Estimating clear-day solar radiation: An evaluation of three models

Three models for estimating clear-day solar radiation were compared to one another and to values of solar radiation measured at Ft Collins, Colo. The models of Campbell (1977), Gates (1962) and McCullough and Porter (1971) all correlate closely with measurements of clear-day solar radiation. The Campbell and the Gates models require less technical expertise and less expensive computations to produce estimates of the direct component of solar radiation. All of the models appear to require calibration in order to correct estimates of the input variables to measured values of irradiance so that accurate calculations of direct solar radiation can subsequently be made. The best estimates of the diffuse component of solar radiation are obtained from the model of McCullough and Porter. The easiest and most accurate predictions of total solar radiation can be obtained from the direct-radiation models of Campbell (1977) and Gates (1962) and a modification of the diffuse-component model of McCullough and Porter (1971).