Hierarchy ofH-2 haplotypes governs inheritance of immune responsiveness to TNP-MSA

Production of indirect TNP-specific plaque-forming cells (PFC) in response to immunization with 2, 4, 6-trinitrophenyl (TNP) conjugated to autogenous mouse serum albumin (MSA) in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) is underH-2 control. On the C57BL/10 (B10) background,H-2 ^b andH-2 ^d strains of mice are high responders, whereasH-2 ^a ,H-2 ^k orH-2 ^y2 strains yield low levels of indirect TNP-specific PFC. An unusual pattern of inheritance has been revealed in B10 congenic mice: high responsiveness controlled byH-2 ^b is inherited recessively, while high responsiveness controlled byH-2 ^d is inherited dominantly. On the C3H and A strain backgrounds, high responsiveness controlled byH-2 ^b is partially recessive;H-2 ^b /H-2 ^a F₁ mice respond with 20%-40% of the high responderH-2 ^b response. Yet, high responsiveness controlled by theH-2 ^d haplotype remains dominant on the C3H background. A hierarchy of haplotypes in order of decreasing immune responsiveness to TNP-MSA is evident as follows:H-2 ^d >H-2 ^b >H-2 ^k ,H-2 ^a orH-2 ^y2 . The unusual patterns of inheritance in the TNP-MSA system reveal graded regulation of responsiveness attributable to bothH-2 and non-H-2 genes.     

Two distinct high immune response phenotypes are both controlled by H-2 genes mapping K or I-A

Murine responses to immunization with 2, 4, 6-trinitrophenyl (TNP) conjugated to autogenous mouse serum albumin (MSA) in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) are controlled by a gene(s) in the K or I-A region of H-2 complex. High immune responses of both H-2d and H-2b mice have been mapped to this region of the major histocompatibility complex. No modifying effects were observed from genes to the right of I-A in either responder haplotype. High responsiveness controlled by Kb or I-Ab is inherited with complete or partial recessivity, depending on the route of immunization and the sex of the responder. However, high responsiveness controlled by Kd or I-Ad is inherited dominantly. This unusual pattern of inheritance of immune responsiveness to TNP-MSA is consistent with the genetic mapping to K or I-A. TNP-MSA-specific T-cell reactivity following immunization with TNP-MSA in vivo was examined utilizing a T-cell-dependent proliferation assay in vitro with cells obtained from high or low responder mice. Genetic mapping and mode of inheritance in this assay for antigen-specific T-cell reactivity corresponded with results obtained from a plaque-forming cell (PFC) assay measuring antibody production by B cells. Both the proliferative and PFC responses are probably under the same Ir gene control. Both gene dosage effects and Ir-gene-product interaction could influence the generation of specific immune responsiveness in F1 hybrids between high and low responders to TNP-MSA.     

A hierarchy of responsiveness and the production of nonprecipitating antibodies to F antigen

The immune response to F antigen by a variety of inbred strains and F₁ hybrids has been studied. All of the mice responding to appropriate preparations of F antigen share ak allele atH-2K orI-A. In F₁ hybrids, however, this permissive gene is sometimes expressed as dominant responsiveness, while in other combinations as dominant nonresponsiveness. There appears to be a hierarchy of responsiveness among the responder strains tested. Finally, some strains produce nonprecipitating antibodies against F antigen which may represent a genetically controlled restriction of the response to this antigen.     

H-2 effects on cell-cell interactions in the response to single non-H-2 alloantigens

Individual mice were tested for their proliferative T-cell response to H-Y- and H-3-incompatible stimulator cells in secondary mixed lymphocyte culture. Responders expressing the H-2 ^bhaplotype were restricted in their response to stimulators presenting H-Y and H-3 in the context of H-2 ^b. Lymphocytes from individual B10 females proliferated in response to H-Y presented with I-A ^band D ^b. The ratio of I-A ^b/D ^b-restricted responses varied between individual responders, indicating significant qualitative variation between genetically identical responders. The majority of the proliferative response in all tested mice was restricted to the entire H-2 ^bhaplotype suggesting complementation of I-A ^b- and D ^b-region genes in presenting the H-Y antigen. Similar observations were made in the response of individual B10.LP mice to the H-3 antigen. H-3-specific, proliferating T cells were restricted to H-3 antigen presented with K ^bA^band D ^bwith significant variation between individuals in their preference for H-3 plus K ^bA^band D ^b. In contrast to the response to H-Y, the proliferative response to H-3 plus H-2 ^bcould be accounted for by the summation of the proliferative responses to H-3. plus K ^bA^band D ^b. These observations demonstrate that the proliferative response to non-H-2 H antigens in the context of I-region determinants is not a sine qua non for the T-cell response to these antigens. Further, the individual qualitative and quantitative variation observed with individual genetically identical mice has strong implications for our knowledge of intrastrain variation in immune responsiveness and the characterization of inbred strains for immune responsiveness.     

Polygenic control of the immune response to F antigen

The ability to produce an autoimmune response to F antigen in mice is underH-2-linked and non-H- 2-linkedIr-gene control. There is an absolute requirement for ak allele atH-2K orI-A in order to produce anti-F antibodies. Low and high responsiveness is controlled by a non-H-2-linkedIr gene which behaves in a similar fashion toIr-3, in that as the dose of F-antigen is lowered, low responders behave as high responders and vice versa. This conversion from low to high responsiveness also occurs within a month after ATX.— Most F₁ hybrids derived from (responder x nonresponder) parents bearing identical F-types behave as dominant nonresponders. As a result of ATX, such F₁ mice convert to high responders. This conversion occurs if the animals are not immunized before day 90. If they receive F antigen prior to that time, they remain nonresponders for 7–9 months. One F₁ combination — AKD2 — behaves as a dominant high responder. Genetic analysis showed that in the presence of ak allele atH-2K orI-A, a non-H-2-linkedIr gene inherited from the AKR mice determined dominant responsivenss. No manipulation of the immune response or combination of genes converted nonresponders lacking ak allele into responders. Such complex genetic control suggests regulation by a number of independently segregating loci whose function it is to limit the autoimmune response to F antigen.     

Serological and complementation studies in four C57BL/6H-2 mutants

C57BL/6 (H-2 ^b ) mice, and four mutants (B6.C-H-2 ^ba , B6-H-2 ^bg1 , B6-H-2 ^bg2 , B6-H-2 ^bh ) derived from this strain after separate mutations had occurred at the same locus within theH-2 complex, were analyzed to determine whether the mutations had led to anyH-2 (or Ia) difference which could be detected serologically. The strains were typed directly with antisera specific for H-2K and H-2D public and private specificities and for the Ia specificities; quantitative absorption studies were also performed for the relevant H-2K^b, H-2D^d and Ia^b specificities. In no case was any quantitative or qualitative difference detected serologically between any of the strains. In addition, by using a variety of techniques to produce and assay for antibody, we failed to produce any antisera between the parental strains and the four mutants. TheH-2 mutations therefore appear to give rise to a type of antigenic specificity which is recognized byT cells and which generateT, but notB cell responses; nor are they recognized by H-2 or Ia alloantisera. The location of the mutating locus within theH-2 complex was shown by the complementation method to be within theK orIA region and not in theIB region, since crosses of the mutant strains with B10.A(4R) or D2.GD failed to complement for a subsequent C57BL/6 skin graft.     

The genetic control of the immune response to murine histocompatibility antigens

The genetic control of the immune response to H-4 histocompatibility alloantigens is described. The rejection of H-4.2-incompatible skin grafts is regulated by anH-2-linkedIr gene. Fast responsiveness is determined by a dominant allele at theIrH-4.2 locus. TheH-2 ^b ,H-2 ^d , andH-2 ^s haplotypes share the fast response allele;H-2 ^a has the slow response allele. Through the use of intra-H-2 recombinants, we have mapped theIrH-4.2 locus to theI-B subregion of theH-2 complex; theH-2 ^h4 ,H-2 ¹⁵, andH-2 ^t4 haplotypes are fast responder haplotypes. These observations suggest that the strength of non-H-2 histocompatibility antigens is ultimately determined by the antigen-specific recipient responsiveness.     

Intra-H-2 recombination in the mouse

Serological characterization of threeK-S interval recombinant strains, TBR2 (H-2 ^at2 ), TBR3 (H-2 ^at3 ) and AIR1 (H-2 ^a2 ) was performed using anti-H-2, Ia, Ss and Slp antisera. The data presented here reveal that the crossover events in both TBR2 and TBR3 occurred between theI-A andI-E subregions. In both cases, theH-2K andI-A subregions were derived from theH-2 ^t1 chromosome, while theI-E, S andH-2D regions were derived from theH-2 ^b chromosome (K ^s A ^k E ^b S ^b D ^b ). TheH-2 ^a2 chromosome resulted from a crossover event between theH-2 ^a1 andH-2 ⁱ⁹ chromosomes. Ia and Ss typing of AIR1 suggested that theK toI-E regions originated fromH-2 ^a1 and theS andD regions originated fromH-2 ⁱ⁹ (K ^k A ^k E ^k S ^b D ^d ).     

Aberrancy in immunogenicity and cell-surface expression of H-2 antigens on erythrocytes

Immunogenicity for T cell-independent B-cell response assessed by splenic plaque-forming cell (PFC) response and cell-surface expression measured by laser flow cytometry of various class I H-2 antigens on mouse red blood cells (RBC) were compared. It was found that the order of magnitude of both immunogenicity and cell-surface expression on RBC is H-2D^d H-2D^b > H-2K^d, H-2K^b. Furthermore, H-2^d public antigens and H-2L^d antigens were neither immunogenic nor easily demonstrable on RBC. These findings contrasted with poor immunogenicity for PFC response (Nakashima et al. 1982, 1983) and proportionally strong expression of H-2 antigens on lymphoid cells. Immunogenicity and cell-surface expression of H-2D^d antigen on RBC were not shown to be controlled by the action of genes outside H-2D. It was therefore suggested that a number of H-2 antigens, including H-2K^d private, H-2K^b private, and H-2^d public specificities are at least functionally defective on RBC. This is possibly due to the structural characteristics of the antigens. Since immunogenicity and cell-surface expression were in parallel, the expression of H-2 antigens on RBC must be dictated by a subset of B cells whose activity was assessed by PFC response. This finding supports the view that the H-2 molecules display a new category of activity which is different from their ability to activate T cells and depends on their expression on RBC.     

Do histocompatibility antigens recognize themselves?

In the Simonsen spleen weight assay, theH-2K ^ba mutant does not respond against theH-2K ^bd mutant orH-2K ^bd /H-2K ^b hybrid, while the parentalH-2K ^b haplotype does respond. TheH-2K ^ba /H-2K ^b hybrid reacts strongly to bothH-2K ^bd andH-2K ^bd /H-2K ^b , indicating that the donor genotype could influence the reactivity against the same antigenic difference. The response of theH-2 ^ba mutant against a number of unrelated H-2 antigens does not differ from that of the parental haplotype. TheH-2K ^bd mutant reacts againstH-2K ^b andH-2K ^ba , and theH-2K ^b parent reacts against both theH-2K ^ba andH-2K ^bd mutants. The specific defect of reactivity in theH-2K ^ba mutant is effectively complemented by crossing with a number of unrelatedH-2 haplotypes. TheH-2 ^ka andH-2 ^fa mutants complement poorly compared to corresponding parental strains CBA and A.CA, while the B10.M (H-2 ^f ) strain does not complement at all (which is probably attributable to an undetectedH-2 mutation in the last strain). The data strongly suggest that the product of theH-2K locus-which is known to function as a transplantation antigen, lymphocyte activating determinant, and serologically defined antigen-also influences the immune response capacity against a mutant histocompatibility determinant.     

H-2 antigen variants in a cultured mouse leukemia cell line

We have investigated the effect of immune selection against a single gene product on a cultured mouse Friend leukemia cell line. The clonal cell line used is heterozygous at theH-2 complex and expresses theH-2 ^d andH-2 ^b haplotypes. The genes selected against were theH-2K locus alleles. Variants were obtained after a single-step selection using either antiH-2K^b or anti-H-2K^d serum. The phenotypes of the variants obtained showed an interesting asymmetry between the two haplotypes. Selection against theH 2K ^b allele resulted in the isolation of the two expected types of variant-those that had lost only H-2K^b and those that had lost both H-2K^b and the linked H-2D^b. Selection against H-2K^d yielded, exclusively, variants that had lost both the selected antigen and the linked H-2D^d. None of the variants showed an alteration in expression of antigens intrans configuration. Karyotypic analyses of the variants revealed that all the cells had retained both copies of chromosome 17 present in the wild-type cells. The results suggest that the variants did not emerge through chromosome loss.     

H-2-linked recessiveIr gene regulation of high antibody responsiveness to TNP hapten conjugated to autogenous albumin

The antibody response to the hapten 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl (TNP) conjugated to autogenous mouse serum albumin (MSA) is regulated by anIr gene(s) located within the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). Both the qualitative and quantitative ability of congenic strains to produce TNP-specific antibodies are functions of theH-2 haplotype. Thus, mouse strains may be classified as high (H-2 ^d), intermediate (H-2 ^b,H-2 ^s), and low responders (H-2 ^a,H-2 ^k,H-2 ⁿ,H-2 ^p,H-2 ^q). Antibody responses, as measured by antigen-binding capacities in modified Farr assays, were compared among strains carrying recombinantH-2 haplotypes and their hybrid progenies. Distinct high- and low-responder phenotypes were evident throughout the time course of both primary and secondary antibody responses. The gene locus controlling specific responsiveness to TNP-MSA, now designatedIr-6, was mapped within theI-B subregion of theH-2 complex. Recessive inheritance of high responsiveness was confirmed in hybrid progenies of three different low × high-responder crosses.     

Receptor specificity,functional characteristics,and cell-surface phenotype of a highly selected anti-I-Ab-specific,long-term T-cell line

A highly selected alloreactive T-cell line was developed by repeated restimulation of B10.D2/n lymph-node cells with irradiated C57BL/10Sn (BIO) spleen cells in long-term MLC for up to 2 1/2 years. Continuous growth of the line requires restimulation every 2 to 4 weeks with fresh H-2^b stimulator cells. The line proliferates strongly against H-2^b but not againstH-2 ^d ,H-2 ^f ,H-2 ^q ,H-2 ^r , orH-2 ^s stimulators. Analysis of recombinant mouse strains showed that the proliferative response is directed against I-A^b but not K^b or D^b determinants. During the growth period of the line, strong cross-reactivity with H-2^p (B10.P) and weak cross-reactivity with H-2^k strains (e.g., CBA/J and B10.BR) was observed. A clone with exquisite specificity for I-A^b, but with no cross-reactivity with H-2^p or H-2^k was isolated from the line; thus clonal heterogeneity of the line still exists despite the highly selective growth conditions. — The majority of T cells from the line or clone were shown to bind I-A^b but not K^b or D^b determinants either spontaneously during restimulation with fresh B10 stimulator cells or via membrane vesicles expressing I-A^b determinants. No killing activity by the line in either specific or nonspecific cytolytic T-cell assays was observed nor was the T 145 glycoprotein, characteristic of killer T cells, detected.Abbreviations used in this paper B6 C57BL/6J - B10 C57BL/10Sn - Con A Concanavalin A - CTL cytotoxic T lymphocyte - FCS fetal calf serum - FDA fluorescein diacetate - FITC fluorescein isothiocyanate - Ia I-region-associated antigens - LPS lipopolysaccharide fromE. coli - Lyt T-lymphocyte-defined antigen - MLC mixed leukocyte culture - NP-40 nonidet P-40 - PAGE pofyacrylamide gel electrophoresis - PHA phytohemagglutinin fromPhaseolus vulgaris - PM plasma membrane - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate - TCGF T-cell growth factor(s) - TdR thymidine     

IgG-specific helper activity of t lymphocytes from mice lacking theIr-IgG gene

Cooperative interactions between T and B cells from the congenic inbred mouse strains B10.A(2R) and B10.A(4R) in antibody responses controlled byIr genes have been studied. Within theI region of the MHC, these strains share only theI-A subregion. TheIr gene controlling responsiveness to IgA maps in theI-A subregion, both strains being responders to IgA. T cells from 2R mice collaborate effectively with B cells from 2R or 4R mice for antihapten antibody responses to DNP-IgA. TheIr gene controlling responses to IgG maps in theI-B subregion, and 2R mice are nonresponders for this antigen. Nevertheless, 2R T cells primed with IgG can help responder (4R) B cells -but not syngeneic nonresponder (2R) B cells -in responding to DNP-IgG. These results indicate that mice lacking theIr-IgG gene nonetheless may develop helper T lymphocytes specific for myeloma proteins. In addition, they indicate that cells from congenic mice sharing only theA subregion of theI region can collaborate efficiently.     

Non-H-2 and H-2-Linked immune response genes control the cytotoxic T-cell response to H-Y

The immunoregulation of cytotoxic T-cell responses to the male-specific antigen H-Y in mice has been found to be genetically controlled by genes of the major histocompatibility complex (H-2). Responsiveness was mainly confined to H-2 ^b strains, but it has also been found in recombinant strains, F₁ hybrids, and chimeras that carry at least part of the H-2 ^b haplotype. By using a different immunization procedure it has been shown recently that an H-2 ^k mouse strain (CBA) is also able to mount an equivalent H-Y-specific response. We investigate here, by applying this immunization technique, the responsiveness of other H-2 ^k strains and of strains of other independent H-2 haplotypes. Both responders and nonresponders are found in three haplotypes: k, s, and d. The strain distribution pattern of responsiveness shows a combined influence of non-H-2 and H-2 genes. In certain strains there is a high variability in responsiveness between genetically indentical individual animals. We discuss a model of immune response (Ir) gene function which could account for these observations.     

Complementation between a gene of theI-E subregion and a non-H-2 gene in the class-specific suppression of IgG2a antibody to sheep erythrocytes

A low level of IgG2a antibodies is observed in B10 mice after primary immunization with SRBC. Analysis of the response in different H-2^b mice and among B10 animals with differentH-2 haplotypes reveals that this selective isotype deficiency is under the control of at least two genes: a background gene and anH-2-linked gene. Responses ofH-2 recombinant B10 strains map theH-2-linked gene to theI-E subregion. Evidence is presented for complementation betweenH-2 and non-H-2 genes in the determination of the low responder phenotype. Low responsiveness appears to be inherited as a dominant trait. Possible functions of the two series of genes are discussed in relation to suppressor mechanisms.     

Activation or suppression of bactericidal activity of macrophages during a graft-versus-host reaction againstI-A andI-J-region differences,respectively

Systemic graft-versus-host reactions (GVHR) were induced in F₁ heterozygous mice by injecting 10⁸ parental lymphocytes. The Anti-Thy 1.2-sensitive, T-cell mediated activation of macrophages was assessed by their increased capacity to destroy a facultative intracellular bacteriumListeria monocytogenes. The difference inMHC regions causing a GVHR that induced high levels of macrophage activation mapped toI-A. In contrast, differences atK orD, in any of the otherH-2 subregions or in the non-H-2 background, includingMls alone or in combination, did not induce a GVHR leading to macrophage activation, unless these differences were combined with a difference atI-A. The numbers of parental cells needed to activate macrophages via a GVHR caused byI-A vs. non-I-A differences, varied at least 30- to 100-fold. When parental cells were injected into F₁ offspring of parents differing atI-J, growth ofListeria was enhanced significantly; this negative effect on macrophages was not seen when parental combinations differing atI-A alone were compared with those differing atI-A plusI-J orI-J plus otherH-2 regions.     

Genetic control of contact sensitivity in mice: Effect ofH-2 and nonH-2 loci

The genetic control of delayed-type hypersensitivity in mice was investigated by contact sensitization with picryl chloride. Distribution patterns of contact sensitivity in 11 inbred strains of mice showed significant differences among strains. Comparison of levels of response between congenic-resistant lines and their inbred partners, at 9 to 11 weeks of age, revealed a clear association betweenH-2 haplotype and the magnitude of response. Testing ofH-2 recombinants further suggested the influence of two genes mapping at either end of theH-2 complex. While theH-2K ^d andH-2D ^k alleles were associated with a high response, theH-2K ^k ,H-2K ^b ,H-2D ^d , andH-2D ^b alleles were associated with a low response. Analysis of the ontogeny of response suggested that theH-2 haplotype manifests its effect through the maturation of contact sensitivity. On both the C57BL/6By and C57BL/10Sn backgrounds, theH-2 ^d haplotype was associated with early maturation of response, while theH-2 ^b haplotype was associated with late maturation. Analysis of the response of congenic lines with different genetic backgrounds and of CXB recombinant-inbred lines further revealed the marked effects of yet other genes on this trait.     

Class I MHC molecules rather than other mouse genes dictate influenza epitope recognition by cytotoxic T cells

Influenza nucleoprotein (NP) is an important target antigen for influenza A virus cross-reactive cytotoxic T cells (Tc). Here we examine the NP epitope recognized by cloned and polyclonal BALB/c Tc and the genetics of this recognition pattern. We can define NP residues 147–161 as the epitope seen in conjunction with K ^d , the only H-2^d class I responder allele for NP restriction. H-2 ^d /H-2 ^b F₁ mice (C57BL × DBA/2) primed by influenza infection lyse only H-2^d target cells treated with peptide 147–161 while H-2^b targets are recognized only after treatment with NP residues 365–379 (previously found to be recognized by D^b restricted Tc cells). Tc cell recognition of NP peptide 147–161 is entirely dictated by expression of K ^d and not by other B10 or OH background genes of congenic mice. Restriction of a unique NP sequence by each responder class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) allele suggests that antigen and class I MHC interact for Tc recognition.     

H-2 effects on cell-cell interactions in the response to single non-H-2 alloantigens

Immune response (Ir) genes mapping in theI region of the mouseH-2 complex appear to regulate specifically the presentation of a number of antigens by macrophages to proliferating T cells. We have investigated the possibility that similarIr genes mapping in theH-2K andH-2D regions specifically regulate the presentation of target antigens to cytotoxic effector T cells. We report that the susceptibility of targets expressing specific non-H-2 H alloantigens to lysis by H-2-compatible, H-antigen-specific cytotoxic effector T cells is controlled by polymorphicH-2K/D genes. This control of susceptibility to lysis is accomplished through what we have defined operationally as antigen-specific regulation of non-H-2 H antigen immunogenicity. High immunogenicity of the H-4.2 alloantigen is determined by a gene mapping in theH-2K region ofH-2 ^b . However, high immunogenicity of H-7.1 is determined by a gene mapping in theH-2D region ofH-2 ^b . High immunogenicity of the H-3.1 alloantigen is determined by genes mapping in both theH-2K andH-2D regions ofH-2 ^b . Therefore, genes mapping in theH-2K andH-2D regions serve a function in presenting antigen to cytotoxic effector T cells. This function is analogous to that played byI-regionIr genes expressed in macrophages which present antigen to proliferating T cells. We present arguments for classification of theseH-2K/D genes as a second system ofIr genes and discuss the implications of twoH-2-linkedIr-gene systems, their possible functions, and their evolution.