Suppression of natural killer cell cytotoxicity by splenocytes from Corynebacterium parvum-injected, bone marrow-tolerant, and infant mice.

Natural killer (NK) cell cytotoxicity to YAC-1 lymphoma was investigated in mice tolerant to bone marrow grafts (BM-tolerant), Corynebacterium parvum- (C. parvum) treated mice, and infant mice. Also the comparison was made between the NK cell and the hemopoietic-resistance effector (HR-E) cells. It was found that the BM-tolerant mice and C. parvum-treated mice showed either no or markedly decreased NK cell cytotoxicity. These mice were also nonresponders to bone marrow grafts in vivo. The lack of or decreased reactivity was apparently caused by the regulatory cell activities of the suppressor cell since the splenocytes from C. parvum-treated and BM-tolerant mice suppressed significantly the cytotoxic activities of otherwise fully functional NK cells. Similar suppressive effect on NK cells was mounted by splenocytes from infant mice, indicating again the suppressor cell regulation of NK cell cytotoxicity.     

Regulation of natural killer progenitors. Studies with a novel immunomodulator with distinct effects at the precursor level

NK cells originate from progenitors in the bone marrow and maturate independently of other lymphoid organs. NK cell maturation represents an important site for regulation of the level of NK activity and constitutes a potentially interesting target for therapeutic intervention. The effect of the immunomodulator Linomide (carboxamide-3-quinoline) on the regeneration of NK cells was studied in vivo after depletion of mature NK cells. Linomide significantly, although to various extent, accelerated the maturation of NK cells after specific depletion with antibodies to asialomonoganglioside, treatment with cyclophosphamide or lethal irradiation and syngeneic bone marrow grafting. Examination of the target cell spectrum lysed by spleen effector cells during Linomide treatment as well as studies of phenotype, clearly indicated that the effector cells studied were NK cells. Treatment of mice for 4 days with Linomide increased the frequency of bone marrow NK cell progenitors from 1/11,900 to 1/6,000 as judged by limiting dilution analysis. Direct addition of Linomide in vitro had no effect on cultures of mature NK cells from spleen, but had an additive effect to IL-2 on the generation of NK cells when added to bone marrow cultures. Our study indicates that different mechanisms exist for the regulation of progenitor and mature NK cells, and that the immunomodulator Linomide represent a potentially important tool for investigating the mechanisms governing NK cell maturation.     

Regulation of the NK cell alloreactivity to bone marrow cells by the combination of the host NK gene complex and MHC haplotypes

Host NK cells can reject MHC-incompatible (allogeneic) bone marrow cells (BMCs), suggesting their effective role for graft-vs leukemia effects in the clinical setting of bone marrow transplantation. NK cell-mediated rejection of allogeneic BMCs is dependent on donor and recipient MHC alleles and other factors that are not yet fully characterized. Whereas the molecular mechanisms of allogeneic MHC recognition by NK receptors have been well studied in vitro, guidelines to understand NK cell allogeneic reactivity under the control of multiple genetic components in vivo remain less well understood. In this study, we use congenic mice to show that BMC rejection is regulated by haplotypes of the NK gene complex (NKC) that encodes multiple NK cell receptors. Most importantly, host MHC differences modulated the NKC effect. Moreover, the NKC allelic differences also affected the outcome of hybrid resistance whereby F1 hybrid mice reject parental BMCs. Therefore, these data indicate that NK cell alloreactivity in vivo is dependent on the combination of the host NKC and MHC haplotypes. These data suggest that the NK cell self-tolerance process dynamically modulates the NK cell alloreactivity in vivo.     

In vitro modulation of mouse natural killer (NK) cell activity by the serum thymic factor (FTS)

Previous studies indicated that the serum thymic factor (FTS) could modulate in vivo the level of splenic natural killer (NK) cell activity in mice. The present report shows that such an effect is also observed after a short term in vitro incubation of the effector cells with FTS. The regulatory effects of FTS result in an increase or a decrease of the splenic NK cell cytotoxicity depending upon the age and the mouse strain. Furthermore, FTS is able to enhance the NK cell activity of thymus and bone marrow cells which are known to be weakly reactive in NK cytotoxicity. Depletion experiments demonstrated that the FTS-induced increase of NK cell activity was not mediated by Thy 1+ cells nor macrophages, thus suggesting a direct action of FTS on the effector cells. Comparative studies using other thymic hormones revealed similar patterns of reactivity. These results favor the hypothesis of a close relationship between the thymus and NK cells.     

Roles for common cytokine receptor gamma-chain-dependent cytokines in the generation, differentiation, and maturation of NK cell precursors and peripheral NK cells in vivo

NK cells differentiate in adult mice from bone marrow hemopoietic progenitors. Cytokines, including those that signal via receptors using the common cytokine receptor gamma-chain (gamma(c)), have been implicated at various stages of NK cell development. We have previously described committed NK cell precursors (NKPs), which have the capacity to generate NK cells, but not B, T, erythroid, or myeloid cells, after in vitro culture or transfer to a fetal thymic microenvironment. NKPs express the CD122 Ag (beta chain of the receptors for IL-2/IL-15), but lack other mature NK markers, including NK1.1, CD49b (DX5), or members of the Ly49 gene family. In this report, we have analyzed the roles for gamma(c)-dependent cytokines in the generation of bone marrow NKP and in their subsequent differentiation to mature NK cells in vivo. Normal numbers of NKPs are found in gamma(c)-deficient mice, suggesting that NK cell commitment is not dependent on IL-2, IL-4, IL-7, IL-9, IL-15, or IL-21. Although IL-2, IL-4, and IL-7 have been reported to influence NK cell differentiation, we find that mice deficient in any or all of these cytokines have normal NK cell numbers, phenotype, and effector functions. In contrast, IL-15 plays a dominant role in early NK cell differentiation by maintaining normal numbers of immature and mature NK cells in the bone marrow and spleen. Surprisingly, the few residual NK cells generated in absence of IL-15 appear relatively mature, expressing a variety of Ly49 receptors and demonstrating lytic and cytokine production capacity.     

Analysis of cytotoxic effector cell function in patients with leukemia or aplastic anemia before and after marrow transplantation

Cytotoxic effector cells mediating natural killing (NK), antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC), and lectin-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (LDCC) were studied in patients with leukemia or aplastic anemia before and/or after marrow transplantation. Before transplantation, about one-third to one-half of the patients were deficient in cytotoxic activity. In patients with leukemia, this was most likely due to large numbers of circulating blast cells diluting or replacing the effector cells. In patients with aplastic anemia there was an apparent absence of the effector cells in a proportion of the patients. After marrow transplantation, cytotoxic activity in all three systems returned to normal rapidly, by 30 days, and remained so through 100 days. However, about 20% of patients studied beyond 1 year were deficient in these functions. There were no significant associations between cytotoxic activity and important clinical parameters including infections, graft-vs-host disease, and recurrence of leukemia. Our findings do not support an immunosurveillance role for NK against leukemia after marrow transplantation. Furthermore, they point out the need for new in vitro approaches for meaningful monitoring of marrow transplant patients. Finally, our results showed a significant discordance between NK, ADCC, and LDCC activities in these immunologically perturbed individuals, indicating that either different cell populations or different cellular mechanisms are involved in these cytotoxic functions.     

Physiology of natural killer cells. In vivo regulation of progenitors by interleukin 3

Adoptive transfer of bone marrow cells to syngeneic lethally irradiated C57BL/6 mice was used to study the maturation of natural killer (NK) cells from their progenitors. The NK progenitor cell was found to be asialomonoganglioside-negative, (aGM1-) Thy-1-, NK-1-, Ly-1-, Ly-2-, and L3T4-. The NK cells emerging from the bone marrow grafts were aGM1+, NK-1+, Thy-1+/-, Ly-1-, Ly-2-, and L3T4- and to have a target specter similar to that of NK cells isolated from the spleen of normal mice. The regulatory role of interleukin 2 (IL-2) and interleukin 3 (IL-3) for the maturation of NK cells was examined by exposure of the bone marrow cells to the lymphokines in vitro before bone marrow grafting or by treatment of bone marrow-grafted mice with lymphokines through s.c. implanted miniosmotic pumps. IL-3 antagonized the IL-2-induced maturation of NK cells in vitro and strongly inhibited the generation of NK cells after adoptive transfer of bone marrow cells in vivo. The suppressive effect of IL-3 was evident throughout the treatment period (8 or 16 days) but was apparently reversible because NK activity returned to control levels within 8 days after cessation of treatment. The inhibition of cytotoxic activity was accompanied by a reduced appearance of cells with the NK phenotypic markers aGM1 or NK-1, indicating that not only the cytotoxic activity of NK cells but also their actual formation was inhibited. Concomitantly, a moderate increase in cells expressing the T cell marker L3T4 and an increased proliferative response to the T cell mitogen concanavalin A was observed. A direct estimate of the effect of IL-3 on the frequency of NK cell progenitors was obtained by limiting dilution analysis of bone marrow cells at day 8 after bone marrow transplantation. The estimated minimal frequency of NK cell progenitors was reduced from 1/11,800 in control to 1/41,900 in IL-3-exposed mice. IL-3 may take part in the homeostasis of NK cells by the down-regulation of their progenitors.     

Functional defects of NK cells treated with chloroquine mimic the lytic defects observed in perforin-deficient mice

NK cells are the primary effectors mediating acute rejection of incompatible bone marrow cell grafts. To reduce rejection, we evaluated the ability of chloroquine (CHQ) to prevent perforin-dependent NK cell activity. Perforin is a key cytotoxic component released from the lytic granules of activated NK cells. Generation of functional perforin requires an acidic protease activity that occurs in the secretory, lytic lysosomes. Our hypothesis was that CHQ, a lysosomotropic reagent, would raise the pH of the acidic compartment in which perforin is processed and thereby block perforin maturation and cytotoxicity. We have measured NK cytotoxicity in vivo by clearance of YAC-1 tumor cells from the lungs and by rejection of incompatible bone marrow transplants and in vitro by cytolysis of YAC-1 and Jurkat cells. The engraftment of bone marrow cells was monitored by recolonization of the spleen with hemopoietic cells from transplants of MHC class I-deficient bone marrow cells into lethally irradiated recipient mice. Transplant rejection was compared in two inbred strains of mice: 129, which apparently use perforin-dependent cytotoxicity, and C57BL/6, in which rejection can be perforin-independent. CHQ treatment reduced NK cell activity in 129 mice in which perforin is important for mediating rejection. CHQ affected the fraction of NK cell cytolysis that was Fas independent. In addition, we found that CHQ prevents perforin processing by LAK cells in vitro. These data indicate that CHQ may impair rejection of incompatible bone marrow transplants and other functions mediated by NK and cytotoxic T cells.     

Donor-type activated natural killer cells promote marrow engraftment and B cell development during allogeneic bone marrow transplantation.

Purified NK cells were obtained from mice with severe combined immune deficiency and were activated with human IL-2 (hrIL-2) in vitro to determine if, once activated, these cells could be transferred with compatible bone marrow cells (BMC) and promote marrow engraftment in irradiated allogeneic recipients. After culture with hrIL-2, these cells maintained a phenotypic and lytic spectrum consistent with a pure population of activated NK cells. These activated NK cells were then adoptively transferred with the donor BMC and rhIL-2 into lethally irradiated allogeneic hosts. The addition of NK cells with the BMC allowed for more rapid hematopoietic engraftment as determined through short term studies, and greater donor-derived chimerism with accelerated reconstitution of the B cell population as determined with long term analysis. No evidence of graft-vs-host disease was detected in the recipients receiving the activated NK cells with allogeneic T cell replete BMC and hrIL-2. The mechanism by which the transferred NK cells improved BMC engraftment was at least partly through the abrogation of the host effector cell's ability to mediate resistance to the marrow graft. Thus, the administration of donor-type activated NK cells with BMC and hrIL-2 may significantly augment hematopoietic engraftment and immune reconstitution in the clinical setting of allogeneic BMT without giving rise to graft-vs-host disease.     

Multiple deficiencies underlie NK cell inactivity in lymphotoxin-alpha gene-targeted mice.

We have evaluated the NK cell antitumor activity in lymphotoxin (LT)-deficient mice. Both NK cell-mediated tumor rejection and protection from experimental metastases were significantly compromised in LT-alpha-deficient mice. Analysis of LT-alpha-deficient mice revealed that the absolute number of alphabetaTCR- NK1.1+ NK cells was reduced in bone marrow and thymus, but with overall proportional decreases in other hemopoietic organs. In addition, the antitumor potential of alphabetaTCR- NK1.1+ cells, as determined by their lytic capacity and perforin expression, was reduced 1.5- to 3-fold in LT-alpha-deficient mice, as compared with wild-type mice. Combined defects in NK cell development and effector function contribute to compromised NK cell antitumor function in LT-alpha-deficient mice.     

Simultaneous development of antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) and natural killer (NK) activity in irradiated mice reconstituted with bone marrow cells

Spleen cells from irradiated, bone marrow-reconstituted mice were tested for their ability to mediate antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity against P815 target (ADCC-P815), ADCC against sheep red blood cells (ADCC-SRBC), and natural killer (NK) activity judged as YAC-1 lysis at different times after bone marrow reconstitution. Donor-derived ADCC-P815 effectors were found to appear in the spleens 10-12 days after bone marrow reconstitution simultaneously with the appearance of donor-derived NK cells. NK cells recently derived from bone marrow are known to express the Thy-1 antigen; the phenotype of the "early" ADCC-P815 effectors was found to be the same as that of NK cells, i.e., Thy-1+, asialo-GM1+. These data suggest that ADCC-P815 effector cells belong to the NK cell population. ADCC-SRBC, in contrast to ADCC-P815 and NK activity, was already high on Day 7 after bone marrow reconstitution. However, it was mediated partly by recipient-derived effectors. ADCC-SRBC effectors were characterized to be different from ADCC-P815 effectors.     

Signal via lymphotoxin-beta R on bone marrow stromal cells is required for an early checkpoint of NK cell development

NK cells play an important role in the immune system but the cellular and molecular requirements for their early development are poorly understood. Lymphotoxin-alpha (LTalpha)(-/-) and LTbetaR(-/-) mice show a severe systemic reduction of NK cells, which provides an excellent model to study NK cell development. In this study, we show that the bone marrow (BM) or fetal liver cells from LTalpha(-/-) or LTbetaR(-/-) mice efficiently develop into mature NK cells in the presence of stromal cells from wild-type mice but not from LTalpha(-/-) or LTbetaR(-/-) mice. Direct activation of LTbetaR-expressing BM stromal cells is shown to promote to early NK cell development in vitro. Furthermore, the blockade of the interaction between LT and LTbetaR in adult wild-type mice by administration of LTbetaR-Ig impairs the development of NK cells in vivo. Together, these results indicate that the signal via LTbetaR on BM stromal cells by membrane LT is an important pathway for early NK cell development.     

Efficient natural defense mechanisms against Listeria monocytogenes in T and B cell-deficient allogeneic bone marrow radiation chimeras. Preactivated macrophages are the main effector cells in an early phase after bone marrow transfer

Radiation chimeras in the early phase after bone marrow transplantation are a good model to study the efficiency of the body's nonspecific defense system represented by macrophages (M phi), polymorphonuclear cells (PMN), and NK cells. These cell types are present in large numbers in spleen and liver at that time, whereas the specific immune system represented by T and B cells is functionally deficient. We previously reported enhanced activities in vitro of M phi (and PMN) from recipient animals in an early phase after allogeneic bone marrow transfer. We here demonstrate that these activities result in enhanced spontaneous resistance against Listeria monocytogenes in vivo: CFU of L. monocytogenes in spleen and liver 48 h after infection were about 1 or 2 to 4 log steps less than in untreated control mice of donor or host haplotype. This enhanced resistance decreased over the 4-mo period after marrow transfer. Preactivated M phi were identified as the most important effector cells. Isolated from spleen and peritoneal cavity, they performed enhanced killing of phagocytosed Listeria. Such preactivated M phi occurred in recipient animals after transfer of allogeneic but not of syngeneic bone marrow. The precise mechanism of M phi activation in the allogeneic radiation chimera in the complete absence of any detectable T cell function is not clear at present. However, these preactivated M phi display an important protective effect against L. monocytogenes: chimeras could eliminate Listeria without acquisition of positive delayed-type sensitivity when infected with 10(3) bacteria. An inoculum of 5 . 10(3) L. monocytogenes resulted either in prolonged survival compared with normal mice of the recipient haplotype or in definitive survival accompanied by a positive delayed-type sensitivity. We concluded that enhanced nonspecific immune functions can in part compensate for the defective specific immune system after bone marrow transfer.     

In vitro and in vivo analysis of bone marrow-derived CD3+, CD4-, CD8-, NK1.1+ cell lines

The development of methods of avoiding graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) while retaining the alloengraftment-promoting and anti-leukemic effects of allogeneic T cells is a major goal of research in bone marrow transplantation (BMT). We have recently obtained evidence suggesting that natural suppressor (NS) cells derived from T cell-depleted (TCD) syngeneic marrow can protect against GVHD while permitting alloengraftment. We have now attempted to enrich and then propagate NS cells in vitro, with the goal of obtaining an enhanced anti-GVHD effect by adoptive transfer in vivo. Two long-term cell lines were generated culturing BMC depleted of Mac1-positive cells and of Mac1-positive plus Thy1-positive cells in high concentrations of IL-2. Both cell lines showed anti-GVHD effects when administered along with a GVHD-producing inoculum, while permitting complete allogeneic reconstitution. A clone derived from Mac1-depleted BMC protected completely against a more chronic pattern of GVHD. These cell lines demonstrated suppressive activity in vitro, cytolytic activity against a broad range of natural killer (NK)-sensitive and NK-resistant targets, and a novel cell surface phenotype, with characteristics of both alpha beta-TcR-bearing T cells and of NK cells. In some respects, these cells resemble LAK cells and differ from fresh NS cells, and from the cloned NS cells derived from spleens of total lymphoid irradiation (TLI)-treated mice and neonatal mice. To our knowledge, this is the first detailed phenotypic analysis of cell lines with in vivo anti-GVHD activity. If applicability can be demonstrated in large animal models, the ability to use bone marrow as a source of such protective cell lines might also have potential utility in clinical BMT.     

Natural immunity to grafts of FLD-3 erythroleukemia cells by irradiated mice

Mice were irradiated and infused with BALB/c Friend virus-induced FLD-3 erythroleukemia cells. Growth of the cells was estimated by measuring splenic incorporation of 5-iodo-2'-deoxyuridine-125I 5 days after cell transfer. BALB/cJ and C3H mice were 'poor responders' in that FLD-3 cells grew well in their spleens, while mice of other strains were 'good responders', resisting the growth of FLD-3 cells. No H-2 or Fv genetic locus was associated with resistance. Athymic nude mice and mice depleted of marrow tissue by 89Sr or estradiol resisted FLD-3 cells, indicating that the effectors were thymus- and marrow-independent. Silica, carrageenan and Propionibacterium acnes organisms all altered resistance, suggesting a function of macrophages. Neither interferon nor anti-interferon serum treatment altered resistance. Anti-asialo GM1 serum inhibited resistance to FLD-3 cells in vivo and inhibited natural cytotoxic (NC) activity against FLD-3 cells in vitro. NC (FLD-3) activity was greatly decreased in spleens 3 days after irradiation, in contrast with NK (YAC-1) and NC(WEHI-164.1) activities. Moreover, a 3-day delay in infusion of FLD-3 cells 'synergized' with silica in weakening genetic resistance in vivo. Thus, natural immunity to FLD-3 cells in vivo differs from that of genetic resistance to normal bone marrow cell allografts, and the lysis of FLD-3 cells in vitro seems to be mediated by cells which do not easily fit into the definition of natural killer (NK) or natural cytotoxic (NC) cells.     

Induction of bone marrow allograft rejection and hybrid resistance in nonresponder recipients by antibody: is there evidence for a dual receptor interaction in acute marrow graft rejection?

Acute marrow graft rejection in allogeneic or semiallogeneic donor-recipient mouse combinations has been suggested to be caused by natural killer (NK) cells. The unique in vitro specificity of NK cells for tumor cells, however, does not explain the specific rejection of bone marrow grafts by NK cells. Recent experiments have implicated antibody in marrow graft recipients as the specificity-inducing component that guides NK cells in an antibody-dependent cytotoxic (ADCC) reaction to attack the marrow graft. On the basis of this hypothesis, one would postulate that nonresponder marrow graft recipients can be converted into responders by injection with antibody of appropriate specificity. Results presented in this report show that this is indeed possible. Specific monoclonal or polyclonal antibody of IgG isotype induces marrow graft rejection in nonresponder recipients. This can be demonstrated in allogeneic as well as in semi-allogeneic (hybrid resistance) donor-recipient strain combinations. Antibody-induced marrow graft rejection is independent of complement and dependent on the presence of NK cells. Surprisingly, graft rejection induced by antibody is quite efficient in allogeneic and semiallogeneic marrow donor-recipient combinations, whereas it is generally poor in syngeneic combinations. This result is not understood if NK cells lyse bone marrow cells solely in an ADCC-type reaction. Because NK cells can lyse targets in an antibody-dependent as well as independent reaction, it is proposed that the binding of NK cells to targets via their receptors plays an additional role in the rejection of bone marrow in vivo. Preliminary evidence for this possibility is that NK cells in the apparent absence of antibody may have a detectable suppressive effect on the growth of marrow grafts in F1 hybrid mice transplanted with parental marrow grafts.     

Bone marrow-derived IFN-producing killer dendritic cells account for the tumoricidal activity of unpulsed dendritic cells

The CD11c(int)B220(+)NK1.1(+)CD49(+) subset of cells has recently been described as IFN-producing killer dendritic cells (IKDC), which share phenotypic and functional properties of dendritic cells and NK cells. Herein we show that bone marrow-derived murine dendritic cell preparations contain abundant CD11c(int)B220(+)NK1.1(+)CD49(+) cells, the removal of which results in loss of tumoricidal activity of unpulsed dendritic cells in vivo. Moreover, following s.c. injection, as few as 5 x 10(3) highly pure bone marrow-derived IKDC cells are capable of shrinking small contralateral syngeneic tumors in C57BL/6 mice, but not in immunodeficient mice, implying the obligate involvement of host effector cells in tumor rejection. Our data suggest that bone marrow-derived IKDC represent a population that has powerful tumoricidal activity in vivo.     

Different sensitivities to hydrocortisone of natural killer cell activity and hybrid resistance to parental marrow grafts.

Natural killer cells and cells mediating F1 anti-parent responses in vivo and in vitro differ in their sensitivity to hydrocortisone acetate. NK cell activity is sharply decreased after in vivo drug administration whereas induction of specific F1 anti-parent or anti-allogeneic cytotoxicity and hybrid resistance to parental marrow grafts are not impaired. Because of several other properties shared by the NK and anti-Hh host reactivities, it is still suggested that the effector cells are generated from a single differentiation pathway, but that they differ with respect to specificity and sensitivity to hydrocortisone.     

Rapid conversion of effector mechanisms from NK to T cells during virus-induced lysis of allogeneic implants in vivo

Viral infections can strongly stimulate both NK cell and allospecific CD8 T cell responses, and these same effector cells can lyse allogeneic cell lines in vitro. However, the impact of viral infections on the effector systems mediating rejection of allogeneic tissues in vivo has not been fully explored. Using in vivo cytotoxicity assays, we evaluated the effector systems mediating the rejection of CFSE-labeled allogeneic splenocytes after an infection of C57BL/6 (B6) mice with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus. Naive B6 mice predominantly used a NK cell-effector mechanism to reject allogeneic splenocytes because they rejected BALB/C (H2(d)) splenocytes but not CBA (H2(k)) splenocytes, and the rejection was prevented by immunodepletion of NK1.1(+) or Ly49D(+) NK cells. This rapid and efficient in vivo cytotoxicity assay recapitulated the specificity of NK cell-mediated rejection seen in longer duration in vivo assays. However, as early as 1 day after infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus, a CD8 T cell-dependent mechanism participated in the rejection process and a broader range of tissue haplotypes (e.g., H2(k)) was susceptible. The CD8 T cell-mediated in vivo rejection process was vigorous at a time postinfection (day 3) when NK cell effector functions are peaking, indicating that the effector systems used in vivo differed from those observed with in vitro assays measuring the killing of allogeneic cells. This rapid generation of allospecific CTL activity during a viral infection preceded the peak of viral epitope-specific T cell responses, as detected by in vivo or in vitro cytotoxicity assays.