N90 index: A new approach to biodiversity based on similarity and sensitive to direct and indirect fishing impact

An important effort has been made to develop diversity indices suitable to monitor the loss of biodiversity due to anthropogenic impacts in an accurate and comprehensible way. Here, N₉₀, a diversity index based on the species’ contribution to the similarity between samples in a group, is presented. N₉₀ uses the results of the classic Similarity Percentage analysis and a jack-knife routine to calculate the average and a dispersion value of the number of species contributing up to the ninety percent of the similarity in a group of samples. N₉₀ is applied to two groups of samples subjected to contrasting levels of bottom trawl fishing pressure using time series of experimental bottom trawl surveys of the Balearic Islands. The results are compared to those obtained using more ‘traditional’ diversity indices such as species richness, Shannon–Wienner, Simpson, Pielou, and Margalef diversity indices. The N₉₀ diversity index displayed a clear response to fishing pressure with significantly lower values in impacted communities, while the ‘traditional’ diversity indices showed almost null sensitivity to fishing pressure. In addition, N₉₀ also detects indirect fishing impacts by fluctuating in response to environmental variation in impacted areas, making this index sensitive to the synergies between climate and fishing impact at community level. The application of the N₉₀ diversity index to the case study shows that it may be an alternative to ‘traditional’ diversity indices when trying to monitor fishing impacts and the effects of environmental changes. Its units, number of species, and the corresponding summary list of species facilitate the interpretability of the results, improving the communication to managers and stakeholders.