to lipid packing govern this effect. We discuss our data in the context of ion-induced pores and transient defects and how lipid packing affects membrane disruption by small molecules.