A directional nucleation-zipping mechanism for triple helix formation

A detailed kinetic study of triple helix formation was performed by surface plasmon resonance. Three systems were investigated involving 15mer pyrimidine oligonucleotides as third strands. Rate constants and activation energies were validated by comparison with thermodynamic values calculated from UV-melting analysis. Replacement of a T·A base pair by a C·G pair at either the 5′ or the 3′ end of the target sequence allowed us to assess mismatch effects and to delineate the mechanism of triple helix formation. Our data show that the association rate constant is governed by the sequence of base triplets on the 5′ side of the triplex (referred to as the 5′ side of the target oligopurine strand) and provides evidence that the reaction pathway for triple helix formation in the pyrimidine motif proceeds from the 5′ end to the 3′ end of the triplex according to the nucleation-zipping model. It seems that this is a general feature for all triple helices formation, probably due to the right-handedness of the DNA double helix that provides a stronger base stacking at the 5′ than at the 3′ duplex–triplex junction. Understanding the mechanism of triple helix formation is not only of fundamental interest, but may also help in designing better triple helix-forming oligonucleotides for gene targeting and control of gene expression.     

Intramolecular triple-helix formation at (PunPyn).(PunPyn) tracts: recognition of alternate strands via Pu.PuPy and Py.PuPy base triplets.

Triple-helical DNA shows increasing potential for applications in the control of gene expression (including therapeutics) and the development of sequence-specific DNA-cleaving agents. The major limitation in this technology has been the requirement of homopurine sequences for triplex formation. We describe a simple approach that relaxes this requirement, by utilizing both Pu.PuPy and Py.PuPy base triplets to form a continuous DNA triple helix at tandem oligopurine and oligopyrimidine tracts. [Triplex formation at such a sequence has been previously demonstrated only with the use of a special 3'-3' linkage in the third strand [Horne, D. A., & Dervan, P. B. (1990) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 112, 2435-2437].] Supporting evidence is from chemical probing experiments performed on several oligonucleotides designed to form 3-stranded fold-back structures. The third strand, consisting of both purine and pyrimidine blocks, pairs with purines in the Watson-Crick duplex, switching strands at the junction between the oligopurine and oligopyrimidine blocks but maintaining the required strand polarity without any special linkage. Although Mg2+ ions are not required for the formation of Pu.PuPy base triplets, they show enhanced stability in the presence of Mg2+. In the sequences observed. A.AT triplets appear to be more stable than G.GC triplets. As expected, triplex formation is largely independent of pH unless C+.GC base triplets are required.     

Single-Stranded DNA and RNA Targeted Triplex-Formation: UV,CD and Molecular Modeling Studies of Foldback Triplexes Containing Different RNA, 2′-OMe-RNA and DNA Strand Combinations

Abstract

We studied the influence of different 2′-OMe-RNA and DNA strand combinations on single strand targeted foldback triplex formation in the Py.Pu:Py motif using ultraviolet (UV) and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy, and molecular modeling. The study of eight combinations of triplexes (D D:D, R* D:D, D D:R*, R* D:R*, D R:D, R* R:D, DR:R*, and R*-R:R*; where the first, middle, and last letters stand for the Hoogsteen Pyrimidine, Watson-Crick [WC] purine and WC pyrimidine strands, respectively, and D, R and R* stand for DNA, RNA and 2′-OMe-RNA strands, respectively) indicate more stable foldback triplex formation with a DNA purine strand than with an RNA purine strand. Of the four possible WC duplexes with RNA/DNA combinations, the duplex with a DNA purine strand and a 2′-O-Me-RNA pyrimidine strand forms the most thermally stable triplex, although its thermal stability is the lowest of all four duplexes. Irrespective of the duplex combination, a 2′-OMe-RNA Hoogsteen pyrimidine strand forms a stable foldback triplex over a DNA Hoogsteen pyrimidine strand confirming the earlier reports with conventional and circular triplexes. The CD studies suggest a B-type conformation for an all DNA homo-foldback triplex (D.D.D), while hetero-foldback triplex spectra suggest intermediate conformation to both Atype and B-type structures. A novel molecular modeling study has been carried out to understand the stereochemical feasibility of all the combinations of foldback triplexes using a geometric approach. The new approach allows use of different combinations of chain geometries depending on the nature of the chain (RNA vs. DNA).     

Energetics of strand-displacement reactions in triple helices: a spectroscopic study.

DNA triple helices offer exciting new perspectives toward oligonucleotide-directed inhibition of gene expression. Purine and GT triplexes appear to be the most promising motifs for stable binding under physiological conditions compared to the pyrimidine motif, which forms at relatively low pH. There are, however, very little data available for comparison of the relative stabilities of the different classes of triplexes under identical conditions. We, therefore, designed a model system which allowed us to set up a competition between the oligonucleotides of the purine and pyrimidine motifs targeting the same Watson-Crick duplex. Several conclusions may be drawn: (i) a weak hypochromism at 260 nm is associated with purine triplex formation; (ii) delta H degree of GA, GT and TC triplex formation (at pH 7.0) was calculated as -0.1, -2.5 and -6.1 kcal/mol per base triplet, respectively. This unexpectedly low delta H degree for the purine triple helix formation implies that its delta G degree is nearly temperature-independent and it explains why these triplexes may still be observed at high temperatures. In contrast, the pyrimidine triplex is strongly favoured at lower temperatures; (iii) as a consequence, in a system where two third-strands compete for triplex formation, displacement of the GA or GT strand by a pyrimidine strand may be observed at neutral pH upon lowering the temperature. This original purine-to-pyrimidine triplex conversion shows a significant hypochromism at 260 nm and a hyperchromism at 295 nm which is similar to the duplex-to-triplex conversion in the pyrimidine motif. Further evidence for this triplex-to-triplex conversion is provided by mung bean-nuclease foot-printing assay.     

Pyrimidine morpholino oligonucleotides form a stable triple helix in the absence of magnesium ions

Oligonucleotides can be used as sequence-specific DNA ligands by forming a local triple helix. In order to form more stable triple-helical structures or prevent their degradation in cells, oligonucleotide analogues that are modified at either the backbone or base level are routinely used. Morpholino oligonucleotides appeared recently as a promising modification for antisense applications. We report here a study that indicates the possibility of a triple helix formation with a morpholino pyrimidine TFO and its comparison with a phosphodiester and a phosphoramidate oligonucleotide. At a neutral pH and in the presence of a high magnesium ion concentration (10 mM), the phosphoramidate oligomer forms the most stable triple helix, whereas in the absence of magnesium ion but at a physiological monovalent cation concentration (0.14 M) only morpholino oligonucleotides form a stable triplex. To our knowledge, this is the first report of a stable triple helix in the pyrimidine motif formed by a noncharged oligonucleotide third strand (the morpholino oligonucleotide) and a DNA duplex. We show here that the structure formed with the morpholino oligomer is a bona fide triple helix and it is destabilized by high concentrations of potassium ions or divalent cations (Mg(2+)).     

Effect of a 5'-phosphate on the stability of triple helix.

An effect of 5'-phosphorylation on the stability of triple helical DNA containing pyrimidine:purine:pyrimidine strands has been demonstrated by both gel electrophoresis and UV melting. A 5'-phosphate on the purine-rich middle strand of a triple helix lowers the stability of triple helix formation by approximately 1 kcal/mol at 25 degrees C. The middle strand is involved in both Watson-Crick and Hoogsteen base pairing. In contrast, a 5'-phosphate on the pyrimidine-rich strands, which are involved in either Watson-Crick or Hoogsteen base pairing, has a smaller effect on the stability of triple helix. The order of stability is: no phosphate on either strand > phosphate on both pyrimidine strands > phosphate on purine strand > phosphate on all three strands. Differential stability of triple helix species is postulated to stem from an increase in rigidity due to steric hindrance from the 5'-phosphate. This result indicates that labelling with 32P affect equilibrium in triplex formation.     

Investigation of the formation and intracellular stability of purine.(purine/pyrimidine) triplexes.

In a previous work we showed that a short triple helix-forming oligonucleotide (TFO) targeted to the murine c-pim-1 proto-oncogene promoter gives a very stable triple helix under physiological conditions in vitro . Moreover, this triplex was stable inside cells when preformed in vitro . However, we failed to detect triplex formation for this sequence inside cells in DMS footprinting studies. In the present work, in order to determine whether our previous in vivo results are limited to this particular short triplex or can be generalized to other purine.(purine/pyrimidine) triplexes, we have tested three other DNA targets already described in the literature. All these purine.(purine/pyrimidine) triplexes are specific and stable at high temperature in vitro . In vivo studies have shown that the preformed triplexes are stable inside cells for at least 3 days. This clearly demonstrates that intracellular conditions are favourable for the existence of purine. (purine/pyrimidine) triplexes. The triplexes can also be formed in nuclei. However, for all the sequences tested, we were unable to detect any triple helix formation in vivo in intact cells by DMS footprinting. Our results show that neither (i) chromatinization of the DNA target, (ii) intracellular K+concentration nor (iii) cytoplasmic versus nuclear separation of the TFO and DNA target are responsible for the intracellular arrest of triplex formation. We suggest the existence of a cellular mechanism, based on a compartmentalization of TFOs and/or TFO trapping, which separates oligonucleotides from the DNA target. Further work is needed to find oligonucleotide derivatives and means for their delivery to overcome the problem of triplex formation inside cells.     

Physico-chemical studies on DNA triplexes containing an alternate third strand with a non-nucleotide linker

Differential scanning calorimetric (DSC), circular dichroism (CD) and molecular mechanics studies have been performed on two triple helices of DNA. The target duplex consists of 16 base pairs in alternate sequence of the type 5′-(purine)_m(pyrimidine)_m-3′. In both the triplexes, the third oligopyrimidine strand crosses the major groove at the purine–pyrimidine junction, with a simultaneous binding of the adjacent purine tracts on alternate strands of the Watson–Crick duplex. The switch is ensured by a non-nucleotide linker, the 1,2,3 propanetriol residue, that joins two 3′–3′ phosphodiester ends. The third strands differ from each other for a nucleotide in the junction region. The resulting triple helices were termed 14-mer-PXP and 15-mer-PXP (where P=phosphate and X=1,2,3-propanetriol residue) according to the number of nucleotides that compose the third strand. DSC data show two independent processes: the first corresponding to the dissociation of the third strand from the target duplex, the second to the dissociation of the double helix in two single strands. The two triple helices show the same stability at pH 6.6. At pH 6.0, the 15-mer-PXP triplex is thermodynamically more stable than the 14-mer-PXP triplex. Thermodynamic data are discussed in relation to structural models. The results are useful when considering the design of oligonucleotides that can bind in an antigene approach to the DNA for therapeutic purposes.     

Chemical modification of the third strand: differential effects on purine and pyrimidine triple helix formation.

DNA triple helices offer exciting perspectives toward oligonucleotide-directed control of gene expression. Oligonucleotide analogues are routinely used with modifications in either the backbone or the bases to form more stable triple-helical structures or to prevent their degradation in cells. In this article, different chemical modifications are tested in a model system, which sets up a competition between the purine and pyrimidine motifs. For most modifications, the DeltaH degrees of purine triplex formation is close to zero, implying a nearly temperature-independent affinity constant. In contrast, the pyrimidine triplex is strongly favored at lower temperatures. The stabilization induced by modifications previously known to be favorable to the pyrimidine motif was quantified. Interestingly, modifications favorable to the GT motif (propynyl-U and dU replacing T) were also discovered. In a system where two third strands compete for triplex formation, replacement of the GA or GT strand by a pyrimidine strand may be observed at neutral pH upon lowering the temperature. This purine-to-pyrimidine triplex conversion depends on the chemical nature of the triplex-forming strands and the stability of the corresponding triplexes.     

Recognition of nucleic acid double helices by homopyrimidine 2', 5'-linked RNA.

We have studied the effect of a 2',5'-RNA third strand backbone on the stability of triple helices with a 'pyrimidine motif' targeting the polypurine strand of duplex DNA, duplex RNA and DNA/RNA hybrids. Comparative experiments were run in parallel with DNA and the regioisomeric RNA as third strands adopting the experimental design of Roberts and Crothers. The results reveal that 2',5'-RNA is indeed able to recognize double helical DNA (DD) and DNA (purine):RNA (pyrimidine) hybrids (DR). However, when the duplex purine strand is RNA and the duplex pyrimidine strand is DNA or RNA (i.e. RD or RR), triplex formation is not observed. These results exactly parallel what is observed for DNA third strands. Based on T m data, the affinities of 2',5'-RNA and DNA third strands towards DD and DR duplexes were similar. The RNA third strand formed triplexes with all four hairpins, as previously demonstrated. In analogy to the arabinose and 2'-deoxyribose third strands, the possible C2'- endo pucker of 2',5'-linked riboses together with the lack of an alpha-2'-OH group are believed to be responsible for the selective binding of 2',5'-RNA to DD and DR duplexes, over RR and RD duplexes. These studies indicate that the use of other oligonucleotide analogues will prove extremely useful in dissecting the contributions of backbone and/or sugar puckering to the recognition of nucleic acid duplexes.     

Influence of pH on the equilibrium association constants for oligodeoxyribonucleotide-directed triple helix formation at single DNA sites.

The energetics of oligodeoxyribonucleotide-directed triple helix formation for the pyrimidine.purine.pyrimidine structural motif were determined over the pH range 5.8-7.6 at 22 degrees C (100 mM Na+ and 1 mM spermine) using quantitative affinity cleavage titration. The equilibrium binding constants for 5'-TTTTTCTCTCTCTCT-3' (1) and 5'-TTTTTm5CTm5CTm5CTm5CTm5CT-3' (2, m5C is 2'-deoxy-5-methylcytidine) increased by 10- and 20-fold, respectively, from pH 7.6 to 5.8, indicating that the corresponding triple-helical complexes are stabilized by 1.4 and 1.7 kcal.mol-1, respectively, at the lower pH. Replacement of the five cytosine residues in 1 with 5-methylcytosine residues to yield 2 affords a stabilization of the triple helix by 0.1-0.4 kcal.mol-1 over the pH range 5.8-7.6. An analysis of these data in terms of a quantitative model for a general pH-dependent equilibrium transition revealed that pyrimidine oligonucleotides with cytidine and 5-methylcytidine form local triple-helical structures with apparent pKa's of 5.5 (C+GC triplets) and 5.7 (m5C+GC triplets), respectively, and that the oligonucleotides should bind to single sites on large DNA with apparent affinity constants of approximately 10(6) M-1 even above neutral pH.     

Presence of divalent cation is not mandatory for the formation of intramolecular purine-motif triplex containing human c-jun protooncogene target

Modulation of endogenous gene function, through sequence-specific recognition of double helical DNA via oligonucleotide-directed triplex formation, is a promising approach. Compared to the formation of pyrimidine motif triplexes, which require relatively low pH, purine motif appears to be the most gifted for their stability under physiological conditions. Our previous work has demonstrated formation of magnesium-ion dependent highly stable intermolecular triplexes using a purine third strand of varied lengths, at the purine?pyrimidine (Pu?Py) targets of SIV/HIV-2 (vpx) genes (Svinarchuk, F., Monnot, M., Merle, A., Malvy, C., and Fermandjian, S. (1995) Nucleic Acids Res. 23, 3831-3836). Herein, we show that a designed intramolecular version of the 11-bp core sequence of the said targets, which also constitutes an integral, short, and symmetrical segment (G(2)AG(5)AG(2))?(C(2)TC(5)TC(2)) of human c-jun protooncogene forms a stable triplex, even in the absence of magnesium. The sequence d-C(2)TC(5)TC(2)T(5)G(2)AG(5)AG(2)T(5)G(2)AG(5)AG(2) (I-Pu) folds back twice onto itself to form an intramolecular triple helix via a double hairpin formation. The design ensures that the orientation of the intact third strand is antiparallel with respect to the oligopurine strand of the duplex. The triple helix formation has been revealed by non-denaturating gel assays, UV-thermal denaturation, and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. The monophasic melting curve, recorded in the presence of sodium, represented the dissociation of intramolecular triplex to single strand in one step; however, the addition of magnesium bestowed thermal stability to the triplex. Formation of intramolecular triple helix at neutral pH in sodium, with or without magnesium cations, was also confirmed by gel electrophoresis. The triplex, mediated by sodium alone, destabilizes in the presence of 5'-C(2)TC(5)TC(2)-3', an oligonucleotide complementary to the 3'-oligopurine segments of I-Pu, whereas in the presence of magnesium the triplex remained impervious. CD spectra showed the signatures of triplex structure with A-like DNA conformation. We suggest that the possible formation of pH and magnesium-independent purine-motif triplexes at genomic Pu?Py sequences may be pertinent to gene regulation.     

Design and simple routes of synthesis of oligonucleotide conjugates for studies of DNA triple helix formation

A series of oligonucleotides conjugated to intercalators, as well as fluorescent and lipophilic substances, minor groove binders and photoactive molecules were synthesized for studies of their ability to form a stable triple helix. Purine-rich short double stranded DNA fragments from HIV-1 genome and pyrimidine 16-mer oligodeoxyribonucleotide were used as models. A conjugate of a dipyrido[3,2-a:2',3'-c]phenazine-ruthenium (II) complex and a triple helix-forming oligonucleotide was constructed. Upon sequence-specific duplex and triplex formation of the conjugate, the ruthenium complex becomes highly fluorescent. The attached ruthenium complex induces a stabilization of the DNA triple helix and a significant increase of the time of residence of the third strand on the duplex.     

DESIGN AND SIMPLE ROUTES OF SYNTHESIS OF OLIGONUCLEOTIDE CONJUGATES FOR STUDIES OF DNA TRIPLE HELIX FORMATION

A series of oligonucleotides conjugated to intercalators, as well as fluorescent and lipophilic substances, minor groove binders and photoactive molecules were synthesized for studies of their ability to form a stable triple helix. Purine-rich short double stranded DNA fragments from HIV-1 genome and pyrimidine 16-mer oligodeoxyribonucleotide were used as models. A conjugate of a dipyrido[3,2-a:2′,3′-c]phenazine-ruthenium (II) complex and a triple helix-forming oligonucleotide was constructed. Upon sequence-specific duplex and triplex formation of the conjugate, the ruthenium complex becomes highly fluorescent. The attached ruthenium complex induces a stabilization of the DNA triple helix and a significant increase of the time of residence of the third strand on the duplex.     

Stabilities of intrastrand pyrimidine motif DNA and RNA triple helices

Nucleic acid triple helices have provoked interest since their discovery more than 40 years ago, but it remains unknown whether such structures occur naturally in cells. To pursue this question, it is important to determine the stabilities of representative triple helices at physiological temperature and pH. Previous investigations have concluded that while both DNA and RNA can participate in the pyrimidine triplex motif under mildly acidic conditions, these structures are often relatively unstable at neutral pH. We are now explorin g the stability of intrastrand DNA and RNA pyrimidine motif triplexes at physiological temperature and pH. Duplex and triplex formation were monitored by thermal denaturation analysis, circular dichroism spectroscopy and gel shift experiments. Short intrastrand triplexes were observed to form in the pyrimidine motif in both DNA and RNA. In the presence of physiological concentrations of Mg²⁺ and at physiological pH, all detected triplexes were sufficiently stable to persist at physiological temperature. If sequences specifying such intrastrand triplexes are encoded in genomes, the potential exists for the formation of stable structures in RNA or DNA in vivo.     

Extension of the range of DNA sequences available for triple helix formation: stabilization of mismatched triplexes by acridine-containing oligonucleotides.

Triple helix formation usually requires an oligopyrimidine*oligopurine sequence in the target DNA. A triple helix is destabilized when the oligopyrimidine*oligopurine target contains one (or two) purine*pyrimidine base pair inversion(s). Such an imperfect target sequence can be recognized by a third strand oligonucleotide containing an internally incorporated acridine intercalator facing the inverted purine*pyrimidine base pair(s). The loss of triplex stability due to the mismatch is partially overcome. The stability of triplexes formed at perfect and imperfect target sequences was investigated by UV thermal denaturation experiments. The stabilization provided by an internally incorporated acridine third strand oligonucleotide depends on the sequences flanking the inverted base pair. For triplexes containing a single mismatch the highest stabilization is observed for an acridine or a propanediol tethered to an acridine on its 3'-side facing an inverted A*T base pair and for a cytosine with an acridine incorporated to its 3'-side or a guanine with an acridine at its 5'-side facing an inverted G*C base pair. Fluorescence studies provided evidence that the acridine was intercalated into the triplex. The target sequences containing a double base pair inversion which form very unstable triplexes can still be recognized by oligonucleotides provided they contain an appropriately incorporated acridine facing the double mismatch sites. Selectivity for an A*T base pair inversion was observed with an oligonucleotide containing an acridine incorporated at the mismatched site when this site is flanked by two T*A*T base triplets. These results show that the range of DNA base sequences available for triplex formation can be extended by using oligonucleotide intercalator conjugates.