Group stability and homing behavior but no kin group structures in a coral reef fish

Understanding the reasons behind stable group formations hasreceived considerable theoretical and empirical attention. Stablegroups displaying homing behavior have been suggested to formas a result of, for instance, benefits from knowledge of thesocial or physical environment or through kin selection andthe forming of kin groups. However, no one has disentangledpreference for grouping in a familiar location from preferencefor grouping with familiar or related individuals. To investigatethis, we conducted a series of field experiments and a groupgenetic analysis on the group-living Banggai cardinalfish (Pterapogonkauderni). We found homing behavior but no evidence for recognitionof familiar group members. Instead, homing was based on theoriginal location of their group rather than the individualsin that group. Moreover, we found no evidence for kin structureswithin these groups. We suggest that benefits from living ina known social environment drive homing behavior in this speciesand that homing behavior is not enough for the formation ofkin group structures. Instead, our results suggest that kinrecognition may be a prerequisite for the forming of kin groups.