STUDIES IN THE QUERCUS UNDULATA COMPLEX. IV. THE CONTRIBUTION OF QUERCUS HAVARDII

Scrub oak populations in the semidesert area of northeastern Arizona and southeastern Utah are ordinarily identified in regional manuals as Quercus undulata. They are very similar, both morphologically and ecologically, to Q. havardii of the Staked Plain of the Texas Panhandle and southeastern New Mexico. They differ, however, in a number of inconspicuous characters. Population sample analyses indicate that most of these differences are suggestive of Q. gambelii, and the deviant populations are thus interpreted as having been derived from ancestral Q. havardii through introgression by Q. gambelii. Two differences are not in accord with this interpretation; these are regarded as possible cases of transgressive segregation. Considering the evolution of these hybridized populations, it is speculated that the ancestral Q. havardii occurred to the south and west of the present range of this species during the Kansan period of the Pleistocene. During subsequent northward dispersal, it became split in two. The eastern portion ultimately came to occupy the present range of the species in the Staked Plain; the western portion—lying to the west of a north-south mountain barrier in central New Mexico—became introgressed by Q. gambelii (and locally by Q. turbinella), resulting in the present populations of Arizona and Utah.