Foliar damage, parasitoids and indirect competition: a test using herbivores of birch

ABSTRACT.

• 1 The hypothesis that leaf-chewing caterpillars and leaf miners indirectly compete via the influence of foliar damage on parasitoids was experimentally tested using the leaf miner Coleophora serratella (L.) and a complex of folivorous caterpillars on birch.
• 2 Separate experiments tested the effects of manipulating artificial or caterpillar-induced leaf damage on parasitism of leaf miners at several spatial scales.
• 3 Parasitism of C. serratella by specialist and generalist parasitoids was independent of the extent of either collateral or leaf-miner damage, whether experimentally or naturally induced.
• 4 Support in the literature for the hypothesis is restricted to a single case, and only on a limited spatial scale; thus, the idea that collateral damage directs parasitoid-mediated competition among herbivores remains highly speculative.