Tertiary plotopterids (Aves, Plotopteridae) and a novel hypothesis on the phylogenetic relationships of penguins (Spheniscidae)

Plotopterids (Aves: Plotopteridae) are extinct wing-propelled diving birds which exhibit a strikingly similar wing morphology to penguins (Spheniscidae), but also share derived characters with 'pelecaniform' birds that are absent in penguins. The similarities between Plotopteridae and Spheniscidae have hitherto been attributed to convergence, and plotopterids were considered to be most closely related to the 'pelecaniform' Phalacrocoracidae (cormorants) and Anhingidae (anhingas). However, here I show that assignment of plotopterids to 'pelecaniform' birds does not necessarily preclude them from being the sister taxon of penguins. Cladistic analysis of 68 morphological characters resulted in sister group relationship between Plotopteridae and Spheniscidae, and the clade (Plotopteridae + Spheniscidae) was shown to be the sister taxon of the Suloidea, i.e. a clade including Sulidae (boobies and gannets), Phalacrocoracidae, and Anhingidae. Derived characters are discussed which support this novel hypothesis. Paedomorphosis probably accounts for the absence of derived characters in penguins that are shared by Plotopteridae and members of the Steganopodes. Plotopterids exemplify the importance of fossil birds for analyzing the phylogenetic relationships of modern taxa that exhibit a highly apomorphic morphology.