Systematic overestimation of Salicaceae seed survival using radicle emergence in response to drying and storage: implications for ex situ seed banking

Biodiversity conservation programmes are underpinned by seed banking following drying to low water contents (WC), and supported by both the assessment and prediction of seed viability over time. The means of judging viability is thus crucial to the comprehension of seed vigour. We selected seeds of three species and one hybrid in the Salicaceae likely to have variation in tolerance to drying, processing and storage, including in relation to cryobanking, and compared survival growth as radicle emergence (germination) and normal seedling production. With three seed lots of Salix gracilistyla, air-drying to 8–10 % WC enhanced seed survival after 40 days’ storage at 5 °C as compared with non-treated seeds at 14–20 % WC. Four seed lots of Populus alba × P. glandulosa showed equally high germination (88–100 %) and proportions of normal seedlings (81–99 %) when stored at 5 °C for 7–10 weeks. Among seven seed lots of S. gracilistyla, two groups with different storage behaviour could be statistically distinguished with normal seedling production ranging from 0 to 45 % after storage at 5 °C for 13 weeks. Seed tolerance to WC manipulation and cryopreservation was very variable among species and seed lots. Seed lots of S. hallaisanensis and S. gracilistyla with ~80 % germination survived cryopreservation at 10 % WC, but were sensitive to lower WCs. In contrast, Populus seeds had greater desiccation tolerance combined with cryopreservation capability. With seed lots of all species and hybrids, cryopreservation had little effect on viability unless the high moisture freezing limit had been exceeded (~10–20 % WC, depending on seed lot). However, under all conditions of handling (drying, rehydration, storage at 5 °C or cryopreservation) using germination as the only indicator of viability over-estimated survival compared with normal seedling production.