Evolution of insecticide resistance in Culex pipiens populations: The Corsican paradox

Culex pipiens mosquitoes from Corsica have been subject to insecticide treatments since 1971, using temephos (an organophosphate). After 17 years, resistance has not developed beyond a 14-fold level. This relatively low resistance is due to the presence of several identified resistance genes, including the insensitive target ( Ace^R ) and overproduced esterases (A1, A4 and B4). The fact that only a low resistance has developed after 17 years of treatment and that this low resistance level is the result of a relatively large number of resistance genes constitute a paradox. To understand this situation and explain why a higher temephos resistance level has not evolved in Corsica as in other parts of the world, it is proposed that the occurrence (through mutation or migration) of efficient resistance genes was a limiting step, and that the only resistance genes available at that time through migration from the surrounding Mediterranean countries had a low cross-resistance to temephos. The local situation of Corsica is discussed in the light of recent data on the world distribution of the known organophosphate resistance genes in this species, and the relative role of mutation and migration in the evolution of insecticide resistance in natural populations.