Lanthanide ion catalysis of the trans-cis isomerization of trans-bis(oxalato)-diaquochromate(III) and trans-bis(malonato)diaquochromate(III) [1]

The lanthanide ion catalyzed trans-cis isomerizations of trans-bis(oxalato)diaquochromate(II) and trans-bis(malonato)diaquochromate(III) have been studied. A linear free energy relationship was found correlating the catalytic rate constants for the oxalate reaction with the corresponding formation constants of complexes formed between simple monocarboxylic acids and the light (LaGd) members of the lanthanide series. The results indicates that for this portion of the series, the reaction mechanism is related to the formation of monocarboxylate complex intermediates. When the ionic radius of the lanthanide ion decreases below a particular value (as in the latter half of the series), the metal ion remains coordinated to both carboxylates of the oxalate ion rather than simply binding to only one carboxylate. In either situation, isomerization to the cis product eventually occurs, and the lanthanide ion is released.The reaction rates associated with the trans-bis(malonato)diaquochromate(III) reaction were found to be significantly slower than those of the corresponding oxalate system. However, in the malonate system, no linear free energy relationship was found relating the catalytic rate constants with the corresponding formation constants of monocarboxylic acids. One does find a linear relationship between the catalytic rate constants for the malonate reaction and the log K₁ values for the corresponding lanthanide/malonate complexes. During the course of the trans-cis isomerization, the lanthanide ion chelates the dissociated malonate group of a pentavalent Cr(III) intermediate. In the mechanism the lanthanide ion does not aid in ring opening, and neither does it singly bond to the intermediate