Self-incompatibility (S) alleles of the rosaceae encode members of a distinct class of the T2/S ribonuclease superfamily

Stylar riboncleases (RNases) are associated with gametophytic self-incompatibility in two plant families, the Solanaceae and the Rosaceae. The self-incompatibility-associated RNases (S-RNases) of both the Solanaceae and the Rosaceae were recently reported to belong to the T2 RNase gene family, based on the presence of two well-conserved sequence motifs. Here, the cloning and characterization of S-RNase genes from two species of Rosaceae, apple (Malus × domestica) and Japanese pear (Pyrus serotina) is described and these sequences are compared with those of other T2-type RNases. The S-RNases of apple specifically accumulated in styles following maturation of the flower bud. Two cDNA clones for S-RNases from apple, and PCR clones encoding a further two apple S-RNases as well as two Japanese pear S-RNases were isolated and sequenced. The deduced amino acid sequences of the rosaceous S-RNases contained two conserved regions characteristic of the T2/S-type RNases. The sequences showed a high degree of diversity, with similarities ranging from 60.4% to 69.2%. Interestingly, some interspecific sequence similarities were higher than those within a species, possibly indicating that diversification of S-RNase alleles predated speciation in the Rosaceae. A phylogenetic tree of members of the T2/S-RNase superfamily in plants was obtained. The rosaceous S-RNases formed a new lineage in the tree that was distinct from those of the solanaceous S-RNases and the S-like RNases. The findings suggested that self-incompatibility mechanisms in Rosaceae and Solanaceae are similar but arose independently in the course of evolution.     

Cloning and characterization of cDNAs encoding S-RNases from almond ( Prunus dulcis ): primary structural features and sequence diversity of the S-RNases in Rosaceae

cDNAs encoding three S-RNases of almond (Prunus dulcis), which belongs to the family Rosaceae, were cloned and sequenced. The comparison of amino acid sequences between the S-RNases of almond and those of other rosaceous species showed that the amino acid sequences of the rosaceous S-RNases are highly divergent, and intra-subfamilial similarities are higher than inter-subfamilial similarities. Twelve amino acid sequences of the rosaceous S-RNases were aligned to characterize their primary structural features. In spite of␣their high level of diversification, the rosaceous S-RNases were found to have five conserved regions, C1, C2, C3, C5, and RC4 which is Rosaceae-specific conserved region. Many variable sites fall into one region, named RHV. RHV is located at a similar position to that of the hypervariable region a (HVa) of the solanaceous S-RNases, and is assumed to be involved in recognizing S-specificity of pollen. On the other hand, the region corresponding to another solanaceous hypervariable region (HVb) was not variable in the rosaceous S-RNases. In the phylogenetic tree of the T2/S type RNase, the rosaceous S-RNase fall into two subfamily-specific groups (Amygdaloideae and Maloideae). The results of sequence comparisons and phylogenetic analysis imply that the present S-RNases of Rosaceae have diverged again relatively recently, after the divergence of subfamilies. Received: 28 May 1998 / Accepted: 13 August 1998     

Primary structural features of rosaceous S-RNases associated with gametophytic self-incompatibility

We isolated cDNA clones encoding five S-RNases (S_1-,_S3- , S_5-, S_6-, S_7-RNases) from pistils of Pyrus pyrifolia (Japanese pear), a member of the Rosaceae. Their amino acid sequences were aligned with those of other rosaceous S-RNases sequenced so far. A total of 76 conserved amino acid residues were stretched throughout the sequence, but were absent from the 51–66 region which was designated the hypervariable (HV) region. The phylogenetic tree of rosaceous S-RNases showed that S-RNase polymorphism predated the divergence of Pyrus and Malus. Pairwise comparison of these S-RNases detected two highly homologous pairs, P. pyrifolia S_1- and S_4-RNases (90.0%) and P. pyrifolia S_3- and S_5-RNases (95.5%). The positions of amino acid substitutions between S_1- and S_4-RNases were spread over the entire region, but in the pair of S_3- and S_5-RNases, amino acid substitutions were found in the 21–90 region including the HV region. The substitutions in this restricted region appear to be sufficient to discriminate between S₃ and S₅ pollen and to trigger the self-incompatible reaction.     

Cloning and characterization of cDNAs encoding S-RNases from almond (Prunus dulcis): primary structural features and sequence diversity of the S-RNases in Rosaceae

cDNAs encoding three S-RNases of almond (Prunus dulcis), which belongs to the family Rosaceae, were cloned and sequenced. The comparison of amino acid sequences between the S-RNases of almond and those of other rosaceous species showed that the amino acid sequences of the rosaceous S-RNases are highly divergent, and intra-subfamilial similarities are higher than inter-subfamilial similarities. Twelve amino acid sequences of the rosaceous S-RNases were aligned to characterize their primary structural features. In spite of?their high level of diversification, the rosaceous S-RNases were found to have five conserved regions, C1, C2, C3, C5, and RC4 which is Rosaceae-specific conserved region. Many variable sites fall into one region, named RHV. RHV is located at a similar position to that of the hypervariable region a (HVa) of the solanaceous S-RNases, and is assumed to be involved in recognizing S-specificity of pollen. On the other hand, the region corresponding to another solanaceous hypervariable region (HVb) was not variable in the rosaceous S-RNases. In the phylogenetic tree of the T2/S type RNase, the rosaceous S-RNase fall into two subfamily-specific groups (Amygdaloideae and Maloideae). The results of sequence comparisons and phylogenetic analysis imply that the present S-RNases of Rosaceae have diverged again relatively recently, after the divergence of subfamilies.     

Identification of regions in which positive selection may operate in S-RNase of Rosaceae: Implication for S-allele-specific recognition sites in S-RNase

A stylar S-RNase is associated with gametophytic self-incompatibility in the Rosaceae, Solanaceae, and Scrophulariaceae. This S-RNase is responsible for S-allele-specific recognition in the self-incompatible reaction, but how it functions in specific discrimination is not clear. Window analysis of the numbers of synonymous (d_S) and non-synonymous (d_N) substitutions in rosaceous S-RNases detected four regions with an excess of d_N over d_S in which positive selection may operate (PS regions). The topology of the secondary structure of the S-RNases predicted by the PHD method is very similar to that of fungal RNase Rh whose tertiary structure is known. When the sequences of S-RNases are aligned with the sequence of RNase Rh based on the predicted secondary structures, the four PS regions correspond to two surface sites on the tertiary structure of RNase Rh. These findings suggest that in S-RNases the PS regions also form two sites and are candidates for the recognition sites for S-allele-specific discrimination.     

PD1, an S-like RNase gene from a self-incompatible cultivar of almond

 Many flowering plants contain stylar S-RNases that are involved in self-incompatibility and S-like RNases of which the biological function is uncertain. This paper reports the deduced amino acid sequence of an S-like RNase gene (PD1) from the self-incompatible plant Prunus dulcis (almond). The amino acid sequence of PD1, which was derived from cDNA and genomic DNA clones, showed 34–86% identity to acidic plant S-like RNases reported so far, with the highest degree of similarity being to an S-like RNase from Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia). Based on RNA hybridisation experiments it appears that, like for many other S-like RNases, the expression of PD1 is not pistil-specific. Analysis of the genomic structure revealed the presence of three introns, of which one is similar in location to that of the related S-RNase gene from Solanaceae and Rosaceae. At least four bands hybridising to PD1 were found upon Southern hybridisation, suggesting the presence of a multigene family of S-like RNase genes in almond. The putative biological function of PD1 is discussed. Received: 22 November 1999 / Revision received: 18 February 2000 · Accepted: 13 March 2000     

Evolutionary analysis of S-RNase genes from Rosaceae species

Eight new cDNA sequences for S-RNases were cloned and analysed from almond (Prunus dulcis) cultivars of European origin, and compared to published sequences from other Rosaceae species. Insertions/deletions of 10-20 amino acid residues were detected in the RC4 and C5 domains of S-RNases from almond and sweet cherry. The S-RNases of the Prunus species and those of the genera Malus and Pyrus formed two distinct groups on phylogenetic analysis. Nucleotide substitutions were analysed in the S-RNase genes of these species. The S-genes of almond and sweet cherry have a lower Ka/Ks value than those of apple, pear and wild apple do. The fact that there is no fixed difference between the S-RNase genes of almond and sweet cherry, or between apple and pear, suggests that nucleotide substitutions only introduce transient polymorphism into the two groups, and rarely became fixed and contribute to divergence. Through the comparative study of 17 S-RNase genes from the genus Prunus and 18 from the genera Malus and Pyrus, some fixed nucleotide differences between the two groups were identified. These differences do not appear to be the result of selection for adaptive mutations, since the number of replacement substitutions is not significantly greater than the number of synonymous substitutions. S-RNase genes of almond and sweet cherry, and of apple and pear, showed little heterogeneity in nucleotide substitution rates. However, heterogeneity was observed between the two groups of S-alleles, with the Prunus alleles exhibiting a lower rate of non-synonymous substitutions than alleles from Malus and Pyrus. The evolutionary relationships between these species are discussed.     

Self-incompatibility RNases from three plant families: homology or convergence?

In the Rosaceae, Scrophulariaceae, and Solanaceae, the stylar product of the self-incompatibility (S-) locus is an RNase. Using protein sequence data from 34 RNase genes (three fungal RNases, seven angiosperm non-S RNases, 11 Rosaceae S-alleles, three Scrophulariaceae S-alleles, and ten Solanaceae S-alleles) we reconstructed the genealogy of angiosperm RNases using the neighbor joining method and two distance metrics in order to assess whether use of S-RNases in these families is the result of homology or convergence. Four monophyletic groups of angiosperm RNases were found: the S-RNases of each of the three families and a group comprising most of the angiosperm non-S RNases. The S-RNases of the Scrophulariaceae and Solanaceae were found to be homologous but strong inference concerning the homology or convergence of S-RNases from the Rosaceae with those of the other families was not possible because of uncertain placement of both the root and two of the angiosperm non-S RNases. The most recent common ancestor of the Rosaceae and both the Scrophulariaceae and Solanaceae is shared by ~80% of dicot families. If the -RNases of the Rosaceae are homologous to those of the Scrophulariaceae and Solanaceae, then many other dicot families might be expected to share RNases as the mechanism of gametophytic self-incompatibility.     

Characterization of the flanking regions of the S-RNase genes of Japanese pear (Pyrus serotina) and apple (Malus×domestica)

Genomic sequences of the self-incompatibility genes, the S-RNase genes, from two rosaceous species, Japanese pear and apple, were characterized. Genomic Southern blot and sequencing of a 4.5-kb genomic clone showed that the S⁴-RNase gene of Japanese pear is surrounded by repetitive sequences as in the case of the S-RNase genes of solanaceous species. The flanking regions of the S²- and S^f-RNase genes of apple were also cloned and sequenced. The 5′ flanking regions of the three alleles bore no similarity with those of the solanaceous S-RNase genes, although the position and sequence of the putative TATA box were conserved. The putative promoter regions of the Japanese pear S⁴- and apple S^f-RNase genes shared a stretch of about 200 bp with 80% sequence identity. However, this sequence was not present in the S²-RNase gene of apple, and thus it may reflect a close relationship between the S⁴- and S^f-RNase genes rather than a cis-element important in regulating gene expression. Despite the uniform pattern of expression of the rosaceous S-RNase genes, sequence motifs conserved in the 5′ flanking regions of the three alleles were not found, implying that the cis-element controlling pistil specific gene expression also locates at the intragenic region or upstream of the analyzed promoter region.     

Sequence divergence and loss-of-function phenotypes of S locus F-box brothers genes are consistent with non-self recognition by multiple pollen determinants in self-incompatibility of Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia)

The S-RNase-based gametophytic self-incompatibility (SI) of Rosaceae, Solanaceae, and Plantaginaceae is controlled by at least two tightly linked genes located at the complex S locus; the highly polymorphic S-RNase for pistil specificity and the F-box gene (SFB/SLF) for pollen. Self-incompatibility in Prunus (Rosaceae) is considered to represent a 'self recognition by a single factor' system, because loss-of-function of SFB is associated with self-compatibility, and allelic divergence of SFB is high and comparable to that of S-RNase. In contrast, Petunia (Solanaceae) exhibits 'non-self recognition by multiple factors'. However, the distribution of 'self recognition' and 'non-self recognition' SI systems in different taxa is not clear. In addition, in 'non-self recognition' systems, a loss-of-function phenotype of pollen S is unknown. Here we analyze the divergence of SFBB genes, the multiple pollen S candidates, of a rosaceous plant Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia) and show that intrahaplotypic divergence is high and comparable to the allelic diversity of S-RNase while interhaplotypic divergence is very low. Next, we analyzed loss-of-function of the SFBB1 type gene. Genetic analysis showed that pollen with the mutant haplotype S(4sm) lacking SFBB1-S(4) is rejected by pistils with an otherwise compatible S(1) while it is accepted by other non-self pistils. We found that the S(5) haplotype encodes a truncated SFBB1 protein, even though S(5) pollen is accepted normally by pistils with S(1) and other non-self haplotypes. These findings suggest that Japanese pear has a 'non-self recognition by multiple factors' SI system, although it is a species of Rosaceae to which Prunus also belongs.     

Pollen-expressed F-box gene family and mechanism of S-RNase-based gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) in Rosaceae

Many species of Rosaceae, Solanaceae, and Plantaginaceae exhibit S-RNase-based self-incompatibility (SI) in which pistil-part specificity is controlled by S locus-encoded ribonuclease (S-RNase). Although recent findings revealed that S locus-encoded F-box protein, SLF/SFB, determines pollen-part specificity, how these pistil- and pollen-part S locus products interact in vivo and elicit the SI reaction is largely unclear. Furthermore, genetic studies suggested that pollen S function can differ among species. In Solanaceae and the rosaceous subfamily Maloideae (e.g., apple and pear), the coexistence of two different pollen S alleles in a pollen breaks down SI of the pollen, a phenomenon known as competitive interaction. However, competitive interaction seems not to occur in the subfamily Prunoideae (e.g., cherry and almond) of Rosaceae. Furthermore, the effect of the deletion of pollen S seems to vary among taxa. This review focuses on the potential differences in pollen-part function between subfamilies of Rosaceae, Maloideae, and Prunoideae, and discusses implications for the mechanistic divergence of the S-RNase-based SI.     

The RHV region of S-RNase in the European pear (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Pyrus communis</Emphasis>) is not required for the determination of specific pollen rejection

In the gametophytic self-incompatibility system, growth of self-pollen tubes in the style is inhibited in a haplotype-specific manner by S-RNase. The mechanism by which S-RNase confers its specificity is unknown. However, a hypervariable region (RHV in Rosaceae and HVa-HVb in Solanaceae) that differs among the many cloned S-RNase alleles has been proposed to be involved in conferring the S-haplotype specificity of the S-RNase. Region swapping experiments between S-RNases and crystallography of the enzyme support this assumption. However, the deduced amino acid sequences of Sn-RNase and Si-RNase alleles from the European pear (Pyrus communis) were recently found to have an identical RHV. In the present study it is shown that Sn-RNase does not prevent fertilization by Si-pollen haplotype, thus presenting a case in which RHV is not required for the determination of specific pollen rejection by S-RNase, and implying that other regions in the enzyme may be sufficient for this specificity.     

基于cDNA芯片的梨品种S基因型鉴定及新S-RNase基因进化分析

梨品种S基因型鉴定对梨栽培中授粉品种选择和遗传育种都具有重要意义。本研究利用梨S-RNase基因荧光标记的特异引物PCR扩增获得梨品种荧光标记的cDNA特异产物;进一步完善梨S-RNase基因cDNA芯片,以被检测梨品种cDNA特异序列与梨S-RNase基因cDNA芯片杂交检测不同梨品种S基因型,并发现新的S-RNase基因。结果表明:利用梨S-RNase基因cDNA芯片鉴定了泸定王皮梨、兴山24号、弥渡百合等35个未知S基因型梨品种,确定了各品种的S基因型。结合PCRRFLP及DNA克隆和测序等技术,发现了7个新的S-RNase基因资源,获得了新S-RNase基因序列。序列分析表明各新S-RNase基因均具有S-RNase基因特异区域序列的典型特征;进化分析显示7个新S-RNase基因主要属于蔷薇科苹果亚科S-RNase类群,且存在种间和属间比种内和属内进化关系更近的现象。7个新的S基因分别命名为:PpS_(53)(Pyrus pyrifolia S53)、PpS_(54)、PpS_(55)、PpS_(56)、PpS_(57)、PpS_(58)和PpS_(59),GenBank登录号分别为:KX581753、KX581754、KX581755、KX581756、KX581757、KX581751和KX581752。     

Identification and evolutionary analysis of a relic S-RNase in<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Antirrhinum</Emphasis>

In several gametophytic self-incompatible species of the Solanaceae, a group of RNases named relic S-RNase has been identified that belong to the S-RNase lineage but are no longer involved in self-incompatibility. However, their function, evolution and presence in the Scrophulariaceae remained largely unknown. Here, we analyzed the expression of S-RNase and its related genes in Antirrhinum, a member of the Scrophulariacaeae, and identified a pistil-specific RNase gene; AhRNase29 encodes a predicted polypeptide of 235 amino acids with an estimated molecular weight of 26 kDa. Sequence and phylogenetic analyses indicated that AhRNase29 forms a monophyletic clade with Antirrhinum S-RNases, similar to that observed for other relic S-RNases. Possible evolution and function of relic S-RNases are discussed.     

Structural and transcriptional analysis of the self-incompatibility locus of almond: identification of a pollen-expressed F-box gene with haplotype-specific polymorphism

Gametophytic self-incompatibility in Rosaceae, Solanaceae, and Scrophulariaceae is controlled by the S locus, which consists of an S-RNase gene and an unidentified "pollen S" gene. An approximately 70-kb segment of the S locus of the rosaceous species almond, the S haplotype-specific region containing the S-RNase gene, was sequenced completely. This region was found to contain two pollen-expressed F-box genes that are likely candidates for pollen S genes. One of them, named SFB (S haplotype-specific F-box protein), was expressed specifically in pollen and showed a high level of S haplotype-specific sequence polymorphism, comparable to that of the S-RNases. The other is unlikely to determine the S specificity of pollen because it showed little allelic sequence polymorphism and was expressed also in pistil. Three other S haplotypes were cloned, and the pollen-expressed genes were physically mapped. In all four cases, SFBs were linked physically to the S-RNase genes and were located at the S haplotype-specific region, where recombination is believed to be suppressed, suggesting that the two genes are inherited as a unit. These features are consistent with the hypothesis that SFB is the pollen S gene. This hypothesis predicts the involvement of the ubiquitin/26S proteasome proteolytic pathway in the RNase-based gametophytic self-incompatibility system.     

Gametophytic self-incompatibility in Lycium parishii (Solanaceae): allelic diversity, genealogical structure, and patterns of molecular evolution at the S-RNase locus

We characterized allelic diversity at the locus controlling self-incompatibility (SI) for a population of Lycium parishii (Solanaceae) from Organ Pipe National Monument, Arizona. Twenty-four partial sequences of S-RNase alleles were recovered from 25 individuals. Estimates of allelic diversity range from 23 to 27 alleles and, consistent with expectations for SI, individuals are heterozygous. We compare S-RNase diversity, patterns of molecular evolution, and the genealogical structure of alleles from L. parishii to a previously studied population of its congener L. andersonii. Gametophytic SI is well characterized for Solanaceae and although balancing selection is hypothesized to be responsible for high levels of allelic divergence, the pattern of selection varies depending on the portion of the gene considered. Site-specific models investigating patterns of selection for L. parishii and L. andersonii indicate that positive selection occurs in those regions of the S-RNase gene hypothesized as important to the recognition response, whereas positive selection was not detected for any position within regions previously characterized as conserved. A 10-species genealogy including S-RNases from a pair of congeners from each of five genera in Solanaceae reveals extensive transgeneric evolution of L. parishii S-RNases. Further, within Lycium, the Dn/Ds ratios for pairs of closely related alleles for intraspecific versus interspecific comparisons were not significantly different, suggesting that the S-RNase diversity recovered in these two species was present prior to the speciation event separating them. Despite this, two S-RNases from L. parishii are identical to two previously reported alleles for L. andersonii, suggesting gene flow between these species.     

Purification and characterization of a non-S-RNase and S-RNases from styles of Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia)

In this study we biochemically characterized stylar ribonucleases (RNases) of Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia), which exhibits S-RNase-based gametophytic self-incompatibility. We separated the RNase fractions NS-1, NS-2, and NS-3 from stylar extracts of the cultivar Nijisseiki (S(2)S(4)). The RNase in each fraction was purified to homogeneity through a series of chromatographic steps. Chemical analysis of the proteins revealed that the basic RNases in the NS-2 and NS-3 fractions were the S(4)- and S(2)-RNases, respectively. Five additional S-RNases were purified from other cultivars. An acidic RNase in the NS-1 fraction was also purified from other cultivars, and identified as a non-S-allele-associated RNase (non-S-RNase). The non-S-RNase is composed of 203 amino acids, is non-glycosylated and is a N-terminal-pyroglutamylated enzyme of the RNase T(2) family. The substrate specificities and optimum pH levels of the non-S-RNase and S-RNases were similar. Interestingly, the specific activity of the non-S-RNase was 7.5-221-fold higher than those of the S-RNases when tolura yeast RNA was used as the substrate. The specific activity of the S(2)-RNase was 8.8-28.6-fold lower than those of the other S-RNases. These differences in specific activities among the stylar RNases are discussed.     

The evolution of self-incompatibility: a molecular voyeur's perspective

This review summarises current understanding of the evolution of self-incompatibility inferred from DNA sequence analysis. Self-incompatibility in many plant families is controlled by a single, highly polymorphicS-locus which, in the Solanaceae, encodes an allelic series of stylar ribonucleases known as the S-RNases. PCR approaches are a convenient way to examine the diversity of S-RNase sequences within and between wild populations of a self-incompatible species and provide a unique view into the species' current and historic population structure. Similar molecular appoaches have also been used to show that S-RNases are involved in self-incompatibility in families other than the Solanaceae. A model for the evolution of ribonuclease-based self-incompatibility systems is discussed.