Organic mulches vs. black plastic in organic strawberry: does it make a difference for ground beetles (Col., Carabidae)?

Abstract:  Carabid beetles were sampled by pitfall traps in May–September 2002 and 2003 in an experimental organic strawberry field in seven different mulching row treatments and in fescue-growing row spaces to determine the effect of mulches on carabid activity–density and species composition. There were no differences between treatments or row spaces in total numbers of all carabid species in either season. Of the 67 identified species and 4374 individuals, the most trapped ones were Clivina fossor (11.7% of total catch), Dyschirius globosus (10.2%), Patrobus atrorufus (9.3%), Pterostichus niger (8.8%), Bembidion properans (7.4%), Pterostichus melanarius (6.0%), Bembidion lampros (5.7%), Pterostichus crenatus (5.7%), Amara communis (4.1%), Trechus secalis (3.9%), Pterostichus strenuus (3.9%), Loricera pilicornis (3.1%), Harpalus rufipes (2.8%) and Carabus nemoralis (2.6%). Large carabid species P. niger and P. melanarius were trapped more in all mulched rows than in row spaces, and C. nemoralis was trapped more in the mixture of pine woodchip/buckwheat husk mulch than in row spaces, barley straw and birch woodchip mulch. The small but abundant species P. atrorufus was trapped more in buckwheat husk mulch than in row spaces and B. properans in row spaces than in buckwheat husk mulch. H. rufipes , being also a pest in strawberry, was trapped more in cut grass mulch than in row spaces. The Shannon H' diversity index was significantly higher in the mixture of pine woodchip/buckwheat husk mulch than in black plastic, buckwheat husk mulch or in row spaces, and in birch woodchip and cut grass mulches than in row spaces. The results of trapping studies show the species preference to the specific mulches, and reflect positive or negative effect of mulches on carabid diversity with consequences to plant protection.