Variation in chromatin structure in two cell types from the same tissue: a short DNA repeat length in cerebral cortex neurons

We have used micrococcal nuclease as a probe of the repeating structure of chromatin in four nuclear populations from three tissues of the rabbit. Neuronal nuclei isolated from the cerebral cortex contain about 160 base pairs of DNA in the chromatin repeat unit, as compared with about 200 base pairs for nonastrocytic glial cell nuclei from the same tissue, neuronal nuclei from the cerebellum and liver nuclei. All four types of nuclei show the same features of nucleosomal organization as other eucaryotic nuclei so far studied: nucleosomes liberated by digestion with micrococcal nuclease give a “core particle” containing 140 base pairs as a metastable intermediate on further digestion and a series of single-strand DNA fragments which are mutiples of 10 bases after digestion with DNAase I. Nuclei from cerebral cortex neurons, which have a short repeat, are distinct from the others in being larger, in having a higher proportion of euchromatin (dispersed chromatin) as judged by microscopy and in being more active in RNA synthesis in vitro.     

Structure of eukaryotic chromatin. Evaluation of periodicity using endogenous and exogenous nucleases.

DNA isolated from (a) liver chromatin digested in situ with endogenous Ca2+, Mg2+-dependent endonuclease, (b) prostate chromatin digested in situ with micrococcal nuclease or pancreatic DNAase I, and (c) isolated liver chromatin digested with micrococcal nuclease or pancreatic DNAase I has been analyzed electrophoretically on polyacrylamide gels. The electrophoretic patterns of DNA prepared from chromatin digested in situ with either endogenous endonuclease (liver nuclei) or micrococcal nuclease (prostate nuclei) are virtually identical. Each pattern consists of a series of discrete bands representing multiples of the smallest fragment of DNA 200 +/- 20 base pairs in length. The smallest DNA fragment (monomer) accumulates during prolonged digestion of chromatin in situ until it accounts for nearly all of the DNA on the gel; approx. 20% of the DNA of chromatin is rendered acid soluble during this period. Digestion of liver chromatin in situ in the presence of micrococcal nuclease results initially in the reduction of the size of the monomer from 200 to 170 base pairs of DNA and subsequently results in its conversion to as many as eight smaller fragments. The electrophoretic pattern obtained with DNA prepared from micrococcal nuclease digests of isolated liver chromatin is similar, but not identical, to that obtained with liver chromatin in situ. These preparations are more heterogeneous and contain DNA fragments smaller than 200 base pairs in length. These results suggest that not all of the chromatin isolated from liver nuclei retains its native structure. In contrast to endogenous endonuclease and micrococcal nuclease digests of chromatin, pancreatic DNAase I digests of isolated chromatin and of chromatin in situ consist of an extremely heterogeneous population of DNA fragments which migrates as a continuum on gels. A similar electrophoretic pattern is obtained with purified DNA digested by micrococcal nuclease. The presence of spermine (0.15 mM) and spermidine (0.5 mM) in preparative and incubation buffers decreases the rate of digestion of chromatin by endogenous endonuclease in situ approx. 10-fold, without affecting the size of the resulting DNA fragments. The rates of production of the smallest DNA fragments, monomer, dimer, and trimer, are nearly identical when high molecular weight DNA is present in excess, indicating that all of the chromatin multimers are equally susceptible to endogenous endonuclease. These observations points out the effects of various experimental conditions on the digestion of chromatin by nucleases.     

A site of discontinuity in the interaction between DNA and histones in nucleosomes of sea urchin embryo chromatin.

Digestion of chromatin DNA in nuclei of sea urchin embryos with pancreatic nuclease and with micrococcal nuclease give additional details concerning the interaction between DNA and histones. A specific site of hydrolysis appears to be located on the nucleosome in such a position as to split the DNA unit length in two equivalent fragments of about 60–70 base pairs in length. The complete digestion of chromatin DNA appears to depend on the low stability of the nucleosome containing the split DNA fragments.     

The subunit structure of chromatin from Physarum polycephalum.

Nucleosome DNA repeat lengths in Physarum chromatin, determined by nuclease digestion experiments, are shorter than those observed in most mammalian chromatin and longer than those reported for chromatin of certain other lower eukaryotes. After digestion with staphylococcal nuclease for short periods of time an average repeat length of 190 base pairs is measured. After more extensive digestion an average repeat length of 172 base pairs is measured. Upon prolonged digestion DNA is degraded to an average monomer subunit length of 160 base pairs, with only a small amount of DNA found in lengths of 130 base pairs or smaller. Mathematical analysis of the data suggests that the Physarum nucleosome DNA repeat comprises a protected DNA segment of about 159 base pairs with a nuclease-accessible interconnecting segment which ranges from 13 to 31 base pairs. The spacing data are compatible with measurements from electron micrographs of Physarum chromatin.     

Maturation of newly replicated chromatin of simian virus 40 and its host cell

The DNA in replicating simian virus 40 chromatin and cellular chromatin was labeled with short pulses of [³H]thymidine. The structure of pulse-labeled nucleoprotein complexes was studied by micrococcal nuclease digestion. It was found that in both newly replicated viral and cellular chromatin, a structural state appears which is characterized by an increased sensitivity to nuclease and a faster than usual rate of cleavage to DNA fragments of monomeric nucleosome size and smaller. Pulse-chase experiments show that each of these effects requires a characteristic time to disappear in both systems, suggesting the existence of different sub-processes of chromatin maturation. One of these processes, detectable by the reversion of the unusually fast production of subnucleosomal fragments, is delayed in SV40 chromatin replication.     

Nascent DNA in nucleosome like structures from chromatin

We have used chromatin sensitivity to cleavage by micrococcal nuclease as a probe for differences between chromatin containing nascent DNA and that containing bulk DNA. Micrococcal nuclease digested the nascent DNA in chromatin of swimming blastulae of sea urchins more rapidly to acid-soluble nucleotides than the DNA of bulk chromatin. A part of the nascent DNA occurred in micrococcal nuclease-resistant structures which were either different from, or temporary modifications of, the bulk nucleosomes. This was inferred from the size differences between bulk and nascent DNA fragments in 10% polyacrylamide gels after micrococcal nuclease digestion of nuclei from a mixture of ¹⁴C-thymidine long- and ³H-thymidine pulse-labeled embryos. Bulk monomer and dimer DNA fragments contained about 170 and 410 base pairs (bp), respectively, when 18% of the bulk DNA had been rendered acid-soluble. At this level of digestion, “nascent monomer DNA” fragments of about 150 bp as well as 305 bp “large nascent DNA fragments” were observed. Increasing levels of digestion indicated that the large nascent DNA fragment was derived from a chromatin structure which was more resistant to micrococcal nuclease cleavage than bulk dimer chromatin subunits. Peaks of ³H-thymidine-labeled DNA fragments from embryos which had been pulse-labeled and then chased or labeled for several minutes overlapped those of ¹⁴C-thymidine long-labeled monomer, dimer and trimer fragments. This indicated that the chromatin organization at or near the replication fork which had temporarily changed during replication had returned to the organization of its nonreplicating state.     

Nucleoprotein chromatin subunit from Physarum polycephalum

The nucleoproteins resulting from digestion of the nuclei of the true slime mold Pysarum polycephalum with micrococcal nuclease have been resolved according to the size classes in linear sucrose gradients containg 0.5 M NaCl, and analysed for DNA, RNA and protein content. The basic nucleoprotein subunit has been found to contain a DNA fragment of about 150--170 base pairs complexed with an approximately equal amount, on a weight basis, of basic proteins and a relatively small amount of non-histone proteins (about 35% of the amount of DNA). Higher nucleoprotein oligomers were shown to contain spacer DNA fragments between adjacent subunits and a considerably higher ratio of non-histone proteins to DNA than the basic subunit. Both the basic subunit and higher nucleoprotein oligomers of Physarum chromatin contain some amount of tightly bound RNA. However, in contrast to the distribution of the non-histone proteins, the ratio of RNA to RNA is similar in both fractions.     

Accessibility of some regions of DNA in chromatin (chicken erythrocytes) to single strand-specific nucleases.

The susceptibility of the DNA in chromatin to single strand-specific nucleases was examined using nuclease P1, mung bean nuclease, and venom phosphodiesterase. A stage in the reaction exists where the size range of the solubilized products is similar for each of the three nucleases and is nearly independent of incubation time. During this stage, the chromatin fragments sediment in the range of 30 to 100 S and contain duplex DNA ranging from 1 to 10 million daltons. Starting with chromatin depleted of histones H1 and H5 similar fragments are generated. In both cases these nucleoprotein fragments are reduced to nucleosomes and their multimers by micrococcal nuclease. Thus, chromatin contains a limited number of DNA sites which are susceptible to single strand-specific nucleases. These sites occur at intervals of 8 to 80 nucleosomes and are distributed throughout the chromatin. Nucleosome monomers, dimers, or trimers were not observed at any stage of single strand-specific nuclease digestion of nuclei, H1- and H5-depleted chromatin, or micrococcal nuclease-generated oligonucleosomes. Each of the three nucleases converted mononucleosomes (approximately 160 base pairs) to nucleosome cores (approximately 140 base pairs) probably by exonucleolytic action that was facilitated by the prior removal of H1 and H5. The minichromosome of SV40 is highly resistant to digestion by nuclease P1.     

Adenoassociated virus has a unique chromatin structure

The organization of intranuclear adenoassociated virus DNA (AAV) was examined following micrococcal nuclease digestion of nuclei prepared from cells coinfected with AAV type 2 (AAV-2) and adenovirus type 2 (Ad2). Blot-hybridization analysis of the DNA with AAV-2, Ad2, and cellular DNA probes revealed that AAV-2 chromatin has a unique structure, which upon nuclease digestion gives rise to a smear of oligomeric DNA fragments from 600-2200 base pairs in length with only a very faint band about 160 base pairs and no discrete multimers. This structure was similar to, but distinguishable from, Ad2 chromatin and completely unrelated to eukaryotic chromatin.     

Comparison of nuclease digestion of polyoma virus nucleoprotein complex and mouse chromatin.

We digested polyoma virus nucleoprotein complex, isolated from disrupted virions, with micrococcal nuclease and DNase I. The results were compared with digestions of chromatin from mouse nuclei. The nucleosome "core" structures were similar, but the spacing of the nucleosomes in the isolated polymoma nucleoprotein complexes was irregular, whereas in mouse chromatin it was regular. The average nucleosome repeat length in each case was 190 to 200 base pairs. This figure suggests that, unless there are substantial stretches of free DNA, the polyoma nucleoprotein complex contains about 26 nucleosomes. The commonly used method of preparing the nucleoprotein complex by disruption of virions at pH 10.2 may lead to significant damage to the structure. Such damage may be more clearly revealed by the susceptibility of the DNA to nuclease digestion than by the usual criteria of sedimentation velocity and buoyant density.     

Nucleosome assembly capacity of nuclear lysate after nuclease digestion

Limited digestion of lymphocyte nuclei with micrococcal nuclease degrades the nuclear DNA and results in a resistant plateau of about 50% of the original DNA. During the course of the nuclease cleavage as more and more DNA becomes acid-soluble an increasing amount of core histone is released from the disintegrated chromatin indicating that a part of nucleosomal protected DNA is degraded. These free histones appeared not to be different from those arising from resistant chromatin fragments. The released histones are in a native state which allows the exogenous DNA to be converted into nucleoprotein complexes which appear to exhibit a typical nucleosomal structure as tested by several criteria.     

Nuclease Digestion of Chromatin from the Eukaryotic Algae Olisthodiscus luteus,Peridinium balticum,and Crypthecodinium cohnii 1, 2

Chromatin from a uninucleate dinoflagellate, Crypthecodinium cohnii, a binucleate dinoflagellate, Peridinium balticum, and a chromophyte, Olisthodiscus luteus, was examined by nuclease digestion and the results were compared to those from vertebrates. Gel analysis of the products of staphylococcal (micrococcal) nuclease digestion revealed a DNA repeat unit of 220(±5) base pairs for O. luteus and 215(±5) for P. balticum. Limit digestion gave a core particle of 140 base pairs, revealing that these longer repeat sizes are due to longer linker regions. No repeating subunit structure was found upon electrophoresis of digests of C. cohnii nuclei. Examination of the DNA fragments produced by DNAse I digestion of nuclei isolated from P. balticum and O. luteus showed the same ladder of ten base multiples as seen in chromatin from other eukaryotes. Examination of the kinetics of digestion by DNAse II of Peridinium chromatin revealed less susceptibility when compared to DNAse I digestions while 70% of Olisthodiscus chromatin and 35% of C. cohnii chromatin was sensitive to DNAse II. These data, taken together with previous results from Euglena, indicate that while algal chromatin is similar to that of higher eukaryotes in regard to DNAse I and II action, it differs in that the linker DNA is longer. In addition, the Hl-like histone from O. luteus and P. balticum is located in the linker DNA as in higher eukaryotes.     

Chromatin assembly in isolated mammalian nuclei.

Cellular DNA replication was stimulated in confluent monolayers of CV-1 monkey kidney cells following infection with SV40. Nuclei were isolated from CV-1 cells labeled with [3H]thymidine and then incubated in the presence of [alpha-32P]deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates under conditions that support DNA replication. To determine whether or not the cellular DNA synthesized in vitro was assembled into nucleosomes the DNA was digested in situ with either micrococcal nuclease or pancreatic DNase I, and the products were examined by electrophoretic and sedimentation analysis. The distribution of DNA fragment lengths on agarose gels following micrococcal nuclease digestion was more heterogeneous for newly replicated than for the bulk of the DNA. Nonetheless, the state of cellular DNA synthesized in vitro (32P-labeled) was found to be identical with that of the DNA in the bulk of the chromatin (3H-labeled) by the following criteria: (i) The extent of protection against digestion by micrococcal nuclease of DNase I. (ii) The size of the nucleosomes (180 base pairs) and core particles (145 base pairs). (iii) The number and sizes of DNA fragments produced by micrococcal nuclease in a limit digest. (iv) The sedimentation behavior on neutral sucrose gradients of nucleoprotein particles released by micrococcal nuclease. (v) The number and sizes of DNA fragments produced by DNase I digestion. These results demonstrate that cellular DNA replicated in isolated nuclei is organized into typical nucleosomes. Consequently, subcellular systems can be used to study the relationship between DNA replication and the assembly of chromatin under physiological conditions.     

The structural organization of sperm chromatin

The structure of rabbit, fowl, and Xenopus laevis sperm chromatin was explored by study of the reaction of their decondensed nuclei with DNase 1 and micrococcal nuclease. Those of rabbit and fowl were readily digested by DNase 1, and the polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis profiles of DNAs extracted from the digests were similar, each being polydisperse with a single discrete band of DNA smaller than 72 base pairs. There were differences, however, between the sperm chromatins in the course of their digestion by micrococcal nuclease. A limit digest at about 45% acid solubility was obtained with Xenopus sperm chromatin, while 90% of fowl sperm DNA was rendered acidsoluble by the enzyme. The gel profiles of the limit digests were polydisperse, but only those of rabbit and fowl sperm chromatins possessed a discrete band of DNA smaller than 72 base pairs. Bleomycin did not react with DNA of rabbit, fowl, or Xenopus spermatozoa. Since bleomycin reacts with somatic cell chromatin, and the course of DNase 1 or micrococcal nuclease digestion of sperm chromatin was different from that found for somatic cell chromatin, it would appear that sperm chromatin does not have the repeating nucleosometype structure of somatic cell chromatin. The nuclease digestion studies further suggest that the organization of rabbit and fowl sperm chromatins is similar, and is different from that of Xenopus sperm chromatin. The dependence of the structure of sperm chromatin on the composition of its basic proteins, and a possible structure for a protamine-type sperm chromatin, are discussed.     

Sea urchin sperm chromatin structure as probed by pancreatic DNase I: Evidence for a novel cutting periodicity

Chromatin from mature sea urchin spermatozoa is highly compacted and composed almost entirely of DNA and the five histones, although sperm H1, H2A, and H2b histones differ from those found in embryo or somatic cell nuclei. Release of acid-soluble DNA during pancreatic DNase I digestion is 20-fold slower from sperm nuclei than from embryonic nuclei. Following DNase I digestion, most sperm nuclear DNA remains at high molecular weight, although there appears to be some release of 10 base oligomer fragments. Size analysis of the higher molecular weight DNA reveals a series of fragments that indicate a cutting periodicity of approximately 500 base pairs. This pattern remains when electrophoretic separation is carried out under denaturing conditions. The 500 base pair cleavage pattern was not detected in digestions of embryonic nuclei. Nucleosomes reconstituted with fractionated core histones from sperm gave, upon digestion, a characteristic 10 base “ladder,” with no resistant high molecular weight DNA. Micrococcal nuclease and DNase II digested sperm nuclei to produce DNA fragments with a calculated repeat length of 248 ± 3 and 246 ± 6 base pairs, respectively. The structural basis for the 500 base pair cutting periodicity in sperm nuclei may reside in the unique sperm H1 histone.     

Evidence for a subunit structure of chromatin in mouse myeloma cells

If micrococcal nuclease is allowed to digest chromatin as it exists inside intact nuclei isolated from mouse myeloma tissue culture cells, more than 60% of the DNA can be isolated as a homogeneous fragment on a sucrose gradient. Analytical ultracentrifugation indicates that the protected DNA is native, unnicked, and about 140 +/- 10 base pairs long. After less extensive nuclease digestion, the protected DNA migrates in gels in lengths which are integral multiples of this 140 base pair "monomer" band. A submonomer band, 105 "/- 10 base pairs long, can also be detected. Similar digestion patterns were obtained by two different nuclear isolation procedures and even when intact cells were gently lysed directly in the digestion medium. These results confirm and extend the chromatin digestion studies of previous investigators and provide support for a subunit model for eukaryotic chromatin. The single strand specific S1 nuclease did not digest intranuclear chromatin under the conditions used.     

Periodicity and fragment size of DNA from mouse TLT hepatoma chromatin and chromatin fractions using endogenous and exogenous nucleases

Summary The action of micrococcal nuclease, DNase I and DNase II on mouse TLT hepatoma chromatin revealing the periodicity of its structure as visualized by denaturing and nondenaturing gel electrophoresis, was consistent with the action of these enzymes on other chromatins. Micrococcal nuclease showed a complex subnucleosome fragment pattern based on multiples of 10 base pairs with a prominant couplet at 140/160 base pairs and the absence of the 80 base pair fragment. This couplet of the core and minimal nucleosome fragments was conspicuously present in the mononucleosomes found in the 11S fractions of a glycerol gradient centrifugation. DNase I and II produced a fairly even distribution of a 10 base pair increasing series of fragments to about 180 base pairs, a pattern also repeated in the DNA of nucleosome glycerol-gradient fractions. In limited digestions by these nucleases multinucleosomic DNA fragments are pronounced. These fragment lengths are multiples of an estimated average repeat length of nucleosome DNA of 180 base pairs. The action of the endogenous Mg/Ca-stimulated endonuclease produced only limited cuts in the hepatoma chromatin resulting primarily in multi-nucleosommc DNA fragment lengths and only upon lengthy digestion limited subnucleosomic, 10-base-pair multiple fragments are produced. The putative euchromatin-enriched fractions (50–75S) of the glycerol gradient centrifugation of autodigested chromatin, similarly, contained primarily the multinucleosomic DNA fragment lengths. These results are consistent with our previous electron microscopic demonstration that autodigested chromatin as well as the putative euchromatin-enriched fractions were composed of multinucleosomic chromatin segments containing a full complement of histones.     

Subunit organization of Euglena chromatin

Digestion of $\text{Euglena}$ nuclei or extracted chromatin with micrococcal nuclease results in the identification of a repeating structure. The DNA repeat size, analyzed on agarose and polyacrylamide gels, is found to be 225±13 base pairs. DNase I digestion produces a serie of fragments multiples of roughly 10 bases. Eventhough pressure shearing is necessary to disrupt the though pellicule of the phytoflagellate, we confirm that, in $\text{Euglena}$, chromatin organization is similar to that of other eukaryotes.     

Quantitative analysis of the digestion of yeast chromatin by staphylococcal nuclease.

The DNA in intranuclear yeast chromatin is protected from rapid staphylococcal nuclease degradation so as to yield an oligomeric series of DNA sizes. The course of production and disappearance of the various oligomers agrees quantitatively with a theory of random cleavage by the enzyme at uniformly susceptible sites. The sizes of the oligomers are integral repeats of a basic size, about 160 base pairs, and 80-90% of the yeast genome is involved in this repeating structure. Within this repeat there exists a 140 base pair core of more nuclease-resistant DNA. During the course of digestion, the sizes of the oligomers decrease continuously. The widths of the distribution of DNA sizes increase in order: monomer (1 X repeat size, half width = 5-7 base pairs) less than dimer (2 X repeat size, half width = 30 base pairs) less than trimer (3 X repeat size, half width = 40-45 base pairs). The yeast genome thus seems to have variable spacing of the nucleaseresistant cores, to produce the average repeat size of about 160 base pairs. Also, the presence of more than one species of monomer and dimer at certain times of digestion suggests a possible heterogeneity in the subunit structure.