Prediction of Secchi disc depths in Florida lakes: Impact of algal biomass and organic color

A model for the prediction of Secchi disc depths in Florida lakes was developed and tested using data from 205 lakes. A statistical analysis showed that the best estimate of lake Secchi disc depths could be obtained by In (SD) = 2.01 ? 0.370 In (Chla) ? 0.278 In (C) where SD is Secchi disc depth (m), Chla is the chlorophyll a concentration (mg/m³) and C is the organic color concentration (mg/l as Pt). The model yields unbiased estimates of lake Secchi disc depths over a wide range of algal and organic color concentrations and has a 95% confidence interval of 47 to 224% of the calculated Secchi disc depth. Other published Secchi-Chlorophyll models are less precise but can be used almost equally well. This indicates organic color concentrations do not affect lake Secchi disc depths as much as algal levels. Further reductions in the remaining error term, however, might be accomplished by including a variable for suspended inorganic sediment.     

Relationships between Fish Species Abundances and Water Transparency in Hypertrophic Turbid Waters of Temperate Shallow Lakes

We explored the relationships between Secchi disc depth and the abundance of fish species in very shallow, hypertrophic, turbid waters of Pampa Plain lakes, Argentine. We tested whether the abundance of any of the species present was associated with water transparency for lakes where water transparency, as measured by Secchi disc depth, ranged from 0.1 to 0.4 m. Overall, the abundance of five species (Cnesterodon decemmaculatus, Jenynsia multidentata, Corydoras paleatus, Pimelodella laticeps and Odontesthes bonariensis) seemed to be affected by this narrow gradient in water transparency. These findings represent an interesting result for turbid hypertrophic environments where narrow ranges in water transparency are traditionally neglected as important factors for fishes. We show, however, how water transparency patterns may be still important for some species in highly turbid waters with extremely narrow gradients in Secchi disc depth. (© 2010 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)     

The influence of biomass and structure of the crustacean plankton on the water transparency in the Saidenbach storage reservoir

Planktonic crustacean biomass as well as structure are important factors influencing water transparency. The significant dependence of the water quality (Secchi depth) on the concentration and the share of the Daphnia biovolume and not on the total Crustacea biovolume in the Saidenbach reservoir indicates that the density of the Crustacea is only a measure of the cleaning performance, if Daphnia dominates. Using the mean size, the influence of the crustacean structure on the Secchi depth can be recorded. If big size categories prevail (like Daphnia) the water transparency is high. The mainly occurrence of little species (Mesocyclops, Bosmina) results in lower Secchi depths. However, a well defined (significant) relationship is being prevented by the different feeding behaviour of the several species.     

The effect of non-algal turbidity on the relationship of Secchi depth to chlorophyll a

Data from four reservoirs representative of different trophic states and with different apparent optical properties were analyzed to determine the relationship of Secchi depth to algal biomass as measured by chlorophyll a. In the eutrophic reservoir Secchi depth was determined partially by the chlorophyll a content (r² = 0.31) but only when chlorophyll a data from bloom conditions are included. In the two mesotrophic reservoirs, Secchi depth was entirely determined by non-algal turbidity. In the oligotrophic reservoir, Secchi depth was determined neither by chlorophyll a nor non-algal turbidity and was probably determined by dissolved color. When data from the four reservoirs were pooled (N = 205), 53% of the variation in Secchi depth was explained by: SD = 2.55–0.52 ln (Turbidity) + 0.005 (Chlorophyll a). It is apparent that attempts to estimate algal biomass for trophic state classification or other management practices from Secchi depth data are inappropriate even where moderate amounts of non-algal turbidity are present.     

Effects of planktivore abundance on chlorophyll-a and Secchi depth

We used two analyses to test the hypothesis that planktivore abundances contribute to the residual variations of Secchi depth or chlorophyll-a plotted with respect to mean summer epilimnetic total phosphorus. The first analysis involved 15 lake years of data from six lakes. The data set comprised mark-recapture assessments of piscivore and planktivore numbers and estimates of mean summer chlorophyll-a, total phosphorus and Secchi depth. We found that residual chlorophyll-a variation was not significantly (p>0.05) correlated with planktivore densities, but that planktivore densities did contribute (p<0.02) to the residual variation of Secchi depth on mean total phosphorus. The second analysis included all of the data used in the first plus an additional 13 lake years of data from the literature. These data showed that the percentage of the total fish community comprising planktivores did not significantly (p>0.05) contribute to the residual variation in chlorophyll-a with respect to mean summer total phosphorus. Together, our results suggest that planktivore abundance has a significant cascading impact on water clarity, but no long term statistically significant impact on mean summer chlorophyll-a concentration.     

Effects of macrophytes on lake‐water quality across latitudes: a meta‐analysis

Macrophytes are widely recognized for improving water quality and stabilizing the desirable clear‐water state in lakes. The positive effects of macrophytes on water quality have been noted to be weaker in the (sub)tropics compared to those of temperate regions. We conducted a global meta‐analysis using 47 studies that met our set criteria to assess the overall effects of macrophytes on water quality (measured by phytoplankton chlorophyll a concentration, total nitrogen concentration, total phosphorus concentration, Secchi depth and the trophic state index) and to investigate how these effects correlate with latitude using meta‐regressions. We also examined if the effects of macrophytes on lake‐water quality differ with growth form and study design in (sub)tropical and temperate areas by grouping the data and then comparing the effect sizes. We found that macrophytes significantly reduced phytoplankton chlorophyll a concentration, total nitrogen concentration, total phosphorus concentration, as well as the trophic state index, but they did not have a significant overall effect on Secchi depth. The effects of macrophytes on reducing phytoplankton chlorophyll a concentration, total nitrogen concentration and the trophic state index did not differ with latitude. However, the reduction of total phosphorus concentration was greater at lower latitudes. We showed that at lower latitudes, the positive effects of macrophytes on water quality are similar to or greater than those at higher latitudes, thus challenging the prevailing paradigm of macrophytes being less effective at enhancing lake‐water quality in the (sub)tropics. Furthermore, our data showed that the macrophyte effects vary by growth forms, and the growth forms that positively affect water quality differ between the (sub)tropical and temperate areas. We showed a lack of significant macrophyte effects in surveys within and outside macrophyte stands, suggesting difference in the sensitivities of study designs or possibly weaker effects of macrophytes in lakes compared to experimental settings.     

Reference conditions for phytoplankton at Danish Water Framework Directive intercalibration sites

Phytoplankton is one of the biological quality elements included in the EU Water Framework Directive (WFD). Classification of water quality according to the WFD is based on the deviation of the present conditions from reference conditions. Given the lack of data from pristine conditions, this study used approximately 100-year-old measurements of Secchi depths from Danish waters in combination with relationships between Secchi depth and chlorophyll a (as a proxy for phytoplankton biomass) obtained from recent monitoring to calculate ‘historical’ or reference chlorophyll a (Chl-a) concentrations. Historical Secchi depth data were available for 9 out of the 11 Danish WFD intercalibration sites. At eight of the sites, reference summer (May–September) Chl-a concentrations were in the range 0.7–1.2 μg l⁻¹. At one site, west of Bornholm in the western Baltic Sea, historical Secchi depth measurements date back to only the late 1950s corresponding to a calculated Chl-a concentration of 1.3 μg l⁻¹. This value cannot be considered representative of reference conditions. Guest editors: J. H. Andersen & D. J. Conley Eutrophication in Coastal Ecosystems: Selected papers from the Second International Symposium on Research and Management of Eutrophication in Coastal Ecosystems, 20–23 June 2006, Nyborg, Denmark     

Biological assessment of the euphotic zone in a turbid man-made lake

The underwater light climate in the turbid waters of the Hendrik Verwoerd Dam (South Africa) was assessed using an underwater lightmeter with glass colour filters, a Secchi disc and a biostimulatory response technique. Secchi readings varied between 17 to 25% of the light penetration as measured with the underwater lightmeter. Active ¹⁴C assimilation took place at depths 530% deeper than the 1% light intensity depth. Red light was transmitted most in the waters.     

Biological and water quality effects of artificial mixing of Arbuckle Lake,Oklahoma, during 1977

This paper describes the effects of total lake mixing with 16 axial flow (Garton) pumps on the water quality, algal biomass and community metabolism of Arbuckle Lake, Oklahoma.Pumping began on July 1, 1977, and subsequently lowered the thermocline throughout the lake. The concentration of dissolved oxygen rose in formerly anoxic strata. Water quality in the former hypolimnion improved. Concentration of ammonia and BOD₅ decreased, and concentrations of manganese remained unchanged in 1977 compared to the control year (1976). But, concentrations of sulfide in the hypolimnion were higher in 1977 than in 1976. Algal biomass as chlorophyll a was about the same in 1977 as in 1978. The depth of the Secchi disc was also the same. An algal bloom did not occur. Pumping decreased the ratio gross production: community respiration as measured by a free water method, suggesting that lakes which are artificially mixed will have lower net primary productivities than lakes which are not artificially mixed.     

Influence of predation by fish and water turbidity on a Daphnia gessneri population in an Amazonian floodplain lake,Brazil

The population behavior of Daphnia gessneri Herbst, 1967 in a floodplain lake (Lago Grande) of the lower Rio Solimões was investigated between April 1979 and March 1980 with regard to 1) predation by the fish called tambaqui (Colossoma macropomum, Characidae), 2) water level fluctuation and 3) water transparency. Zooplankton density samples were collected at two sites near mid-lake, where water depth and Secchi disc transparency were measured. In addition, qualitative samples of zooplankton and fish collections were taken at several sites in the adjacent floodplain areas. The author concludes that fluctuations in Daphnia gessneri populations correlate most with intense predation by fish and water turbidity.     

Responses of a eutrophic pond community to separate and combined effects of N:P supply and planktivorous fish: a mesocosm experiment

We conducted an outdoor mesocosm experiment of factorial design consisting of three levels of nutrient supply (no nutrient addition and additions of nitrogen and phosphorus in ratios of 10:1 and 45:1) cross-classified with two levels of bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus) (presence and absence). Nutrient supply significantly affected total phosphorus (TP), total nitrogen (TN), TN: TP ratio, turbidity, Secchi depth, phytoplankton chlorophyll, filamentous blue-green algae, periphyton chlorophyll, Asplanchna and non-predatory rotifers. The presence of bluegill significantly increased TP, turbidity, diatoms, unicellular green algae, colonial blue-green algae, filamentous blue-green algae, periphyton chlorophyll, Asplanchna and non-predatory rotifers, and decreased Secchi depth, cladocerans, cyclopoid copepodids, copepod nauplii and chironomid tube densities. Nutrient supply and fish effects were not independent of each other as shown by significant nutrient × fish interaction effects for TP, Secchi depth, filamentous blue-green algae, periphyton chlorophyll, Asplanchna and non-predatory rotifers.     

Female ornamentation and egg carotenoids of six sympatric gobies

Belly colouration, gonad carotenoid concentration and skin transparency were quantified in gravid Gobiusculus flavescens, as well as in females of five sympatric gobies where belly ornamentation has not been described. Although G. flavescens females did, indeed, have far more colourful bellies than the other species, this could only in part be explained by a high concentration of total gonad carotenoids. Comparable, or occasionally higher, carotenoid levels were found in the gonads of other species. Instead, the unusual ornamentation of G. flavescens arises from a unique combination of carotenoid‐rich gonads and a highly transparent abdominal skin.     

Secchi disk — chlorophyll relationships in a lake with highly variable phytoplankton biomass

In meseutrophic Lake Constance mean euphotic phytoplankton chlorophyll concentrations vary about 100-fold over the year. Concomitant fluctuations in euphotic depth (Z_eu) and Secchi depth (Z_s) are related to each other in a non-linear fashion that as a rough approximation can be expressed by Z_eu 5 Z_s.Secchi depth is to a great extent a function of beam attenuation of light which depends on the inherent optical properties of the water and is highly sensitive to light scattering from particles. Euphotic depth, by contrast, is a function of the vertical light attenuation coefficient which also depends on absorption and scattering, but is less sensitive to the latter than beam attenuation. Algal cells both absorb and scatter light and therefore influence Secchi depth and euphotic depth, however, in different fashions.Whenever the lake is clear due to scarce phytoplankton, scattering is small and beam attenuation only exceeds vertical light attenuation by a relatively small factor. As a consequence, the ratio of euphotic depth to Secchi depth is small (1.5–2.5). When the lake is turbid due to high algal density, enhanced scattering from algal cells and detrital particles causes beam attenuation to rise more than vertical light attenuation, thus leading to high ratios of euphotic depth to Secchi depth (3–5). The relatively close relationships between Secchi depth and chlorophyll in Lake Constance are due to (1) high influence of chlorophyll concentration on water transparency, (2) co-variation of phytoplankton and other suspended particles, and (3) limited variation of cellular chlorophyll contents.     

Chemical limnology of two artificial lakes used for both stormwater management and recreation

The aims of this study were to document the mainly chemical behaviour of two linked artificial lakes used for both stormwater management and recreation in the new town of Craigavon. Further, the understanding of their behaviour should help in their management and the design of other similar lakes.The lake mean total phosphorus (73 µg P l^–1), nitrate (0.50 mg N l^–1) and chlorophyll a (25 µg l^–1) concentrations, Secchi depth (1.2 m) and the estimated total phosphorus loading (1.98 g m^–2 a^–1) all classify the main lake as eutrophic. An important source of the phosphorus load on the lakes is the urban area of Craigavon (52% of the total load). The interrelationships between total phosphorus, chlorophyll a and Secchi depth in the main lake are similar to those in natural ones. In addition, the lake follows the total phosphorus load — trophic state relationships (lake total phosphorus and chlorophyll a concentrations and Secchi depth) found to apply elsewhere. These two points indicate that the artificial lakes in Craigavon behave similarly to natural ones.     

Limnological studies on the Pretoria Salt Pan,a hypersaline maar lake

The Pretoria Salt Pan is shallow (maximum depth 2.85 m) and alkaline (surface water pH varied from 9.6 to 10.9) with pronounced mesothermy (38.2 °C in spring) at a depth of between 0.55 and 0.7 metres. Secchi disc transparencies ranged from 7 to 19 cm. A total ionic concentration gradient increasing from 59 500 mg · ?^?1 near the surface to 298 000 mg · ?^?1 at 2.75 metres stabilized the thermally inverted water column. Sodium was the major cation and nearly equal proportions of chloride plus carbonate and bicarbonate accounted for over 98% of the anions. The lake was meromictic with a steep chemocline, persistent thermally inverted temperature profile and complete anoxia at depths greater than 50 cm. The diel pattern of dissolved oxygen distribution involving a nocturnal deoxygenation and diurnal reoxygenation was unusual.     

Environmental conditions and phosphorus removal in Florida lakes and wetlands inhabited by Hydrilla verticillata (Royle): implications for invasive species management

Hydrilla verticillata is considered the most problematic aquatic plant in the United States. In south Florida, Hydrilla dominance has also been documented in treatment wetlands. This paper characterizes (1) environmental conditions which favor Hydrilla growth and (2) understand its nutrient removal capability. Despite its occurrence over a wide range of environmental conditions, Hydrilla abundance increased with increasing pH, alkalinity, total P and total N, and decreased with water depth in selected Florida lakes. No relationship was found between color, Secchi depth and Hydrilla abundance. In several Hydrilla-dominated lakes, mean total P concentration (126 μg/l) at inflow was reduced to 106 μg/l at outflow. The maximum inflow total P concentration in a lake with positive nutrient reduction was 148 μg/l. Total P removal efficiency by Hydrilla-dominated lakes and wetlands was comparable to or higher than systems dominated by emergent and other submerged plants. Mean total P settling rates for lakes and a constructed wetland dominated by Hydrilla were estimated at 19 and 34 m/year, respectively, which were higher than or comparable to similar systems dominated by other aquatic plants. Results from this study suggest that reduction of Hydrilla from constructed wetlands will not likely improve nutrient removal performance.     

Evaluating short-term effects of omnivorous fish removal on water quality and zooplankton at a subtropical lake

We evaluated a biomanipulation program to test for short-term changes in water quality (chlorophyll a, Secchi depth, total phosphorus) and macrozooplankton biomass following partial removal of omnivorous gizzard shad Dorosoma cepedianum. The removal occurred at a eutrophic subtropical lake, and responses were compared to an unmanipulated control lake using a before-after-control-impact paired series analysis. The removal reduced the biomass of large (>300 mm) gizzard shad by 75% over 2 years via a subsidized commercial gill net fishery. However, the total population biomass of gizzard shad was reduced by approximately 32% from an average pre-manipulation biomass of 224 kg ha⁻¹ due to the size selectivity of the gear, which did not effectively capture small fish (<300 mm). No significant short-term changes in chlorophyll a concentration, Secchi depth, total phosphorus concentration or macrozooplankton biomass were detected following biomanipulation. The partial removal may have fallen short of the biomass reduction required to cause ecosystem responses. Our results suggest that moderate omnivore removals (i.e., <40% biomass reduction) will have little short-term benefits to these lakes, and future manipulations should use a less size-selective gear to achieve a larger total biomass reduction.     

Decrease in water clarity of the southern and central North Sea during the 20th century

Light in the marine environment is a key environmental variable coupling physics to marine biogeochemistry and ecology. Weak light penetration reduces light available for photosynthesis, changing energy fluxes through the marine food web. Based on published and unpublished data, this study shows that the central and southern North Sea has become significantly less clear over the second half of the 20th century. In particular, in the different regions and seasons investigated, the average Secchi depth pre‐1950 decreased between 25% and 75% compared to the average Secchi depth post‐1950. Consequently, in summer pre‐1950, most (74%) of the sea floor in the permanently mixed area off East Anglia was within the photic zone. For the last 25+ years, changes in water clarity were more likely driven by an increase in the concentration of suspended sediments, rather than phytoplankton. We suggest that a combination of causes have contributed to this increase in suspended sediments such as changes in sea‐bed communities and in weather patterns, decreased sink of sediments in estuaries, and increased coastal erosion. A predicted future increase in storminess (Beniston et al., 2007; Kovats et al., 2014) could enhance the concentration of suspended sediments in the water column and consequently lead to a further decrease in clarity, with potential impacts on phytoplankton production, CO₂ fluxes, and fishery production.     

Temporal distribution of phytoplankton in Lake Nyamusingiri in the Albertine Rift Valley,Uganda

A study aimed at investigating the temporal variation of phytoplankton assemblages in Lake Nyamusingiri was carried out during the period of December 1997–May 1998. Uganda’s freshwaters are ecologically diverse but a few are intensively studied. Research on phytoplankton has been restricted to large water bodies. There is little information on phytoplankton of the western Uganda crater lakes, which are important water and biodiversity resources. This study provided baseline data on phytoplankton, which will serve as a basis for monitoring the effects of human activities on the lake that might result in ecological transformations like loss of biodiversity because of overexploitation. A laboratory thermometer and Winker’s method were used to determine temperature and dissolved oxygen concentration, respectively. Lake transparency was measured by using the Secchi disc. A Van Dorn sampler was used to collect water samples. Nutrient and chlorophyll a concentrations were determined by using facilities at the Fisheries Resources Research Institute (FIRRI), Jinja. The Sedgwick‐Rafter counting chamber was used to analyse phytoplankton. Variation in temperature was small (25.4–26.2°C). Stable thermal stratification was not evident. The Secchi disc transparency was less than unity. The chlorophyll a value was high. Biomass was found to be light‐limited by nonalgal materials. Dissolved oxygen concentration was more than 100% in the surface waters but declined to <20% at the bottom, which reflected the eutrophic nature of the lake. Diversity indices were low. Eighteen species and five classes of phytoplankton were revealed by this study. The phytoplankton flora was dominated by chlorococcal green algae characteristic of the large eutrophic East African lakes.