Plot size for progeny selection in maize (Zea mays L.)

Summary Six progeny trials that included 147 half-sib progenies of maize (Zea mays L.) population ESALQ PB-5 were conducted for the purpose of studying plot size and its consequences in recurrent selection programs. The progenies were evaluated in three 7x7 duplicate simple lattice experiments using one-row plots of 5 m². At harvest each plot was partitioned into five sub-plots (sampling units), and data was collected from each sampling unit. At the same time and place the same progenies were evaluated in three 7x7 duplicate simple lattice experiments using 1-m² (linear row with 5 plants) plots. Data were collected for plant and ear height, ear diameter, total ear weight, and total grain yield. The data were combined by using adjacent sampling units, and the analyses were performed by considered five plot sizes in addition to those of the independent trials with 1-m² plots. The experiments with 1-m² plots were less efficient in discriminating for yield traits among progenies than those with 5-m² plots. The combination of plot size and number of progenies evaluated indicated that an optimum plot size for yield was between 3 and 4 m², or 15–20 plants per plot. With such sizes the expected gain was maximized for the four replications used in this study. If the total area covered by each progeny is constant, the maximum gain from selection, however, is attained by decreasing plot size and increasing the number of replications. The minimum size of plots is, however, limited by practical or theoretical criteria. Plot size affected the estimates of additive genetic variance, coefficient of heritability, and genetic coefficient of variation for all of the traits. No practical limitation was observed for conducting experiments with 1-m² plot.