Identification of single nucleotide mutations that prevent developmentally programmed DNA elimination in Paramecium tetraurelia

The excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs) occurs during the differentiation of a new somatic macronuclear genome in ciliated protozoa. In Paramecium tetraurelia, IESs show few conserved features with the exception of an invariant 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide that is part of an 8-bp inverted terminal repeat consensus sequence with similarity to the ends of mariner/Tc1 transposons. We have isolated and analyzed two mutant cell lines that are defective in excision of individual IESs in the A-51 surface antigen gene. Each cell line contains a mutation in the flanking 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide of IES6435 and IES1835 creating a 5'-CA-3' flanking sequence that prevents excision. The results demonstrate that the first position of the 5'-TA-3' is required IES excision just as previous mutants have shown that the second position (the A residue) is required. Combining these results with other Paramecium IES mutants suggests that there are few positions essential for IES excision in Paramecium. Analysis of many IESs reveals that there is a strong bias against particular nucleotides at some positions near the IES termini. Some of these strongly biased positions correspond to known IES mutations, others correlate with unusual features of excision.     

Developmentally programmed excision of internal DNA sequences in Paramecium aurelia

The development of a new somatic nucleus (macronucleus) during sexual reproduction of the ciliate Paramecium aurelia involves reproducible chromosomal rearrangements that affect the entire germline genome. Macronuclear development can be induced experimentally, which makes P. aurelia an attractive model for the study of the mechanism and the regulation of DNA rearrangements. Two major types of rearrangements have been identified: the fragmentation of the germline chromosomes, followed by the formation of the new macronuclear chromosome ends in association with imprecise DNA elimination, and the precise excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs). All IESs identified so far are short, A/T rich and non-coding elements. They are flanked by a direct repeat of a 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide, a single copy of which remains at the macronuclear junction after excision. The number of these single-copy sequences has been estimated to be around 60,000 per haploid genome. This review focuses on the current knowledge about the genetic and epigenetic determinants of IES elimination in P. aurelia, the analysis of excision products, and the tightly regulated timing of excision throughout macronuclear development. Several models for the molecular mechanism of IES excision will be discussed in relation to those proposed for DNA elimination in other ciliates.     

Homology-Dependent Maternal Inhibition of Developmental Excision of Internal Eliminated Sequences in Paramecium tetraurelia

Thousands of single-copy internal eliminated sequences (IESs) are excised from the germ line genome of ciliates during development of the polygenomic somatic macronucleus, following sexual events. Paramecium IESs are short, noncoding elements that frequently interrupt coding sequences. No absolutely conserved sequence element, other than flanking 5′-TA-3′ direct repeats, has been identified among sequenced IESs; the mechanisms of their specific recognition and precise elimination are unknown. Previous work has revealed the existence of an epigenetic control of excision. It was shown that the presence of one IES in the vegetative macronucleus results in a specific inhibition of the excision of the same element during the development of a new macronucleus, in the following sexual generation. We have assessed the generality and sequence specificity of this transnuclear maternal control by studying the effects of macronuclear transformation with 13 different IESs. We show that at least five of them can be maintained in the new macronuclear genome; sequence specificity is complete both between genes and between different IESs in the same gene. In all cases, the degree of excision inhibition correlates with the copy number of the maternal IES, but each IES shows a characteristic inhibition efficiency. Short internal IES-like segments were found to be excised from two of the IESs when excision between normal boundaries was inhibited. Available data suggest that the sequence specificity of these maternal effects is mediated by pairing interactions between homologous nucleic acids.     

Developmentally programmed excision of internal DNA sequences in Paramecium aurelia

The development of a new somatic nucleus (macronucleus) during sexual reproduction of the ciliate Paramecium aurelia involves reproducible chromosomal rearrangements that affect the entire germline genome. Macronuclear development can be induced experimentally, which makes P. aurelia an attractive model for the study of the mechanism and the regulation of DNA rearrangements. Two major types of rearrangements have been identified: the fragmentation of the germline chromosomes, followed by the formation of the new macronuclear chromosome ends in association with imprecise DNA elimination, and the precise excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs). All IESs identified so far are short, A/T rich and non-coding elements. They are flanked by a direct repeat of a 5’-TA-3’ dinucleotide, a single copy of which remains at the macronuclear junction after excision. The number of these single-copy sequences has been estimated to be around 60 000 per haploid genome. This review focuses on the current knowledge about the genetic and epigenetic determinants of IES elimination in P. aurelia, the analysis of excision products, and the tightly regulated timing of excision throughout macronuclear development. Several models for the molecular mechanism of IES excision will be discussed in relation to those proposed for DNA elimination in other ciliates.     

A mutation in Paramecium tetraurelia reveals functional and structural features of developmentally excised DNA elements.

The excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs) from the germline micronuclear DNA occurs during the differentiation of a new macronuclear genome in ciliated protozoa. In Paramecium, IESs are generally short (28-882 bp), AT rich DNA elements that show few conserved sequence features with the exception of an inverted-terminal-repeat consensus sequence that has similarity to the ends of mariner/Tcl transposons (KLOBUTCHER and HERRICK 1995). We have isolated and analyzed a mutant cell line that cannot excise a 370-bp IESs (IES2591) from the coding region of the 51A variable surface protein gene. A single micronuclear C to T transition within the consensus sequence prevents excision. The inability to excise IES259 I has revealed a 28-bp IES inside the larger IES, suggesting that reiterative integration of these elements can occur. Together, the consensus sequence mutation and the evidence for reiterative integration support the theory that Paramecium IESs evolved from transposable elements. Unlike a previously studied Paramecium IES, the presence of this IES in the macronucleus does not completely inhibit excision of its Mild-type micronuclear copy through multiple sexual generations.     

The micronuclear gene encoding a putative aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase cofactor of the ciliate Euplotes octocarinatus is interrupted by two sequences that are removed during macronuclear development.

The micronuclear gene of the ciliated protozoan Euplotes octocarinatus (Eo) syngen 1 encoding the putative aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase cofactor (ARCE), as well as its macronuclear version and the corresponding cDNA, were amplified and sequenced. Analyses of the sequences revealed that the micronuclear gene contains two sequences (430 and 625bp long) that are missing in the macronuclear version of this gene. These sequences are called 'internal eliminated sequences' (IESs) and appear to occur in all ciliates. The two IESs are located in the coding region of the micronuclear gene. One IES is flanked by a pair of dinucleotide 5'-TA-3' direct repeats and the other one by a pair of hepta-nucleotide 5'-TTACTGA-3' direct repeats. Inside the two IESs, several other sequence repeats were found. The macronuclear DNA molecule carrying this gene is 1517bp long and shows characteristics typical of macronuclear chromosomes of hypotrichous ciliates. Copy number determination revealed that the molecule is amplified to only about 750 copies per macronucleus. The deduced protein is a 441-amino-acid (aa) polypeptide with a molecular mass of 50kDa. It shares a conserved endothelial monocyte-activating polypeptide II (EMAP II)-like carboxyl-terminal domain and a hydrophilic central domain containing a KEKE-motif with a group of proteins associated with aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and tRNAs.     

Processing of double-strand breaks is involved in the precise excision of paramecium internal eliminated sequences

In ciliates, the development of the somatic macronucleus involves the programmed excision of thousands of internal eliminated sequences (IES) scattered throughout the germ line genome. Previous work with Tetrahymena thermophila has suggested that excision is initiated by a staggered double-strand break (DSB) at one IES end. Nucleophilic attack of the other end by the 3'OH group carried by the firstly broken chromosome end leads to macronuclear junction closure. In this study, we mapped the 3'OH and 5'PO(4) groups that are developmentally released at Paramecium IES boundaries, which are marked by two conserved TA dinucleotides, one of which remains in the macronuclear genome after excision. We show that initiating DSBs at both ends generate 4-base 5' overhangs centered on the TA. Based on the observed processing of the 5'-terminal residue of each overhang, we present a new model for the precise closure of macronuclear chromosomes in Paramecium tetraurelia, different from that previously proposed for tetrahymena. In our model, macronucleus-destined broken ends are aligned through the partial pairing of their 5'-nTAn-3' extensions and joined after trimming of the 5' flaps.     

Role of histone deacetylation in developmentally programmed DNA rearrangements in Tetrahymena thermophila

In Tetrahymena, as in other ciliates, development of the somatic macronucleus during conjugation involves extensive and reproducible rearrangements of the germ line genome, including chromosome fragmentation and excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs). The molecular mechanisms controlling these events are poorly understood. To investigate the role that histone acetylation may play in the regulation of these processes, we treated Tetrahymena cells during conjugation with the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A (TSA). We show that TSA treatment induces developmental arrests in the early stages of conjugation but does not significantly affect the progression of conjugation once the mitotic divisions of the zygotic nucleus have occurred. Progeny produced from TSA-treated cells were examined for effects on IES excision and chromosome breakage. We found that TSA treatment caused partial inhibition of excision of five out of the six IESs analyzed but did not affect chromosome breakage at four different sites. TSA treatment greatly delayed in some cells and inhibited in most the excision events in the developing macronucleus. It also led to loss of the specialized subnuclear localization of the chromodomain protein Pdd1p that is normally associated with DNA elimination. We propose a model in which underacetylated nucleosomes mark germ line-limited sequences for excision.     

Lia1p, a novel protein required during nuclear differentiation for genome-wide DNA rearrangements in Tetrahymena thermophila

Extensive genome-wide rearrangements occur during somatic macronuclear development in Tetrahymena thermophila. These events are guided by RNA interference-directed chromatin modification including histone H3 lysine 9 methylation, which marks specific germ line-limited internal eliminated sequences (IESs) for excision. Several genes putatively involved in these developmental genome rearrangements were identified based on their proteins' localization to differentiating somatic nuclei, and here we demonstrate that one, LIA1, encodes a novel protein that is an essential component of the genome rearrangement machinery. A green fluorescent protein-Lia1 fusion protein exhibited dynamic nuclear localization during development that has striking similarity to that of the dual chromodomain-containing DNA rearrangement protein, Pdd1p. Coimmunoprecipitation experiments showed that Lia1p associates with Pdd1p and IES chromatin during macronuclear development. Cell lines in which we disrupted both the germ line and somatic copies of LIA1 (DeltaLIA1) grew normally but were unable to generate viable progeny, arresting late in development just prior to returning to vegetative growth. These mutant lines failed to properly form Pdd1p-containing nuclear structures and eliminate IESs despite showing normal levels of H3K9 methylation. These data indicate that Lia1p is required late in conjugation for the reorganization of the Tetrahymena genome.     

Detection of circular forms of eliminated DNA during macronuclear development in E. crassus

Following their sexual cycle, hypotrichous ciliated protozoa transform a copy of a chromosomal micronucleus into a macronucleus containing small, linear DNA molecules. A frequent event during macronuclear development is the removal of short segments of DNA (internal eliminated sequences: IESs) by a process equivalent to DNA breakage and rejoining. In this study we used a polymerase chain reaction procedure to demonstrate that free circular forms of IESs are present in cells undergoing macronuclear development. Sequencing of the junctions of the free circular IESs suggests that they share 12 nucleotides with the macronuclear DNA molecules that are generated following IES removal. The results provide evidence that IESs are removed by an active DNA breakage and rejoining process, which may involve staggered cuts in the substrate DNA.     

Internal eliminated sequences are removed prior to chromosome fragmentation during development in Euplotes crassus.

The hypotrichous ciliated protozoa undergo a massive genome rearrangement process after their sexual cycle. One frequent type of rearrangement is the removal of DNA sequences (internal eliminated sequences; IESs) from internal regions of DNA molecules. In this study, we characterized the removal of IESs in Euplotes crassus. Southern hybridization analyses combined with cytological observations indicated that IES removal is an early event in macronuclear development, occurring during the polytene chromosome stage and prior to the chromosome fragmentation process. The results are consistent with IES removal occurring via an intramolecular DNA breakage and rejoining process.     

Volatility of internal eliminated segments in germ line genes of hypotrichous ciliates.

Germ line micronuclear genes in ciliated protozoa contain two types of interrupting sequences. Some genes contain introns, but internal eliminated segments (IESs) are much more prevalent. IESs are AT-rich DNA segments that separate macronucleus-destined segments (MDSs) in micronuclear genes. All IESs are excised and destroyed when a micronucleus develops into a macronucleus after each cell mating. IESs have no discernible function. Therefore, an investigation of the behavior of IESs in evolution has been undertaken to assess their possible significance. The IESs in the micronuclear gene encoding the beta-subunit of the telomere-binding protein (beta-TP) are not conserved in number, position, sequence, or length during the evolution of four oxytrichid ciliates. In contrast, the scrambled pattern of MDSs and IESs of the micronuclear actin I gene has been conserved during evolution; however, the precise positions, sequences, and lengths of the IESs differ among species, and in some organisms the actin I gene contains an additional IES and MDS. Corresponding IESs in the actin I genes among the different organisms have shifted positions by 1 to 14 bp, presumably by a mutation-shifting mechanism, creating differences in the repeat sequences flanking IESs. Thus, conservation of a particular repeat sequence among species is not required for IES excision. The changes in IES number and position in the beta-TP genes among ciliates are in sharp contrast to the stability of the intron position. Therefore, IESs are volatile, hypermutable elements that are inserted, removed, shifted, and modified continuously in the germ line through evolutionary time.     

Developmentally programmed DNA splicing in Paramecium reveals short-distance crosstalk between DNA cleavage sites

Somatic genome assembly in the ciliate Paramecium involves the precise excision of thousands of short internal eliminated sequences (IESs) that are scattered throughout the germline genome and often interrupt open reading frames. Excision is initiated by double-strand breaks centered on the TA dinucleotides that are conserved at each IES boundary, but the factors that drive cleavage site recognition remain unknown. A degenerate consensus was identified previously at IES ends and genetic analyses confirmed the participation of their nucleotide sequence in efficient excision. Even for wild-type IESs, however, variant excision patterns (excised or nonexcised) may be inherited maternally through sexual events, in a homology-dependent manner. We show here that this maternal epigenetic control interferes with the targeting of DNA breaks at IES ends. Furthermore, we demonstrate that a mutation in the TA at one end of an IES impairs DNA cleavage not only at the mutant end but also at the wild-type end. We conclude that crosstalk between both ends takes place prior to their cleavage and propose that the ability of an IES to adopt an excision-prone conformation depends on the combination of its nucleotide sequence and of additional determinants.     

Internal eliminated sequences interrupting the Oxytricha 81 locus: allelic divergence, conservation, conversions, and possible transposon origins

Internal eliminated sequences (IESs) often interrupt ciliate genes in the silent germline nucleus but are exactly excised and eliminated from the developing somatic nucleus from which genes are then expressed. Some long IESs are transposons, supporting the hypothesis that short IESs are ancient transposon relics. In light of that hypothesis and to explore the evolutionary history of a collection of IESs, we have compared various alleles of a particular locus (the 81 locus) of the ciliated protozoa Oxytricha trifallax and O. fallax. Three short IESs that interrupt two genes of the locus are found in alleles from both species, and thus must be relatively ancient, consistent with the hypothesis that short IESs are transposon relics. In contrast, TBE1 transposon interruptions of the locus are allele-specific and probably the results of recent transpositions. These IESs (and the TBE1s) are precisely excised from the DNA of the developing somatic macronucleus. Each IES interrupts a highly conserved sequence. A few nucleotides at the ends of each IES are also conserved, suggesting that they interact critically with IES excision machinery. However, most IES nucleotide positions have evolved at high rates, showing little or no selective constraint for function. Nonetheless, the length of each IES has been maintained (+/- 3 bp). While one IES is approximately 33 bp long, three other IESs have very similar sizes, approximately 70 bp long. Two IESs are surrounded by direct repeats of the sequence TTCTT. No other sequence similarities were found between any of the four IESs. However, the ends of one IES do match the inverted terminal repeat consensus sequence of the "TA" IESs of Paramecium. Three O. trifallax alleles appear to have been recipients in recent conversion events that could have been provoked by double-strand breaks associated with IES ends subsequent to IES transposition. Our findings support the hypothesis that short IESs evolved from ancient transposons that have lost most of their sequences, except those necessary for precise excision during macronuclear development.      

Genome-wide analysis of genetic and epigenetic control of programmed DNA deletion

During the development of the somatic genome from the Paramecium germline genome the bulk of the copies of ∼45 000 unique, internal eliminated sequences (IESs) are deleted. IES targeting is facilitated by two small RNA (sRNA) classes: scnRNAs, which relay epigenetic information from the parental nucleus to the developing nucleus, and iesRNAs, which are produced and used in the developing nucleus. Why only certain IESs require sRNAs for their removal has been enigmatic. By analyzing the silencing effects of three genes: PGM (responsible for DNA excision), DCL2/3 (scnRNA production) and DCL5 (iesRNA production), we identify key properties required for IES elimination. Based on these results, we propose that, depending on the exact combination of their lengths and end bases, some IESs are less efficiently recognized or excised and have a greater requirement for targeting by scnRNAs and iesRNAs. We suggest that the variation in IES retention following silencing of DCL2/3 is not primarily due to scnRNA density, which is comparatively uniform relative to IES retention, but rather the genetic properties of IESs. Taken together, our analyses demonstrate that in Paramecium the underlying genetic properties of developmentally deleted DNA sequences are essential in determining the sensitivity of these sequences to epigenetic control.     

Preferential cleavage of Paramecium DNA mediated by the C. elegans Tc1 transposase in vitro

In the ciliate Paramecium aurelia complex, thousands of internal eliminated sequences (IESs) are excised from the germline micronuclear DNA during macronuclear differentiation. Based on the resemblance of Paramecium IES end sequences to Tc1 transposon termini, it has been proposed that Paramecium IESs might have degenerately evolved from Tc1 family transposons, and still be removed by an enzyme homologous to a Tc1 transposase. In this study, we found that transposase preferentially cleaved (or nicked) 58 sites near the IESs in Paramecium DNA, at sequences consisting of TT or TCTA. Since one excision junction of the P. primaurelia W2 IES was included in such sites, this suggests that a Tc1-like transposase is involved in the IES excision process, although it is probably not a sole factor responsible for the precise cleavage. In addition, unmethylated substrate DNA appeared to decrease the cleavage specificity, suggesting an involvement of DNA methylation in the cleavage. Although these results do not directly address the transposon origin of Paramecium IESs, it is likely that the enzymatic machinery responsible for the initial cleavage is derived from a Tc1-like transposase. The mechanism necessary for precise excision is discussed, in relation to recent knowledge of IES excision obtained in Tetrahymena and Paramecium.