Motor control and cardiovascular responses during isoelectric contractions of the upper trapezius muscle: evidence for individual adaptation strategies

Ten females (25–50 years of age) performed isometric shoulder flexions, holding the right arm straight and in a horizontal position. The subjects were able to see the rectified surface electromyogram (EMG) from either one of two electrode pairs above the upper trapezius muscle and were instructed to keep its amplitude constant for 15 min while gradually unloading the arm against a support. The EMG electrodes were placed at positions representing a “cranial” and a “caudal” region of the muscle suggested previously to possess different functional properties. During the two contractions, recordings were made of: (1) EMG root mean square-amplitude and zero crossing (ZC) frequency from both electrode pairs on the trapezius as well as from the anterior part of the deltoideus, (2) supportive force, (3) heart rate (HR) and mean arterial blood pressure (MAP), and (4) perceived fatigue. The median responses during the cranial isoelectric contraction were small as compared to those reported previously in the literature: changes in exerted glenohumeral torque and ZC rate of the isoelectric EMG signal of −2.81% · min⁻¹ (P = 0.003) and 0.03% · min⁻¹ (P= 0.54), respectively, and increases in HR and MAP of 0.14 beats · min⁻² (P= 0.10) and 0.06 mmHg · min⁻¹ (P= 0.33), respectively. During the contraction with constant caudal EMG amplitude, the corresponding median responses were −2.51% · min⁻¹ (torque), 0.01% · min⁻¹ (ZC rate), 0.31 beats · min⁻² (HR), and 0.93 mmHg · min⁻¹ (MAP); P=0.001, 0.69, 0.005, and 0.003, respectively. Considerable deviations from the “isoelectric” target amplitude were common for both contractions. Individuals differed markedly in response, and three distinct subgroups of subjects were identified using cluster analysis. These groups are suggested to represent different motor control scenarios, including differential engagement of subdivisions of the upper trapezius, alternating motor unit recruitment and, in one group, a gradual transition towards a greater involvement of type II motor units. The results indicate that prolonged low-level contractions of the shoulder muscles may in general be accomplished with a moderate metabolic stress, but also that neuromuscular adaptation strategies differ significantly between individuals. These results may help to explain why occupational shoulder-neck loads of long duration cause musculoskeletal disorders in some subjects but not in others. Accepted: 1 March 1997