Mitochondrial gene fragments suggest paraphyly of the genus Panorpa (Mecoptera, Panorpidae)

Life history studies of scorpionfly species have been used to test predictions of evolutionary theory, but comparative analysis has been hampered by a lacking phylogeny of scorpionflies. We present a molecular phylogeny of selected panorpid scorpionflies inferred from mitochondrial 12S, 16S rRNA, and COI gene fragments, using parsimony and maximum-likelihood methods. Maximum-likelihood reconstructions depend on an explicit evolutionary substitution model; therefore, we estimated fit of substitution models to our data and used an optimal evolutionary substitution model in subsequent reconstructions. Both reconstruction methods converge on compatible trees with considerable statistical support for a majority of nodes. We performed parametric tests of most important phylogenetic conclusions employing the fitted GTR + %I + Gamma substitution model. Parametric bootstrapping allowed rejection of alternative explanations of the data set, where classical tests, like the KHY test, failed. Parametric bootstrapping confirmed that the association of Neopanorpa sp. with Asian Panorpa species is currently the superior explanation of the data set. Therefore, it is concluded that the genus Panorpa is most likely paraphyletic to the representative of the genus Neopanorpa. We conclude that the sequenced mitochondrial gene fragments appear to be well suited for future more comprehensive phylogenetic investigations of panorpid scorpionflies.