Comparison of the folding of 2-Keto-3-deoxy-6-phosphogluconate aldolase,triosephosphate isomerase and pyruvate kinase: Implications in molecular evolution

The 8-fold α/β barrel conformation of 2-keto-3-deoxy-6-phosphogluconate aldolase has been compared to that of triosephosphate isomerase and the A-domain of pyruvate kinase. There are eight supersecondary structure units (α/β) in each of these proteins, and the comparisons were carried out in orientations corresponding to each of the possible congruences, i.e. first to first, first to second,… of the supersecondary structure units. The comparison of the C_α structure of the main chain folding of the three enzymes indicated about 150 equivalences with rootmean-square differences of about 3.1 Å, with no orientational preference, including the aldolase with itself. In addition, there is no sequence homology between the aldolase and the isomerase, and no indication of gene duplication in the former. The lack of orientational preference among the three enzymes suggests convergence to a fold of exceptional stability. However, all three enzymes activate a CH bond adjacent to a carbonyl, and their active sites correspond to the f strand, F helix region of the α/β barrel, thus contradicting the foregoing and suggesting divergent evolution from a common precursor. Other and similar arguments are also presented for and against convergent evolution of these three strikingly similar enzymes.