Using the nematophagous fungus Esteya vermicola to control the disastrous pine wilt disease

The present study evaluated the protective effects of the nematophagous fungus Esteya vermicola on the large pine trees of Mt. Wora, Jinju, South Korea for six years. When pine trees were treated with E. vermicola 110 days before artificial normal pinewood nematode (PWN) infection, 30–50% of the trees survived for six years. When pine trees were treated with E. vermicola one week after artificial normal PWN infection, 40% of the trees were saved. In contrast, all of the control trees were killed by pine wilt disease in the first year. Although it has been more than six years since the beginning of this experiment, the existence of E. vermicola inside the treated pine trees was successfully detected using a PCR method with two pairs of specific primers for E. vermicola. These results suggest that E. vermicola possesses great potential as a biocontrol agent to combat the disastrous pine wilt disease. This is the first report of using nematophagous fungi to control pine wilt disease in the field for a duration of over five years.     

Host Deception: Predaceous Fungus,Esteya vermicola,Entices Pine Wood Nematode by Mimicking the Scent of Pine Tree for Nutrient

Background

A nematophagous fungus, Esteya vermicola, is recorded as the first endoparasitic fungus of pine wood nematode (PWN), Bursaphelenchus xylophilus, in last century. E. vermicola exhibited high infectivity toward PWN in the laboratory conditions and conidia spraying of this fungus on Japanese red pine, Pinus densiflora, seedlings in the field protected the pine trees from pine wilt disease to some extent, indicating that it is a potential bio-control agent against PWN. Previous research had demonstrated that the living fungal mycelia of E. vermicola continuously produced certain volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which were responsible for the PWN attraction. However, identity of these VOCs remains unknown.

Methodology/Principal Findings

In this study, we report the identification of α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphor produced by living mycelia of E. vermicola, the same volatile compounds emitted from PWN host pine tree, as the major VOCs for PWN attraction using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS). In addition, we also confirmed the host deception behavior of E. vermicola to PWN by using synthetic VOCs in a straightforward laboratory bioassay.

Conclusions/Significance

This research result has demonstrated that the endoparasitic nematophagous fungus, E. vermicola, mimics the scent of PWN host pine tree to entice PWN for the nutrient. The identification of the attractive VOCs emitted from the fungus E. vermicola is of significance in better understanding parasitic mechanism of the fungus and the co-evolution in the two organisms and will aid management of the pine wilt disease.     

Biological control of the pinewood nematode <Emphasis Type="Italic">Bursaphelenchus xylophilus</Emphasis> by application of the endoparasitic fungus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Esteya vermicola</Emphasis>

Esteya vermicola (Ophiostomataceae) is the first reported endoparasitic fungus of the pinewood nematode (PWN), Bursaphelenchus xylophilus (Nematoda: Aphelenchoidoidea). It has high in vitro infectivity. In this study, the nematocidal effect of E. vermicola in logs was investigated and evaluated. Two months after inoculation of pine wilt-killed Pinus densiflora logs with E. vermicola conidia suspensions of 3 × 10⁸ and 3 × 10⁶ ml⁻¹, the density of nematodes decreased by approximately 79% and 47%, respectively. When the fungus was sprayed on to four-year-old pine seedlings one month before PWN inoculation, the survival index of seedlings reached 0.67 compared with only 0.067 for control seedlings without fungal spraying. These results suggest that conidia spraying of E. vermicola can, to some extent, protect pine trees from wilt disease. Moreover, infected nematodes and hyphae of E. vermicola were observed in the treated wood sections.     

Viability and pathogenicity of Esteya vermicola in pine trees

Esteya vermicola, as the first reported endoparasitic fungus of pinewood nematode (PWN), exhibited high infectivity in vitro and has been patented based on its potential as a bio-control agent against PWN. The isolation substrates and taxonomic status suggested E. vermicola is associated with beetles, saprotrophic and kills nematodes in trees. However, the direct experimental evidence for this was still lacking. In the present studies, beta-tubulin gene was applied to confirm the taxonomic identification of E. vermicola. Furthermore, our results showed that E. vermicola survived resin and other chemicals secreted by pine trees, and reproduced with new lunate conidia to parasitize other migratory PWNs. In order to confirm the pathogenicity of E. vermicola, pine seedlings and large pine trees were inoculated with 300 µL and 40 mL conidia suspensions (10⁹ mL^?1). The results showed that all treated pine trees were healthy with no differences compared to the controls. Furthermore, necrosis or discoloration caused by this fungus was not observed on wood slices. Basal knowledge was provided for the application of E. vermicola to control PWN in vivo.     

Laboratory studies on the development of a conidial formulation of Esteya vermicola

The endoparasitic nematophagous fungus, Esteya vermicola, has potential as a biocontrol agent against pinewood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus. An E. vermicola conidial formulation was developed to improve conidial resistance to ultraviolet (UV), drought and heat stress. The effective concentration of each protective additive [UV protectant [fulvic acid (FA) and skim milk (SM)]; drought protectant (sorbitol) and heat protectant (calcium chloride)] was determined based on the germination rate of E. vermicola conidia after exposure to the different stressors. A combination of 0.2% FA and 4% SM, 5% sorbitol and 0.05% calcium chloride provided the most effective protection. In addition, the concentrations of spreader–sticker and antibiotic were also decided. The final formulation could be used to improve the resistance of E. vermicola conidia to multiple stressors and to increase nematode mortality compared with unformulated conidia.     

Optimization of storage condition for maintaining long-term viability of nematophagous fungus Esteya vermicola as biocontrol agent against pinewood nematode

The fungus, Esteya vermicola has been proposed as biocontrol agent against pine wilting disease caused by Bursaphelenchus xylophilus. In this study, we reported the effects of temperature and different additives on the viability and biocontrol efficacy of E. vermicola formulated by alginate-clay. The viability of the E. vermicola formulation was determined for six consecutive months at temperature ranged from ?70 to 25 °C. The fresh conidia without any treatment were used as control. Under the optimal storage conditions with E. vermicola alginate-clay formulation, the results suggested that E. vermicola alginate-clay formulation with a long shelf life could be a non-vacuum-packed formulation that contains 2 % sodium alginate and 5 % clay at 4 °C. Three conidial formulations prepared with additives of 15 % glycerol, 0.5 % yeast extract and 0.5 % herbal extraction, respectively significantly improved the shelf life. In addition, these tested formulations retained the same biocontrol efficacy as the fresh conidial against pinewood nematode. This study provided a tractable and low-cost method to preserve the shelf life of E. vermicola.     

Comparison between conidia and blastospores of Esteya vermicola, an endoparasitic fungus of the pinewood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus

Esteya vermicola, an endoparasitic fungus of Bursaphelenchus xylophilus, the pinewood nematode (PWN), exhibits great potential as a biological control agent against this nematode. E. vermicola produces blastospores in liquid media and aerial conidia on solid media. The agent was mass-produced using two kinds of culture media: S (50 % wheat bran and 50 % pine wood powder), L (0.5 g wheat bran and 0.5 g pinewood powder in 200 ml of potato dextrose broth), and two controls: SC (potato dextrose agar), LC (potato dextrose broth). Yields, multiple stress tolerance, storage life, new generation conidial number, and PWN mortality rates of the spores were measured in each of these four media and compared. The spore yields, new generation conidial number, and nematode mortality rates of blastospores were higher than those of conidia. Nevertheless, the conidia had a higher germination rate than the blastospores during the storage process and multiple stress treatments. Considering the number of spores surviving from the process of the storage and multiple stress treatments per unit of mass media, the blastospores from L survived most. Comprehensive analysis indicates that the L culture medium is the most optimal medium for mass production relatively.     

Effect of Nutrition and Environmental Factors on the Endoparasitic Fungus Esteya vermicola, a Biocontrol Agent Against Pine Wilt Disease

The nematophagous fungus Esteya vermicola has tremendous potential for biological control. This species exhibits strong infectious activity against pinewood nematodes, whereas the study on the effect of nutrition and environmental factors is still of paucity. Carbon (C), nitrogen (N), pH value, temperature, and water activity have great impact on the fungal growth, sporulation, and germination. In nutrition study, the greatest number of conidia (2.36 × 10⁹ per colony) was obtained at the C:N ratio of 100:1 with a carbon concentration 32 g l^?1. In addition, the germination rate and radial growth of E. vermicola were used to evaluate the effects of environmental conditions and they were optimized as following: pH 5.5, 26 °C and water activity of 0.98. Our results also confirmed that variation of environmental factors has a detrimental influence on the efficacy of active conidia and growth of fungus. Moreover, under above optimal condition, the biocontrol efficacy was significantly improved in regard to the increase of adhesive and mortality rate, which highlight the study on the application of E. vermicola as pine wilt disease biocontrol agent.     

Effects of mineral salts on the growth,sporulation and virulence of Esteya vermicola,an endoparasitic fungus of the pinewood nematode,Bursaphelenchus xylophilus

Esteya vermicola, an endoparasitic fungus of pinewood nematode, exhibits great potential as a biological agent against nematodes. In this study, various mineral supplements, such as chloride salts (KCl, CaCl₂, MgCl₂, FeCl₂, and FeCl₃) and calcium salts (CaCl₂, CaCO₃, and CaSO₄) were evaluated for their ability to enhance the growth, sporulation and virulence of E. vermicola. Of the cations tested, CaCl₂ provided the greatest enhancement of growth speed and sporulation. Of the anions tested, CaCO₃ produced the highest proportion of lunate conidia, and CaCl₂ produced the highest adhesive rate and mortality against the nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus. The optimum concentration of CaCl₂ for optimization of sporulation and virulence was 0.4–0.6%. In conclusion, CaCl₂ is highly effective in enhancing growth, sporulation and virulence of Esteya vermicola.     

Population dynamics of pinewood nematode and the endoparasitic fungus Esteya vermicola: interactions under experimental conditions

Esteya vermicola (Ophiostomataceae), an endoparasitic fungus, exhibits great potential as a biological control agent against pinewood nematodes (PWNs). The present study reports the interaction between PWNs and E. vermicola at different spore concentrations, number of PWNs and the time of culture. The addition of PWNs enhanced the sporulation of E. vermicola after 10 days of culture. The 5-day-old cultures of E. vermicola prior to addition of PWNs increased the highest amount of sporulation than that of 10- or 15-day-old cultures. The PWNs were completely killed by E. vermicola in the pine tree powder culture medium at the concentrations of 10⁷ and 10⁸ colony-forming-units (CFU) per ml. The interaction of the PWNs and E. vermicola was that PWNs provide nutrition to E. vermicola, however, the PWNs can also feed on mycelium of E. vermicola. The effect of E. vermicola on control of PWNs was determined by the population size, time of pest infection and the duration of co-infection.     

Attraction of Pinewood Nematode to Endoparasitic Nematophagous Fungus Esteya vermicola

The investigations on attraction of nematodes to nematophagous fungi have mostly dealt with the nematode-trapping species. Esteya vermicola is the endoparasitic fungus of pinewood nematode (PWN) with high infection activity. In the present study, the attraction of PWNs to E. vermicola was investigated. It was confirmed that the living mycelia and exudative substances of E. vermicola were attractive to PWN. Compared with the nematode-trapping fungus A. brochopaga as well as nematode-feeding fungus B. cinerea, E. vermicola showed the significantly strongest attraction ability to nematode. It therefore appeared that the attraction ability reflects the dependence of the fungi on nematodes for nutrients. Furthermore, a new method was developed and used in the study to confirm the effect of volatile substances for the attraction of nematode to fungi. The results suggested that the attractive substances were consisted of avolatile exudative and volatile diffusing compounds.     

Pathogenicity and repulsion for toxin‐producing bacteria of dominant bacteria on the surface of American pine wood nematodes

Bacteria were isolated from the surface of two samples of American pine wood nematodes to identify methods of controlling pine wilt disease. The dominant bacterial strains were identified, and their toxicity and pathogenicity, in addition to their competitiveness with other pathogenic bacteria, were measured to ascertain how bacteria on the surface of American pine wood nematodes might be used to prevent and control pine wilt disease. The bacterial isolates show that the dominant bacteria carried by the two samples of pine wood nematodes are US4, US5, Smal‐007 and Rrad‐006. Based on routine staining, morphological observation and 16S rDNA sequence analysis, the four strains were identified as Delftia lacustris, Pseudomonas putida, Stenotrophomonas maltophilia and Rhizobium nepotum. The incubation of four dominant bacterial strains and Chinese dominant bacterial strains on the surface of aseptic nematodes and in nutrient broth showed that Smal‐007 and Rrad‐006 have strong competitiveness on the surface of pine wood nematodes. Using a bacterial culture medium to measure the propensity of pine seedlings to wilt, all the American dominant bacterial strains were shown to be less toxic than the Chinese dominant strains. If pine seedlings are inoculated with both bacterial and aseptic pine wood nematodes, American dominant bacterial strains present less pathogenicity than the Chinese dominant bacterial strains. In particular, Smal‐007 and Rrad‐006 show the lowest pathogenicity. If pine seedlings are inoculated with both bacterial and wild pine wood nematodes, American dominant bacterial strains significantly reduce the pathogenicity of wild pine wood nematodes isolated from Zhejiang Province, China. The effects of Smal‐007 and Rrad‐006 are confirmed as the most prominent. The American dominant strains Smal‐007 and Rrad‐006 satisfy two main requirements: excellent repulsion performance and low pathogenicity. Therefore, they can be used as candidate strains for biocontrol bacteria.     

Rapid molecular detection of Esteya vermicola based on specific primers and the FTA-DNA extraction method

Esteya vermicola is an endoparasitic fungus of the pinewood nematode and thus has great biocontrol value. At present, the detection of this fungus is still based on microscopic observations and morphological identification, and the sampling is notably inconvenient and inefficient. In the present study, a pair of specific primers (upstream primer, 5′-GTGCCTCTACCAAGACTCGC-3′; downstream primer, 5′-CGCCAAATGTCAAGATCCGC-3′) was designed to detect E. vermicola. The analysis of the PCR amplification and the agarose gel electrophoresis results led to the establishment of a new method for the detection of E. vermicola through the presence of a 176-bp specific fragment. In addition, the use of a FTA-DNA direct extraction method for the detection of E. vermicola was explored. The results suggest that the proposed method can be effectively used for the rapid detection of E. vermicola and may provide important technical support for follow-up studies of the fungus in field experiments.     

Dispersal capacity of Monochamus galloprovincialis,the European vector of the pine wood nematode,on flight mills

The pine wood nematode (Bursaphelenchus xylophilus), which causes the symptoms of pine wilt disease, is recognized worldwide as a major forest pest. It was introduced into Portugal in 1999. It is transmitted between trees almost exclusively by longhorn beetles of the genus Monochamus, including, in particular, M. galloprovincialis (Coleoptera: Cerambycidae) in maritime pine forests. Accurate estimates of the flight capacity of this insect vector are required if we are to understand and predict the spread of pine wilt disease in Europe. Using computer‐linked flight mills, we evaluated the distance flown, the flight probability and speed of M. galloprovincialis throughout adulthood and investigated the effects of age, sex and body weight on these flight performances, which are proxies for dispersal capacity. The within‐population variability of flight performance in M. galloprovincialis was high, with a mean distance of 16 km flown over the lifetime of the beetle. Age and body weight had a significant positive effect on flight capacity, but there was no difference in performance between males and females. These findings have important implications for managing the spread of the pine wood nematode in European forests.     

Microbial transformation of ginsenoside Rg3 to ginsenoside Rh2 by <Emphasis Type="Italic">Esteya vermicola</Emphasis> CNU 120806

In the present investigation, we successfully employed a cell-free extract of Esteya vermicola CNU 120806 to convert ginsenoside Rg3 to Rh2. Three important factors including pH, temperature and substrate concentration were optimized for the preparation of Rh₂. The optimal condition was obtained as follows: 50°C, pH 5.0 and substrate concentration of 3 mg ml⁻¹. The yield of conversion was up to 90.7%. In order to identify the specificity of the β-glucosidase activity of Esteya vermicola CNU 120806, ginsenoside Re (protopanaxatriol saponins) was treated under the same reaction system. Interestingly, no new metabolite was generated, which elucidated that the enzymatic process only occurred by hydrolysis of the terminal glucopyranosyl moieties at the C-3 carbon of ginsenoside Rg₃. The crude enzyme extract can be used for commercial ginsenoside Rh₂ preparation.     

Succession of secondary forests affected by pine wilt disease in western Japan followed on vegetation maps

Abstract. Succession, changes in the distribution pattern of forest vegetation, and Pinus forest survival following pine wilt disease were clarified based on phytosociological analysis and vegetation maps. Survival of Pinus forests was restricted to the early successional stages, which were located on ridges and the upper part of slopes. Subsequent to pine wilt disease, the succession progressed from early to late substages of Pinus forest, mixed deciduous and evergreen Quercus, to evergreen Quercus forest. Succession occurs in abandoned pine forests which apparently are in a bad state and are vulnerable to attacks by pine wilt disease.     

Morphological,molecular and biological characterization of Esteya vermicola,a nematophagous fungus isolated from intercepted wood packing materials exported from Brazil

The nematophagous fungus Esteya vermicola, strain NKF 13222, was purified from an isolate of Bursaphelenchus rainulfi which was intercepted from wood packaging materials originating in Brazil and arriving at Tianjin port in China. The fungus produced two types of conidiogenous cells and conidia, each with different germination modes. More lunate adhesive conidia than bacilloid conidia were produced on nutrient-poor water agar medium. Morphological comparisons revealed the NKF 13222 strain closely resembled the Taiwan strain E. vermicola (ATCC 74485) previously isolated from the pinewood nematode B. xylophilus. Phylogenetic analysis of the β-tubulin and elongation factor 1-α genes indicated that the NKF 13222 grouped with other strains of E. vermicola including the Taiwan strain. This was the first record of E. vermicola from B. rainulfi in South America. Infection tests demonstrated that NKF 13222 was more infective to aphelenchid than tylenchid nematodes and that only lunate adhesive conidia were infectious. The results suggest that the fungus might be a pathogen of plant parasitic nematodes with a broad distribution and provide new information for the potential biocontrol of plant diseases caused by B. xylophilus, Aphelenchoides spp. and Ditylenchus destructor.     

Identification and validation of reference genes for RT‐qPCR analysis in banana (Musa spp.) under Fusarium wilt resistance induction conditions

Banana (Musa spp.) is severely damaged by Fusarium wilt caused by Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubense (Foc). Biocontrol by inducing systemic resistance has been considered as one of the most important strategies to improve plant health. Very few studies have investigated appropriate reference gene selection for RT‐qPCR (quantitative real‐time polymerase chain reaction) analysis suitable for conditions of systemic activated resistance. In this study, we assessed over a time‐course the expression of seven candidate reference genes (EF1, TUB, ACT1, ACT2, L2, RPS2 and RAN) for Cavendish cultivar Brazilian (Musa spp. AAA) and dwarf banana cultivar Guangfen No. 1 (Musa spp. ABB) that were inoculated by Bacillus subtilis strain TR21 and Foc. We choose these plants because they are commonly planted in Southern China. Expression stability of the candidate genes was evaluated using various software packages (GeNorm, NormFinder and BestKeeper). L2 and TUB genes displayed maximum stability in Guangfen No. 1. In Brazilian, ACT1 and TUB were the most stable genes. To further validate the suitability of the reference genes identified in this study, the expression of pathogenesis‐related 1 (PR1) gene under TR21 and Foc strains Foc004/Foc009 treatments was also studied. Identified reference genes in this work that are most suitable for normalizing gene expression data in banana under Fusarium wilt resistance induction conditions will contribute to the understanding of disease resistance mechanisms induced by biocontrol strains in banana.     

Effects of pine wilt disease invasion on soil properties and Masson pine forest communities in the Three Gorges reservoir region,China

Pine wilt disease (PWD) has caused significant Masson pine mortality in the Three Gorges reservoir region in central China. In this study, five uniform Masson pine stand types infected by PWD were selected and surveyed on slopes and aspects with similar environmental conditions. In sites that had been infected, soil bulk density was reduced, and the difference among the groups was statistically significant (P < 0.05) at the 0–10 cm and 10–20 cm soil layers, but not at 20–40 cm. Other soil water‐related physical properties, excluding noncapillary porosity, significantly differed among the groups in all soil layers. Additionally, the values of available phosphorus, sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium were higher in the invaded stands, but the total nitrogen and organic matter contents were lower. Masson pine does not become reestablished following PWD‐induced mortality but is instead replaced by broad‐leaved tree species. Among the 19 examined environmental variables, five were found to be significantly related with the ordination of plant community structure: Masson pine stumps (MPS), K⁺, capillary water holding capacity (CWHC), capillary porosity (CP), and soil water content (SWC). Among these factors, the plant community structure was principally related to MPS and K⁺. The findings of this study show that the outbreak of PWD has impacted Masson pine forest soil properties and altered forest community composition. The disease is negatively related with the presence of Masson pine and positively associated with that of broad‐leaved tree species.     

Development of secondary pine forests after pine wilt disease in western Japan

Abstract. The development of secondary Pinus densiflora (Japanese red pine) forests after pine wilt disease was studied through phytosociological analysis, estimation of forest structure before disease and size-structure, tree ring and stem analyses. Following the end of the disease, the growth of previously suppressed small oak trees was accelerated. This is quite different from the development of forests following fire, which starts with the establishment of pine seedlings. Pine wilt disease shifted the dominance of secondary forests from Pinus densiflora to Quercus serrata oak forest. In pine forests, disturbance by fire is important for forest maintenance. In contrast, disturbance by pine wilt disease leads to an acceleration of succession from pine forest to oak forest.