High phenotypic variability in the wood decay fungus Phellopilus nigrolimitatus

Genetic and phenotypic variation among individuals increases population resilience to external disturbances and enables quicker adaptation to changing environments. Since the predominant phase in the fungal lifecycle occurs belowground or within substrates, it is difficult to assess the level of variation in functional traits occurring within species in natural environments. In this study, we investigated phenotypic variation in the wood-decay fungus Phellopilus nigrolimitatus and related this to genet size, measured as vegetative compatibility groups (VCGs). Out of 321 wood samples and sporocarps collected on six logs of Picea abies, we isolated 230 dikaryotic isolates that were grouped into 53 VCGs based on culturing experiments. The number of VCGs per log varied from six to twelve, with large variation in sizes; the smallest VCG was derived from a single wood sample, while the largest was isolated across 31 wood samples stretching over 15 m. The size of the VCGs was positively correlated with the area of the spore-producing layer of the sporocarps, implying that larger genets produce more spores. Additionally, the phenotypic variation among isolates of P. nigrolimitatus was high, both in terms of growth morphology and coloration, and consistent with the delimitation of isolates into VCGs. Isolates could to a large extent be correctly assigned to the VCGs a priori based purely on culture phenotype. This study reveals that extensive phenotypic variation can be observed between fungal genets at very fine spatial scale, and calls for more studies looking at intraspecific phenotypic variation, in line with assessing genetic diversity in fungi.